Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-05-492\3 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:4.05.492.11490 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding deportation of foreign national based on procedural errors.

Case Number 4-05-492\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appeal against the administrative decision to deport the appellant, finding the lower court's review insufficient. The appellant argued that the deportation order violated his right to a fair hearing and due process, while the opposing party contended the administrative body acted within its statutory authority. The court ruled that the administrative decision was not arbitrary and the procedural safeguards were adequately met, thus upholding the deportation order.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 of the Aliens Act 1993; s. 10 of the Aliens Act 1993: The court must review administrative deportation decisions for legality and proportionality, ensuring the appellant had adequate opportunity to present their case before the decision was finalized.

Keywords

AI generated
Aliens Act 1993 deportation order administrative appeal procedural fairness foreign national due process rights judicial review

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 of the Aliens Act 1993

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

 



                

          

   !""#$$       %&"'&%(%&&')"'*   $$+$!      ,$     -,!$./0%123.        -                  

       453$!65.!$.,$ !7$58$5  !""#  !,5.$ $$!5$2$.+28$5    !"##    $""    %&'()   *         +,  # ),,,(5 !!* "  (" -             $" "    *     .                         *      /   0'+"        "  )"  *  $""     .    (),(+5 9 $+*  (!+ + ..!$$. . ,$5+,$  """1%: """0   $!. ;.63< ,..!$  7$:"""%'0*           !+ .   1      *           

    ((!,()&&23,3  . 

 *  !,((,,)'&03,!! 5 . 

1    '!,,,3'2+2"        !!$5$,=.,+65$+$.!+6$55!.$7$55..3!5$!$!$.+



! +< !$!+$ .52$ 5! $.! $ 6$, 25< ,!$ !!$  5! .$ 6$,! .25.5!    ,.! !+ 6$55!..=.3! 2 $.!+$ 6$55!.$7$ ' 6$, 25,!$6$,! .5!!65!$5$!!, .$!!$+,  !!!$$! 2!$5$..$$!!, .$ !!$+,5!$ !.!""#  6768 -!!."""',!$6!55$55$!<$!!2!."""'$55'' 6.$  525,55.!.& .!&.,!&$$ !1.5 $$!.5 3$$65$ !=.+.! -1$3.!$$. . 3.3< .55$5. !>>!, 5..52$5$,5,$ ..$ ==!$$+$! ,!+ ,=. ..+ ,=. 5+, $+$ ?.!5$ %'  $55.$!$3$,$3.-5..5$$.2/%=+$.+26.!. $5..5$+$ /0%123.,5.@.!$$.!,,!$   64 -$. 5$ ,!$2 ! .$5$ .5 + $3 !!5$+ 2 ! .$ $+.59 .! !!$!..5.5!!!$+)!510) !,5.$ $$!5$  - !.!+   99+ 2 ,5++ !.  !$ $!!)!5')  49 764 !,5.$ $$!5$2 6$7 - 99 ,!$  / 0%1  23. !=$+! 5$.+$< $! !$  .! ,=. 55 !, '" !,.9.! !,5.$ $$!5$2 657 @.$$.+ $+$?.!5$%'2,52 =.! $$!55$5!..5!$6$!...5+  6644 6$7,=. 5. /"535$52! .! $$!55$..!  ..5$$.2/%!$!7<$!=.+.$.!.55$+ $.+< .,=. 5+,+,!+ 5..52$5$,5,$..$ ==!$$+$!,=...+$55$!>>+ ..5$+$/0%1$5! !=.+.2!. .$$$!< .55$7..$ ==!$$+$! ,!+ ,=. $55$ !>>+ ..+ ,=. 5+, $+$< A .!!$ !,.3 . "" !,.9.!   55$ 57. ,..+ !5. . .$ !$3. .+5< $! - !$3$,  =.3$!. ,5.@.!$$.!+ 2 99  / 0%1 23. ,5.@.!$$.!, ,!$ !. $6$ .$  5$.++ !=$+ .!B 9+ ,!56!55.32@!+$3< .55$$5!"""'$  525,55.!.& .!&.,!&$$ !1 57.,..++,!5$3!,!!.< $!-65!2.!+!.,$3 2.65$$. .952$+.,!2! $$!, !65!6$$+$$+ $!.!$2$5!$65!..$)!5#&)C !$6$!...2. .5.!.$$:"""'$6$!...!.3< .55$!!7<$! $$!55$ .. !! 5$.!+ $+$ .2+$3 ?.!5$ %' ,=. 5+7 ,!+ 5..52$5$,5,$..$ ==!$$+$!)!5"&)C $$!55$..$+!,5.$ $$!5$!+9!5!$3)!5')< .55$$5!2!. ! $ 5 !!   $3  < .55$ 5. !>>!, +&+$!$!<  ! $. 5+ !$+5.<$! $!.$.!.$+!+-$!$7!. !C $$3  !=$+!+< $! - 65! 2.!, ! 5. """' !>>!, $+$< .

 ,=. 5+,!+5..52$5$,5,$..$ ==!$$+$!,=...+$55$!>>+-. 2$5.5! /%=+$.+26.!. $/0%123.,5.@.!$$.!,,!$ /0%1$7.!$$!!$!,..""!,.9.! !,5!/'#53&5$ !5$7 .!$ =.! .$5 ! 65! ,$!+ $3$+,.+ 2 $+,.+ 25.+< ,=. 5! =2!+ 99+5! $+6.+. .+  99!$3+$ !. $6$ .$! 2 =.3 .! .$,..+  5$.7< $! !+ 2  99+5$ ,!!! $3$+, 25 6!9+ 5. $! !!!$+,+25+6+,+$$37$.5$<$!-! !5$7.!+'"!,.9.$!,.31""".  !,5.$ $$!5$2 !!5$7 $5$, ,!$2 $$!55$5! ..5!  ,=$!+ ,!$ !. $6$ .$ ,$! 72$!.  5..52$5$,5,$ ..$ ==!$$+ $ ,! .! ,=. 5+,$+ $?.!5$%'@.$$. .!  /:15323.,=.75++!!5.99!$!. $6$ .$,$+.299!$3 ++,@.$$. .!<.$$+5,+!$!$3$ .$25!. $6.25$ !$ !. $6$ .$,$+..3,!$,$!72$!.5+.$,=.$$ $,=.7/:1 5=.3$!$A'!$!!+2!+$5@.$$.+$+$$!!$!+!,5.$ $$!5$2 5$.7<$!!,5.$ $$!5$2!!56=2$+!+2575+ .$5$.3 $$3 57 -  ,=$!+ 5..52$5$,5,$ ..$ ==!$$+ $ ,! .! ,=. 5+, $+$?.!5$%'@.$$. .$5$   / :" 53 $5!  9,.!7 99+. =.!, !!$ 5 $$!55+ 99+. =.!$! 7..3. 5.!$1":"" $#1( +$!+:"#""% $3 '* 5$5 =.!7  $$!55$5! ..5! $$!55 ,52 $6$!...!  1"&.   +$! !.