Legislator Case Law & Legislation
XI ZR 328/22 ECLI:DE:BGH:2024:090424BXIZR328.22.0 AI generated

Cost allocation in § 91a ZPO mootness proceedings: allocation based on probable merits outcome of unadjudicated revision

Case Number XI ZR 328/22
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome struck_off
Court Costs Borne by appellant

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Bundesgerichtshof (BGH) ordered the plaintiff to bear the full costs of the litigation following the parties' joint declaration that the matter was resolved. This cost allocation decision, rendered by the 11th Civil Senate, was based on an assessment that the plaintiff's revision appeal would have been unsuccessful had it proceeded to a substantive judgment, thereby establishing that the respondent prevailed on the merits of the underlying dispute. The case involved a civil procedure where the parties declared the matter moot (*erledigt*), prompting the court to apply the equitable discretion provided in German civil procedure law to determine costs. The decisive legal basis for the ruling was § 91a Abs. 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO), which mandates cost allocation based on the probable outcome of the proceedings and the circumstances of the case, with the specific substantive issues being identified by reference to the Senate's earlier judgment in a related proceeding.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

§ 91a Abs. 1 ZPO; Cost allocation in § 91a ZPO mootness proceedings: allocation based on probable merits outcome of unadjudicated revision: This cost allocation decision, rendered by the 11th Civil Senate, was based on an assessment that the plaintiff's revision appeal would have been unsuccessful had it proceeded to a substantive judgment, thereby establishing that the respondent prevailed on the merits of the underlying dispute. The case involved a civil procedure where the parties declared the matter moot (*erledigt*), prompting the court to apply the equitable discretion provided in German civil procedure law to determine costs. The decisive legal basis for the ruling was § 91a Abs. 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure (ZPO), which mandates cost allocation based on the probable outcome of the proceedings and the circumstances of the case, with the specific substantive issues being identified by reference to the Senate's earlier judgment in a related proceeding.

Keywords

AI generated
allocation of costs revision of a judgment civil litigation procedure related proceedings assessment on basis of discretion party costs

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Cited Case Law

AI generated
AI generated

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Die Kosten des Rechtsstreits trägt die Klägerin.

[GRUENDE]

Der Senat hat gemäß § 91a Abs. 1 ZPO über die Kosten des Rechtsstreits zu entscheiden, nachdem die Parteien - was auch noch im Revisionsverfahren zulässig ist (vgl. Senatsbeschluss vom 8. März 2022 - XI ZR 571/21, AG 2022, 443 Rn. 7 mwN) - den Rechtsstreit übereinstimmend für erledigt erklärt haben. Dabei hat der Senat unter Berücksichtigung des bisherigen Sach- und Streitstandes nach billigem Ermessen über die Kosten zu entscheiden, wobei der mutmaßliche Ausgang des Revisionsverfahrens zu berücksichtigen ist (Senatsbeschluss aaO Rn. 9 mwN). Danach sind die Kosten in vollem Umfang der Klägerin aufzuerlegen, weil nach dem Sach- und Streitstand bei Eintritt des erledigenden Ereignisses die Revision keinen Erfolg gehabt hätte. Zur Begründung wird auf das Senatsurteil vom 27. Februar 2024 (XI ZR 258/22, ZIP 2024, 625) verwiesen.

Grüneberg

Derstadt

Schild von Spannenberg

Sturm

Ettl