Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-5044\7 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:1.06.5044.19017 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against conviction for illegal possession of firearms and ammunition under Estonian Criminal Code.

Case Number 1-06-5044\7
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Pärnu Court of First Instance dismissed the defendant's appeal against his conviction for illegal possession of firearms and ammunition. The court found that the defendant knowingly possessed prohibited weapons without a license, despite his argument that the items were for hunting purposes. The court ruled that the evidence was sufficient to establish the criminal intent and lack of legal justification required for the charges.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Criminal Code § 140; § 141: The court established that possession of firearms and ammunition without a license constitutes a crime regardless of the alleged hunting purpose, provided the defendant had knowledge of the items' nature and prohibited status.

Keywords

AI generated
illegal possession of firearms criminal code provisions prohibited weapons hunting license requirement criminal intent established appeal against conviction Estonian criminal law

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Criminal Code § 140
Criminal Code § 141

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                    

              !"               

 !" #$%$& ' (!  

"  !" #$%$&)##)#&   * +!     #$ "%& %''%"   &

( )**+ ,, "- -.&/ /0  //  " & 0  )  12    ,   "  - -.&  %1 ,  1" & 0/) 1/*3 "- -./ " & 0 )  3 "     - - .         /  " &   , - '' &  / 3 " 0)/ 3 "- $ .&  , ""  0)// 3 " - $.&  , " "    1%"   " &&"4$" "    !  &5 %& &%'' %"   &  

()/13 "- -.&/ /0 /  /  " &     &6    0 )/3 "- -.& %/ %%/,1

 " & 0/)13 " - -.&1 %/ %%/,1 " & 0 ) 1/3 "- -..& ,/ %%/  " &        , 0 ) 1/ 3 "     - - .& /     %%/%    ,  1        "  0)/$ - -./ %%/ " & 1)*$ - -./  %%/      " &     /% "      " &&""3 &  ,   $66&  & # $ " - $ .     & % 1% * ,  , 7  /&" % &" &&- $./* 6   &"7

-  & &"   -   &  $66&  & !  & 5  - $ .     & % 1% * ,  , 7   &"   $66&  & !  & 5  - $ .      ,  , 7    &"   $66&  & !  & 5  - $ . *    ,  , 7    &"   - $./ ,  & /" % &" &&- $ ./* 6  &"7

-  &"   -    " " /    % " "  8  &     &    & * " "   -   &  27 &"  ,#$ ",!  &5     , 7#$ ",!  &5 &     +! ,!   , 7#$ "*   $"9, ":  , 7#$ "  $ , &  , 7#$ "  # $   , 7!  &5  %1  !  

 , 7!  &5 /        , 7 # $ "      &    & ; &      "& "

 / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   % %  

% 7& & )  , 7 !  & 5       &    & ; &      "& "

 / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   % %  

% 7& & )  , 7# $ " / %1     7      & ; &      "& "

 / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   % %  

% 7&,)  , 7!  &5 /%  7    & ; &      "& "

 / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   % %  

% 7&,)  , 7 !  & 5  /1        & ; &      "& "

 / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   % %  

% 7& )  , 7 # $ " *          ,& , &  &    & ; &      "& "  / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   %% % 7&)  , 7 !  & 5  *          ,& , &  &    & ; &      "& "  / *1% "    *  < %    &  &   %% % 7&)  , 7      " &&" 4 $" " '' 7    %/    , 7   " &&""3 &''7    %/    #7 &&6 ,&  &"&  # 7    "   &      ,  , 1 " ,%   "7  "  

 #  "7  &  , 2         ,&",%"%     "7 "&   $ & %7  % %   ,&, & & "7  &   ,7  6  , - &    & , , &% &   &   ''     - &"  7  "  "6 ",     $66&"&#$ "%  "      & "  , !5   ,"          &  7 -"- 6+!"= , " &>    &? @  9%   /  % >    &? @  9     1   %   #        %        # 

   *   % "   A !B       % ",A!B     %       % "       %   

  9C       %  6  6 C C         %  &  

      % 7        %  & 

      % 

     /   % 7   & 

      %     D 

  /  %      %    ,    &  ,         %  ,    "           %               %     ,      *   %   @      *  %,        %/,         1   % / ,            % ,         //   % 1,         /*   % ,         /*   % /,            %  ,      77&  

         %  ,      77&  

         %  ,      77&  

      /1   %  &     &       /1  %B&     %E 66"7 &      %'' &&;D  %   ,? @  9%  #% # )%         %2    

      % &,       %    

      % 1 &       /   % &        % &     1   % /          %         %"     %       % ''         %         %         %   , "     

   %  , "       % /           *   % /              %     %1     %         % &   1  %"7     /  %/             %          1  %,        %/ 6           % "&     /   %"       %  ,$ "%  &  ,   ,         % / &" ,        %66 ,     %  1

      %"&     %       &      /   %             %            % &     /   %  7       % *  &      1  %*"7 

7          % /          %    & 

   /*   %   , &    1   %   ",&% /           11   %    ,

    %F     *  %         1   %    7        1/   %             *   %       &           %     :      *1   %      "          %       "          %     B     %    -,

     % ""         %    " &  &   /   % " >"

      % %  "    & & "&       %2G&  &   /  % 2&

    %   F"      % H?  $        +!I"  ,

/11    $66&" #$ "%  "      & " % ,"  /* /*/ "77 ",  "7    &        # " & 6   $"9, ":I"" ,,   "   "   "        %  "      %*          % 2  "  "7        %          7&      1   %        &      , 7 " "  %  "  6        7   /    # $ "" ,/  ,7       $66&" #$ "%   "      & " % ,"  *      **  *     "77  ",  "7   &    3 "3 "3   6        $ ,  &I " " ,,

  "           &       %

  

        %        % 7        % &        % ''"

      %  J" 6       % 7        %                    % ,  $        %

"     1   % "       %

@       %       /   % 7 "  "      %     &  ,7 ""& %" &&, "  "  "  "&% %  , & &   #$ "  " ,  %" , 7      $66&"&#$ "%"    &" %,!5  1*     & "77  ",  "7    &       7 "    &    -  "   & 6 " +  " ,    " &     &   "      %    " ,%   , 7 "    %&"     % ,    "      %   "      % ''     "      %  & , "    "     %, "    %" &"      % &%  % " ,"    %" 

 "    %  &"     % " && 6  "   /   %         7 "      %  "    % "     , "  ,&  &     " ,    $66&"#$ "%"    &" %," /*      &- "+6"#  $ I"    ''&&"    " ''    " "

       , &&  6  6, "    "        %"7  &,          "  , /    , 7       $66&"#$ "%"    &" %    ",  6 4   

   7 ",  "   D  -   7& F & C 

        11#>?    66&  " &   &  C "      % 7  9C "   1   % 7    2$  "    % J "         

   " & 7&    66& " &   " "    "     & &6  "  /   ;6  &/  )%" "  "    

 &     "    ;  &/   )%&" ,7" D-   7  $66&" !5 %   "      & " %       " ""  &       "    &  "7  6 !   "7      ,;/    "    *     ,      "      )% & !   ,        

     &

 &  &  , /        

 &

  , 1 ,    "" &  

 ,% ,       7,  $ 66&66&"&#$ ",!5 - $.  & %1%*, "@ "      $66&"!5 "& & 2 

        ,   &   && / , " &  %  1  7   "   &   ,   &     &&         &            , "7   D   " 

!5 "&.   %"&   &   %    ,   @ %./  

  "&@66 " 7     &  ,. % "7   &"&%  "   $ 66&66&"!5 - $. * , "@ "       $66&"!5 "& &  2      && 

 6 % &6"&, 1 

,6  6     & ", ,6 6   &&   & 7  , , "7&    D   "   !5  !7  ,& .      %   %    "&7  ,  7 7  ,  ,&   $ 66&66&"!5 - $.   , "@ "       $66&"#$ "   &66&  $66&"!5    &66&  -  %  66&" #$ " , !5   +!   "      7 & & &

 $6 & "  % & %@    "%-"- 6 +!  &  7   -  +! ,!    &6 %" &,&   ,  "%,"     7    & -  "  , "  7 66& && &  !     %   6 & ""7    % 7 & "   % @        "%#$ "&%#,"7 !  "& &(

 %&,%  &%& %7%    %  %   

 & &,  %&" &% & &%   , "%   %  &     & , "7 

7  % &   %   %  % 6%     $66&"#$ ",!5 6 %6  

  % @      "%  66&"& ,"  &- "+! ,!    " &66&&& &  $66&" #$ " , !5      &&   7 """&,&&"&  $66&"&#$ ",!5  66"7 &,&"&  &66& ""&,&  -         66&"&  #$ " , !5   &    + , !  "  ,  /1    -     &  &" & &

/%1 -  & +3!"&66&"", 7&,

    ,7  &, $66&"&#$ ",!5  "  "  "&% & "7"&  %  &  "  &,7 &  &     && 

& $    66&" #$ ",!5 & ", 7      +! ,!   -  %  66&" !5   7    

  ,"      7 & & &  $6 & "  / %  %@    "%  7     &      ,% 

      & 7        &  &%/%, 

,"7          "%  7        !    -  !     &6  "%"        / 6  /  "   %    "  & &  % "7&/    %

7 &&  2 , -  6 % 6       / % @      "%  /    , 6 -& -& % ,  & 7  &   !  ,& "& ,

&"  -  -    , %   ,    2   ,     "  6 & 

  / % @  %

  ,"  */  "%-"7     ," */ ,1 ,    2 , -" = &  6     "%  /  &   , ''&2 ,"&  ,   2 ,          ", "& %   7 

"$C % &&   7,       K @& ,    &      1/     "%   , -= &   &   @& !5 %   &

''     "  6 & 

  // % 7 & "   / %","7  D /%    L   "% ,-= &   /  &    L!     7   %!5     2 , # &  + &   6     "%   "%  7  6        " %    "    ,,  ,  %    "&

  "7& &% , %  "   $66&"!5 6  "% "  

  &   &  7   

  ,%/   ,   7

  / % 7 & "    / %

   L% ""   7  "77  &     /  "%!5 "7   L, ""  7 "77  &   

$66&" !5      &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"!5  66"7  ,&"& 66&""&,&  -         66&" !5   &    !   "  ,   %1    */    , 6 & ""7   "  1  %    & &

  ,%  /%     66& D< 36

       %        , 6 & ""7   "    %    & &   ,%  %    % %   &%1%  %1%/1 6& 66&D<36

     *1/%1   D< 36

 1    %  "

    "      ,  & 

  & /     & , & *1/%/     $   "   D< 36

  &  %1     $  ,    !     %1  &, "     -  !   66&"", 7 , & %1  $66&"!5 " ""&%"7  %    , &  %1  &, "  $    66&"  !5  ", 7   %1      !    -         66&" !5   &       ,  /         " 7      &         *1  KK  &    %*  ,  "   &     K  &  

  & % ML-        /  *1  KK  &          " &  , 

  & 

  %  ML  &   %  "  "&   &% %* %  ML  7 & %  &  "&

  & ,  

 & $     , 

 /     7      & % /% %     

 & & & & , &"&     -          7

 &# " "& &   7      & % /% %  , & ,&    %    7     &%/%% &   ,   ,

1 %  ", "& &.  &   *    *  1 ,  -         &, #" $     66&" ", 7  , /    $66&" !5  " ""&%"7  %   &   & , 

 /    $    66&"  !5  ", 7 /       -  %  66&" #$ "  $9, ": " , "       7 & & & 

$6 & "  /*%@   "% &  6 " $9, ": " ,,     & ,"  /*/*          -  $ ,9, ":6  "%," / /*     &   " ,, &  6 ,     " & 66&&& &  2 ,3& 6  "% *=  ''&&" " " %  $ & ''& = &  $66&" #$ " 6 % 6 ,      %@   "%66&"#$ ""  ,"  //* &  6 $9, ": " , 66& && &  $66&" #$ "     &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"  #$ "   66"7   , &"&   66& ""& ,&  -         66&"  #$ "  &    $9, ": "  ,  /    -    $9, ":   66&"", 7&,

/ ,7  & ,  $66&"#$ "" ""&%"7  %    "  & , 7 &  &     && 

& $    66&" #$ " ", 7  *       $9, ":  -  %  66&" #$ "  $ & " , "       7 & & &  $6 &  "   **% @  %       "%  ,"  ***          &3  6"$ &" ,,  $     **%    $ & 6     "%  ,"  ***          & 3   6 " " ,,   " &   66& && &  $66&" #$ " 6 % 6 ,      % @      "%  ,"  ***          3   6 " " ,,   " 66&&& & 

$66&" #$ "     &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"  #$ "   66"7   , &"&   66& ""& ,&  -         66&"  #$ "  &    $ & "  ,       -    $ &   66&" ", 7 & , 

     , 7   & ,    $66&" #$ " "  "  "&%  "7   %    "  & , 7 &  &     && 

&$  66&"#$ "", 7 1    $ &  -  %  66&" #$ " , !5   +   "      7 & & &  $6 & "  1*%@   "%  1*     &   & 6 " +   7 "    &      "& ,,&  ", , &%   + "  9,   % &+ "& ,&  -   +  6     "%       & 6   1*   & 7 "    &   , " & 66&&& &  2 , #  D,  6     "%  1*   4

 ",, %+  ,,  7&%   &  < ,%   2  +  2 ,&6  , !5 $,  2      , , & -   & "  &&   3  &+ &"7&,&  2 ,  -&  -  , <  -6 6     "%  & &4

 ",%# D,  & &"  !5 % #$ "-

    ,

 7&  2 , @ ! 6     "%  1* 4

  ",    !5  ,#$ "%  " &  %     &,  $66&"#$ ",!5 6 %6, 

  1% @      "%   &  1*  &  +     & 6 7 "    &   " &66&&& & 

$66&" #$ " , !5      &&   7 """&,&&"&  $66&"&#$ ",!5  66"7 &,&"&  &66& ""&,&  -         66&"&  #$ " , !5   &   + " ,  & &   &     &"   -  %  66&" #$ "  #$   & "       7 & & &  $6 & "  1%@  %    "%  ,"  /*       + 6 "#$  "    -  # $ 6  "%," /*       + 6 "   "   ," 66&&& &  #$   , % 7 & "    % @     "%#$    &" &

   $66&" #$ " 6 % 6 ,      *%@   "%," /*  

 &  + 6 "   "   ," 66&&& &  $66&" #$ "     &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"  #$ "   66"7   , &"&   66& ""& ,&  -      66&"#$ " &  #$  "  ,      -   #$    66&" ",

7 & , 

    , 7   & ,   %  , "& &  7&& &    & ,    $66&"  #$ " "  "  "&%  "7   %    "  & , 7 &  &     && 

& $    66&"#$ "", 7    #$   -  %  66&"#$ "D-   ,  "      7 & & &  $6 & "  %@  %    "%  ,"      ,  6 4  



   " D-   7&    11 #>? 7 ", "   -  D -  6  "%    ,  6 4   

   " D-   7&    11#>?7 "," ,66" &,  

   66& &&  &% &    , 7 "    "  7  2 , #    6     "%   %  D-   &    "  &   6 %     " #$ "   4     4 #F- &  &,&  "    $66&"#$ "6  "%66& " &  " D-    ,  

   66& && &  $66&" #$ "     &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"  #$ "   66"7   , &"&   66& ""& ,&  - %66&"!5    &    7 & & &  !     % 7 & "   1% @   "%!5 &2   ,"7 /, "&    $66&" !5  6     "%    &  "    & 2       &   && / , "&        29/ L*     "%   &'' &&,6&  1&   & 7   "    # &  &  &    &  & & "&  D  "  !5 "&. %  %  "&    &   %    ,   @ 0./  %   "&@66 "  7     & ,. % "7   &"& %  "   $66&" !5      &&   7 " ""& ,&&"& 

$66&"!5  66"7  ,&"& 66&""&,&  -  %  66&" !5   7  ,  &    7 & & &  !     % 7 & "   1% @   "%!5 &2   ,"7  6   $66&" !5  6     "%    &  " &2    &  &&6       #!/1/L*     "%    &  & "     ,6   6   $  6  7   D  "  !5 !7  ,&.  &% %    "&7  ,  7 7  ,  ,&   $66&" !5      &&   7 " ""& ,&&"&  $66&"!5  66"7  ,&"& 66&""&,&  $66&"#$ ",!5      &66  $66&"#$ "     &" ,& - $ . 1 ,    ,  & ,& 6"   -   &"& ,& &"&- $.*,   $66&" #$ "   "    &  

    

 , 6 6 

" 

 

 7& "&7   "       &      &  "        & $    #$ "  & , &  & -  & & 66&" #$ "  &     -   &      & ,&    & !& & , 7 

   "&%  %66&"#$ "  &"      &     7     -  "   ,%  #$ "6&    $66&" !5      &" ,& - $ . 1 ,     ,  & ,& 6"   -   &"& ,& &"&- $.*,   $66&" !5    "    &   

    

 ,  

" 

 

 7& "&7 $    !5  "     7 "7 & -  & &

66&" !5   &

    -   &      & ,&    & !& & , 7 

   "&%   %  66&" !5     & "     &  7        7   &    " &&" 4$" " 7        ,

(     "   /  0           *   - 1*  %   &   *N%/%/    7  & " &&"3 &7  

   ,

(     "   / 0        * -1* %  &    *N%/%/      - (