Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-7032\4 ECLI:EE:TMK:2006:1.06.7032.20602 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against conviction for theft, upholding original judgment on evidence sufficiency.

Case Number 1-06-7032\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the defendant's appeal against the first-instance conviction for theft, rejecting the claim that the evidence was insufficient. The prosecution presented witness testimony and physical evidence linking the defendant to the stolen goods, while the defense argued the identification was unreliable. The appellate court found the lower court's assessment of the facts correct and the evidence legally sufficient to support the conviction.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Criminal Procedure Code § 329; Criminal Procedure Code § 330: An appeal against a conviction is dismissed if the appellate court finds that the lower court's assessment of the evidence was legally sound and the facts were established beyond reasonable doubt.

Keywords

AI generated
criminal appeal theft conviction insufficient evidence appellate review burden of proof witness testimony criminal procedure

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Criminal Procedure Code § 329
Criminal Procedure Code § 330

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

       

             

  !"!!#$%&'()  

     *+,"-   ./ /0&/((&1        #. '&  0&20$ '  

   //1# /. 330/   40&,,1%5+)67+67+61% )8%/1&55&(&.&1 &   /.&9&&      //1# /.   /0 :::::::::::7  &1 :::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::::: 100 '/ (/  ' &(/  ; /(/.1)'88& /  50<     .0&0' .9/(&   !"   #  $%&   &  '   ($)*           

+% &   &  '   ()$* $           

,% &   &  '   ($-- ./)0*           

$

 %  (,) $                &  '  1      $

 $$

 

 %   ( 2)   .                  ,  %   ( ,*                         

 

    &   '  1    

   /   0%$3%

  .33,% %  (2) $0. 4       $

  +       /  0 &  '     .

    /                     ( 2+          /     # $%     /         555555555555555555555555555556 .%     

     

     

       6 4%    

                                  6 )% 

   

               $+/ 6 +% 

   

       70 7 //         &  '       (2+ ./$              

         4$%  .332% 0   

     

  .33,%  433%7         %  &   '            8  &

  

    7'          /  

 

       %  .% &     &   '  1         )+33%7 %               $3..334)*333$20    .*333)-*2) 9    : / 

% 8        

  43 /         % 8              /          %  4% &     &   '  1          $+.3%7    

   1  /       %            

         $3..334)*333$20    .*333)-*2)9  : / 

%8       

  43 /         % 8               /                %  )%&   &  '  1     /    +,,+%7  % /        

 

         $3..334)*333$20    .*333)-*2)9  : / 

%8       

  43 /         % 8               /                %  +% &     &   '  1  .++3%7   ;       %  ,% &     &   '  1  433%7       /   %  2% &     &   '  1  $+3%7   <   '   %  *%<  '  1             7    /0 / /0   0   = / 0     > ?  @0 ,

    / 0

    /   



0     / 0 / 0   0 /   0    0        /0      /     $30     0     0   >0  /0

 7   7      / 0   0   /0  0      

0 

 /  /  7    

   <  '   

 %  -%  &   1              7    7               &   1  

 %  $3% & 

   '  1                7 /   0  0    / 

    

   /     

   / 7           & 

   '  1 



 %  $$%;   9   1             7     0 $+           /   7            ;       

 %  $.% &   '  1               7/  0  /0   0           .0  0     / 0

  0   0  0 

  /  / //   7           / >   '

 /    0        

   &  '  1  %  $4% &   '   1     

    

 +       &  '  1  

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

  &&%&(/ &1)/.0<  40& ,1%1)+7+7+7+61%15+7+,!  ./G11//G 

9E  /0&/((&1./