Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-9147\3 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal regarding illegal detention of a foreign national without a valid residence permit.

Case Number 1-06-9147\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Pärnu Court of First Instance dismissed the appellant's appeal against the decision to detain a foreign national. The appellant argued that the detention was unlawful because he lacked a valid residence permit and the administrative body failed to provide sufficient justification. The court ruled that the detention was lawful under the relevant immigration regulations as the individual was present in the country without proper documentation, thereby justifying the temporary restriction of liberty.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Immigration Act; Residence Permit Act: The court established that the detention of a foreign national without a valid residence permit is lawful when the individual is present in the country without proper documentation, provided the administrative decision is based on statutory grounds.

Keywords

AI generated
illegal detention foreign national residence permit immigration law administrative appeal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Immigration Act
Residence Permit Act

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

        

          

     !!"#$ %    

   &! ' %()&! !!"#$ % "#$( *!+!  

      ,)-),    #$( ." /01 (% %      !.1.#220/  

   30%4% %553.%( %0%  6/'7 !6/')27-76 ) 76+'./5$.*00(/ %0"#!%  !.0.%!!     30%4%   0/ "#$(87 .%." "##387 (99"#$(82 3 :&  !!%0*"!.%(!( %8 & &)&)&!& .!"#$( 2##/(  6 /')27 )7  !/ %0/ ) !!%(!%0 1!:!3 %0"!#( %0'!  !!%(!%0 "!(%0!+!'!; )& & &&!& .!"#$( 2##/(  6/')2 7 !/ %0/!!%(!%01!:!3 %0"!#( %0'!;

& ,&,&&!& .!"#$( 2##/(  6 /')27 )7 !/ %0/,"##.%  %0!$!(!$1.'!; & ,&&)&!& !!"#$( 2##/(  6 /')2)7 7 6/'!/ %0/!!%(!%0+!" /.%01!:!3 %0"!#( %0'!; ,& ,&&)&!& !!"#$( 2##/( !6-/')2) !/ %0/ !!%(!%01!'.%( %0'! !!%(!%0"!(%0!+!'!; & &&),&!& !!"#$( 2##/( !6/')277 -!/ %0/!!%(!%0+!" /.%01!'.%( %0'!&

 )      1!30!31#"!!(."(# #</#1  ! = $.3 30% 6)

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

A"!% "%  0/.(0.%(( $!("#/*%!3! "##.7  !!2!!3 %:5##"!% "%,- 1..%(0.%(( $!("!$0"%!%!3!"50 "##.7 /:0(!(+ B.%"."!% "%) 5"%( $!("!"%%!3!" %"503 "##.7 .(!/C!((0>."!% "% 0/."503( $!( "##.&



  /+!*4.%(!30%4% >/(8 66/'2)!/ %0/% 3!$!7,2!/'!!/!!%7%&#&, 0/.( $!(1..%%!3! "##.; 6,/'2!/ %0/(!% ..'.4.' %!:.00%()) "50( $!("!"%%!3!"!"%"503 0/. "##.+!%0(.;  6 , /'  2  !/ %0/ /!.:! "#$( !%(/."  0"%20(..%. *!"% * % , 0/. ( $!( 1..%%!3!  "##.7 ( /0"!$+  0"%20(..%. *!"% * % , 5"% ( $!( 1..%%!3!  "##.7 D 0"%20(..%. *!"% * % ,- 1..% ( $!( "!$0"%!%!3!0/."503 "##.+!"#$( 2%5$$.!!(.!2%5$$#/##'.! 0"%20(..%. *!"% * %

-  "#/* ( $!( "#/*%!3! "!$0"%!"503 "#/*  "##. +! ,) %0(. *.//.%03(!% 3!..'.( / 30%%0 201!+##"% /!$!3 %*..%(00. *.!10/0&)) - 0%(.A$.%2!'!% 1..(0 *:0)- & %.(403.3@ ) 2!"". 2!:0(!%" (." .3@ 6)/' 2!/ %0/$1.(!3!" .1( %0( 3 !%+!3&       

(% %0/0 !20//!(%.##"!0: %( 0%.(!3! 0. %!!7 " ! "4." "#$( *00(/ %0 2##/03 /##: %.3 "#$( % !20//!(%.##.4.' %0%(&   

/01 (% % #$( ."