Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
JAAC 64.134 AI generated

Applicant Fails to Exhaust Domestic Remedies Before Bringing Liberty Claim

Case Number JAAC 64.134
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Administrative Practice of Federal Authorities (VPB) (CH)
Decision Date
Outcome Inadmissible
Open official source Entscheidsuche mirror Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court declared an application inadmissible because the applicant failed to exhaust domestic remedies. While the applicant alleged a violation of his right to liberty due to a forced hospitalization, the court found that he could have raised the issue of excessive procedural delay in a subsequent action for damages, which would have constituted exhaustion of available domestic remedies. The applicability of Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights was left open as the applicant's stay in the clinic was brief and he maintained social contacts without surveillance.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 5 CEDH, Art. 429a CC, Art. 397f CC, Art. 5 EMRK, Art. 429a ZGB, Art. 397f ZGB; Applicant Fails to Exhaust Domestic Remedies Before Bringing Liberty Claim: While the applicant alleged a violation of his right to liberty due to a forced hospitalization, the court found that he could have raised the issue of excessive procedural delay in a subsequent action for damages, which would have constituted exhaustion of available domestic remedies. The applicability of Article 5 of the European Convention on Human Rights was left open as the applicant's stay in the clinic was brief and he maintained social contacts without surveillance.

Keywords

AI generated
exhaustion of domestic remedies violation of procedural rights actions for damages procedural delays failure to prove deterioration medical unfitness

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 5 CEDH
This provision was discussed in relation to the right to liberty and security, although its applicability was left open.
Art. 429a CC
This provision was cited as the domestic remedy that could have been used to address the complaint about the length of the procedure.
Art. 397f CC
This provision was cited in relation to the requirement for a speedy procedure, which was relevant to the exhaustion of domestic remedies.
Art. 5 EMRK
Betreffend die vom Beschwerdeführer geltend gemachte Rüge der zu langen Verfahrensdauer im Sinne von Art. 5 § 4 EMRK wurde der innerstaatliche Instanzenzug nicht ausgeschöpft, da er mit Verantwortlichkeitsklage gemäss Art.
Art. 429a ZGB
5 § 4 EMRK wurde der innerstaatliche Instanzenzug nicht ausgeschöpft, da er mit Verantwortlichkeitsklage gemäss Art. 429a ZGB hätte geltend machen können, das Verfahren sei nicht rasch genug im Sinne von Art.
Art. 397f ZGB
429a ZGB hätte geltend machen können, das Verfahren sei nicht rasch genug im Sinne von Art. 397f ZGB geführt worden.
Art. 5 CEDU
Betreffend die vom Beschwerdeführer geltend gemachte Rüge der zu langen Verfahrensdauer im Sinne von Art. 5 § 4 EMRK wurde der innerstaatliche Instanzenzug nicht ausgeschöpft, da er mit Verantwortlichkeitsklage gemäss Art.
Art. 35 § 1 CEDH
This provision was applied to declare the application inadmissible due to the failure to exhaust domestic remedies.
AI generated
JAAC 60.129
Inadmissibility of Application for Failure to Exhaust Domestic Remedies

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 35 § 1 CEDH

This provision was applied to declare the application inadmissible due to the failure to exhaust domestic remedies.

Art. 5 § 4 CEDH

This provision was discussed in relation to the exhaustion of domestic remedies for the complaint concerning excessive procedural length.

Art. 397f CC

This provision was cited in relation to the requirement for a speedy procedure, which was relevant to the exhaustion of domestic remedies.

Art. 429a CC

This provision was cited as the domestic remedy that could have been used to address the complaint about the length of the procedure.

Art. 5 CEDH

This provision was discussed in relation to the right to liberty and security, although its applicability was left open.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

JAAC 64.134

Déc. rendue en anglais par la Cour eur. DH le 6 avril 2000, déclarant irrecevable la req. N° 28917/95, A. B. c / Suisse

Procédure relative à l’hospitalisation forcée du requérant dans une clinique psychiatrique du canton de Bâle-Ville (art. 397a ss. CC). Art. 5 CEDH. Droit à la liberté et à la sûreté. En l’espèce, on pouvait laisser ouverte la question de savoir si cette disposition était applicable, alors que le requérant n’avait passé que la nuit dans la clinique et avait pu maintenir, sans surveillance, des contacts sociaux. Art. 35 § 1 CEDH. Epuisement des voies de recours internes. Quant au grief soulevé par le requérant au sujet de la longueur excessive de la procédure au sens de l’art. 5 § 4 CEDH, les voies de procédure internes n’ont pas été épuisées, étant donné qu’il aurait pu faire valoir, dans le cadre de l’action en responsabilité au sens de l’art. 429a CC, que la procédure n’avait pas été menée de manière suffisamment rapide au sens de l’art. 397f CC.

Verfahren betreffend die zwangsweise Hospitalisierung des Beschwerdeführers in einer psychiatrischen Klinik im Kanton Basel-Stadt (Art. 397a ff. ZGB). Art. 5 EMRK. Recht auf Freiheit und Sicherheit. Im vorliegenden Fall konnte offenbleiben, ob diese Bestimmung zur Anwendung kommt, wenn der Beschwerdeführer nur die Nacht in der Klinik hatte verbringen müssen und soziale Kontakte ohne Überwachung hatte unterhalten können.

Art. 35 § 1 EMRK. Erschöpfung des innerstaatlichen Instanzenzuges. Betreffend die vom Beschwerdeführer geltend gemachte Rüge der zu langen Verfahrensdauer im Sinne von Art. 5 § 4 EMRK wurde der innerstaatliche Instanzenzug nicht ausgeschöpft, da er mit Verantwortlichkeitsklage gemäss Art. 429a ZGB hätte geltend machen können, das Verfahren sei nicht rasch genug im Sinne von Art. 397f ZGB geführt worden.

Procedura relativa all’ospedalizzazione forzata del ricorrente in una clinica psichiatrica del Cantone di Basilea Città (art. 397a segg. CC). Art. 5 CEDU. Diritto alla libertà e alla sicurezza. Nella fattispecie è rimasta aperta la questione dell’applicabilità di questa disposizione, visto che il ricorrente non aveva passato la notte nella clinica e aveva potuto mantenere contatti sociali senza sorveglianza. Art. 35 § 1 CEDU. Esaurimento delle vie di ricorso interne. Per quanto concerne la censura sollevata dal ricorrente concernente l’eccessiva lunghezza della procedura ai sensi dell’art. 5 § 4 CEDU, le vie processuali interne non sono state esaurite, dato che egli avrebbe potuto far valere, attraverso l’azione di responsabilità secondo l’art. 429a CC, che la procedura non era stata condotta in modo sufficientemente rapido ai sensi dell’art. 397f CC.

Schweizerisches Bundesarchiv, Digitale Amtsdruckschriften Archives fédérales suisses, Publications officielles numérisées Archivio federale svizzero, Pubblicazioni ufficiali digitali

JAAC 64.134 - Déc. rendue en anglais par la Cour eur. DH le 6 avril 2000, déclarant irrecevable la req. N° 28917/95, A. B. c / Suisse

In Verwaltungspraxis der Bundesbehörden Dans Jurisprudence des autorités administratives de la Confédération In Giurisprudenza delle autorità amministrative della Confederazione

Jahr 2000 Année Anno

Band 64 Volume Volume

Seite --- Page Pagina

Ref. No 150 004 568

Das Dokument wurde durch das Schweizerische Bundesarchiv und die Bundeskanzlei konvertiert. Le document a été digitalisé par les Archives Fédérales Suisses et la Chancellerie fédérale. Il documento è stato convertito dall'Archivio federale svizzero e della Cancelleria federale.