Legislator Case Law & Legislation
2 BvR 2728/13, 2 BvR 2730/13, 2 BvR 2731/13 ECLI:DE:BVerfG:2018:rs20180516.2bvr272813 AI generated

Constitutional complaint cost allocation and subject value determination based on contribution to clarifying fundamental legal questions

Case Number 2 BvR 2728/13, 2 BvR 2730/13, 2 BvR 2731/13
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Court Costs Borne by public authority

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Federal Constitutional Court ordered the respondent state to reimburse one-third of the complainants' necessary attorney fees and fixed the matter's value for procedural costs at €1,000,000 per case. This decision addresses ancillary cost allocations in constitutional complaint proceedings, following a substantive ruling where the complaints were partially dismissed and partially rejected. The Court applied Section 34a(3) of the Federal Constitutional Court Act, determining that a partial refund was equitable because the proceedings, despite their mixed outcome, contributed to clarifying issues of fundamental legal significance, while Sections 37(2) and 22(1) of the Lawyers' Fees Act governed the valuation of the legal matter.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

§ 34a Abs 3 BVerfGG, § 22 Abs. 1 RVG, § 37 Abs. 2 RVG; Constitutional complaint cost allocation and subject value determination based on contribution to clarifying fundamental legal questions: This decision addresses ancillary cost allocations in constitutional complaint proceedings, following a substantive ruling where the complaints were partially dismissed and partially rejected. The Court applied Section 34a(3) of the Federal Constitutional Court Act, determining that a partial refund was equitable because the proceedings, despite their mixed outcome, contributed to clarifying issues of fundamental legal significance, while Sections 37(2) and 22(1) of the Lawyers' Fees Act governed the valuation of the legal matter.

Keywords

AI generated
legal fees allocation of costs procedural issues inadequate constitutional complaint valuation proceedings constitutional jurisdiction

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Cited Case Law

AI generated
BVerfGE 36, 146
BVerfGE 36, 146 ; 109, 190 ; 116, 69 ; 130, 1 ).
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
§ 34a Abs. 3 BVerfGG

Basis for the order to reimburse one-third of the complainants' necessary legal costs.

§ 37 Abs. 2 RVG

Basis for fixing the value of the subject matter for the calculation of attorney fees.

§ 22 Abs. 1 RVG

Basis for fixing the value of the subject matter for the calculation of attorney fees.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Anordnung der teilweisen Auslagenerstattung im Verfassungsbeschwerdeverfahren (§ 34a Abs 3 BVerfGG) sowie Gegenstandswertfestsetzung

[TENOR]

Die Bundesrepublik Deutschland hat den Beschwerdeführern ihre notwendigen Auslagen zu einem Drittel zu erstatten.

Der Wert des Gegenstandes der anwaltlichen Tätigkeit der Bevollmächtigten im Hauptsacheverfahren wird jeweils auf 1.000.000 € (in Worten: eine Million Euro) festgesetzt (§ 37 Abs. 2, § 22 Abs. 1 RVG).

[GRUENDE]

Die Entscheidung über die Anordnung der Erstattung der Auslagen beruht auf § 34a Abs. 3 BVerfGG. Die Verfassungsbeschwerden sind zwar teilweise verworfen und teilweise zurückgewiesen worden, haben aber in der Sache zur Klärung von Fragen von grundsätzlicher Bedeutung beigetragen (vgl. BVerfGE 36, 146 ; 109, 190 ; 116, 69 ; 130, 1 ).

Es entspricht der Billigkeit, den Beschwerdeführern die durch das Verfassungsbeschwerdeverfahren entstandenen notwendigen Auslagen in Höhe von einem Drittel zu erstatten.