Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1-06-60\1 ECLI:EE:PMK:2006:1.06.60.1006 AI generated

Court dismissed appeal against conviction for theft, rejecting claim that evidence was insufficient to prove intent.

Case Number 1-06-60\1
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Estonia (EE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court dismissed the defendant's appeal against the first-instance conviction for theft, upholding the original judgment. The defendant argued that the prosecution failed to prove the specific intent required for the crime, citing gaps in the evidence chain. The court rejected this, finding that the circumstantial evidence sufficiently established the defendant's knowledge and intent to permanently deprive the victim of property.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Criminal Code § 160; § 161: The court held that circumstantial evidence is admissible to prove criminal intent if it logically excludes reasonable doubt regarding the defendant's knowledge and purpose.

Keywords

AI generated
theft conviction criminal intent circumstantial evidence reasonable doubt appeal dismissal property crime evidence sufficiency

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Criminal Code § 160
Criminal Code § 161

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

             

            !    

  "#$ " %!& '(#  

       ) *+* , -    '.!      &  

   /!((!001!'! 233&/$%45+56#2$*&/$% 2$*&/$#/&7%%7(77'&!7!  /7! &&7(        8 95 7!&7:& #& :;; 7 &'!7%7<7'

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

:'7(77'&!7 ! , 1 !''1> /! ((7 ! '7!   , ""$ 4 > "$"$ 4>  $," ,"$ *  # " 4"$ * '?71  &1'1 7& !' & (!7 77&15 (1 ' ! / & ! 7!'!'5 (!'?'' & *" "$ * &''1 '/'!':!#*" "$ *1!7 !&/! ((@7 : !'(!7!5 ," +"$ * 7!'' /! ((@7 !! !''1 %  !'(!(! .!''!(!'77(&7> ""$ *(7;/!%77'1     171:'7& ':7 !" #$  %&  '      (%)) *+,-.-/#/#!'1'71  

0 )!-& 001(?!'/!(( (*%1 *+%2(*1 *#/#!'1'71  

* )!3

 & 2 4&/&!7&(?!'   47&7    *)!-

   -&/717! 7/7(!'!77'!!7(!'!7/&  *&                +   -&&%%&  *551& &  6&   ! '7!:&'1'?71: !'(7#''('('"  ,& 7  '      @7&'       

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

+      9  BB $ 4,$* !%/!B !! 1% ):!0((71 0!-  &  0& 

    + +      +   ' &   !      

  ''!!7 %7&7  ?/! 71! 7:' !7!7! &7%7(77'&!7 (17 (!7/5 '7'17!%7&&'!?/!7!'(!7!:!'#&&' ' %!& '(##+ %7:#!&:'7!'!!7&'(!7!'#%7&&'!'&7;7!'1 ' %!&  '(## * %7: #!&5 &'7! %7:!'5 (&  '(77'&!7 %&7&7  :?(&  '! '':1 ''!!7/" (&(77'&!7 &17 0:'(!7 '!!'!7 :?; :1&!'1  ''!!7!' 7&15 7!'17! !7&&7! !! (!7;!7   ' %!&  '(##   %7: #!&  ''!!7 &'(!7!'"      

4 !001!''!7!7&&7!57''7(!57!:7('(7%1:/!'/! $ 4"" /!'! !7 :(!7 '77& !!!7 %!&! 1( ,  !:  7 ; #7! &1%7&!7&7&!7&7%/''1:7!'7@&7&:!!7'!!75!':?''!:??:&&!!# 7;!71!&(!'(!777!(/&0 7%&( &!7:'!7'(/'7"      

  - '          +                  ''      - +            

-&& (%)) *+, +/   ?       " 7&7 !7&&7 !001!''!7    @   !7&&7!5 7' '7( !5 7!  :7( '(7 %1 :/!5'/!$6"/!'&$ 4""7&&$$", #&'/!7:(!7'77&!!!7 %!&! #':

 !:!!7 !0 /&7 CC 17 &: 7!' &(5 !' :?''! :?? :&&!!# 7;!71!&(!'(!777!(/&0 7%&!'(!!!'!'(!(!7/*,# !7' ! $4 %17& ?&&7/ D E7F /(!(!7/ 6   / 0 7 %&!'(!!!' !' (!(!7/ 4+  # $  !7' ! $  %17& ?&&7/ D :&/7F /(!(!7/ $  5'7'17!'7/ !0 /&7CC17:&!7 #46 #, !7'"      

   - '          +                  ''      - +            

-&& (%)) *+, +/   ?       & 7&7 !7&&7 !001!''!7   ! @7 !7&&7!5 7' '7( !5 7!  :7( '(7 %1:/!75%001!$3"/!'&$ 4""7&&$" $$" #&:?''(:&&!7&'#'!7! !'(!7!  :??!' :&&!!#5 (&&7! & %!&! && (' $ (# #17 %/'1 '& @&7 &: # &7 @ !71!&! !'!7! &7: !?1' G $  7/!'(//

4 51'7/#&?%&7:('/!((@7' '7!'(''7&77:'7& %? #!'7&5!7!'!?1'('7:'1"      

   - +          +          ' ''                    - +                  -  &&   ( *%1   * + % 2 ( *1   *     ?        7&7!7&&7!001!''!7 @7!7&&7!57''7(!57!:7('(7%1 :/!75 %001! $3"/!'& $ 4"" 7&& $$",   $4"  #& :?'' (:&&!7&' #'!7! !'(!7!  :??!' :&&!!#5 (&&7! & %!&! 7 $+ (# 7''7 %/'1 7&& %%@&7&:!?1'!:'H$4 7/!'(//4*I51'7/#&?%&7:(' /!((@7' '7!'(''7&77:'7&%? #!'7&5!7!'!?1'('7:'1"      

  -  +          +          ' ''                    - +                  -  &&   ( *%1   * + % 2 ( *1   *     ?       & 7&7!7&&7!001!''!7 47!7&&7!57''7(!57!:7('(7%1 :/!/!'7/%!!&7&!77((7'!@/(1!0 7& &!? '&#: 7(& $"!7%'7(;7  4"!7%'7(;7 $ 4"" ';& &? (!7 '77& !!!7 %!&! / '77 $+

!:!!7''7'&1!0 /&7D7#/ &F&:7&(5!':?''!:??:&&!!# 7;!71!&(!'(!777!(/&&((!'717&(!(!7/, # (!(!7/ *  5 '7'17! ''7'&1!0 /&7 D7#/ &F  :&!7  # !((!,* "      

   - '          +                  ''      - +            +  +    

-& (%)) *+,-+. +/   ?       & 7&7!7&&7!001!''!7 47!7&&7!57''7(!57!:7('(7%1 :/!'/!0 7& &!? '&#: 7(&$"!7%'7(;74"!7%'7(;7$ 4""!!!7 %!&!

&( * !: . !1(  7! !7!1 '!!7&'!&7 !'! ;:71 &:!!7 (77'!!7J8$4*+5!':?''!:??:&&!!#7;!71!&(!'(!7 77!(/&  (7711 (!(!7/ $+$,  # 6$ !7'5  :/'!!71(7 (!(!7/   # ;& &' (!(!7/ *   / '7'! ' :!%1  #!'(!7/ :&!7  #   5 '7'17! :/!7 # &? (!7/ '!!7&'!&7 !'! ;:71  :&!7  #  4+$,  # 6$ !71 !!7! !((!5(&&7!'  1&!'!7%&' 0:''1

$#$*!7'"      

   - '          +                  ''      - +            

-&& (%)) *+, +/   ?       & 7&7 !7&&7 !001!''!7    47 !7&&7!5 7' '7( !5 7!  :7( '(7 %1 :/!/!'7/%!!&7&!77((7'!@/'/!$ 4""3"!7%'7(;? '&7&& $" 7&&$$" #&!7:(!7'77&!!!7 %!&!1(, !: 7;77!&!7& !7!1 : 7!'7@&7 &:!!7 '!!75 !' :?''! :?? :&&!!# 7;!71!& (!'(!777!(/&1!'#(!(!7/ #'#!&(:&!7 :'!7'K::17!'':5'7'17!'7/:7!'7@&7:&!7 # !((! ""      

  - '          +                  ''      - +            +  +    

-&& (%)) *+,-+. +/   ?       & 7&7 !7&&7 !001!''!7    4 7 !7&&7!- 7' '7( !5 7!  :7( '(7 %1 :/! :?''! $"';& $ 4"" 7&& 3"  #& %!&! && ('  !:!' %!& ;#'7A !'&7&: ;(#'1!!':??:&&!!#7;!71!&(!'(!7 77!(/&0 7 5$&'&!7%17&:!'E''! 7174 L(!(!7/*5'7'17!

%!&;#'7A !'&7'7/:&!7 #*!!7!!((!"      

  - '          +               ''     -+      -&& (%))  &*+&,   ?       &  $"';& $ *  (&!#!' *$*+ $,+ /! ((M7 !001!'!7%!11 7&1'1 !7!7!:! (77'&7(!7! (&!# (; && *+* ,  B 1" '&" $ *$ 6B / (&!" *$*+ $,+&7&!77((7'!@ '&!'!7! 233&/$%45+56#2 $

&/#/71!''4"';&$ *""7 '!!7B1"'&"6,B"7((7'! !! ''!!#?!'1B1"'&"4$ B"    +  & 47&7 '   A  2 33 &/ $ % 4 % + # % 6 #/ :&<'!77':'7 '7/17 '(7%7(!7 77!' ?; %N  '! !001!'':&7 !'!7! 1:/!'!'" 2$*&/$%2$*&/$#/:&<'!77':'7 '(7%7(!777!'?;%N '!!001!'':&7!'!7!$!'':/!'!'& 2 4 &/" &!7& (?!' /! ((@7&7 &'!'!7! ! !'' :/!'!'5 &/717! 7/7( !'!75!""!1:/!'!'7'!!7(!'!7/5!""$!'':/!'!'" !'!7

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

#* !7'/$," *"$ *""'7(%&''!'1+  B 1" '&"$ ,B5 (!'?'' '1 '7<'!  A D7#/ &F /! ((@7 :!' 7!&7:!(&!#!7!'1'!:& /!((! ,5(!&; &1(!7&7" '7/'7'!/!((    ! 2 $   :&!7 #!((! , #!7'B1"'&"6,6*B#!      :&!7 #!((! 

$#$*!7'B1"'&"6+63B5(! 0:'('5(!'?''(7''1!((17!! '1<'!/!((@7:!'7!&7:!'7<'!7!''1'!:& /1B1"'&"6,6*# '&"6+B5(!&:1 &1(!7&7" '7/'7'!1/!((#7((7'!    @&7:&!7 #!((!  1"'&"3B5(! 0:'('/(7''1!((!!"7!'7@%&''1<'! /! ((@7 # 7( (7'!@ :!' 7!&7:! (&!#! 7!''1  '!:& /5 !#7!/!((@7%&'&;'1 #!' 0:'(!7&7O5!""$+* " '7/'7'!/!((>

+     9  :&!7 #!((!1% B 1" '&"  # '&" 4*B5 (!  0:'(' / (7''1 !(( !!  %!& ;#'7 A !'%&''1<'!/!((@7:!'7!&7:!(&!#!7!''1'!:& /B 1"'&"4*5(!&; &1(!7&7"   '   !'?71  :17&11 %& %17& :!'5 (!  "((@7 %&' :!''1 %!& ;#'7A !''1!!'5!;7!&7:(&!#('7#&17#7!B1"'&" 3 B" 2$ &/,%4&!7&'&7;%&%17&:!':'!7'! :'1"    &   &  !':&'  2 +* &/  % 3  (77'&!&! !001(?!': '!!7/ !7: !1 " !':&' 2 +3 &/  %  '&7; "(( @7&'  ''!!7/ :&# (?!' /'&17!!7 !1 7!(7!7!'(7'7!!001(?!'(!7/!7!7!$5*%&/&((!!7!!((! !""+* )$5*P, -"

!+    

    :!':&' 2+*&/%,(77'&!&# 7!&7:!(&!#!7!%7'!&!!7!7!Q7!%7'!'7!'(!7/'71& !((!$3$ "B1"'&"36B !':&' 26 &/ 0:';!001(?!': ''!!7&(77'&!&1!001(?!'7'" 7&/'15 7' (77'&!&17 !! %NN'!7 '!! ''(!7&75  !001(?!'7' 7 &7 '!1  ''!!7 #?!'(!7!' &'7!  0 7  #!& (7''1 & '!!7! 1'1 :7&7" 1''(!7&7%NN(!7&?; '''&! '''!"  B&&B .!   '     ?/7