Legislator Case Law & Legislation
VII ZR 117/19 ECLI:DE:BGH:2022:141222BVIIZR117.19.0 AI generated

HOAI minimum fee rates under EU competition law; estimation of claim amount under § 287 Abs. 2 ZPO

Case Number VII ZR 117/19
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Court Costs Borne by appellant

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Federal Court of Justice (BGH) dismissed the defendant's complaint against the non-admission of revision, thereby upholding the final judgment of the Frankfurt Higher Regional Court and leaving the defendant liable for the costs of the complaint proceedings. The dispute concerned the validity of minimum fee rates under the German Fee Ordinance for Architects (HOAI) and their compatibility with EU competition law, alongside a challenge to a specific estimate regarding the calculation of the awarded claim. The court held that the admissibility grounds were no longer present because the relevant legal question on HOAI minimum fees had been definitively resolved by a prior BGH decision dated November 3, 2022, which also established that the defendant's substantive revision arguments lacked success; furthermore, the appellate court's estimation of the claim amount was deemed legally valid under Section 287(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, rendering further reasoning unnecessary under Section 544(6) Sentence 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

§ 287 Abs. 2 ZPO, § 97 Abs. 1 ZPO, § 544 Abs. 6 Satz 2, 2. Halbsatz ZPO; HOAI minimum fee rates under EU competition law; estimation of claim amount under § 287 Abs. 2 ZPO: The dispute concerned the validity of minimum fee rates under the German Fee Ordinance for Architects (HOAI) and their compatibility with EU competition law, alongside a challenge to a specific estimate regarding the calculation of the awarded claim. The court held that the admissibility grounds were no longer present because the relevant legal question on HOAI minimum fees had been definitively resolved by a prior BGH decision dated November 3, 2022, which also established that the defendant's substantive revision arguments lacked success; furthermore, the appellate court's estimation of the claim amount was deemed legally valid under Section 287(2) of the Code of Civil Procedure, rendering further reasoning unnecessary under Section 544(6) Sentence 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure.

Keywords

AI generated
architect fees legal fees Civil Procedure Code cost calculation regional law revision proceedings

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Cited Case Law

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
§ 544 Abs. 6 Satz 2, 2. Halbsatz ZPO

Procedural basis cited in the decision to justify the omission of further reasoning because it would not contribute to clarifying the conditions for admitting revision.

§ 97 Abs. 1 ZPO

Cost allocation rule cited to impose the costs of the complaint proceedings on the defendant.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Die Beschwerde des Beklagten gegen die Nichtzulassung der Revision in dem Urteil des 3. Zivilsenats des Oberlandesgerichts Frankfurt am Main vom 2. Mai 2019 wird zurückgewiesen.

Die von der Beschwerde geltend gemachten Zulassungsgründe im Hinblick auf die Frage der Anwendbarkeit der Mindestsätze der HOAI unter Berücksichtigung des Rechts der Europäischen Gemeinschaften/der Europäischen Union liegen nicht mehr vor. Die insoweit entscheidungserheblichen Rechtsfragen sind durch das Urteil des Senats vom 3. November 2022 - VII ZR 724/21 entschieden und damit geklärt.

Eine Revision des Beklagten hätte auch in der Sache keine Aussicht auf Erfolg. Dies ergibt sich zum einen ebenfalls aus den Gründen des Urteils vom 3. November 2022 - VII ZR 724/21. In Bezug auf die weitere von ihm erhobene Rüge betreffend eine Position bei der Ermittlung der Höhe der zuerkannten Forderung begegnet das Urteil keinen Bedenken, weil das Berufungsgericht gemäß § 287 Abs. 2 ZPO eine Schätzung vornehmen durfte.

Von einer weiteren Begründung wird abgesehen, weil sie nicht geeignet wäre, zur Klärung der Voraussetzungen beizutragen, unter denen eine Revision zuzulassen ist (§ 544 Abs. 6 Satz 2, 2. Halbsatz ZPO).

Der Beklagte trägt die Kosten des Beschwerdeverfahrens (§ 97 Abs. 1 ZPO).

Gegenstandswert: 25.954,90 €

Pamp

Halfmeier

Jurgeleit

Sacher

Pamp

RinBGH Dr. Brenneisenist aufgrund Erkrankung ander Beifügung der Unterschriftgehindert