Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-05-864\4 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:1.05.864.1903 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against criminal order for non-enforcement of administrative penalty for tax evasion.

Case Number 1-05-864\4
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appellant's appeal against a criminal order issued for failing to pay an administrative tax penalty. The appellant argued that the tax authority had not properly calculated the fine and failed to consider mitigating circumstances regarding the delay in payment. The court rejected these claims, ruling that the administrative body had correctly determined the amount and that the procedural requirements for issuing the criminal order were fully met.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Tax and Customs Code; Criminal Procedure Code: The court established that a criminal order for non-enforcement of an administrative penalty is valid if the penalty amount is correctly calculated and the procedural prerequisites for initiating criminal proceedings are satisfied.

Keywords

AI generated
administrative penalty enforcement criminal order non-enforcement tax evasion proceedings procedural requirements appeal against criminal order

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Tax and Customs Code
Criminal Procedure Code

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

      

                 

     ! "            #$%&'(    )*)+*''&+'+,('&*)'&&+ -+$ ("." - +$ &&'+     /)0+)  '+&1 ))21 &33&1  4'*&+)+&)&&2'++     5)22' --2'  "- "- .+$ 6,('&2/)0+)&')*)+*''&+  &2/)0+)7)&%8)&*&+29  ) +*&&2'+) )! '&))$&*''9('8!+2*))&'')*)8'&8'+'

9. :)($"8))&'*0'  &2/)0+)7)&&'$'*&2)%+2+)&332'  !++&'   ) .   &&)*)++2)2'&+)&'+'$ ++) . .)2' "/)0+)+'"(3)+'!)&!+'  '+$)&2/)0+)7+'"!+)&')&)2'2+'8,'&2&&'20(3,+ -  +$!$))*)+*''&++'**'$          &*8)2+&*)'+'*'0'- -9(.!$)')+ 



   !    %%2)&  ')&&2 /) 0+)7+' '++'" '& &'* ++' )&&2 58 & (+&

   *+$ -+$ ("!$)%'&'8$)&'$"*)++'&)&*)' +%&) '2) ' &' &'! !+" ++' ''$  -  +$  (  &'2&2 ))  

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