Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-06-1623\5 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:4.06.1623.24093 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding revocation of residence permit for illegal stay.

Case Number 4-06-1623\5
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the administrative decision to revoke their residence permit due to illegal stay. The applicant argued that the revocation violated their right to a fair trial and proportionality, claiming the administrative body failed to consider mitigating circumstances. The court ruled that the administrative decision was lawful because the applicant's continued illegal residence constituted a serious breach of immigration law, justifying the immediate termination of their permit without further procedural safeguards.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Immigration Act § 10(1); Residence Permit Act § 12(1): The court may revoke a residence permit if the holder has committed a serious breach of immigration law, such as illegal stay, without requiring a separate fair trial procedure for the revocation itself.

Keywords

AI generated
residence permit revocation illegal stay administrative decision immigration law proportionality principle fair trial rights residence permit holder

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Immigration Act § 10(1)
Residence Permit Act § 12(1)

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





 















      







 !"#$

 

 





%&'% % ($$ (

 



  

 !"#)*+'$( ,(()+(&  *)(" $&   - 

.



 

(( /($)

 

  

*( $$

 

 

%

%

! (0$

(

"+')$('1(2(!)'

($$ (

1"+')$('& "$!"  * (,!"$) 0(+ +,()  +3( !""$) )/

.%%% %!'',(()+$(")$$(+(





   





 

   



(0$( ($') &  % % 

4 !"#)*+'$( ,(()+(&  (

"+')$('1(2(!)' ($$ (1"+')$('& "$!"  $!"#)"$$'

- ($$ (

($'/ & * (,!"$) 0(+ +,() +3(

%&'% %





 5)) ! (0$ #+/ , ) %



! 5)) ,), ) ("+')$('1(2(!)' ($$ (1"+')$('& "$!" * (,!"$) 0(+ +,()

 +3(.%%% %!'',(()+$(")$$ !"#)*+'$(,(()+(& *)(" $& -.

%

%'! '$) ,'$($+''!+$$( /$(6-.+3&3' # ) #*'3 ) #*'7#'!)$"!""'%



"  )  # ) #*) #*'7#'!) !""'

"$')') $,'$(!$% # ) #*)+(0) $/ ! #(

!&""!$+*8/$()($"$ /($4$%"!""'!$%





 



 



)$$( 1( +( *8'0 !"#),(()+$( 1""+ * /( /*"! /'$) ($'/ &  * #(/$(+ ($') / 

! $$ )$'""! (0$( ''3'!"#)+(  1(*  &""!$+ + )($ ")$$( !+) ,'$($) &  ")$$( !"#)$

))*,'$(!$ !))($ ,'$( 1(* $)% $$ )$'""8'3$( $""*'$) )+(0 - 1(*  &""!$+ !'& +'!+)

)( ) /  !"#) ($$ (!"#), & +( + )($!"#)")$$(!+) ,'$($)%





 



"#)")$$ "   !"#) ($$ ( !"#), &  ! )$(+('$ $!"# 3  "$$'  ($$ ($

))*,'$(!$!))($ / * + )($%&'$)% %



 # ) #*)+(0) $/ 1 ! !($"+(* ")$$((/ $'! (0 ,'$()#) & &""!$+ + )($1(* $)4,'+

!"#)")$$"!"#),(()+$(1""+(+(!"#)$))*,'$(!$!))($ / *4! !"#)")$$199 ) !$(

)'),'$(+(!'1(* $)4,'+")$$"!"#)$))*,'$(!$!))($ / *",99//(/ $'! (0 ,'$(

)#) (3 &  ,(()+$ +( '$'! (' "+(  # ) #*' )'($ + )$($ ) $/ *8' !' ")$$( 1( +( (' "+(

! (0$)($') )/%

 # ) #* )+(0 ) $/   # /$,''$)((',' :!+(    -;  '$  ($)'

<#'$1 !*8'--='$

$ 1 !4*'')(,0("=.=% $,'$(+,!'/ 

$(+3')$$(")$$(,0(%



($"+(* $ $& $ 199 0 !"#)")$$( )'),'$(+( $ , $ *)(" $& $ ($, !"/$(+) + #(/' )('/

!"#)*+'(,(()+(& %



#$#%

( "+')$('1(2(!)' ($$ ( 1"+')$('& "$!"  * (,!"$) 0(+ +,()  +3(

!""$) )/.%%% %!'',(()+$(")$$(3 ! '$) )'%%')+''!+$$( /$( 

6-.+3

&3' # ) #*'3 ) #*'7#'!)$"!""'%



)$$($)#)04()%%')! '$) )'*)(",(()+$($$(++((($)4()) .%%!(++ %.

1 '! ($$ ($  3' &  99 ) *  '$),'!+ +''!/($ ($!' ) *  $ $ &#)'/($

,"")"$8'/!')(''/ /$ ,3 ()1( )((+)!8* +)((+($8')($4'!!/($$(++(3 

+''!+$(($!'& 6=8/('/4,'++'()(3"!* +'2')$((') **)(" 6-.+3&3'%



=%%% %($') $%%((+',() )/")$$(1( +(! (0$(, !"#)+(4) ")+(/($!"#)*+'$(

,(()+(& ")$$()7#'$) ,'$)& *)(",(()+$(+81() ,'$)%

(0$($,3') !$(4()! (0$(($') & ('"+(8$)(, $#)($ +$) )/*)(",(()+$(3 4

$("$($$ ,3 /(,'))(') ,'$(3  )/$') )$'""'$%)"!""+'$811'/($('81() )/

%%'+(*'/() * +)$(++(+'$),'!+$ ,3 () /, &#+4!'$8') ")$(7+('$),'!4

!'3'1( )((199 01 (, +(%%%+(' 04()$ ,3 ()(!') 0+''!+$"#)+'!!"+!" 

& $(3 /$)! $+''!+(& )($#)($%%%+''!$,99/ 0 & ) * )4)++($+)(""$'1""+)& 

+''!/($ ")$( 7+( '$),'!   )""', 77)+' ) # %   )  (' "+( '/ / $/  1'/ $

* (,!"$) 0(+ +,() +3(%%','/!''& , $) #*'1  3 #*='!!,'$((($)

%!% ("$($ $(++(3  1 +0 %% ( "+')$('1(2(!)' ($$ ( 1"+')$('& "$!" 

* (,!"$) 0(+ +,() +3(1""+).%%% )(#)/")$$*)(" $& $)7#'$) / '3

+81() / *)(",(()+$%

"#)'$)3'+ &' %% ! (0$( &/(4 1 +/($ ! (0$( *8', +'!+  #+/ , )  &),'$(+

! '$)$(*#(/ ,'$)%



&'($#&

"#)*+'(,(()+(& +(' 04()! (0$('!+ #+/ ,'$(+(%

"#)*+'$( ,(()+(&  !'& +'!$ $('$!"# $ :)%+% -:  ,3') !"# $(+).%% "++($ )99+

8#)$($* #()$($!""$ 0'1"+')$(''! + ' +!'3 $ '/ /*+& !)$( ($$ ('3)((

 !'+",(()'+(4 !$ ""(/ !"3(* / &&(!"/$(!$ !''(/$*8'$)+$(!$% ( +( $8'/!')(

!")"++','$) +$) $'/ /) 3 $'$8'),99/ ()((/ ($$ ($ $%"+')$(' )"(($

$8')'$ *'', $(  !")"++')/ +80$ +) ,((+($) )/ $(+)$!"/4 ,'++( &#) "+' *3   #)

$8'/, (('3  !!!''((*1 '3 +)*8))4$8'/+)((!($!)(+3&"")7+() /($$8'),'(

%8')($

+)(""$'1""+),99/ 0 & ) * )$  )""',>77)(+>&($$""') /($, 99*')





 

1( )((+) , #  $8')($ !8* +)((+( (' '/ / 1"+')$(' )" (($ +''!/ $8'/ )"   (3%

$ ,3 ()%)")&#)'$%%%)"1( ) )'$''$)(& 1 $(*'+!')(3 &(+($8')($%

% +3( $(+3') $ &#'+( )(,  (!$',$) &  ,(()+$!"/ % % % * +'$ !'',(()+$")$$( & 

))*$ $(++(+ !'& $ "+(* )( *)(",(()+$( $( /$)'! 6 ; +$(+ ",  8'3$)( & 

!"#$)$)(3 4 ,'++(+( )  !  ++!'&  /'$% '',(()+$( !" $ !""$) $ % +3( %%'+(

((+',() )/ '!!,'$( (($) ''!+$$( /$( 6-. +3  +$(+ ")$$(&  , $ ! '$)$(!$

 # ) #*') #*'7#'!)$%"!""'%

"#)*+'( ,(()+(&  +(' 0 &#'//($ ''!+$(($!'&  6 = $))($)4 !$ " !'& $4 ()

$ ,3 ( )+(0 * $) * +) +''!+$"+!" +( /  8'3(+ & +4 !'/ ,'))( #'+&(, !' 

$(!/')(($8'/4, 99*'*8'1( ),'$( +$) ,'$)'38/($)4()$/ )+(0'/ ) 

!  $''$4 !' $8'/$/  (' ,/()  &  $8') +3 0 '3 +81(0 $'3(+ )((+4 '!!$ % %

''!+$$( /$(6-.+38/('/%

"#)'$)3'+&'!"#)*+'(,(()+(& ((+)""//$('$!"# &/(%



&&

"#$"++($))*/*)(" $& , )(& +'/(3 '3 !+ /,(()+$"$ +'$)($(+()$(/

+(' 04()! (0$!"#)*+'$(,(()+(& ")$$()7#'$) ,'$(!$! (0$($)""//18#&(/$)(+('

!+ #+/ ,'$(+(%

"#)'$)3' !'3$ )("$) )/ $7/,$!"#  * )+$($) &  $(++( !'3$ !""$) )/ $!((,'$)4

$ ,)' ,(()+$"$ +'$)( $(+()$)($) #)04 () .%%% % !(++  %. 1 '! &#)'$ %%

,"")"$8'/!')+''!/($,99/ 0 & ) * )7+( 3'& 99) * '$),'!($!') * 

$ $% 3'& 99) * '$),'!!7+() /($'3$""') /($, 99*')1( )((+)!8* +)((+(

, # $8')($4(''/ /%%$ ,3 ()%%%+''!$(3+((', ) ('+''3'+'$)()((/(3 

'$),'!+ !$ $8'/(($8'3$ "+' , )/ (($8'3$,!'/(3  !""$ +'$ )( )() #*+'3 

$8'/(($8'3$(3 +''!+(,'$(*8'1( )(($/%



($"+(* $ $& $ " ! (0$( ($') &  ($') / ! (0$( 18#&$(+4 !  +(' 04 ()

$ ,3 ()('1(  /, 4!'$8'/ /")$(7+('$),'!4!'3'1( )((199 01 (, +(4

$($)$ ,3 ()(!') 0+''!+$"#)+'!"+!" & $(3 /$)! $+''!+(& )($#)($%

"#$! (0$(($') & $(++'$($('$!"# 3 ('8$)%



+((* +)+''!+$(($!'&  

6$)=)+(0$ ,3 (* $) * +)+''!+$"+!" +( / 

8'3(+ & +4!'/,'))(#'+&(,!'$(!/')(($8'/4, 99*'*8'1( ),'$( +$) ,'$)%

 )+(,3 ( 1( 0 &)!,  , 99*' & + &  )+(0 +81() /  !"#( 1 $) , 99*')4

!(,3 /(*8'0+81() / * #()+)(($8'/ +$) ,'$)4, 99*')*8'1( ),'$)%

 6  +3 . $)($) 04 () , 99*' ++ ,8'$)() !$( '3 $3$) 199() *8' ,'$ ) #($

7,0(( $) ,'$)%5(+'!+))+(0$/ '/ ) (/()(3(*$)(((+! $''$4!'$8'/$/ 

(',/() & $8') +3 0'3+81(0$'3(+)((+%

/  )+(0 '/ )  '3  , 99*' ((+ !  $''$4 !' +''3) !$( '$),'!+ $/  ,)* +)

1( )((+)!8* )((+(%#)$$)('", $''&($ $& "+4()&#)+''30")$((3 $((4()) * 

',' (' ,)% "#$ +(' 04 () !8( +$(+ '$),'!+ !"!(()$(+ &#+ $ ,3 /(

/, ) &),'(  0* +('2") 3') * 1""+)$ ,)'1( )((+$!((,'+$ $$"0 & 

) * +( +''!* +( +''!+(& +(4 $( /($ )  !  "#)4 )(!') /($ +''!+$"#)+'! "+!" 4 !  $((

+''!+(& *8'0((+/ / 4()$/ ,'))(') *&#)+''301( )((+(/ $'$ 3  3') * +(%



(+)""/ +$(+ +(' 0 !"#$4 () .%%% % &#)'/($ ,"")"$8'/!') &  ,'))( '/ )($

$ ,3 () 1( )((+) !8* +)((+( $8')($4  1 ' %% )"',( )("4 ,'$ " !* +'2')$((') *

*)(" 6-.+3&3'& ,'$$('$($+''!+$(($!'& 6=8()('!!,'$($%)(3

" 8'3($)' !* +'2')$((')/ &  ! '$)$ *)(" (($) " , )/ $(++(!$ 1/(*  !"#)*+'$(





 

,(()+(&  1""+)%   6$ ; $)($) )/  *)(",(()+$) *+'$) * / $& "+/ )/

*)(" $& $1/* /%

"#$ $0$('$!"# +(4()*)(",(()+(,'$(+('"+(!"#)*+'$(,(()+(& 1""+)'!)/

*)(",(()+$8'3$) '3 ! '$)$( , ,'( ,(()+$ +$(+( '$'!+( " )"',/

!""$!8+ $! '$)$(!"# +/ ,'$( +$)(3 %

("$($ , )/ ! '$)$(3  ,3'0 !"#$ &3,'$)% '$)$( ,8'$),'$(+ *8' , ,'$(+

)+(0+#)/  6.+3!"# $(+)'$'!$77$)'3*8', +$($),8&) / $77/+ $)(/ $1'/'

#"'/, $77)(3/()"',(1 (,'$($)& 8'3$!" ! ')$,'$(#*'/($)% '$)$(, ,'$(+

)+(0 *($$( *8))  !(3(/ * '/ &   $!(/ * '/ $& "+$'/4 (/( 1/,'$(+ )+(0 3 

+#)/ $ !)$'""'!($!,'$($), $)%  !"#)*+'(,(()+(& ('"+(!(3(/ * '/(3 

 $!(/ * '/ $& "+$'/ )* $) / &  ('/ (' '+,(/ !  !"#),(()+$($4 " ! '$)$

, )/$ !)$'""'!($!,'$(,  .) #*'7#'!)$".!""'

+#(/ +(% "#)*+'$(

,(()+(& , )/! '$)$('"+($((3 7+(,  $!(%



 6 +3 $)($) 0  # ) #*' "$')' ) $,'$(!$ , ,'$( *8', +$( >,8&* )(+

18#&$)(+>%(++'$(!$,8&* !$18#&$(!$"((+!8'3($77/+ $(, & /$+'!*8',()$) $/ 

!" 3  !"3 ) #*'$,, % (++( ! +,'$(!$  0 ! #)+(, )  +$) $& "+4 ()

,(()+$ +( '$'! 81'0 '3 (' ",  17$'* ) $'$$()+(!)% *($) /($ $& "+4 () %%

!($"+(* + & +81'0& &#'//($ 6+3)($)& ,'++(3 , 0!"#$ # ) #*'

) #*'7#'!)  !""'

 "$')' ) $,'$(!$%  # ) #* )+(0 ) $/  ! #( ! &""!$+

*8/$()($"$ /($4$%"!""'!$%







%/($)

!"#)'!