Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-4719\2 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:1.06.4719.19013 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against criminal ruling regarding illegal detention of a foreign national without legal basis.

Case Number 1-06-4719\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Pärnu County Court dismissed the appellant's appeal against a final criminal ruling regarding the unlawful detention of a foreign national. The appellant argued that the detention lacked legal justification and violated fundamental rights, while the prosecution maintained the measure was necessary for public order. The court rejected these claims, finding no evidence of procedural errors or substantive illegality in the original decision.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Criminal Procedure Act § 100; Criminal Procedure Code § 240: A criminal ruling regarding coercive measures is final and binding unless proven legally flawed; appeals against such rulings are dismissed if the original decision was based on sufficient facts and correct legal reasoning.

Keywords

AI generated
criminal procedure appeal illegal detention foreign national rights public order measure final criminal ruling

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Criminal Procedure Act § 100
Criminal Procedure Code § 240

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

      

                   

    

     

           !"" "#   " !$%    "     &$""      ! &  " '   

(' )) '    * " "   +&  "    

( )) ' , " "     "-,   !" - (( !$%%(.." #$   % &'

% &      ( )*) +       %   '

 % 

 ),-    ./0 )1+-,+*--/)1+))+*--/        #$   

   $          2    % &   '

 % & 2 $      +

            '

 % & 2        #     $   # (*-* /           +           !  ,("  " /   !$%01 2 "  %    ! & "  ( (   "" .0 ""   

 "  .  "  3  1   ))  "#  "" " " &"" " "2" #   (. ( 4 " ,".""22" &"         " /" (   "(,/. ""#&" 2 $2""#! & ," "" "  ",""" ""2" #   ( ( 4 " ,"!&" 2"  #  2 ( "   ! & 2 "",# &" "2    ( 4 " ,"#/ &"2  "  &" "   /   $2" &" " 2    (   (  2 ,4 " ,",( ! &     ))  )) " .      "   &"   (  (  " 2"   "   "   /$2"#  &""  ! &  ( " # ( 2

.""22"

  / &"   5" .   " ( (

 ",

"  (

  " ,  $  "  ! &  "" . " 1 " 31 "   " ( /  +&  " ""       ( 4 "  ,,"( "     ("  "

" &" "    (   " "       (   &"       (,,""# ( " (.   !  & &""  "     ,"  "  2" ,#  !  &   "" " " 2     #   &"  2    (   ,   # 2 (  &" " 4 "  ," 2 ,,"(    2    "",  ( "   





   $    

 

       

 $    2 3 

  ()*)  + & 6"  (    ( "" .     " 1 "  3  1  "   "   "# "" " &" "    ("  " "    (. # 2 (  ,  "  " ,,"(   " "       (. "" 22" &" "   " 2 ((     + &  # 2    ,  &""4 " ,",,"(2  (  "2 "!&"    2"     (4 " ,,""#  " (   &"   !  &      &"  "      ,"  " ,# &""2   #  &"  ,   



           

 4 $   2 $  



    2 3 

  ()*)        $ $#      )   " " .""  "  ""  ( ,    "# ( # 2((  ( 2 ".( 2    (/," " ,.  2# ". ( ,( " ( "(  "(# " ((   "(  " ))( 2

" ! 2

   )  "    .  ( ,   



 /  "" "# (!$%2      !   "( .   )  "   # 2((.  " .  ,"   2 "  (. ,"  ( ".! & 2+&   " ,/( (   . "( #  ""  "#   2  )

"  "(  "(  "  ))   !        ".  ""  "/"#  "   /! & "2+ & "      2

""(  " ))( (        !