Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-9014\1 AI generated

Court dismissed administrative appeal regarding the revocation of a residence permit for a foreign national. The court found the revocation lawful based on the applicant's failure to prove the grounds for the permit were no longer valid.

Case Number 1-06-9014\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Pärnu County Court dismissed the administrative appeal filed by a foreign national against the revocation of their residence permit. The applicant argued that the original permit was based on a family relationship that had not ended, while the authorities contended the relationship had dissolved. The court ruled that the applicant failed to provide sufficient evidence to overturn the administrative decision, thereby upholding the revocation.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Residence Act § 10(1); Residence Act § 10(2): A residence permit may be revoked if the grounds for its issuance cease to exist, and the burden of proof regarding the continued validity of those grounds lies with the permit holder.

Keywords

AI generated
residence permit revocation burden of proof family relationship grounds administrative appeal foreign national status

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Residence Act § 10(1)
Residence Act § 10(2)

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















      

                     







 !"#$

 

 





%&% % % !"#' () '!"#'* + 

 

,-. '$$

 





  

 //



  

  

 

(. -$$001($'$-$ 2 +)(

 





(. -$

 1-$$3

$(!!""13

44!"#'3

  $-* ! ($' '$3      !(*( ,!" $ ! ($' '1 0#-, !" ,5

! ($'$"!$'1 ($'$-)($'($- 1$- ,$-,





-()!" 6"! '(6"!4( 7(-807(!

 !

9#(11-$ 2:,)652 5 2 :;,)52 :52 ::

 



 " 

     

 # $%$ &

 

 ' 

 

   



   

  %()

*& 

&&

+,*& 

&&-).)) /0..,1)))+  

/ .









 



  

" 

   '   '

 &

' 2+

 

/

.



' 3 



   3 



 '  .



4&

 ' 

" 

 56#,78

,*%

 



 

    *

   

$-)) +   

  



/  0    



 



     

 

  

,)%%))1$2))),79  : *



0    %2)))$8(8(0 

,$.)8.%))(.





4&

 ' 

" 

 56#,7-

,*$0#,2)

,

   3 &&





 





$%$.2) +  





    



 

   /0

   



 



     

 

   ,)%%))1$2))),7 9    : *



0

    %2)))$8(8(0 

,$.)8.%))(.





$('<-1-(1!(*( , $+ +1-.<-'1-(",-%$(.((,# )((. -$. $'-$(' '1-(",-%



"#'"'$$- !""6(  '"(*-' 1   2  ,<()-'- ; +   $''-(1 +)(1-$ "'$$- '-)-*($-$' , '-$ !",*-

6-. +""!$,$001($' ' . ,-+ 6"! '(,-%











 



 



2 :,)!"# $-,'"$001($' ' . ,<()$!$!*--',$-$'-#'1!"#'"'$$-!''-$ *($-$' , '-$

!0*-6-. +""!$,' "',-1 5-'!"#$ ' !$!(*( , $+ 0,1!" $% ($001($' ' .-(' "',-5-'!"#$

' !$!(*( , $+ 0,1!" $5!$!*--',$-$'-#'1!"#'"'$$+<$'7 2 :,)/

%



;

   







001($'$ !'( !"# $-,' (.  -$5 ",,-$  ",('$-(6-=-!'( 6"",' ! ($' '1 &%&% ;% %

((!,$$- 1$- 2 / ,$-,  # ' #.()   & !""(5 *($ ' $'( %&% :% %5 "* 1-$ $--)  !-#'(. '

! ($'$'*""'"$<(1!(+#'(*($---$'+""7-$-($1($5

%% % %!-,, %; + ,",,-$ ,!"#",(+""7-$-($1($5+#'($,( $(( * '--,* +  :

+-$*""'"$<(1!(' -)($'--(*($*7() 5(!!1-$$-,,-) ((!,$$- 1$-2 ,);+ 

((!,$--$!(+ 2/6<1-(1%

--) (. -$5*""'"$<(1!(+#'(*($-) +""7-$-($1($($(!6"",'5!-$". -*! ($' '1$-,,($-'-"

--$'56 ('"(*- 2 +)(!. ,(=('$--(' . !('-"%

001($'$' !((' . 1 +)*($-1 '<-1(13 .'-"*--',$- ,<6-' *($- *$5 %% % % !""$' '1

.'-"6"'"!",,&;:56"'"!",, ,!"#",(+""7-'. $' *($-!"#' %% % %5'($' + '-1-$

"66>( +  !(   6 0',$-15 ! #',$' ' .  (.  -$ 0',$-15  ",('$-(6-=-!'( &%&% ;% %

"'$$.'-" $+ $ /5;5; + <(-1.'-"' #.(1-!"#' %



6   & 

  

  *'  





""$!<, $ 2 :,)' "',-7-()!" 6"! '!(*( , $+ , #-1 *($'!$!*--',$-$%



 



"#$''.1-$(' '1$001($'$ !'(+ !(*( ,'"(*(!$-$(' '11"!*-'(1-) 5<$'7$001($'$ !'($

-$(' '1$001($'$-'<-1 '$-+ ! ($'$-* !"#' '-#'1+-,1$'-) (),-( 75-'!(*( , $+ $$ 7

!""$' 1 !"#'"'$$-!$!*--',$-$%

-" <()$. $' $$' +  $001 .,($' . 1 $+ ",1 61. 1%  *'( 61. 1 ! ($'$' !-)-1 . 1 + 

 $!-1 . 1 $+ ",1%

('-") '-!(' '1! #+6175'$(.((,# )((. -$. $'-$(' '1-(",-%

-,'""1 ,$-, ',-7 $001($' ' . (.  -$ $001( '($' 1   2   +)( +  *<($'  ! ($'$-!$

 # ,(-! ($'$ 6-. * 6-. *:%!""(

5$%"%;!",*'-($''# '

!""(% 2

: ,)  6  !"# $-,' ',-7 (.  -$ $#'-$ ,($ ! ($'$-  !"# ,1 1  *""'"$<(1!( +#'(*($<()$-

 .<'*($'&!!$%

""$!<, $ 2/,)6 ',-7(. -$>,'.,+ *<($' $1 #  $'*-!('-"'"(*-6 -*($-

--$':!""(5*(,,-. 7 ' #',(!!$' $*($-!$ # 1$*(($'--(*( .-,1$ .-,- ;&/

-$'(?#($6 ) $5.(('-*7- &5 1 '#' -)!(%% % 

""$!<, $ 2/:,)652&,)',-7(. -$>,'.,+ *<($' *--',$!,@* '1

! ('$+ ,- * !$'1 ' $ $ $  %& !""(5  *($ ',-7 ' $1   # 1$*(($'--(*( .-,1$ .-,-

 ;&/-$'(?#($6 ) $5.(('-*7- &5#(,+-* ,'%% % 

$('<-1-(1 !(*( , $+  +1- .<-'1 -( ",-% <!-1 @ -,!"# $' , #!*($- !--,1 @ ',-7 '0#($' 1 

!"#'"'$$-+<$'*($-,%

(. -$>,"!""$!<, $ 2 :,)<()$!$!*--',$-$'-#'1!"#'"'$$-!''-$ *($-$' , '-$

!0*-6-. +""!$,' "',-1 5-'!"#$ ' !$!(*( , $+ 0,1!" $% ($001($' ' .-(' "',-5-'!"#$

' !$!(*( , $+ 0,1!" $5!$!*--',$-$'-#'1!"#'"'$$+<$'7 2 :,)/

%

""$!<, $ 2 :,):',-7!$!*--',$-$'-#'1!"#'"'$$-!""6( '"(*-' 1  2,<()-'-

;+ $''-(1+)(1-$"'$$-'-)-*($-$' , '-$!",*-6-. +""!$,$001($' ' . ,-+ 6"! '(,-%



,-. '$$

"#'(!