Legislator Case Law & Legislation
VIa ZR 455/23 ECLI:DE:BGH:2024:280524BVIAZR455.23.0 AI generated

Admissibility of revision regarding the calculation of imputed usage benefits in property disputes

Case Number VIa ZR 455/23
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed
Court Costs Shared between parties

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) granted partial admission of the plaintiff's non-approval complaint against the appeal court's decision of March 16, 2023, specifically for the portion of the appeal that had dismissed the claim for €22,271.25 plus interest, while rejecting the complaint as unfounded for the remainder, thereby leaving the lower court's decision on the calculation of the imputed usage benefit in force; the case involved a civil dispute where the plaintiff failed to sufficiently demonstrate that the appellate court's reasoning regarding the height of the deductible usage advantage met the threshold for revision on grounds of fundamental significance, further development of law, or legal uniformity, pursuant to § 543(2) sentence 1 ZPO, with the plaintiff bearing the costs of the unsuccessful parts of the proceedings based on a dispute value capped at €6,000 for court fees and €30,000 for attorney fees (allocated 20% against the defendant).

Legislator headnote

AI generated

§ 543 Abs. 2 Satz 1 ZPO, § 97 Abs. 1 ZPO; Admissibility of revision regarding the calculation of imputed usage benefits in property disputes: The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) granted partial admission of the plaintiff's non-approval complaint against the appeal court's decision of March 16, 2023, specifically for the portion of the appeal that had dismissed the claim for €22,271.25 plus interest, while rejecting the complaint as unfounded for the remainder, thereby leaving the lower court's decision on the calculation of the imputed usage benefit in force; the case involved a civil dispute where the plaintiff failed to sufficiently demonstrate that the appellate court's reasoning regarding the height of the deductible usage advantage met the threshold for revision on grounds of fundamental significance, further development of law, or legal uniformity, pursuant to § 543(2) sentence 1 ZPO, with the plaintiff bearing the costs of the unsuccessful parts of the proceedings based on a dispute value capped at €6,000 for court fees and €30,000 for attorney fees (allocated 20% against the defendant).

Keywords

AI generated
value in dispute calculation of benefit civil revision proceedings partial claim legal fees development costs

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Cited Case Law

AI generated
V ZR 343/02
Dezember 2003 - V ZR 343/02, NJW 2004, 1048, 1048 f.).
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
§ 543 Abs. 2 Satz 1 ZPO

Defines the grounds for admitting the revision (fundamental significance, further development of law, or legal uniformity) which the court applied to grant partial admission.

§ 97 Abs. 1 ZPO

Basis for allocating the costs of the unsuccessful portion of the proceedings to the plaintiff.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Auf die Nichtzulassungsbeschwerde der Klägerin wird unter Zurückweisung des Rechtsmittels im Übrigen die Revision gegen den Beschluss des 17. Zivilsenats Oberlandesgerichts Hamm vom 16. März 2023 zugelassen, soweit die Berufung der Klägerin in Höhe von 22.271,25 € nebst Zinsen zurückgewiesen worden ist. Im Umfang der Zurückweisung kommt der Rechtssache weder grundsätzliche Bedeutung zu, noch erfordern die Fortbildung des Rechts oder die Sicherung einer einheitlichen Rechtsprechung diesbezüglich eine Entscheidung des Revisionsgerichts (§ 543 Abs. 2 Satz 1 ZPO). Die Klägerin hat hinsichtlich der selbständig tragenden Erwägungen des Berufungsgerichts zur Höhe des anzurechnenden Nutzungsvorteils einen Zulassungsgrund nicht hinreichend dargetan.

Die Klägerin trägt die Kosten des Beschwerdeverfahrens, soweit es ohne Erfolg geblieben ist. Insoweit beträgt der Wert des Beschwerdegegenstands für die Gerichtskosten bis 6.000 € und für die außergerichtlichen Kosten bis 30.000 € mit der Maßgabe, dass letztere im Verhältnis zur Beklagten nur zu 20 % anzusetzen sind (§ 97 Abs. 1 ZPO, vgl. BGH, Beschluss vom 17. Dezember 2003 - V ZR 343/02, NJW 2004, 1048, 1048 f.).

Von einer weiteren Begründung wird gemäß § 544 Abs. 6 Satz 2 Halbsatz 2 ZPO abgesehen.

C. Fischer

Möhring

Götz

Rensen

Vogt-Beheim