Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1 BvQ 55/15 ECLI:DE:BVerfG:2016:qk20160112.1bvq005515 AI generated

Interim relief against mandatory telecom data retention: balance of disadvantages under § 32 BVerfGG

Case Number 1 BvQ 55/15
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Federal Constitutional Court rejected the applicant's request for interim relief, resulting in a denial of the motion and a victory for the state, thereby leaving the challenged legislation in effect. The dispute concerned the validity of a legislative amendment introducing mandatory data retention and maximum storage periods for traffic data, specifically the new provisions to the Telecommunications Act, which the applicant sought to suspend pending a full constitutional review. The Court declined to issue the order because the applicant failed to demonstrate that the disadvantages of the law taking effect—should it later be declared unconstitutional—clearly outweighed the disadvantages of temporarily blocking a law that might prove constitutionally compliant, applying the strict proportionality doctrine for interim relief under § 32 Abs. 1 BVerfGG.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

§ 32 Abs. 1 BVerfGG; Interim relief against mandatory telecom data retention: balance of disadvantages under § 32 BVerfGG: The dispute concerned the validity of a legislative amendment introducing mandatory data retention and maximum storage periods for traffic data, specifically the new provisions to the Telecommunications Act, which the applicant sought to suspend pending a full constitutional review. The Court declined to issue the order because the applicant failed to demonstrate that the disadvantages of the law taking effect—should it later be declared unconstitutional—clearly outweighed the disadvantages of temporarily blocking a law that might prove constitutionally compliant, applying the strict proportionality doctrine for interim relief under § 32 Abs. 1 BVerfGG.

Keywords

AI generated
interim relief legislative act seizure of electronic data data protection legislation regulation of digital services protection of communications

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Cited Case Law

AI generated
BVerfGE 104, 23
BVerfGE 104, 23 ; 117, 126 ; 121, 1 ; stRspr).
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
§ 32 Abs. 1 BVerfGG

Procedural provision under which the request for interim relief was filed and rejected in the operative order.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Ablehnung des Erlasses einer einstweiligen Anordnung bzgl des Inkrafttretens der §§ 113b, 113c TKG idF des Gesetzes zur Einführung einer Speicherpflicht und einer Höchstspeicherfrist für Verkehrsdaten vom 10.12.2015 ("Vorratsdatenspeicherung")

[GRUENDE]

Der Antrag auf Erlass der begehrten einstweiligen Anordnung gemäß § 32 Abs. 1 BVerfGG hat keinen Erfolg. Das Vorbringen des Antragstellers lässt nicht erkennen, dass Nachteile, die mit dem Inkrafttreten des Gesetzes nach späterer Feststellung seiner Verfassungswidrigkeit verbunden wären, die Nachteile, die im Falle der vorläufigen Verhinderung eines sich als verfassungsgemäß erweisenden Gesetzes einträten, in Ausmaß und Schwere deutlich überwiegen (vgl. BVerfGE 104, 23 ; 117, 126 ; 121, 1 ; stRspr).

Diese Entscheidung ist unanfechtbar.