Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-05-279\2 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:4.05.279.19436 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding deportation of foreign national based on public order grounds.

Case Number 4-05-279\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Court of Appeal dismissed the applicant's appeal against the first-instance decision ordering their deportation. The applicant argued that the deportation violated their right to family life and was disproportionate given their long-term residence. The court held that the administrative authority had correctly assessed the risk to public order and security, finding the deportation necessary and proportionate under the relevant law.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Section 10 of the Aliens Act; Section 11 of the Aliens Act: The court established that deportation of a foreign national is permissible when there are substantial grounds for believing they pose a danger to public order or security, provided the measure is proportionate to the individual circumstances.

Keywords

AI generated
deportation order public order grounds proportionality test family life rights Aliens Act provisions

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Section 10 of the Aliens Act
Section 11 of the Aliens Act

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



        

             !"    

  #$%& '$(          &)") (&)*       *%* (   &)     + ),-*"../"+")" 0 ' 123                        /4 &+"),)5)+(, &+") "  *"+6)&* +")(+-$  ! "#   $$  

   

     %&  '()(           

   '()(    

*+ , & 

      +"") ,)&) (76 )"+/ &+)" +"") 2++)"%") ,2)("+  ,2)( 1 "& )6")  *3  !+&) (  !+%1 /8 +)+/)" )6") )"+%")"+ ))&*)(&+ (  !+%1&)9,2)(1 "&$  -         $:$  "++/4 &+"),)5)+(4 &+") " */, &+ & "+*/+  ),-*"!+)"(22+) , +  &&*9# '#$),-*"../"++")")&&)"8)++ #$:$  )&&9$#,.!")&%"/)""&8(6/)"(&" !"8"(& /+*3"



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