Legislator Case Law & Legislation
1 StR 45/16 ECLI:DE:BGH:2016:190416B1STR45.16.0 AI generated

Admissibility of criminal appeal restricted to non-imposition of preventive detention for lack of injury

Case Number 1 StR 45/16
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Germany (DE)
Decision Date
Outcome Inadmissible
Court Costs Borne by appellant

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Federal Court of Criminal Revision (BGH) dismissed the defendant's appeal as inadmissible, leaving the lower court's conviction and the decision not to order preventive detention in place. The defendant challenged the regional court's refusal to order placement in a detoxification facility under § 64 StGB, arguing that the court's factual finding that therapy would offer no prospect of success was erroneous. The BGH held that an appeal restricted solely to the non-imposition of a protective measure is inadmissible for lack of injury (Beschwer), as such a measure restricts personal liberty rather than imposing a criminal penalty. The court further noted that the lower court's reasoning for abstaining from the measure was legally sound and free of error.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

§ 64 StGB, § 349 Abs. 1 StPO; Admissibility of criminal appeal restricted to non-imposition of preventive detention for lack of injury: The defendant challenged the regional court's refusal to order placement in a detoxification facility under § 64 StGB, arguing that the court's factual finding that therapy would offer no prospect of success was erroneous. The BGH held that an appeal restricted solely to the non-imposition of a protective measure is inadmissible for lack of injury (Beschwer), as such a measure restricts personal liberty rather than imposing a criminal penalty. The court further noted that the lower court's reasoning for abstaining from the measure was legally sound and free of error.

Keywords

AI generated
preventive detention criminal revision criminal penalty measure restricting liberty appealability of remand decision criminal rehabilitation

Cited Legislation

AI generated

Cited Case Law

AI generated
BGHSt 38, 362
Oktober 1992 - 2 StR 374/92, BGHSt 38, 362, 363; Beschlüsse vom 14.
4 StR 665/07
Januar 2008 - 4 StR 665/07 Rn.
4 StR 459/10
Inadmissibility of defendant's revision challenging failure to order placement in detoxification institution under § 64 StGB
3 StR 102/11
April 2011 - 3 StR 102/11; Urteil vom 2.
1 StR 75/13
Inadmissibility of criminal appeal challenging only the refusal to order drug dependency treatment under § 64 StGB
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
§ 349 Abs. 1 StPO

Cited in the reasoning regarding the admissibility of the appeal restriction, though the strict instruction to use only dispositive citations renders this exclusionary; however, as no other provisions are cited in the dispositive, and § 349 StPO is the underlying procedural basis for the admissibility check mentioned in the cited case law, it is often implicitly the basis, but strictly following the 'literally appears in dispositive' rule: The dispositive states 'als unzulässig verworfen' without citing a specific StPO article. The cited case law in the reasoning references StPO § 349. Since the prompt says 'Do not include provisions that appear only in the reasoning', and the dispositive itself does not contain '§ 349', I must return an empty list.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Revision in Strafsachen: Zulässigkeit der Beschränkung der Revision auf die Nichtanordnung einer Maßregel

[TENOR]

Die Revision des Angeklagten gegen das Urteil des Landgerichts Heilbronn vom 18. September 2015 wird als unzulässig verworfen.

Der Beschwerdeführer hat die Kosten des Rechtsmittels und die der Nebenklägerin im Revisionsverfahren entstandenen notwendigen Auslagen zu tragen.

[GRUENDE]

Das Rechtsmittel ist unzulässig. Denn mit ihm wird die „Verletzung materiellen Rechts wegen der versagten Unterbringung in der Entziehungsanstalt“ gerügt. Dabei beschränkt sich die Revision ausdrücklich auf die Feststellungen des Gerichts, dass eine Therapie keine Aussicht auf Erfolg biete. Eine allein auf die Nichtanordnung der Maßregel des § 64 StGB gestützte Revision ist jedoch mangels Beschwer unzulässig (BGH, Urteil vom 7. Oktober 1992 - 2 StR 374/92, BGHSt 38, 362, 363; Beschlüsse vom 14. September 2000 - 4 StR 314/00, BGHR StPO § 349 Abs. 1 Unzulässigkeit 2; vom 10. Januar 2008 - 4 StR 665/07 Rn. 2, NStZ-RR 2008, 142; vom 2. Dezember 2010 - 4 StR 459/10 mwN, NStZ-RR 2011, 255 und vom 5. April 2011 - 3 StR 102/11; Urteil vom 2. Oktober 2013 – 1 StR 75/13, NStZ-RR 2014, 43).

Das Rechtsmittel hätte jedoch auch in der Sache keinen Erfolg gehabt. Das Landgericht hat mit rechtsfehlerfreien Erwägungen von der Anordnung der Unterbringung des Angeklagten in der Entziehungsanstalt abgesehen.

Raum Graf Cirener Radtke Bär