Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-05-682\1 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:4.05.682.21770 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding asylum seeker's residence permit status. Appeal was rejected due to lack of new evidence and procedural errors by the appellant.

Case Number 4-05-682\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appeal filed by an asylum seeker challenging the refusal of their residence permit. The appellant argued that the lower administrative body failed to consider relevant evidence regarding their family ties and fear of persecution. The court ruled that the administrative decision was based on sufficient facts and that the appellant's new arguments did not alter the original legal assessment.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

AsylG 2005 s. 10; Sotsiaalkaitseseadus 2003 s. 10: An appeal against an administrative decision on residence permits is dismissed if the appellant fails to provide new evidence that would change the factual or legal basis of the original decision.

Keywords

AI generated
asylum seeker residence permit administrative appeal procedure burden of proof asylum family ties consideration persecution fear assessment

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AsylG 2005 s. 10
Sotsiaalkaitseseadus 2003 s. 10

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                             

  

   ! ! "

    # $ %! %  "  &      !   ' !! "  &       

   (  ) * ! +!    ,  -( . 

/ 0   (   ( 1   ! ! " 

 !   2 ! 33 45  !   !  ' !!   &  / 



       -(  . 

/ 0  

2 !  / 

      &  (  1   ! 33 

   44""33 !  ' !!  

( 66() 78  

 (!   5/ 5    

( !  !6   "

  55 4 

   5  ("3 &  34!  ' !! !( (-(        2 !  &

  5 (     &

        )   ( 

"/    5) 78 

 (!    ) 

 

( &   &    5  "      345 (  " ( 5  &

    5   :  )   ( 

  (       6   (  &

 ;( 0$5  !"2 -% ! ") !  1 -  5 0! . & 5    5  / (   )   &      5  

  

( &  5  (" !  5 

 ( (      !

(' !!  66  ( 5   )   &     

" 33 34  &

5    ; 4/      / ( ;(  !  7  (&

 )  (    &

 5 0!   (&

"

(/ (  (  1

     :  )   )  :   (     :     2   ! "        "  

  / " (  !

"        :     5    / (   (  7  )      5    6  "   5        : 

  1

    -% !   5 

(  5()  !  ; !  /   " 5   ;(  !   .  /    1

   $5  ! )     ;(  ! /  " 5  5 0! /  6 (  )  / 

 (  6  " ' !!   (!  / ( 5 5(   : (   7 ! ( (  &

  )   (   ((

! 5 ()6 (  " 5  (& "  (

 5 "  (   (    ' !!  

! ("  ( "   ' !! 

66(    5    ((6 (           

      ! "  #$  ! #   %  !  &       &  ! 6  (6  "   &

 5   "5 !&/   <7(= 34"5( ! 5   !   5  5(; ! /      :  ! " !

  !    (   (        > !(  ("   :   ((/ (    "  #$   6   5 "     &

  5     "   

    : " 

 /  7    (' !! ";(  !  !6     !  ( ' !!   : 1

   -   ' !!      (  ( 

 )    : "      !  ' !!  6  "   ( ! (  ! 



      &   6   5 "      &

  5 (    1

 



( ' !! " ;(  ! " 5 0!  )6    "  (  2 ( !

("    ! 



1

      : )  &  ( )   5 /     ( ' !!     ( ! ( &

   ( .    ' !! /  (          '     " 6  "  33 5 &  ::

   !    5  ? &  



 6  "   &

 5    5  5  ' !! !  0 -    /! &

5   7(/   .   ; 4   (&

' !! " 5 0!  ;(  ! 5  &

 

1

    5  ' !! "   / " 5  6 5  /    5   !

 < ( /  ! 55   ("  =     &

 5 0! " /    /    (    !

 &

     ( ;(  !  

 / ' !!  5 0! /( ((&

 6      &

 ( 6  "    ! ( !

   6  "   5 ::

5        !  ; !  /    ) /(( ( ! ( 5 5      :    ' !!  5 0!  5  

 "  ( (5  

(  (  ! &"  (/  )

 (  &

      " !  &" ' !!     ( & ( 5 5(  

 ( (   .   ! &"    &  :    )    ! ( (    6  (" 5    ( !  5      %(  " 6  " 33  3/   &

5 (  ;  4 /    ( &

 ' !!  &    9

( 5   / ( )  :  )  6   / ("5/  ( ( (  ! 5 "!( (( 5  ( 

 &

   " ( (    / ( ' !!   5    5 

 (    ! @    )  ! 6  " 33 &

5 (   7(/      )    1

       "  (   ! (" 

 ( 

(  )    ! ( ( 2   $ !( ! " '   ) !    91 

!  6  ("  



( 6  "   ! ( ' !!     :  &

(  ! ( (   " ! "!

 

5   ) (    &     " 5   

 " / 

  (  "   ("  ( !    5   "     & ! 5 "  

    44""33 &  

     6 ( " !  ' !!  ( /(&) 78 

 ( !         &" !  ' !! / (33   &

 5     34   5  ("5    / (("!( ((&

       )   ( 

"  ' !! / ( 5  () 78 @      &"   ! 5     66 ( ( 6  "    

6(5    ("   ( 6  /   ("   ( &

      ( )   6  "   ' !!  !  ( " 5(    &

  $5  ! )(

  5   6 ($5  !6  " ' !!   &    

! 5  )  " !( ( ( 5  ( 

 &

    2( 6  (     

(  )  6         ' !!  66(  !  

5/ 5  @      &"      6  ("   ( 6  (    5     

5    A ) !(  1 " (  ;(  ! " 2  -% ! " -   5 0! " > !    > !"(   5 6(    &        !

(  // 5  "     )   ! 5        " ' !!  ( (!    (@     &" / 

 (  /( ("   6 (   ( (5

(  &

    

 (6  ( ( ! (" (  )   ( 6  (  "    ( &

 5     "5           (" !&

  ("   &

 ! )(&

 / ( 5 5( ! ( &

  (!(   :      .   

()  ! (" ' !!     !   &    (    & / 



  6 ( " 5   7 8 B  3 / 3   / (   C (  "(( 78(3434 "      "  *         )  +,-,.-.++/-     .00+!+/!+,+,++  !    12.3,*, 4* -  ) 

  !&   ( 

  &  ;  4 /!   

 

 ! 5 /!       (   

   5      /!  

   ! 5 /!     ! !  )          D