Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-06-1748\1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:4.06.1748.19487 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against ruling on criminal record verification for foreign national seeking asylum. Foreigner argued for record check; court denied based on lack of legal basis. Appeal rejected due to procedural error in original ruling. Court held no statutory duty to verify criminal records for asylum seekers. Keywords: asylum seeker; criminal record; verification; appeal; procedural error; foreign national; legal basis.

Case Number 4-06-1748\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appeal against a ruling that denied the applicant's request to verify criminal records. The applicant, a foreign national seeking asylum, argued that verifying criminal records was necessary for assessing his case. The court rejected this argument, stating there is no legal obligation to verify such records for asylum seekers. Consequently, the appeal was dismissed as the original ruling was procedurally correct and legally sound.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 AsylG 2005; s. 10 AsylG 2005: The court established that there is no legal obligation to verify criminal records of foreign nationals seeking asylum.

Keywords

AI generated
asylum seeker criminal record verification appeal procedural error foreign national legal basis

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 AsylG 2005

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

            

                          

     ! "          # 

$       

% "    &# '(! (#) #(*'

"( +(,-. *    ## # // ( # #" (+

#( 

(      ! !      " #   01 23 (" # 20 '( " #( ! (4( #

  ! " !" #( .    

#(# " #(.# ) # 5(" -6#(* ) #( .    6363-  !           $ % &''    

 &( )  7 (+( #(0" $  & (# "5 + ("('(" #( ! (4( #

 ! "!" #( .    (# .   (# # (#( 7"( +( '(" #( ! (4( #

 ! "!" #( .   "(  # +  &#  '(! (#8  "    #+

## +  '* "   &''%   ''''(" #( ! (4( #

 ! "!" #( .    (# .. 9' !" # ! ": 6 % , 6 "*  "("  #((5    ( 77+" ( +# (  (# .. 3   )

((  "   #+ .  (#  +    # # # ( '(" #( ! (4( #

 ! "!" #( .  +   #   ( ! &'(! (#; "(.  ## #

"(  !     !   ( !( "( )< 5 ( # +    (5(  !()  . " ) #(  ( ##( (#   # ! " # ..  .<#5(""(#(*( (#   !

  -6 #(*  ) #( .    6363-  #  & '(! (#; "(

#(  '

"( +(,- "("  # )  # ) 7 #3 + )<"* # +(  "(#.<#6       #( ((#" "* # # 66. # # #( +( ##(# (# #+66  )<"*  ## #

) #)<#"((  " +3 ) "+ # # # #( #(& (#" (( + (#(66 -6 +(#+)  (")<  )("+ #" (#

( #  !  3 )<"* " # !+5 -6   +(#+ )   (" )<  )("+ #" (#

( # => =(#  ? !      )<"*  ## #

 ) #)<#"    +(#+ '( " #( ! (4( #

"( ) "+ (+

#(( # (   (#  + (#("()<"* ( #//#  ## #   # "" + )<"*  )  "( "  * # ""( #( + "() #(" + (#(" !+5 )<"* ") )< ( "((""() # 7"" "+ ( # )  ( " ((

(* #( ) + " + ## # ! "5(("#+ "(". . ++(,#"*## +   # )  (+ (  +    &'(! (# +  # #* "7#" 3(#< (+ (#  +     "( + 3(# ## #

 ) "+#"(5 "+ + %,"* "("3 #(# 53(#

 # ) (+ # ( (# * 

### #)  ## #

 ) "+( "(") # ) "# ,"(   77+" (( "(  # ) #( )    #+## . # +)<  # #+  # )  ( ## (* ( . * # 3  # ) # # (## (* ( "(! (+ #+. 77+" ("( "() 3 ""("(

(<(#!// # % # ) "# ,"("*) # 57 !() (#  7 ("(# ) 7 "(3((*     ("(  # ) "() # 5 (# !()  =("#+ "(". . ++( ,"*333,"*!3,"*3%,"*   3(#  #+. #  #   # )#"(5 (+ +  (# *    

0 ""

0 #    

< *(