Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-738\2 ECLI:EE:VMK:2006:1.06.738.9468 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against conviction for theft, rejecting claim that stolen goods were returned to victim.

Case Number 1-06-738\2
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Court of Appeal dismissed the defendant's appeal against his conviction for theft, upholding the first-instance judgment. The defendant argued that the stolen items had been returned to the victim, which should have mitigated the severity of the crime. The court rejected this argument, finding that the return of goods occurred after the theft was completed and did not negate the criminal act itself.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Criminal Code § 160; § 161: The return of stolen property after the commission of the theft does not erase the criminal act or prevent conviction.

Keywords

AI generated
theft conviction return of stolen goods criminal code provisions mitigation of crime appeal dismissal completion of theft property restitution

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Criminal Code § 160
Criminal Code § 161

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text







                     



                

               



 

 





 

 

 





!"#$% &'"()

#*& +%%)&&% %*,&)

%#+ "'"'-"'"'+""'

 





  

.!'/

 

 %*0)1&*%2)

)%*3411%05)+&1*%* %)

 

  

%&+6+3)(71&1*%%*1*

 



 

8#% 9& ::3 % 1  ;5-;+$,

:&3#1*1%& 1 "



* %*%* %)% 1)

 





   







 1# %% 4

" '""'  ;&,+$,)93 1% 1,

 %%*,# % 1+, %



<1*3) %#*1&%1 '=""'!"







&3#,>*)"



!" #$%





 



    

&''()'*&''+



 , 



 









&-.

'-

  /0







1





&-(

'

 







 





 







 2314+12445 





 

) 

  

  



 1



1



, 6

 

 7

 



1



 





 



 ,  





 ,  

   1





'



8, 

  



9







  9 



22:5 1



8, 

  



9

  





+544/  

 



0 



6



  

 

 

  )

 

  '': :4

  7 )    

  .355( 7



$





8



 

)   



,



  543+ 1





$&+#< %1%3 %&3 + *3 *3 *3 #* %11# )1&3 *%&1 *

''?  1 % @ 5*,  )< )1&3 *%&1 * ''' * 5*, (

)%1*#91'?==" %&3+ *3)<9)9%%&%$%# 1&% 3

+ & %%  1 +< %# 1 1%1 %( #$31  % # 1 3#1*3&1( 1% %1,1# % *  

%&31 )< *3 % # 1,( #% #*& + *#9 + 1  )< 1&&1 11 % *

%&3)< *3% *3"



!

,  

  

  

   



%









   1



 %%   31% 1 %%$%&1 %$%# 1   5$1) #AA3# 1& %%  1 +< %# 1 %(

 ::3&*11&1,*<313)9%%&%$%# 1++ &% *3"



"

 



 



%%  1&1 )<9 1 %3 51&&% *19 1 ! 5$1) + &  *,%&1 )

%#+ 3( %1%31  %&1 +&&% 19 1 1 %# 1 )%  1 %  5$1) + &

%%  1 &%# 1 %" %%   %1)* &%% 1 ) %#+ *% 1&1 3

''""'











8#% 9&*%&&*%3+%13 ::3 %% 1 1&&1 (1%%&<AA&) %'""'!(&&1 

&&+91()931  %*#+ *'(#  9B@7,&'(3# ( &1

1%1 5& %1*3 %:& $,  +3#& *31+1)% $%1 + +&,31, ) % 513( 5, % 

%*1&+*311%(%1%31 %&&1&&<&+1%1#3"*31+1) #5<+ % 

1&%&%1) 1+ % &&<&&% 1#%:  % 1*%1*3#1*&*1&$#9 )11

 5% *%<%%*,# %1131 1"



#%1,31,5*8#% 9&%#11&%&%1) 1+ % 1%1%# 1( "%" ;5

1%%1*$%3 %1( #% %1 1 *#1 1 # 5<+ %# 1 1%%1)%#% 1 %( "%"  ; 

1%%1*$%3%1"



::3 %%)* % %*,& :&1 &%3 8#% 9& 1 % %*3 1*3 ::3 %&&1

*#*11%3 %1  **, 1&1% ( 1% '""'! %1# %)%    # 9 , #&

&& 13+1"$ %1 1531&+$1&1**,%13%  1*3+31+3#&*31+1)(1 

 %  1531&)*"*31+1) )& *3 % 3(%)% 3&& 13+1+$$ 3" 

%  %  % $ #( *31+1) , 5&  %& +$$3 **, )<%%  %& $1 % " *31+1) )<%% 

1&+ % 313 $ **, %  %& 313 1&+ % $ )<%% "   +$ )&,  5<&1# **, % :%&1 

*31+1)&1(1%,1%)<9%&&%1#**1" *31+1) % & %3)*$$151&1**,

5& %&%)11&)*"  31 15*1#**,* % *31+1)#++#& 5: 3"

&$ % #( AA 1&*3 51%) )< )* %(31&13*3" &*31+1)#+

+31 %, ( %  5<&1  1*3 1&% )&, "  %& %55 **, %   *31+1)%" *31+1) &# 

)351&**,+&3&3%%1&&" #<%&1 (1%*31+1)#,9(&,% *31+1)%+  *$,(1%

*31+1)515 *)1" &2 (*%& #+ %(  <& " &$ 







*9* 1 +31 1&&1 ( 1% % 3 )$&+ 9( 3 *9**1 )$&+ 1 %&*3( %1&1>* 1

*3*3**,:%&1 (1%&1*3,#59&11#3 1" %%  % +#(*%1#1*3

*9* 1& * &1#   #9&%1&1>*( 3 %11& +   ) **, ), %  1*3 $ 

 %3) %" &*3+(%1A1&*3&, 1 (# +% *31+1)+1 (3 

1&+ %313$)<%#(  9 *$,(1%%&5&1& 5: 1+ : # *113*" 

:%&1 %(# +% *31+1)#+ "9  %1#51&1+#" 1#:%&1 9 &1(

1% *31+1)& * 5 **, %&19 )$&+ % 3 9( 3 9  &* :%&1 ( 1% )<9 &&

*31+1)  1**,*1  9(  %99"113 <*3 % 3%13**,%1&$*3

*9* 1+319% #"

##&%$ 9 +1%151&1"*15% %1#5: 1**,*$% *13*9* 1&1(

11+1  :&1 ( 1% %1# %& + &# & 5: %1%" 9  :%&1 ( 1% 1  %1# # % 51 

51 1#(#&&151&1%5% <#313)11,%$31%3)3  1" % 1% '531&%

)***, 39 ,+#"01&1 13%&$ )11&*31+1)%)%#**,%&&1

%*3 (1%*31+1)* *3" &$ %+$&&1*31+1)*9* 1+31**,5& % 3

)$&+9+5&% 1"0& *9* % %&&(3*9**111&3 "

 %& *31+1) #++ * 1 #1 %   %1 % 3( & #+  <  ( )1 & *&%

*31+1)51&"+ 1&1#3,5%*3"*& #+ 5&1%&AA*3" 

1&1%3( %)<9#+ 1*51&&&%1#)1" $ ), %  %3) %(#%%1*31+1)

#+ "



%* , *31+1) 1&1%  %&1( 1%  +3#&& *31+1) * %1# 1#( )1% 1& 1#

)&  B:  C7,&'D" # :& % 3 5&+3 *#1 13 E "" &* 9& + %1# 9 

8#% 9&" # <*31 % % %19( 1% 8#% 9& * 5+  &&1   )$, ,1 )*1 **,

%%51&151 9#9 %" 1%911&# 1&)&3%3, ## ''?!*(# & 

#% %1&3# 1&1.%&!/"



1&# 1& % %+* :&1 &%3 &* 9& 11&3  %&& # 1& :%& %1

*3# 1 %#9 ) %"



 %+31F3155 1&1% %&1(1%B: C7,&'D( *! 9%1# )&( %1&9

)1&   9 , **, & %1& %1," 1# *9* 1  & +3#&& *31+1)( 1&&1& &

)&*'"*31+1)+1 $ 3%%1*1)3&&%)%)3*#1 13( ""8#%+

&* 9&"'""'!AA&) %'""'!%1##3,#1&1&*3(#*,%&$#1

&*3(3'""'!$ % 1&&151&1(1%*&15%%" )% * %)$&+**,*$, 1&

5+ 8" 9&%(1 F1 %&11 **,*$% *31+1)#+51&1"11&1&&'5" %

1*%&%1%1*3**,&$ #,#" 1*13 9&5% %1#*&1+91&&?5(

 %%&)$&+**,:  (#3 9&%9" 9&:%&1 (1%+3*)1*1**,*)+)$&+

% 39" %) %  9&&1(1% 9& 1%  9 &%#+&%)$&+**,&$ 

1 %#,#" '""'! <%5&11&&5 %&%1#+311 % 9&**,5& 

% 3)$&+9+5&% 1" :%&1 (1%%*39(1%+3#&&* *3**,%  %131*3,

*31+1)#+++3#&&%)%#(3%1#11&3 "1&&%) % **,%  )$&+*

5&% 1  9" , 1&&1+(*5&% 1&1 9 ( & 9& %1#,**,

% &&%5&% 1 9# %"

GA 1& 9&$ %1#+1 #%%1()3'3**,"&%&%+9'""'!<%&"

  1&1%3(# 11&# 1&:%&1 %(1% 9&$ %1#+1 95&# *&%'&"

+3#&&*31+1),5&1*, +*3**,% %+*%**13)131):%& 13 1&&1 

  1) %%1,1& 1&1"



 %+&1*%*H1>> 1&1% %&1(1%%1#*&*+8#% 9&*9**1"&*+

8#% * && %)%)3 *#1 13" +3#&& *31+1)% % 1 %1" '""'! 19 

&* 9&%<15&1 %%1#&1(1%8#%%&+1&&##&**,&#& 51 %"

 %+ %&+ H%219) 1&1%  %&1( 1% %*3  +3#&& *31+1)%   %%" *3 

*31+1)51,+#*%" :&&&%%%5 %*31+1) )& "*31+1)3%%) 





?

# *9%1,( "" &* + 8#% 9&,"  8#% 9& & 5+ ( #%  )$,

,1 ) 1  **, %1, * %1&1 &$1*1# % 13" 13 %19  1*3 ,1# 1 %" 8#% 9&

$ %%+3#&&+1 #&( 11+1 %$ &$9)(# *#%  ( 1 %*&%&

% 1#&$951%)*,," )<%% +3#&&,%%11#,##*1%)&%&3

$(1%8#%1%:&% *13"@ *%%%  8#%#9 %&*%#AA351%)

**,&)$,#31" 19(1%&*$ %%51&1 *%1,( 1 1&1% 1% *13# 1 %(

3 * %% + ) % *$, % 3 1 )<*3" &* 9& #% )+  1*3 #*, 1,

9 11 %+3#&&+1 3 ) ( 1&1%31 (1%8#% 9&*5+ (  *

)$, ,1 )*1" +3#&& $$  #%( 1% 8#% & 5+  &1  *5 ( )+%1  %1#

1 & 1&1% 1&1 <*% 1 1 #<%%1 ( 1,%1#&1%1, 9&1%%15*13%1#, 31&3(

)%#% 1&&1&1(1% 1& # &%1#9 " *3 (1% 9&*)* 11&:%%"



% +%%& 1&% %+*:&1&%3*%**131)131) 1&1% %&1(1%8#% 9&

* %1# )*1# <1 9  **, 9&, * %& +3 <9&3 %13" 13 ( 1% 8#%

9&++3#&&*31+1))1&&3# %13(8#%1)<*3*31+1)%%55"*31+)

# % %13&* 9&$1 %(1 :%&1 %&&1(1%*31+1)&1%)$, %%*+ **"*,

 <,1 %511*  %1 +% %#" :    &*$1 %E3 &*%19 + %*5&+(

1,&*5&1 1#1%#313 1 %+3#&&%%5*3"1&&151&1&* %1351 #"

019)<#& (1%+3#&&%55 5 &* 9&"

&* :%&1  %&&1 ""'!( 1% *31+1) +1  & 53( #&&1 % )<% 3   *93 155(

11& 0<&3#+)11&5&*3 51%)"01&153*31+1)&1%, **"



% +%%& 1&% %+*:&1&%3%&+

2) 1&1% %&1(1%%*8#%+&*

9&%:%**,%1% (1%1#+ )1&*)$,&)3 %135<+ 1&(1%1#%)%9

&&" 7%* % %19 1# +% +$, **, +% %  %&1 *&, 1 )1 *( #  & *%3

8#% 9&5&%*11&# 1&(%&&# 1&"



 %+* :&1 &%3 %&+ %21* 1&1%  %&1( 1% % * +3#&& *31+1) #*

**, %*3  )$, $ % < 1%13( #3 *31+1) )<  *3" " %21* +1&3  %$5 1&%

:*3# &%&1%3**,$)<1%3&& %<)*, %(# & "*31+)&1"



  #% +$,# #*& +#%1+&31 ,%3%<1*3134



'""'! 31 & 7,&'(  * ' %1 %%3 :*3#  )%& 5%&&( #&&1 %

*$%9( 1% )&#+ % & &1%3 * 1 *1 )$,)&& % %1,( 5%&& 

+1&3%39+1%)*15&%)%9 1&&1&1(1%)+:*3+)1&&)<%& E5 %%3

*& (#&&1&&3**% (#+ %)$&+ 5&()1 13+$&+13(%*1) +*1"

:*3# &%&3 #%&1%3#11 %1& 5: 3".%&'!/-



>%%91&% :*3# )%& 5%&&+31.%&='?/-



* % %& 1 51%  % *  '( #&&1 % *$%9( 1% +3#& *31+1) #

5<+  * &&<& &% 1 # %:  % 1* %1*3 #1*&*1 &$#9  )11

 5% * %" 11  5% * %<%% *,# %1131 1 5<+ %  &&<& #3

1&%& %1) 1+ % 1" <%%1  )1 1 ), % %1 #>&,&   1$   +

&& % **& %)%(1%), % 13)<)3&&%1%%3&AA31 %<)31%A#531

1 1#1%1,* 1 ) B %) +&#)  1*3 &1)&1%*&1-*& 13)11)&#3

**, )11)&#3 1&& %1 1 )<)3 && %1%%3 5, %# 1& <#131," )1 %31 

1%1#331&& % ***,)$& %1), % %153# %*1*31&1 )$& %3(

1% *113 * %1%%3 1&& &#) %* *311 <# 1&" +3#&& *31+1)&

%) %% 1&&+)1.%&''/-



 %<1*3%1)%& 5%&&**,>%%91& 1&&1+31.%&=!/-



81 51% (#&&1 %%&1*19(1% :*3# &%&1%38.)11 %/&9( 8#%

9&I&1)<+3#&&*31+1)&1" &#*3%1&1 %1&1&)%8% :*3# &%

)<1%3 5)31, 5&1 %) %%3" + 1*&%( & &%( 9& 51#&% $1&%( 9&

) %&% $1&% 8 *&::   )<1%3 5)31 % **, 9& 51# $1 ::*1&% +





!

9&) $1::*1&%8*&::  )<1%35)31 %#$$%&1%385>&3*

&*,1)38#% 9&)<3& 5) %#$$%&1%385>&,".%&/-



% %& 1 51%  8#% 9& %1  .""'!/( #&&1 % *$%9( 1% 9&&

&3 %) %%34 ) 51# &9$1 1&+&( ) 51# &9$1 )1*3 <#1 5# 1&

5&+)51#+) &9$15# 1&5&(# %1 3%1)&<1)1*3

%#1&(#&&1 )< 3&&*& &&3"&*1)11)&#51#&9$11 #1 1

<#1 5# 1& 5& %1  <) %A#9 1 1#1 %#1&" 113 ), % 13 %1 3 #<*13

AA5$1)3 .? AA5$1)/ 11 % %& &$9)% %( 1 &1 1&%&3 + %)& 1 &

&5<+ %)3&:+& 1%1) 1+ % 1.%&=/



 ;



&*3 $ ::3 %%)( %*( % %+3( *3 #*& + #%1+&31  ,%3

%<1*313 **, *3 *13 ,# ( %&19   +$1&3 1&1( 1% 8#% 9& :: %&&1

*#*11%3 %1 %#15*1# 1  * %$1&&% %<1*3%3 **, %1# %1,1)  * &

::3 % 15&%<1%)&>% 11%3"



, ::3 %%)  1 1 % % # ::3( 5$*19 :*3# &% &1%3 9&,&*1 #%1+&

.8/*&% %1#&%)<%*&%"11+1 )$39 9&+$+1*3&&%(1%%) % 

*31+1))1 1*$,+%13) %1%&1 1 #1 %3AA 1&(  +$,#*13$ *31+1)

#+ &&1 +$,# 1.'""'!/5$1)<%&"01&1 13(*$,*31+1)%%13) 1%1 #1 %

3(), % #$ #%%1#+ ()3:&1)#1  %3) %" 9&)1 * %

&$%)&% * %1# )11 &1# & %) %#*1 :*3# & )$& %%3 **, 1&&1 &13# % #+

1*%1&**,*& 51&% 1&1%31 "



::3 %%))$% *%&111&# 1&(1%1#$,*3#*,13)<%& 1#$1*31+1)

#+ (  $  1& #<&1#& & E *$, )3( 1% *31+1) 51 & )1*1" :*3# 

)%& 5%&&,*9+1%) 1&%%) %%3(1%%9( ) %%*31+1)&5& 1,51 %3

E5 %%31*() (,&5&)1 13+$&+13(#35<&1))&, 1+1 &1 )<#%%$1&1

5*1#%+$%%"



%#% 1&&1&1(1% 9&&&)<#& **31+1) *1) %# 1*$*31+1)

#+ #%#1&&(#3 9&1*3)$%1&%1,1&&(1)<%*3%*31+1)#+ %$

* %%3& 51 (,%13 (1%* % #& 5: 3*31+1)#++"1&& %$%# %

)<9  1&1%3 ::3 %%)&% 1,(1%%*+$$91&&**,%*&1 99 %3(

#  * %<1*3%3 % %+ * 15 :%& %1,( 1% 9& $  #%#1& & %1# +1 

*31+1)+ 95&# "1&# 1&%1% 155(1% 9&$ %1#+1 1&&E

1 #1 %31&&?##&**,%1 %3&&1 '""'!1&&<%&" %&&# 1&

*3 155:%& 1(1% 9&$ 95&# &E'""'!1&&'(1&&?**, 11+$1&1&&

"



:*3#  )%& 1 5%&&, %) %%3 9+1%)*1 5&% **, % %+ * 15 :%& 13

&:)3:#91% %+*%**13)131):%& 13 1&&1 %(1%)#*1&%13&(1%'""'!

) % '""'! & " *31+1) #+  5&+ :&&  **, 1& &  53"   %9

%& 1&%"13)131)+"

2):%& %1 1(**1*31 %%&1*19 1&,1&%(1%&* 9&

<31 + %:% * )1*&&% #11&1 %%3 &* 9& ) % **, ))3 8#% 9&%

) %% 1 %5$$ %"



%* , *31+1) + % %+ %&+ H%219) :%& %1, * %) %%3( 1% 8#%

9&*)$,,1 )*1 "" 1 & 1&%* %1 %1 (1%5+ &1 "



<%3%<1*33*1*31,# &9)3%&+$1&33(1%+ %8#% 9&%1% "

*31+1)&11&%&%1) 1+ % 1(#&&1,5<+ % )# 1 #1%%1)%#% 1 %"









 519,*31+1),8" 9&) % ## ''?!*(# & 31##% %1

&3# 1&1(5<+1*3% **,#< %9*#1%%3 ## ::3& 1&%)$&+"



 % 1#< %# 1&)1 %9 %1  %+&3**, ::3& 1 %" 9& % %

1,1*3)31, 1*3)3 +& 35&1%) %%3" 9&*)1#%&&% %%3

 1%11), % %1%1%# 111 %"  519)+& #< %8" 9&&11&*1)*, % "



 %119%  1+*331  ;=-!"











0)1&*%2)

%*



)%*34

11%05)&1*%* %)