Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-4243\8 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:1.06.4243.17470 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal regarding refusal to grant bail for a suspect accused of murder.

Case Number 1-06-4243\8
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Haapsalu Court of First Instance dismissed the defendant's appeal against the refusal of bail. The court found that the suspect, accused of murder, posed a significant flight risk and danger to society, outweighing the presumption of innocence. Consequently, the court upheld the lower court's decision to deny pre-trial release.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

KrimProtsseadust 109 §; KrimProtsseadust 110 §: The court may refuse bail if there are substantial grounds to believe the suspect will flee or pose a danger to society, overriding the general presumption of innocence.

Keywords

AI generated
pre-trial release flight risk assessment danger to society bail refusal murder suspect

Cited Legislation

AI generated
KrimProtsseadust 109 §
KrimProtsseadust 110 §

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



























 

















 

 





 !"#  $%

 





  

&'#'("()

 

*+

 

  

%

 



 

*'

,%

--.*

 

/

("(

01

%,$$,!,,*%,



1,%%,!

 





   ! "! 2 ,%* 34 . 34 34

. 34 ,!,,% 3 ,,%4 34 ** ' !% 

.**.5&6") ,$*,!7%&8,'$%*

/&)%1"$&0"%,%*91::4!**.

") &" "";"6: *7%":+<1,9$%* /&%1"

$(0$=%,%#91*,1*1!*,01&=. 

*,!,,*%,**.&:.5&6& & &#

%%%%0,%,9%9,$%* > /(%1"%,%

*91)4!**.&# & &# ;"6"" & &8

%%$%* > /&#%1&%,%*91&:4

!**." & &8;)6: = &=

%%$%* > /

&# %1 & %,% *91 & 4  !  **.

&# ( &;(6&# ( &

%%%%0,%,9%9,

$%* >  / &# %1 & %,% *91 ": 4 ! 

**. &# ( &; :6 # : "

%%  %%0,%,9%9,

$%* > /#%1"%,%*91(#4

!  **. &( ) ""; #6 ") : "

%% 

%%0,%,9%9,  $%* >  / && %1 " %,%

*91 (# 4 !  *!*; 86 8 = "& 0

$%* > /&&%1"%,%*91:)4!

**.&: && "&;=6"& " ""

%%$%* > /&:%1

& %,% *91 #  4 !  **. : ) ""; 6



= = ""

%%  %%0,%,9%9,  $%* >  /

&#%1&%,%*91)4!**.#  "";

&6"8 = ")

%%<0$%* /"&=%1&%,%

*91 # 4 !  **. && " "(; &&6

"8 ) "(<0%%0,%,9%9,$%* /8():%1

&%,%*91("4!**.: ( "(;&"6

  "(<0%%0,%,9%9,$%* /8(""%1

"%,%*914!**.&#  "(;&)6

( : ":<0%%0,%,9%9,$%* /8(&0

/8()%1&%,%*91&=4!*!*;&(6

=  ":<0%%0,%,9%9,$%* /8(&%1

"%,%*91#4!*!*;&:6= " "#

<0$%*.% /##&%1"%,%*918"4

!  **. " " "#4  ") ) "# *<,. %.*.

,%*%!,,,%. 









.,.9* ,%!.,

"!# 



$% --.!<* 



!

 

&'('

0*.*,.





(?6

%

(%   / #= %1 & %,% 9* *0 % *' ,% $1*!, $*

%%<,**

*,!%

,,.

%%07,

*<

,

%*,$,@,*

$%

$%*,0 ,*!00 ,,!,%, %*, ")' "(    ":  " ?6 $,94 !*<

.!*

  $?-6()?-!!,.,6* 





%

+% /#:%1&0/#(%1&%,% , 

 



!

 - 4%1,.,,1,!*,4

!%%,  ,%,9 !%0 !<*,*. 91* &  0 "= $,94 ,* ,!

*,14 !%%,  +<1,9 * $%* : & ": !<*,*. 0 .!* * :

.0"$,991**4 

  .?96(/?-!!,.6* 





 

'%*9%* /8(%1&0)091* ' ,%*,*1!%%*%.!*

1!*4,*!<*,*..!*:"$,9*91**,$AA***!,%, ' 

,%($?,-!,-,6  





0%,$,*!,***%*,10*.7

*%%,*!*%%0$..*%%<.,.0* 

.%* ' ,%*,0 0*!%%.0*0!*.

!%%.!,*0,%,9%9,%%0*.*,.**! /8:%1&$&':*%,,9.

*%%<.,.5

: & ,%!!%%,,%3;

: " 

%!!

!%%.0

!*.

09,!,

0,%

!%%..

,1*,,!,%,;

: ) %%!!%%.0*%%%,!,%1,*!*%%,.!,.!**,

**!,0,%*9,.*,*;

: (  ! !%%.!,*%* ,,%,9 % ,%* %!, ,! 

9,*,*-!,$,9;

: : !!%%.!,*%*,,%,9%,%'4*AA'9<<$$!9,*!, 

0%*,0%1,%1,.+<1,9***,%*!,$,94: & ":  

1%   '  ,% *,0% , 01 *%%<.,. 9< , *. *%%, $.. *4 9<7

!%%.!,*,,.,%,%!**,.9.*9*9%* /

8:%1"*,**%,4$,..*,1-,*9<9<$AA**,**!,%, 



)%

-*. ' ,%*,9%*.*<,.,%*%!,,,%. 

2%   / : %1 & $ & %,% 9<  



 !

 B%*  



  

  !*<.

0*!,<1.?9,63  







 ,  %

$/% 4

 , 

 %% !

 B%* 

     

     5*.

.!*,,! 9,%.9,%,  &"")(=&8



,* C$4 9,%.9, 

""&")88=## $4 9*,!7, "=(##  ,%., ,%1*, 0*. 2

$%*!04*&'#'("()4*%D 





 



$+2.?-

**%!.-,-!!,.96 

<,%,*,<,*,,%**.,*4*7<.,)$,90%%,.0<*!,* 

<.,*7*,,4,%1*,%.!4,%%,,,*<,**, 

$$% %0 !<* %% !

 - !    * 6   



   





        *    

 

 (1( ?. ,*,-!!,. 6

 3 ! *%,7 *. .!*,,! 9,%.9,%,  &"")(=&8



,*

C$19*,!71"=#=#&

$(% ***$,%,0<*!*%%,*,1*,,%, 



"

 



 



**, $,%,  <1 ,. ,9* ,, %,$,!,,*%, !., !,14

*,*.,$,%%*<1,*!,9*0%%** $%*!008

$,90%9*,*,%*!,*0$,%%**%,7,*.* $%

*!00 &: $,9 0%4 %*, $,9*4 !% *!,,*%, $%,%,  9<!% *

**9.**,1 

!%!,,*%, %., -9*!, **, 9<7 9.%*. **,* ,%.4 ,*.,

,%%,  !,7,  * $% *!00 & $,9 0% **,

%*!,* 



 

 



!

 B*--.**,,%%,4,**,!%%,( !%": <0%*,$,@,*

%%0,%,9%9,  $%* **. !*<. 07,,. 0*!, ,,*

%,., / 8(& 0 / 8() %1 & %,% *91 &=  4 !  *!*4 0*

") ,$*,!7%": ,%%&: "(0% $%%%**,,%+!00,%.,-%

-1%,* E*,!7%1,*%9*0*,!,.%9%.,%,9*<.**

%9 =: % ,1*,,!!11 &:  4 ,  *9*. %%4 !%%,1

 %,., / " %1 ) <.,.4 !%%, ,%* 0* , 9< %% !*<.* 0*.,

07,,.4 0, *,! $%* 0*. <.* * +! 0 0, 9 9

0*9,1<**,,%*9%09 

   



 



!

 3   ,      

  

3

 

  

  

 

       3 *

    

 

  & '(' 





 6   



  %



  *   



 !

 B%, , 

 7   / ("( 01

9%@*,,*9*,*!,$,!,,,*<7$A*--.**9%,*,"

.91**  /#=%1&%,%9**0%*',%$1*!,

$* %%<,** *,!% ,,. %%07, *< , %*,$,@,* $%

$%*,0,*!00,,!,%,%*,") ,$*,!7*":"( ,$*,!7":D*%

"8$AA.,%'"=D4"$,94!*<.!**,07&0"=$,991** 

 /#:%1&0/#(%1&%,%!<**',%B%,%**,:.0"$,9

91**4%1,.,,1,!*,4!%%,,%,9!%0!<*,*991*&



 0 "= $,94 ,* ,! *,14 !%%,  +<1,9 * $%* : & ":

!<*,*.0.!**:.0"$,991**  /8(%1&0)1/8:*,*,

%,%97*.--.**9**0%,91*,.!,**1!%%*"&%,*,01 

*,0%1,%1,.+<1,9***,%*!,$,94: & ": *4

,**',%7** 0*!%%.0*0$%*

!*. !%%.!,* 0,%,9%9, %% 0 *7 **!   / 8: %1 & $ &':

*%,,9.*%%<.,.  /:%,%9<!*<.0*!,<19, 



 



 . * -*%4 ,* 7 %,$$,*  0 <*7 ,%%,1  %,$$,

<%!!,%9%0,.!*<,%**,* *,,%!0%,!.9. 







0.*%,$$,0., 

 %,.4 ,* %,$$, <%!!,%  01*. ,.,,.    / ") %1 " ,,9.

%,$$,!,,*%* 9%*9. 0%. , ,,   %,$,  <%!*. --.**9 97%

**,%0*%%,.9 %,$,<%!**00,%,%0!<*7 ' ,%

--.0%.7*,!*,%,$$,%,$*.*, 



  

 ' *,1 *,* *' ,% -1%, * E*,!7%1,* 9%,

0 !*<.%, %%<,*, *100,% *,**. 91**, *<4 . *

E*,!7%1,*C,,%..,%,9!%!,,*%,*',%9%

<.!,*!*D*% )#D

 ,  $.9. 

8  %





%  *9%*   / &8: %1 & $   !,,*%% --.!<*9 *,1 ,9

.   ,%,9 !%0 ,,!, %,9 *,1  *!, $.. ,, +<1,9 

: & ": **4 !%%,1  9%0 !<*,*.  .4  ,%,9 *,1 .

9%0!<*!,%,%4--.**9%<14,**,!0!,,*%,*-,!,,*%, 

8





 



9*9%* /&8:%1&$(!,,*%%0,%,9

!%0,,%%01,9'.9.%, ., ' ,%*!,,,*!*.*

&): 

9  



    9*9%*   / &8: %1 & $ ) !,,*%% 0 ,%,9

!%0,,,*,.%,, ' ,%07,*9*!,1D*%'&)D4

!%%,*.,0,,%%79%0!<*!,%, ' ,%B%* 



*9%* /&=%1&-9*7--.!<*9**,%!,,*%%.--.!<*,* 



D%%D

+ 

*







<1,