Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1 BvR 890/20 ECLI:DE:BVerfG:2020:rk20200527.1bvr089020 AI generated

Right to be heard violated by judgment issued before hearing deadline expired, cured by subsequent consideration of timely submission

Case Number 1 BvR 890/20
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Inadmissible

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Federal Constitutional Court declined to take up the constitutional complaint, leaving the lower civil court judgment in force. The dispute concerned a procedural violation where a civil court rendered a judgment before the expiration of a statutory deadline for the complainant's response, thereby breaching the right to be heard. The Court acknowledged that this initial ruling violated the right to legal hearing but determined that the violation was successfully cured when the lower court subsequently considered the timely filed submission within the scope of the appellate hearing complaint procedure. The decisive legal basis is Article 103 (1) of the Basic Law regarding the right to be heard, applied in conjunction with the doctrine of curative effect in the hearing complaint process.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art 103 Abs 1 GG, § 93d Abs. 1 Satz 3 BVerfGG; Right to be heard violated by judgment issued before hearing deadline expired, cured by subsequent consideration of timely submission: The dispute concerned a procedural violation where a civil court rendered a judgment before the expiration of a statutory deadline for the complainant's response, thereby breaching the right to be heard. The Court acknowledged that this initial ruling violated the right to legal hearing but determined that the violation was successfully cured when the lower court subsequently considered the timely filed submission within the scope of the appellate hearing complaint procedure. The decisive legal basis is Article 103 (1) of the Basic Law regarding the right to be heard, applied in conjunction with the doctrine of curative effect in the hearing complaint process.

Keywords

AI generated
right to be heard violation of procedural rights effects of the judgment statutory right article of civil procedure legal doctrine

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Cited Case Law

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
§ 93d Abs. 1 Satz 3 BVerfGG

Cited in the dispositive to justify the omission of a further reasoning on the decision.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Nichtannahmebeschluss: Verletzung des Anspruchs auf rechtliches Gehör (Art 103 Abs 1 GG) durch zivilprozessuale Entscheidung vor Ablauf einer Stellungnahmefrist - allerdings Heilung des Gehörsverstoßes im fachgerichtlichen Anhörungsrügeverfahren

[TENOR]

Die Verfassungsbeschwerde wird nicht zur Entscheidung angenommen.

[GRUENDE]

Zwar verletzt das Urteil vom 20. Februar 2020 die Beschwerdeführerin in ihrem Anspruch auf rechtliches Gehör (Art. 103 Abs. 1 GG), weil es zu einer Zeit erlassen wurde, zu der die gesetzte Frist noch nicht nachweisbar abgelaufen war (vgl. BVerfGE 49, 212 ; 70, 215 ; BVerfG, Beschluss der 2. Kammer des Ersten Senats vom 19. Dezember 2013 - 1 BvR 859/13 -, Rn. 9, 11; jeweils m.w.N.). Diese Gehörsverletzung wurde aber im Rahmen des Anhörungsrügeverfahrens geheilt (vgl. BVerfGE 73, 322 ; BVerfG, Beschluss der 2. Kammer des Zweiten Senats vom 18. Juli 2019 - 2 BvR 1082/18 -, Rn. 17; jeweils m.w.N.), weil das Amtsgericht dabei den zunächst übergangenen, fristgerecht eingegangenen Schriftsatz vom 20. Februar 2020 im Rahmen einer Hilfsbegründung berücksichtigt hat.

Von einer weiteren Begründung wird nach § 93d Abs. 1 Satz 3 BVerfGG abgesehen.

Diese Entscheidung ist unanfechtbar.