Anhörungsrüge: failure to apply 1998 BGH precedent on exclusion of public hearing for witness examination
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe Federal Court of Justice (5th Criminal Senate) dismissed the convicted defendant's objection to a hearing (Anhörungsrüge) against the Senate's order of March 10, 2026, with costs imposed on the applicant. The dispute concerned a criminal proceeding where the defendant alleged the court utilized evidence or ignored her submissions without providing her an opportunity to be heard, specifically arguing that the court failed to apply a 1998 precedent regarding the exclusion of the public during witness testimonies. The court held that the legal objection was unfounded because the 1998 precedent involved a substantive exclusion of public access for a witness examination, whereas the instant case only involved a procedural hearing on a motion for such exclusion held in a non-public session; thus, no relevant material was ignored and no hearing was denied. The dismissal was ordered under a corresponding application of § 465 Abs. 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO).
Legislator headnote
AI generated§ 465 Abs. 1 StPO; Anhörungsrüge: failure to apply 1998 BGH precedent on exclusion of public hearing for witness examination: The dispute concerned a criminal proceeding where the defendant alleged the court utilized evidence or ignored her submissions without providing her an opportunity to be heard, specifically arguing that the court failed to apply a 1998 precedent regarding the exclusion of the public during witness testimonies. The court held that the legal objection was unfounded because the 1998 precedent involved a substantive exclusion of public access for a witness examination, whereas the instant case only involved a procedural hearing on a motion for such exclusion held in a non-public session; thus, no relevant material was ignored and no hearing was denied. The dismissal was ordered under a corresponding application of § 465 Abs. 1 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (StPO).
Keywords
AI generatedCited Legislation
AI generatedCited Case Law
AI generatedRelated Decisions
AI generatedKey legal questions extracted by Legislator
AI generatedApplied via corresponding application to determine the costs of the proceedings, which were imposed on the appellant following the dismissal of the objection to the hearing.
Full text
Die Anhörungsrüge der Verurteilten gegen den Senatsbeschluss vom 10. März 2026 wird auf ihre Kosten verworfen.
[GRUENDE]
Die zulässige Anhörungsrüge gegen den Beschluss des Senats vom 10. März 2026 hat in der Sache keinen Erfolg, weil der Senat bei seiner Entscheidung weder Verfahrensstoff verwertet hat, zu dem die Verurteilte nicht gehört worden wäre, noch zu berücksichtigendes Vorbringen der Verurteilten übergangen hat. Die von der Verurteilten im Antrag des Generalbundesanwalts vermisste Entscheidung des Bundesgerichtshofs (BGH, Beschluss vom 1. Dezember 1998 - 4 StR 585/98, NStZ 1999, 371) betrifft eine andere Fallkonstellation. Während dort die Öffentlichkeit für die Dauer einer Zeugenvernehmung ausgeschlossen worden war, wurde in der vom Senat entschiedenen Sache lediglich für die Verhandlung über den Antrag eines Beteiligten auf Ausschluss der Öffentlichkeit für die Dauer der Vernehmung eines Zeugen in nicht öffentlicher Sitzung verhandelt.
Die Kostenentscheidung folgt aus einer entsprechenden Anwendung von § 465 Abs. 1 StPO.
Cirener
Mosbacher
Köhler
von Häfen
Werner