Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-05-2112\8 ECLI:EE:TLRK:2006:1.05.2112.14056 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against conviction for tax evasion, upholding original judgment on evidence sufficiency.

Case Number 1-05-2112\8
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Tallinn Court of Appeal dismissed the defendant's appeal against the first-instance criminal judgment regarding tax evasion. The prosecution argued that the defendant concealed assets to avoid paying taxes, while the defense claimed the evidence was insufficient to prove the specific intent required for the crime. The court ruled that the evidence presented at trial was sufficient to establish the elements of the offense, thereby rejecting the appeal and maintaining the original conviction.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Criminal Code § 176; § 177: The court established that the prosecution must prove the specific intent to evade taxes beyond reasonable doubt, and the burden of proof remains with the state even when the defendant raises defenses regarding the nature of the assets.

Keywords

AI generated
tax evasion criminal intent burden of proof appeal dismissal evidence sufficiency

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Criminal Code § 176
Criminal Code § 177

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

�          

     "!#    $ $%& ')(& * +$ $, *+$ *- '". /*+$ *$0     243 

3   ' 576"  8  3 8- 9: ;  2



 .- -<: 0    =  5> @?     5      03

    " A 5>        

B     &3

     $- - C  ;  CC

 : D E   C F   F 3 50C  0  &F   

G H:E  '3  3 I  

 ' J; C    = :?    K3     L     M        

 

      ;      = :?    J

1   50     "5>   ;  N  = :?    3

   



2O

2  3   ;P3      N&3  ; O Q  '  0  8      '  /  

; 5>   '@; C   

   J    3   : @ 

3   ' 5R O         7;C   'S     NK5  TU 2S           T     :V@ 3   '

 M



2W X 43   4    ; C C  

 3  0

: =&Y % ,< Z.(M   N    O3     = :)?   [

  K   N 5  50   

 

2N\  5> 3  > :  : = :?    ;         8  >] 3 3>   N ;  

      ^     3        350 3  )  

 '  :

3    '

5)    &   J3   "   ";CC

 

 3    : =&Y %- $( 9$J  

 "    N      N  = : ?    

     5 & 

5>  @

  C    ;^'

 _ 

  :  '`  = :A?    >  3    0 ' 5>    >

    'NA  5>0;   ;   '  @   N  C ;        : G G = :?     O

1 1   M2  3   ;  \31   \5>    2M3    'O5>      

    V3    5)    P3  ;       :>@    'I  I   P5>      

    J C     ^3 ;    

5> )  5>

2 ;C C   5       &5>     P!JZ-      C  O    3      "3 ;       : = :@?    >  3

   \

8![$.  C

'      3   : a = :?     P        &    ) '  [ P     ;

  5> );CC

         Q

 ; `  ' 

3X   'b 4     `1   3

  3 Q cc'd#I C  

    '

5M3     5)   



;  C       : e/@

    '

5>N[     f50 3  4   I C      ' = :[?      

1   5>   5>  V

g!I$ .9M C ' N0   2h  5> N  /5  3 S  O3 

5>

      = : ?      5>     )3

      : @ 

3   ' 5b    2N" i    \  K3 T   [    = :"?       

    \5>        ' 31  '   >   

1 1    I  'V

;    = :"?    O 

  : 3 M          831  )      

  N  = :&?    83

     3

'    ;V   

j



;   N3  V8 C   j C   

 

  = : ?    8 

 3  

"!Z< '(/5>  A3

    /  5>    : @ 

3   ' 5bM    3   NJ  = :"?   \

1 1I

  50 

 2V   3 '     N  = :@?   J      3

   

2   [  J    P        C  ' "'

  _  C     NA  3  @5 /  '    3 >   ;  3  3   :    3

   '   3X3C 

  I [       I 'I  S3   T3

  33I  '  C ' : @ 

3   ' 5k3     

 2N" >5 K ' ;   'K   = :&?       8       3  5)   

  S3    N[3  7  h

1 1U

O /   'l    g  3          C  >   

   ;3

        3  5>&3

    &#;  '    &B3    5>   3 @ "!@Z< '.&5>   :   3 )    2N "

/!0$.

9  C

'3    /       0  "8;  5>      X3X     O3

     N83  4       X3

    'X \ g;      ;     = : ?   @3

      5>C

3 : @ 

3   ' 5U  'P   5  3 / C     @ P   2N 3 C    ; )    

;      [  3;   

 5> 

 [  'Pmn D o #    cc[       = : ?   @ ;    3U5> 

  &  

       '    

     ; '    3   '3 

  3 5 3

    &

 A3

' 5>@3 

     ' :  :

    3

     ':

p"q rs s t u v w xxy w v w v z { =   @?      

       6J

 >  3 >- 9: ;  2



.-- <: "    

1         C  A       &   / ' A5    5>   :       2J  N    5>[.-- .:  B ; CC

 

'  J  A5>      

;     3@     J '  \  ' 

;      .- - $: #   

  3A     &1   3

  3  cc': =

     P      2T5 M3  2  P;   

5>   ' N> P M P j3

  \

1   :  '   [g    ;  5  h 'N>5     8 

2g    K3

     P3  ;       N^  '0



2[ 2  3   ;       :@ 

3    P 

   

;>[    

  /5 3   NP3  7  g

  7   7 C     3  8   : =

            3  N  3  "

1 1   &  &3 >  3     '      &  3  3

  ' K$/  0 /([3 O  33 P3 

       P   '[   'P  '/;   '             : |w y } ~ xy y t~ x u z v r w v z ~ x u  G)  5)       V5  

       0C

;   0 cc  06"

 g   3  T( Z: - (: .-- *:     = :?      &50     0    3

    J #[5     

3

  5>  " '   C  ;   j3  j1   3K  3/ j3

 3K3 3K C       j   3 

 '  

      5    ' C   '    A(-: - $: .-- *: 3  - 9: - 9: .- - Z: \€3 : (:  *< : G ‚  3 )

;    N@  = :?    

J3    'P C       cc       3     ƒ C    g   'ƒ

  U-%: - *: .-- Z: NI   3M

  5>  ƒ '     N    

  Y 0„4Z$<)A? FP 

 E  'A :5>    J9# ( ();   ^  ; )'

 _   

  N 5>   J3 

      3    2 ^E^: m

]

    ; 3  @; C C

  

 3  K T(V  :Z : = :J?   [  3  >3   5   0'j    V   T  ;      

:   3 4  

 ' O`

 3 \ ;     : = :[?    X  V5 3C         

 3      A C

;        J  A5 J3 >

  NPE  ' :$N '

  _   A

 : †   5>  M3

     S  33      N  C 3 = :0?   O3  S  /5       

    I C     83 ;    

5>  P ‡- *: - ,: .-- Z: T    / T

  8F   F      

 ]  3

        3   3    

   Y 0„XZ $<? FJ  

2     

  5>   0

 "   3  ) :  : N5    J3  >3    2 ^E^: 5>  '3    ; C C  

 3  € 37.)  :(-J : 0 3    

 ' A      = :?    N  A "

       ^  5) 3  @  : '   _  23  

  2        5>€3 : *N   : ., : G { = :@?    P; 

; C    N "    [ 3

 

O ' ;   " [    [   

  5>     NA;  8

  ;      0   1 2

  '  5)   0  5>  @3C  '  N^   T3

    '

K    3   \   3 T  'S7     ; = :P?           ;

    N     &  5>C

' ;2 @3

       : @ 

3   ' 5j C    2N     3     A3 3   3     3

3C     2&

      3  N&3  

 2\  

3  :0     3&      [5>      [3

 2K38  

    5>  N : : 

      ;J  

3    3 5    ;    :        

 " ; C        )3E  ' 3 A5       :€ EA@@g$# ( # ( # ( *< # - $   3 8T   3           

g       N>  = :J?   [

  8  5>        K

    )  0     [  E  ' :^ :^50    ; &'

 _   

 J   'h      

 ^'

  _  

  ^2        5 :  ') A  '   ^   

  5>  ':

3

   ' >  'J C   2>@

J!J% Z" '# (" 5>    

     : @ L!ˆ< Z‰ 'L(‰    4   45        3

   L3   

3L     Š?   3

-<: - Z: .-- $:     '5>     )3

     ' N : : .    &( (&3 J; '       ' 5>  $&           'ƒ3  5>        U C    ;  ;4  : @    &  '   3A   - <: - Z: .- - $: &: ‹tw u v Œ t ;:   ; =   A?  5>C' |@rv xs z u v w xxy (: 1      6J

 K0 3 K- 9: ;   2

 ^.- -<: :   =  50 )?   0

  50     )3

      : .:   [ >   N5     '[5     =  5> >?      [@

8!P$. 9P C 'X     

   $--X C ;  5>C C  :  :( Z&- --\€;       

 3  : $: 0 ^   C   3   A5>

 50  : *: =  5> A?    

       \              :  Ž tv w ~ t r t w v r~x‘ Ž @        @; 2$- C  ; 3

     @3      E  ' 3

  N5>        5>  & ;  

  2"   '33 

 3

    3       &% C ; ^ 3 

 N        j3      3  h    ;  8 '     :>@     g

  2T      3

    3  X   '33  ’3  ’$-b C  ; 4 3   NI    U C  ;  NI5   

5>      “    “L;  5>   3L

 ;  ˆ   '3  3 ”   ': 1

1       ;";  2"3          1 3 A ;3    3     ;      : •"– — ˜™š ›œJ— ˜& žŸ ž

š ›– ž&¡ ¢ £ ¡ ¤¥¦&§ ¨ © ª«§ ¬¬ ®^¨>¯§ ® ° ± ° § ® ² ² ³ §´ ©µ©ª § ® ° ©° § ¶© ª ·J¸¹ º»´ ¼ ª ½§ºµ

¾ § ® ±¿© ¬ ½§ ® ° ® ± ½©À ¶@©ª ·0¸JÁ Â)¾ ½>Ã"´ ©)¸JÄ Ã)¾ ½ º)©¾ ® ± ¾A®

ª ± ¬ ³ ©° § ¨>¯§ ® ° ± ° ³ µ© ª § ® ° ® °^Å"©ª ´ PÆ ©© µÇȰ

É ÃÀ Ê É À ºÊÊ ÂÀ © ǰ ® ® ±½© ¨>¯§ ® ° ± ° ³Pµ © ª § ® ° ® ±)¼ª © µ©¬³ ¨0© ° ©)Ç® © ® À ÇÀº © ©® ° ©´ © É É µ

¿ ¯ª ª ©¬§ ¬ ½¾ ¯Ë ¾ § µ µ®A¾ § § ° µ© ª § ® ° ® ± µ®A¨>¯§ ® ° ± ° §¹&©©® ° ©°´ © É µ )¿© ¬ ½§ ® ° ® ° À ÌÍ ÎÍ"¦§ ¨ ©ª[«§ ¬¬ ®P¨>¯§ ® ° ± ° § ® ² ²³§ ® ± ¾ ¾ ± ® ÏJ± ° ° ± ¨0©K§ ® § µ ¬ © Ï"µ± ³ ©\ǬMµ©ª § ® ° © ° ³ É ÃÀ Ê É À ºÊÊ ÂÀ ©SÅJ© ª ´ ƒÆ © © µÇȰ 4ËÇǾ °V¶@© ª ·7¸h ºÂS© ¾ ® ± ¾\° § ¬ ½§ ¨ § ® §K¹Xµ ¾ § ® ± ¿ © ¬ ½§ ® ° ® ±½©ÐºÑ ©©® ° ©® ±‡µ© ° ® ± © ´ ©½©‡µ ÇǮҨ>Çǰ Ǫ ® ¯§ ³ µ§Ó´

È ° § ¨)§ ® ¯§ ½ ® ± ¼ª © ¿¯° ¨ § ® ±½© É ©©® ° ©µ® ´ ©&Ä&µ

µ ®@ÔµÇÈ °

ǰ ® ® ´ ¯ ® ° ® É ÊÀ Ê ¹À ºÊ Ê ÂÀ ©Õ´

Ȱ § ®Aµ± Ȱ § ¿© µ © ª § ® ° ® ±U© ´ © ¾ ÏVÊ ÁÀ Ê ÂÀ ºÊ Ê ÃÀ ©ÀKµ± ¾ ¾jº ºÀ ¹Ê`© ´ ©¾jÅJ© ª ´ ¨ ©© ¾ ÏjÆ0©© ª ³ ®hÖ§ ¬ ½§j° À ¾ À ¨0Çǰ Ǫ ® ¯§ ³

µ§ °× Æ0ØXª ±½À ¬ª À ùÄÙ « ÚÏǨ>© ¨>© ° ©&¨ Çǰ Ǫ ® ¯§ ³ µ§ ´

Ȱ § ¨>§ ® ±¯§ ½ ® ° À ·© ¨> ° §J° ± ¨>©Ïµ± ¾ ¾ ± ¾ ° Ǿ § É ÃÀ Ê É À ºÊÊ ÂÀ ©‰µ ÇȰ ǰ ® ® ± ½©8¼ª © ¿ ¯± ° ³j¨>Çǰ Ǫ ® ¯§ ³

µ§ ´

Ȱ § ¨>§ ® ¯§ ½ ® Ï ´ Ȱ § ®µ± Ȱ § ¿©>µ© ª § ® ° ® ± © ´ © ¾\ÂÀ Ê ÛÀ ºÊÊ ÃÀ © µ± ¾ ¾AººÀ É Ê © ´ © ¾ÅJ© ª ´ ¨ ©© ¾ Ï Æ ©© ª ³ ® Ï[¶± ± ¨>§ µ ° ±T° À ¾ À0¨0Çǰ Ǫ ® ¯§ ³

µ§ °8× Æ0Ølª ± ½ À0¬ª À>à ¹ÄTÙ«ÚÏPǨ>© ¨>©° © ¨0Çǰ Ǫ ® ¯§ ³

µ§´

È ° § ¨ § ® ±¯§ ½ ® ° À ·± ¾ ¾ § ® ±/° ±½± ¿ ® ±½©8Ë ©¬§J¦§ ¨>© ª « § ¬¬ ® ° ǧ ¨)±8¶@©ª ·K¸/¹º »/´ ¼ ª ½§Jµ¿© ¾ § Ü § ° ® ± ± ª § ° © ¿© µ ª § ° ± ÇK® À Ç À^° ¼§ ° ¨ § ® ± ¾ ±PË Ýݪ © ° ³OµÇȰ ǰ ® ® ±½©/® ² ² ° ±Ç8± ±® °¨0¯§ ® ° ± ° ³\µ© ª § ® ° ® ± ° ¼§ ° ¨ § ® ±® ° µ¯ª ¿ © ¾ ± Èǧ ³ ¨ § ® ±À

Þßà&á â@ßáAãâã ä ä åæçèéê éëAç ç ì&ç í"ç î ä ï ðñò óô æAõ ö ö ÷ ø øõë÷ ø ùúûøø õ úûüý þ ÿ�ô óô  �  ô   

 ñò �          

!#"" $ "% & " !' () *+  , +  **  .-/0 '21--3% % )

% 45  89  4#:35 ;  :3<#=?> @    A = 5 < B   5C   = 5   C    7DC  A3 = >5 .-/0 ' % 'E!#F% )1# ) G

HJI   K >  :  

!#"" $ "%

L  =  EM# :#:386N6 I#I <  86 56 H   O.P Q >  R ST#)$ $ ) )

'2U 1#-3/#0 '2-0 % '2% V   8?B  AWX  Q3 Y Z       A#WX W 86 ST#)$ $ " %

--!#3)%

"& " I#I <   Y L  =  EM# :3:#86 [ -31#' \ H    : O 8#7 ]#^^ U# % " "_ S.  "a`# !!#'2% @  A @b5   :35 @c4 KdA3W <  :  A @ A AX   <#86 @   = eA :<   ff A3WX3  @ 5  A3WX g @ B   <#8#@ Y#  = AX cAW   hAWX WW A#    82<g *i    ,   P .j    :#: M :3: AWX W3W H  Hlk  *  +  R . + <#5 * @  @ mJ9 >  RP.   Y# : R 86 R n H  Hok?p ? RqP?r >  R *    Y# : R 86 R H  O k  m  R *   86  = s      A3   A P   Y3 : R 86  H   O ktp m  R * tPt 86  >  A#   86b7  : R =?86   A  Pu   A   R3 A#WX3 <  =   nvA3   86  W wA :37 A  Y3 : R 86 Y3  Z  82< Px > Y3 n  i* ,  * E m   V   8eB  AWX WW H  O k m  mr9 >  R.PyA 8#8 Y3 : R 86 R H   O k ,l R *  86 Y s5  L  = xM# :3:3826  7E>   = W3W W s  <38 A X  =  <5as  R I X A   A 6h9 aA 8#8#5 A A 8#8 A  H  O kzp m{6 >7  86    ff   8< Y3 : R 86 >    A  7N7 >  =   @ A  L 3M3 :3:386 A3X    A#  bA 56  l :35|7 W =?5}8#8#7y7 X   AA