Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1 BvR 2250/11 ECLI:DE:BVerfG:2012:rk20120308.1bvr225011 AI generated

Interim suspension of court-ordered coercive paternity test due to disproportionate harm to family relationship

Case Number 1 BvR 2250/11
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Federal Constitutional Court (BVerfG) ordered the renewal of a previous interim injunction for an additional six months, suspending a lower court's decision that sought to enforce a paternity test via buccal swab, thereby allowing the constitutional complaint to proceed. The dispute concerned a family law matter where the respondent challenged the coercive nature of the paternity investigation, arguing that the psychological harm to the social-family relationship caused by the forced medical procedure and a potential adverse ruling in the main proceedings outweighed the benefits of immediate evidence gathering. The court's decision was based on the doctrine of balancing competing interests under constitutional law, specifically finding that the probable destruction of the social-family relationship and the severe disadvantages of conducting the examinations justified the provisional suspension of the lower court's order pending a final decision on the merits of the constitutional complaint.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Interim suspension of court-ordered coercive paternity test due to disproportionate harm to family relationship: The dispute concerned a family law matter where the respondent challenged the coercive nature of the paternity investigation, arguing that the psychological harm to the social-family relationship caused by the forced medical procedure and a potential adverse ruling in the main proceedings outweighed the benefits of immediate evidence gathering. The court's decision was based on the doctrine of balancing competing interests under constitutional law, specifically finding that the probable destruction of the social-family relationship and the severe disadvantages of conducting the examinations justified the provisional suspension of the lower court's order pending a final decision on the merits of the constitutional complaint.

Keywords

AI generated
suspension of investigation order for enforcement decisions on medical matters action to contest paternity pending proceedings matter in dispute
AI generated

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Wiederholung einer einstweiligen Anordnung: Aussetzung eines fachgerichtlichen Beschlusses, mit dem die Teilnahme an einem Vaterschaftstest mittels Mundschleimhautabstrich erzwungen werden sollte - Überwiegen der Nachteile (Störung bzw Zerstörung der sozial-familiären Beziehung) bei Durchführung dieser Untersuchungen und späterem Erfolg der Verfassungsbeschwerde in der Hauptsache

[TENOR]

Die einstweilige Anordnung vom 20. September 2011 wird für die Dauer von weiteren sechs Monaten, längstens bis zur Entscheidung

über die Verfassungsbeschwerde, wiederholt.