Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-05-771\1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:4.05.771.3474 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against ruling on criminal record for foreign national seeking asylum. Foreign national appealed ruling on criminal record for asylum. Court dismissed appeal citing lack of new evidence and procedural compliance. Appeal rejected due to absence of new evidence and procedural compliance. Appeal dismissed as no new evidence or procedural error found.

Case Number 4-05-771\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the appeal against a ruling concerning the applicant's criminal record in the context of an asylum application. The applicant argued that the original decision failed to properly assess the relevance of the foreign criminal record to the asylum claim. The court found no merit in the appeal, noting that the original decision was based on established facts and followed the correct legal procedure without requiring further investigation.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

s. 10 AsylG 2004; s. 11 AsylG 2004: The court may reject an appeal against a decision regarding the assessment of a foreign criminal record if the applicant fails to provide new evidence or demonstrate a procedural error in the original decision.

Keywords

AI generated
asylum application criminal record assessment foreign national appeal dismissal procedural compliance

Cited Legislation

AI generated
s. 10 AsylG 2004
s. 11 AsylG 2004

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                                         

                  

      !"          

#$  

%"" #&'(%"#'(')%*+% %% $ ,-% ! #.#*%" %%/%"

 #%"%.#%  ( (    $## %*% %#0% ## %#0% ##" "-0#          +% "#%!%1%#

%% $ ,-% ! #.#*%" %%/%"

  #%"% .#%    ( (         !      " #0%!

#2"%+% %%$ "% !    ! %!%"%.3*%#-0%*% !%." .#% 0% ##%0%#  # !" #0&-0 !")   #! 

*+%#% %"" #%*+%"#%!%1%# %%$ ,-%!#.#*%"%%/%"

#%"%.#%  ( ( 

#!"*0%*%%*%%#0%##%#0#("0%"#0%%#"%%"/#%# ."%0%#3##"#%-"(%##-%#%#""%!##%%"(0#3##%"-#".%0 0##% 0//# .30"# #- #% !%"% %*# %#-  ""% ###  "%" #%##%--%     

 4#%0%%#"%%-#5 "/ !%"#"3/%#-0.3"#"% %*#."%0%%#"%!"#6"-0%%#"%#%#-#%"%4#."#45 "/#"%* 6"-0%%#"% #% !%"% %#- 0#"% %*  !%. "( "#% !%.#( 0" #."%0%%#"%#0%%#""%"%#."%0%%#"%%##%-. 4#."# .#%!#"""%  #."% 0%%#"% #%"% " #."% 0%%#"% # ##.0%##%-."#%

 %*%%#0%.0%##%/" 7 

%* * +% #%  %*% %# .* %*% %#0% ## %#0# 4 5  %"# "-#%(  4 % "% #%##- #%#( .#%0%%#"% 0"0%%#"% ##%-( .%#-% .#%0%%#"% % 4 % #%# %*%## %#0% "%- %%/ #"%* "#- %*%## %#0% ##0%"  5  8%"0%##- 5 "/  %"# %##% 03." !3%" 099-"#- %*%##%/ # 0%/(%""%0%%#"%+3/%"%#"%*%*%##099-"0%03.-!3%- %-%"%(0%%-0%%#"%#3."%-0%/0"(0- !%*03. "#% !"# %##- .#%#0 #"  "%."# .#%!#"""#    

#  %""% #--""(%## : .#%!#""##%4#%!#""(%# #."% 0%%#"% "%-  #."% 0%%#"% % ##%-. "#%

 4#%!#"" !99-%"  6""#  0%%#"% %-%   0%%#""%  .30"%-03/#%#% +#-%%%"#-#"%*(%#

###"%#--"%-##%#0%#" #%-"%""%#(%##-%#%#""%!##%%"#"%"-0//#.30"#.%0#% !%"% %*# %#-( %  "# %*% %#0% ## %#0%  "%*( %#

#2"% # 0%%#"% / .#%!#""(  "  !%.( 0""" "%-  #."%0%%#"%%##%-.

#%"%%#-#"%6####(0"%#" .30##%-0#-!%.".3%-!-.#-"%-.#%%%""%/ #."% 0%%#"%/ 6%-# .3#0#  %%/ % 3"#-

# 3/#% #%#0% 0##% 6#."%0%%#"%!"#"%"##-%"/##%#(.-3

#2"%#- 0%%#"-0%-";.#%!#""(0""%!#%-"% +#-%%%"#-#"%*(%#%"%.""%%%6# 5 "/#--03.# !3#(0"%"%%*%%#0%##%#0% 45 7"/! %"##%%*0#%*%"*.#0##0%#0% -*0%!/#/#*%*%%""%%#-"%(%*%##-45 "3%#%##-##099-0#0##-##%#0# +#-%%%"#--"-%#%-%#%#%#("%*(%#%*%%#0%##%/#"%* ## %#0#(

#  %* #"%*  ## "* .#0#(  #-  %*% %#0% ##%/%*#"%*

#2"%#/#- 4#."#45 : !%0%*#%#-0%%#"##%#0##0%!%"%( 0%*3/%#-%*%"*.#0##0%!%"%   <""< $

#      3/%