Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-5294\3 ECLI:EE:TMK:2006:1.06.5294.15290 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal regarding criminal record certificate validity based on procedural errors in document issuance.

Case Number 1-06-5294\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appellant's appeal against the criminal record certificate issued by the Tartu Regional Court. The appellant argued the document was invalid due to procedural irregularities and lack of proper verification during its creation. The court found that the issuing authority followed the correct legal procedures and that the appellant failed to provide sufficient evidence of any substantive error warranting the document's invalidation.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Criminal Procedure Code; Criminal Record Certificate Act: A criminal record certificate issued by a court in accordance with statutory procedures remains valid even if the applicant disputes the underlying facts, absent proof of procedural violation or substantive error.

Keywords

AI generated
criminal record certificate procedural validity court appeal dismissal document issuance criminal record verification

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Criminal Procedure Code
Criminal Record Certificate Act

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text





        

  

  !    

  " #$%% "  &'%(  

        )*+$ ,$!      () %()  

  

$*$ $!-# !../$!!)!  0/)  %1  2  %1  #  2,1$ %)##)*)-)%!)!  -) %2-(    

$*$ $!-#      $!$/ 3435 )!$ +$$1$ /-$5 )*))%  ))!$ ))%5 %1 $/!)15 )$ 665 )%" &'%( *-/

'%%)!) (%/

!) .%5 ')-/ ( $!*$-)5 $--$ #))/ 4""" 7 ()* $*$-%! $!/8 9 """  &'%(   #%  03 %1  # 553 2,1$ %$!) (+/!)!)17 9"""  &'%(   #% 

0 3 %1  # 53 2,1$ %$!) (+/!)!)17

39 """  &'%(   #% 

0 3 %1  # 553 2,1$   ($1  -$5 *$! !)-// )!$1 3""4" 5 $!!)/ !-/

   -/)/( &))) :,(   ! 

  ;9

$*$ $!-# !../$ --$!/  0  %1  2,1$ 2 $!/  ;!9 !!) (-1$!!)1"

$*$ $!-# !../$ --$!/  0  %1  #  2,1$ 2 $!/  ;!9 %$!) (-1$!!)1"

 0 3 %1  %!)% %1)/ )1)* $!! )! !)* $!!)1 -$-1 *'$!

$*$ $!-# %$$$!!)!  ;!9 ! (-1$!!"

 0 < %1  %!)% ( ))%(-1$!!)! ($$+$/ )1 4"" = """  $!!2 % -$-1 ( $*$ $!-#%) *'$!)/ $!!)! -!  / 2 4 #,)("

 0 43 %1  %!)% (+!/ $*$ $!-# ,$)%$% %%) *'$!)/ (-1$!!) -/*$!)! $-1$*$!$ -$-1 *,,5 ) *'$!)/ $!! )$ #66 ,$*$!)%)5 $  3 ;%*9 !!) !)2 )!)% )$ #-) $*)   %$ $)1"

!)2 %1! ()!/ %)!  !!) %*$!)!" +!/ $*$ $!-# ($$($* ( $ %"

,%2 *'$! $*$ $!-#% $$1$))%()!!)8 9 4 ;!)$!)   ($$!!/9 -$ !-/  )!7 9 3 ;-)%$   %*.)-/ !9 -$ 2  !)-$ *,,/ $!2%) *!( ! )!"

$*$-%*)-)%!) %/ !/  -/!*$-$!))$*$ ()%/!-%) - 3<4  )!$ > $!#-1! ;($$)-*+) <<9   2!% %)!  !!) 2'!*$!)!" :,  #!. $$ = #!. %1$ *#%)!)!#)$$!$ %/ !!  -$ $$1$ -/"

,%2 *'$! $*$ $!-#%8 9  ;($$!!/9 -$ $) )#$ ;$!$/ 39 !!7 9  ;-)%$!/ ($$!.)-/9 -$ -) %/ ;$!$/ <39 !!"

     

 !!) #)%) ('$+ )!$/ #)%%!$-$ $-% %)##)*)-)%! )1%))$() !,)) $*$!) !!  $-1-- %)    /  #,)( 2!% %)! #,)(!5 *$%  *)-)%!) #%)% - ('$*%$  ! (/  !!)15 )/)! !)%%) )!$*$!)! $2%$% " *$! " "

$*$-%*)-)%!) %/) .($*$!) !!!) ('$+ ($/%!/  !!)! )%/$ .*-) #,)( 2!% %)!  !!) %*$!)! *,,!)+!) )!$*$!) ))%   %)"

   ""   

%)##)  !)% !../$!!) $*$ $!-#/ !)%%)!5 ) )*5 3"""  &'%( *--! '%%)!) (%%! !) .%! $) )#$ )% ! -1$! ($$*!)%) %%%)5 (,,-! (,%2 $) )#$ ,) #6$/%5 ) !/ ,)  5 *$%%)! ('$! ,  -$ !% 5 >%%) )#$ #-1/$ *!*!)1 3 -$ 2 ?/$ *!*!)1  -$" $) )#$%) )$! #)* ,) #6$/% )**$5 (%5 !)"



3 ;9 ))1 $*$ $!-# #-$ $*) ('' (%%!!2 ,('*$!) !)%%) )+!)/!%$ *!*$!) ))!*,1$%5 (,1$(%%15 !"  0  %1  2,1$ (%$@$!))$( $)"

))% !../$!!) $*$ $!-#/ !)%%)!5 ) )* 3"""  )%% 3 2% -1$! !$!!) (%/2  ) (!!)% &'%( *--! '%%)!) (%%! !) .%! -) %/ )%  !) %!!) % $'*+*$!) ))% 2 !))2,)% %'$ --- 2%1 #)* )$) #$$-/5 )$/)! ())(%*$ *''/)1 A3 B*"" ))1 $*$ $!-##-$ $*)(%/2  ) (!!)% (''!!) -)!!) )+!)/!%$ -1$*$!) (,1$(%%15 !"  0  %1  #  2,1$ (%$@$!))$( $)"

../$!( $*$ $!-#5 $!2 -$-1 #6$ ( )% !'%*$/ %)##)  !)% - $*$ $!-#%) *'$!)(! $!!)!  0  %1  2,1$  ! (-1$!! 2  0  %1  #  2,1$  / (-1$!!"  0  %1 53 %!)% %$$ $!!)/5 %1)/)! )1)* $!! )! !)* $!!)1 2 %'#%$! $!!)! *'$!  ! (-1$!!5 *$/ )$ #66  0 43 %1  %!)% ,$)%$% ,$*$!)%)5 $  3!!) !)2 )!)% )$ #-) $*)   %$ $)1"

" $!-# - ))%(-1$!!)! ($$+$-/ %)! 4"""  ;% 49"

#

   

 %$ *$!) #' 2%  ! %)$+5 ) %)#) !'%*$/)! - !../$!( (,%2)-/-/ * ')%$!  ) -$-1 $*$-%!2 *)-)%)*$!)% - 2,1$/ %)##)*)-)%!) !,)$/" ../$!( $--$!  $!-1$%5 )  - %)##)!  !-/ 2 -'!+ !)%%)1 -$-1 --$!+ )!$/ !../$!!)! ,$)%$% !../$"

../$!( $!2 2 #6 2,$/  $!-1$% %)##) 2/)" ../$!( %)+ !../$ *'$!  0/)  %1  2  %1  #  2,1$ -$-1 %%) %)+ *'$! %)##) -) $!!" )!)! " $!-# (-1$!!)! $-1$*!$ (+!*$!)15 %)+  ( $!!)! (+!/ ($$($*"

--- $) )#$ - )!$-/ !../$!( (! !$($$% 1$  -$ -'/)! 2 --- -) %/ - )!$-/ !$($$% 1$  -$ -'/)!"

 ! %)$+5 ) 1$/ - #' 2)-// 2 %(/  %/*$!)%)" C 0/) 3 2  %1  #  %!)% %)+ $*$ $!-#% (,%2 *'$!  -$ $) )#$ !! 2  -$ -) %/ !! $)1 )$/  2 )!" ../$!( - )!$/ 1$/ '$1)! ('-/"

,)!%)(! $*$-%!2! )!$-)(/ 2,1*$!)/ *)-)%!%/8 !../$*'$!(  !!)1 !-)( !-/  = 4 -$5 *,,/ $!2%) *!/ ! = 35 -$ ;DD57 % <5 <9 -$-1  #!. $$ = #!. %1$ *#%)!)!#)$$!$ %/ =  -$ ;% 4<9"

 0 < %1   !)% .($+ !../$*'$!(  !!) % *)-)%!%/ !../$*'$!)"  0 < %1 3  !)% ()!+  ! *)-)%!%!$/ *,,)!

  ;9 !../$*'$!) (%$! !)$!-/$ 2 )!!$%$!))*$!(,%2()$/7 $ *)-)%!%/) .($*$-) $%*!)% ,$+ !../$*'$!)%) .%) 2'5 2,+  ! ! -)$! $$1$ -/"

- !../$!(% #/+ 66 5 !)%%)#,! *'$!+  !  0 4 %1  #/)  2  -$-1 0 4 %1  #  %!)% !../$!(% (,%2 $*$-%*)-)%!) %/) )! ($/ 35 -$ -$-1 2,+  #!. $$ = #!. %1$ *#%)!)!#)$$!$ %/ !!  -$5 *$! $%*!)% ,$+ !../$*'$!)%) .%) 2'5 $$1$ -/"

)*+$ ,$!  -$