Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-04-15\3 ECLI:EE:TLRK:2006:1.04.15.11061 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against conviction for tax evasion, upholding original judgment on evidence sufficiency.

Case Number 1-04-15\3
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Tallinn Court of Appeal dismissed the defendant's appeal against the first-instance criminal judgment. The court found that the prosecution successfully proved the defendant's intent to evade taxes through the provided financial records and expert analysis. Consequently, the appellate court ruled that the lower court's decision to convict was legally sound and based on sufficient evidence.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Criminal Procedure Code § 329; Criminal Procedure Code § 330: An appeal against a criminal judgment is dismissed if the appellate court finds that the lower court's decision was based on sufficient evidence and correct application of law.

Keywords

AI generated
criminal appeal procedure tax evasion conviction evidence sufficiency appellate review standard intent determination

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Criminal Procedure Code § 329
Criminal Procedure Code § 330

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

�







 

!"

#

$%&

'(

)+*

*

,

--),

-./0--)+/012

(

'(

7+87+9;:

(

7=<>7+8?

<A@%&

5CBDE

FHG+I

J

3BK>K>LE

)

$=M

:

9;:

N<><+O

<>(

?

<AN

'

9;P7+M

Q+R

K+S

R

Q+T

$%&

'

@%U%U(

(

7+:

(

V>3

,

J

2UW

) -V=)+-XFHG+V

Y>*

,

,

/UF;V>X 

ZU,[\V>3

/U]*

)^W

)=!_)+*

*

V

`I

V+,

F;V+I

$%&

'

:

(

'

N

8:

(

7+@

M

a

M

)+J

W

)+-)b=V+I

/)+J

c

d^eO

@

ZUV+J

*

)+-))

*

*

,

$=M

:

9;:

N<><+O

<>(

:

6E+bE

]]

X,

J

)>3

,[A)+I

f

Q

S

Q

*

.B=g

R

XV

Q

W

)L^W

G+I

.,

hi7+O

O

7>7+M

:

'j @

%&

'%

(

'(

)+*

*

,

--)#,

--)+/01J

2;K+SE

Q>Q

E

BK>K

T

E

)=0J

hi7+O

O

<

(

:

%U%N

:7>(

:

<+?

<+j

]]

X,

J

)+J

)+Z)6E+bE

/)

,

J

W

)*

V

/3

)+-XI[\2

J

0ZUY

I

,

-./0--)+gI

0/U2I

kI_ ZUVA003

J

V+I

lM

%@

'

M

mM

ZUV003

J

V+I

Süüdistatav

hn>o6n

Y>,

/Y>V+*

2/01J

p

YHV+,_J

kkJ

)+YH/qI

.V+FH)1)+I

,

X2

V>.U)

YH/0X

)+/0-X3

V+J

)+Y

)+rU,

V+*

YsZ)+I

V+Ft/01J

2ug

00*

Jv/)+I

,

J

)+J

Xp

Q

Q

KE

K

Q

E

Q+w>x

K>E

)E 6>zy=*

V+F;/01J

2g

00*

J=[\I

[{f

R

XV

Q>Q+w

*

.

Q

|UQ>Q+w

*

.6}

|UQ+w>T

*

.B

|Q>Q+T>R

Q

*

.

Q+|Q>Q+T

*

.

Q+R

Q+T

*

.6B

|Q>Q+T

*

.6BAW

)

Q>Q+T

*

.6}~)

*

V+*

Q>Q

)>)>3

J

)>3

V=Z)+r)>X2

V+/)>0>J

V>.U)

B>^B

w

E

Q>Q

E

Q+w>w

K>E

))+*

*

,

--)6#V+-,

-U,)

W

00-,)+1ZU)+/01J

g

00*

J[\I

[€f>f

Q>Q

L

|Q>Q

D

|Q>Q+T

*

. B

|Q>Q+T

*

. }=W

)

Q>Q>T>R

Q

*

.

Q

)+*

V+*6Z)+r)>X2

V+/)>0J

V>.U)

w

)>)>3

J

)+J

YZ)+1, )+*

* )+*

)+J

V>3

}

Q

E

K>DE

BK>K+}E

)

[A)+,

J

W

)

=*

V+/3

)+-XI[\2

J

0Z

[A)+--)+J

)+-2V>3

,

-X

)

W

)

Y€)+XZE)+,

Z0V

I

.U3

0-

‚Aƒ

„

4 †

d^„

‡

4 4 ˆ

Q>n>d‰

&

:

(

<>j

<d^<+O

O

:

NN<

:

NN<+@%&

'Š>‹n

Œ>Œ>n>>Š>Š>Ž>n

<=%

(

'(\%U(

<

O

:

(

7+O

hno6n



:

O

$<+M

„=Œ>‹>Œ

O

86i

‘

j

7Œ?

<A’?

a

M

8U:9He:

(

'

j @<+M

:

(

'(

7%U(

<>(

n

nd^7+&<6'

'(%

(

'(

“9;:

O

O

7+8<6@<+M

:

(

<+j

<6hno n



:^$<+M

„_ Œ>‹>Œ O

8H i

‘

j

76Œ ?

<6’6?

a

M

8U:^Œ>Š

”

@

‰

9;N7

•

<><>(

<>(

7A–<+N

8:

(

'(

7+8<

“>@<+M

:

(

'(

7<+?

<A<+O

8U'(

7+8<A—>Œn

Š˜+n

>Š>Š>—n

<+n

—n™š''(\%U(

<>(?

a+5

<A@%&

'%

(

'(^9;''

9H<

<>n

‹n^lM

%@

'

M

mM

:<

i7+O

O

<

(

:

%U%N€M

<+&'

O

j

<+j

<H%U(

<+O

:

(

O

“hno6n



:

@<+:

(

?

<H<+i7

O

O

<

(

:

%U%N?

a

<

M

<+&

'

O

j

<+9H<

<

E

ƒ

j

<>(

:

@<>7+P<+9;:

(

7A@%M

j

[A01J

0J

V_gV>)+*

V_Zq,

r

}K_g

G+V+Z)HW

00/3

2*=V>3

,

J

)>X

)_/)>3

)+J

,

00-~,

,

.,

/01J

2*

V+YAF;,

*

*

V

V>3

,

J

)+F;,

V63

00ZU,

JJ

2*

V+r;I

,

-./0--)+/01J

2*

V/U,

I

W

)+*

,

/U2*

JJ

V>)+J

)>X

)6Dg

G+V+Z)=W

00/3

2*

Y)+*

)+J

V>3

/01J

0J

V›/)+-J

V+*

V+,/)+2

X2œJ

V>)+J

)+Z)+/3{J

V.V+F;,

V>3

J

E [A)>3

)+J

,

00-œJ

2*

V+rV>3

,

J

)>X

)

/U,

I

W

)

*

,

/U2*

JžI

,

-./0--)+/01J

2Ÿ/)+2

X2Ÿ}K g

G>V+Z)¡W

00/3

2*

Y¢)+*

)+J

V>3£g

G+V+Z)>3

J

Y¤F;,

*

/01J

2F;V+-V+J

*

V=g

0U0*

V+*0-Zq,

FH)+*

,

/ J

2J

ZU2

X

)=I

,

-./0--)+/01J

2H0J

23

V>.U)E>]]

X,

J

)+J

)+Z

Zq,

r6/)>3

)+J

,

00-,UV>3

,

J

)>X

)A]/3

-V>3^)>XZ0/)>)+X,

JU/)+,

J

W

)Z)+1V+-X2

V+*

E

h„¥

h

46 †

o¦¥

h~™šƒ

ˆ

ƒd

†

„ƒ;$=§‡

$

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

‚\:

N

8U@

%N

N<

@%&

';(

7+:

(

'@%&

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

¨

[A01J

2/0*

*

V+V>.,

2F›*

V+,

)+rYV+JV+V+*

J

00X2J)+I

ZUV>3

J

)>XV>3AJ

2*

V+r;J

]1,

J

)>X

)*

,

--)+/01J

2 0J

23

V>.U)

6EbE

R

*

V€FHq,

J

V+J

Xg

q1W

V+-X

)+FH)+J

2*

J;*

V+V+rUV

W

)~3

,

2*

,

V+*

J;FH0J

,

ZUV+V+I

,

FH)+J

)~3

)+-/UJ

,

00-,

)+*

)+F;FHG>G+I

)*

G+1V+X

)+-V/)

I

,

J

E

[A01J

2/0*

*

V+V>.,

2F;YA)+I

ZUV>3

J

)>XV>3 gI

0/U2I

kI

,Ag

00*

J=V>3

,

*

V"J

q3

J

V+J

X~)>3

W

)>0*

2Y\V+J=6Eb›g

00*

J

/)+--)+J

)+-2J

V

1J

V>3"J

)+I

ZU,

J

)+J

X©

]]

,

*

,

-VšZG>.,

Z)+*

Xg

0*

-2

X3

V+*

*

,

-V+Y=V+J 3

V+*

*

V+.U)

0*

V+/3

/)>)>3

-V+-2

X_-,

F;V+J

)+F;,

ZG>G+I

V>X_J

V+I

ZU,

V+/)+1W

J

23

V>XY

)+F;2J

,)>.U)6/){6EUbªJ

V+I

ZU,

V+*

,

/U/U2

0*

2/0I

X

)+Y*

V

,

)+rYV+JA6Ebz0-0J

J

)+I

rUV+/)>3«FHq,

J

)¬3

)+-/UJ

,

0U0-,\/UV>3

/UFHG>G+I

);*

G+1V>X

)+-V

/)+I

,

J

R

E

0UE

Q

K)>)>3

J

)+JZ)+-.,

J

J

E

Žn

21,

-X2XV>3=V+V+*

J

00X2

JW

)[\I

!"Hf

R

J^}>}D *

.

Q

g S

f }>}

x

g S

}>SK6*

.HSgE

SJ

]1,

J

)+r

/01J

2/0*

*

V+V>.,

2F{)

*

*

,

--)=#,

--)+/01J

2;K+SE

Q>Q

E

B>K>K

T

E

)=0J

Vœb€[A)+I

f

Q

S

Q

*

.B=g

R

XV

Q

W

)=L^W

G+I

.,UFHq,

J

V+J

X/)

I

,

J

V=03

)>3

E

-V=)+-XFHG+V



ZU,U[\V>3

/U]*

)

!_)+*

*

V`I

V+,

F;V+I