Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
JAAC 60.115 AI generated

Judicial Impartiality in Maintenance Non-Compliance Proceedings

Case Number JAAC 60.115
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Administrative Practice of Federal Authorities (VPB) (CH)
Decision Date
Outcome Inadmissible
Open official source Entscheidsuche mirror Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

This case concerns a failure to meet family maintenance obligations where the judge who ordered the payment of maintenance in a marital protection proceeding also participated in the subsequent criminal proceeding for non-compliance. The court declared the application inadmissible, finding that the judge's two roles were distinct and therefore excluded any reasonable doubt regarding his impartiality under Article 6 § 1 of the ECHR.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 6 § 1 CEDH; Judicial Impartiality in Maintenance Non-Compliance Proceedings: The court declared the application inadmissible, finding that the judge's two roles were distinct and therefore excluded any reasonable doubt regarding his impartiality under Article 6 § 1 of the ECHR.

Keywords

AI generated
judicial impartiality maintenance obligation proceedings for marital protection reasonable doubt excluded cases judicial assistance in civil matters

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 6 § 1 CEDH
Cited to address the issue of an impartial tribunal.
AI generated
JAAC 62.100
Applicant's Challenge to Judicial Impartiality Over Previous Ruling Declared Inadmissible
JAAC 55.50
Provisional Order for Debt Enforcement Does Not Raise Reasonable Doubt on Judge's Impartiality

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 6 § 1 CEDH

Cited to address the issue of an impartial tribunal.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

JAAC 60.115

Déc. rendue en anglais1 par la Comm. eur. DH le

16 janvier 1996, déclarant irrecevable la req. N° 23565/94, J. A. B. c / Suisse

Violation d’obligations d’entretien découlant du droit de la famille. Participation à la procédure pénale du juge des mesures protectrices de l’union conjugale, dont la décision ordonnant le versement d’aliments n’a pas été respectée. Art. 6 § 1 CEDH. Tribunal impartial. En l’espèce, les deux fonctions du juge étaient bien distinctes, de sorte que tout doute raisonnable quant à son impartialité est exclu.

Nichterfüllung familienrechtlicher Unterhaltspflichten. Mitwirkung des gleichen Richters im Strafverfahren, welcher im Rahmen des Eheschutzverfahrens die nichtbefolgte Verfügung zur Bezahlung von Unterhaltsleistungen angeordnet hatte. Art. 6 § 1 EMRK. Unparteiisches Gericht. Im vorliegenden Fall erfüllte der Richter zwei klar unterschiedene Funktionen, so dass Zweifel an seiner Unparteilichkeit vernünftigerweise nicht angebracht sind.

Inadempienza degli obblighi di mantenimento derivanti dal diritto di famiglia. Partecipazione alla procedura penale dello stesso giudice che, nell’ambito della procedura volta a proteggere l’unione coniugale, aveva ordinato il versamento di una pensione alimentare; decisione che non è stata rispettata.

Art. 6 § 1 CEDU. Tribunale imparziale. Nella fattispecie, le due funzioni del giudice erano ben distinte; è pertanto escluso qualsiasi dubbio ragionevole riguardo all’imparzialità.

Schweizerisches Bundesarchiv, Digitale Amtsdruckschriften Archives fédérales suisses, Publications officielles numérisées Archivio federale svizzero, Pubblicazioni ufficiali digitali

JAAC 60.115 - Déc. rendue en anglais1 par la Comm. eur. DH le 16 janvier 1996, déclarant irrecevable la req. N° 23565/94, J. A. B. c / Suisse

In Verwaltungspraxis der Bundesbehörden Dans Jurisprudence des autorités administratives de la Confédération In Giurisprudenza delle autorità amministrative della Confederazione

Jahr 1996 Année Anno

Band 60 Volume Volume

Seite --- Page Pagina

Ref. No 150 002 900

Das Dokument wurde durch das Schweizerische Bundesarchiv und die Bundeskanzlei konvertiert. Le document a été digitalisé par les Archives Fédérales Suisses et la Chancellerie fédérale. Il documento è stato convertito dall'Archivio federale svizzero e della Cancelleria federale.