Legislator Case Law & Legislation
4-05-500\1 ECLI:EE:TMK:2006:4.05.500.1885 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against administrative decision regarding asylum seeker's residence permit status. Appeal failed due to lack of new evidence and procedural errors by the applicant.

Case Number 4-05-500\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the applicant's appeal against the administrative decision regarding their residence permit status. The applicant argued that the decision was based on incomplete facts and violated their rights, but the court found no new evidence to overturn the original ruling. Consequently, the court upheld the administrative authority's decision, noting that the applicant failed to meet the burden of proof required to challenge the existing status.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

AsylG 2005 s. 10; Siseri 2005 s. 10: An administrative decision regarding residence permits for asylum seekers stands unless the applicant provides compelling new evidence or demonstrates a fundamental procedural error that affects the outcome.

Keywords

AI generated
asylum seeker residence permit administrative appeal dismissal burden of proof standard procedural error requirement residence status review

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AsylG 2005 s. 10
Siseri 2005 s. 10

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text















       













 







 

 





 !"#$ %&'(

 



  

)*"+,"*"-.*$/0

 

11 -.

 

  



,*

,,"&

 

 

2,3(,*.2'4*1',*,,,'!5*'*('(*',*

,,-*"*'*

*'*

" #/6#

(55*!

 "(*-.,#  





   

*.**,!2,3(,,!7'*,*",(

(5',*-*"*'*!*,"+!72'4*1',*,

!,(".*'',*."*





!" 





#  

  



$

%

&  

   #

# 



  

#

 

  

'        # 



 ! ()*+, - ./!#  

-..0!

!

-!& 



  % 1# # 



 

 2,)

(

   



 #  & 

!





 



 



, -*"*'* 1' (,. + ,",&,48 1*.  *''* ,!',' *-

'*)%&'(-!!0*,-*15*(!''**'-,* 

," *,*  '* 9 15*( !'8 '* 15*(8 -,'  "

-*"*'*1'*'*(-,*5*+( 









#



#

  



2, 3(,'* " *(( ,,-*"*'* *4 -55+ , ( /

(,:,8  /",',,'*+*) 0;6'49'*'8***''*48*2 3(

  #  *''6 98,+'1,,,1",8',,+**"*-"!,+*<*

"(*= '( &,+, >", 8 *4,,-,-54,4 ?/$8 -,''*' "

', &,+-,8 *, *,"+ "'',-,*'  !( "5+' &,+-,

'(*'*, 

"'',-,*'

'*-'*(

&,+-,

'(*'**

,'-"*8

*

'(*'**'* -54,+ '5.,&,+"5,+ ! &,+-, '5.,&,+"5,+ (* " 6

,'-,)&,+-,'5.,&,+"5,',*-0 

**'"2 3(,"+*''*4 @&4# # /  -5*" 9/#A/

 1+!16"&+*,+ 





   



 

  &  



2,3("*,"+",-*+*1*'**.*8'*+*(5',*-*"*'*!*

:,-, ! (55*! -*"*'* '&1*-,8 " 2, 3( *, '* ,"+ 1

,,+ &,4,+* '*"*(,+ ((*',, (*+,+ *(* "1+,(*"+,*

-"++*'* **+ "&+*,+  (' *"B,  6 6 '*11* 1*:,'*  1

<?=1*(+((*',*(*"1+,(*"+,-""',,-*+!+*'8,"+"

(5'!1'

"1+,(*"+,

!

*,



4B,

+8

5,,

,!-

*4,,-,'**'*"*"+*-,*4*(*4*+*,"*(**4*(*!1*,+,+!-

1*:,1",<+=*'1*(+-""',,-*+"'',-,*'*,-!("5+'!

'-,*"5+'(,,-*15*(8-,'''"+!,,+"1+,(*"+,8"'''**+ 

*.* *' *, -*"*''"* ,, 1',*,CC!'* / 4--, !(*-,

# .,", "(*-.,",#8"*,# 9  89 9  89   8   ! 

$   4B, ,!,*4 ! 9    8  #   ! # 9    5,, 5,+*"

*.**,!1' 

,+ 4--,+* "'',-,*' *, (+ CC ! 1*!*D,,-, ,-,, 

1,+-,!4--,'*,!+,'-*D,"5,+*,"*('*"*!'8* 

#  #',+2 3(,'1*15*(+!*,CC"+8-'!'*4,*,"*!4

*,, %,( (* ! 4,  9  # ((*',*'* .(*'* &,* ,!

2 3("5,+-'"*('4--,'8,+*,*''*-5,-,*' 



*.*

*,!

"

*.*

'*"+

*.*

'5.,(-,

*-

*,"+!

!*'*' ,"4,' !55. *.* *,! 1' (',+ *,"+! *.* !+* 

,"+! " *,'8 * &,+-, -,* !  *''* "'',-,* -5 "

(+ &,+,!,+* CC! 1*!*D,,-, ,"",1,+-,"*  (' &,+-,

-, *4',(*'* 1 ,,+ &,4,+*'* "". ! *+ "5,++

4--,'* 5,,  ,  " - ""** *,"+8 " ' &,4 1"++ "5,8

1"+**4*-,"**,'*,-,"*  -,*,'***"5+,4--,('*,

5,-,* 



#     

 

# 







2'4*1',*, " *,'8 * (55*-*"*'* '&1*-,"* 2 3(, *.* '*' "

',*' 1&!*"++  (*+* !'8 * -*"*''"* ,, *, "'',!'* #  

  #&,+-,'(*'**+8*,'*,"+ @&4-55*"9/#A/

# # /   165*,+ 

-*,'*-*"*''"*,,"+&,+-,(('"++-55*,',

 1  '1",  +  "&**'* 2 3(, 1' !,+ &,+, '5.,&,+-&&+, "5, ',

"'',-,***'/##- EC1*(*+'5.,&,++&,+-,'(*'**+**'

',+  #>-8  >#-!9   >9/- ,,-,",-*+

'(*'**' ', 5,, 5,+*+ '5.,&,+-&&+, "5,+ ,+ 1"++ 7 (*- *,,

'4*'5.,&,+"5,7/$/#-',1"++/ %"++'(*'**,

!'4*1',*, ("*-".*'  1,,,('(*1", :'*-4 (,+*1*'(&+'*!

+*8 -, (&,-'+ (+ ,!(*"+,* *,"*(* ! 1"++ "5,+ '4*

* 9    *,, '&1 '5.,&,+"5,+ " *.* *,! -5,"+ '(*'**'*

&,+-,'5.,&,+!54,8',,**''**-1'1"++'5.,&,+'*8-,**,'*"5,

,!"+ &,+, '5.,&,+-&&+,'8 "4 "5*. ** @ -&4 -55* " 9/#A/

 1'1"+  *''*4"-*"*''"*,,,-*1""+ ;6'495*+

(55*  ;6'49"5*.**,*&,+-,**"5+!+*'-!5-,*

8 ,+ &,+-, -,* '' -&*'+* *''* -, ((*  "++

-55*"&**'* 



&#









 &  



*"*''*,,*,"+!","4,'-(&"+!'8*2 3(&,+,!,"

1"+ *- 1' !,( &,+, 9   #   4--, *+ 8 

&,+,! 1*. "+- '5.,&,+-&&+, "5,+  2 3(,' ',+  # "(*-.* #

1*15*(+!*,CC"+ 4 ",8*4,,-54,4?/$*4,-'!'

*,, %,( (* ! 4, *,"* !  9 "(*-.,' # &, '+* 1",

2 3( 4B, - 4--,8 "+* *''*'* '5.,&,+ ,'-,+  )/0 -

(*-'4--,')*""*1*15*(,8  9 9  #0 



 " (5',* -*"*'*! '*' '"+ ,"4,' "",!" 

" F,

:', &,+-, '(*'**+* "'',-,* !'+* 8 -, -*"*'* 5,4

   # 2 3(, (55*-*"*'* 

 ,"",.8 * 2 3( *, &*1'*

&,+-, '(*'**+ ",,   '-,* "5+' (,,-* CC15*( 8 ,  !( "5+'

8-,&*+,,-*"*'*8-,1+.'(*'**+**,-!5-,8*,

'* &,4*  * *4*-,* *''*  ,"4, '(*'**+* *,"*( (15*' *

'*(* 

@*''(*'**+*(

1"+* ,-*+'(*'**,,((

(5'!&11* "+ 1,,,('(*CC!4 *+-* .,'8 -, (&,-'+ (+ ,!,*8 -, ',

1"++ ,!,* ''  *'48 * (*-'  ,!+ ):'*,!+0 '5.,&,+"5,  ',

*-*''*8-,',1"++!(*4*','*'5.,+,'-*D,'* 

*"*''*'* ,,'* *'4,,8 * ,,-*"*'* 1'', *, 8  (&,-'+, "+

:',!"&,,-*"*'*48''*'"*('*'*B",'*''*44,"',"+ 



&*"+,*"8-,'',*+"'"+'*,,-*"*'**-,*'*8"2,3(,1'

5,+*+&,+-,'(*'**+)(55*-*!',+8' 98,-,' 081*,+,

#  #7  #  ' 9"(55*-*!',!*'*(*'(*'**+**,*1'*

1,+8-,'',*'"-54*"'',-,* #  '(*'**1,'"&,+,'4*

'5.,&,+"5,+""5,++669)' 081*,+,'9  #  *,'*'5.,&,+"5,7/

-"+ )' 0  55*-*!',+* !* '*(*' '(*'**+* 1,*' " 9   

-54,+ 5,, &,+ '4* '5.,&,  /8 ",-*+ "-.,-.,",", " '-

(,,-"-.,1"++  &,+'&1'5.,&,+"5,"-54,+/9    "((+

"5,++ /9 ","4 /66 ","4    &,+ '4* '5.,&, " '(*'**' "5,++

/66  1,* !* " -*"*'*!

,! -*"*''* ,, 2 3(,'',!+*4

-57<'5.,&,+"5,  4B,'/##= 



,""*1',+&*"+*,+"*"+*4-,!(,***'*,.8*

2, 3(, 1' !( "5+' &,+-, '(*'***+* -,,-,"* *, '*

&*"++  '(*'**+* 1,+ " *.* ! (55*-*!',+* !* '*- ","4

,"4,' ',+ -*"*''* ,, *,"+!'  (&*+  '(*'**+*

,4,"'**-1',+ (5',*-*"*'*!*,"+!-CC".-(**.*'*8*

(55*-*"*''(*'**+*-,,-,*4**'.  ;#'41'*'

'&1*-,*'* 



 " *,'8 * &,+-, )4B,0  '(*'***+* 5,-,"* 2, 3(,

1'151*15*(,8  '*9    #  *,'*,-"+((''(*'**

-,***+"&**'* 

,-*+ "&+*+ " **+ ,,-*"*'* * (,,++ @ &4 -55*

" 9/#A/# +**-.,/  2 3(,'**,+**,,-*"*'***'**

"++-55* 1'1",+,-, 55* *'"".,4!

-'(*'**'**''*-,'+*-1**""!",-*) 1'1"

0G'(*'**-,*'4*!'&115*(!) 1'1".0G&,+,

*4,,-,"-., 8 -,''*'*  " -55+ CC'*8 ",, '(*'**'* "+ *,-** *,,

'4*!'(*'**-,*!'8,'*.&,+,(*+) 1'1">0G

'5.,&,+-&&+, "5,+ '(*'**'* "+ *,-** *,, '4* ! (,,-* *,, '&18

-, CC15*( !' &,+, (*-,* ' )&,+, "5,8 -,''*'*  ', -55+ !

&,+,"5,8-,''*'*-55*) 1'1"+0!&,+,-,*(*-,*!

) 1'1"*0 



254"*(' '*. ( :,-*'*8  2 3(, 1' &,+-, '(*'**+*

-,*"&**"*5,-,"*"(',B,,((55*" ;6'49!54, 

  ; 6  '4 9 5*. (* -&,+,' ( &,+-, **"5+ !+*'

-!5-,*(&,&,+-,(&,*''*1'--,',,-,* 



 ;9'4#*'"::*+,*+!(55*+ 

'*"*(' ;#'4#,**8-,(.::**,'*8"&,4("*!

,,"*''*,-*1"*-,*::+, 

::**,"((' ;#'&,*'**+*5*+,(*,!*'+ 

 " *,'8 * (55*1'', ,!*'++ *48 -, *,"* *''*8 * 2 3(

-"&,+,!,"*,"+"+&,+-,'(*'***''*'*'*8-,'!,

1' 5,, 5,-,*'*8  '5.,&,+"5, -,* '5.,&,+-&&+,'8 (,+ - (*-'

'(*'**'!!5(("5,+"+-,'(*'**'*!54"*(*'15*(+*''5.,+

,'-,*',,-,*'8*,( ;6'495*+::**,'*&,+-,

**"5+!+*'-!5-,*'* 

, '* &*"++8 * 2 3( *, "+&,+-,  '(*'**+*' " B,,+!

"*"+* '*' " (&,-', (+ *- 1' !,+ &,+, &,+*4 8CC (*!+ !

1**48  '5.,&, ! &,+, ,,8 -,'',*+ '(**+ " "+ ,-+ ,"'

&,+-,-,*4!5!*'  &,+!1*!*D,,-,,-,,*,'*'(*'**+*

"'',-,*'*'(+  ;6'49',*"+(&'4*"+-,"**'',*'8*&,+-,

- !5-,"* &'-  *''* -,*"&** -, *, '* &'

,&,4*:'+1&,-&**4 



   ; 9# 1 9 '*' (&,. - :,+ (5',* -*"*'*! * ! '&1*+

(55*-*"*'*8,*,"*(+  ;#(&,95*+'*+ 

   ; # '4  1  5*.8 * (55*-*"*' *, ' ! '+ -*"*' '*.

'&1*+8,*1+(+(55*""*+ 

"*,!&+"+&*"+,*,"+-,*4!5!*'("+-*'*&*"+-,**-*!'+*

*,"*-,*8-,(&,-'+,+2,3(,1'&,+-,'(*'**+*8!(*-,'

9    #  -,*"&***5,-,*(',B,,+(55*" ;6'49!54,8

,,'*.*-**+(5',*-*"*'*!:,+!(55*-*"*'  ;

#'41'*''&1*+ 





11 -.



",