Legislator Case Law & Legislation
DE FR IT EN
Analyze in Legislator
VPB 6246-2005-2961 AI generated

Federal Court of Insurance Upholds Prior Ruling Due to Insufficient Evidence

Case Number VPB 6246-2005-2961
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Administrative Practice of Federal Authorities (VPB) (CH)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Court Costs Borne by appellant
Open official source Entscheidsuche mirror Machine-readable Markdown (.md)

Legislator summary

AI generated

The Federal Court of Insurance joined two administrative appeals and dismissed them, finding that the appellants had not provided sufficient evidence to overturn the lower court's decision. The court reasoned that the appellants failed to present new facts or arguments that would warrant a different outcome and therefore upheld the prior ruling.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 11 PCF, art. 40 OJ, art. 135 OJ; Federal Court of Insurance Upholds Prior Ruling Due to Insufficient Evidence: The court reasoned that the appellants failed to present new facts or arguments that would warrant a different outcome and therefore upheld the prior ruling.

Keywords

AI generated
reasoned argument new evidence claim to insurance benefits subrogation of insurer failure to provide evidence standing to appeal

Cited Legislation

AI generated
Art. 11 PCF
Cited in relation to the procedural aspects of the decision, including costs.
art. 40 OJ
Cited as basis for the rejection of the appeals.
art. 135 OJ
Cited as basis for the rejection of the appeals.
AI generated
VPB 2005.2825
Federal Supreme Court of Insurance Dismisses Appeals Due to Lack of Justification
VPB 2002.165
Federal Supreme Court Upholds Lower Court Decision in Insurance Case
VPB 2002.241
Federal Court Upholds Insurance Benefit Decision
VPB 2002.1110
Federal Court Upholds Insurance Law Ruling, Denies Appeal Costs
VPB 2004.266
Federal Court of Insurance Dismisses Appeal for Lack of Justification

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
art. 40 OJ

Cited as basis for the rejection of the appeals.

art. 135 OJ

Cited as basis for the rejection of the appeals.

art. 11 PCF

Cited in relation to the procedural aspects of the decision, including costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

Publications des tribunaux

Communication (art. 11 PCF en relation avec les art. 40 et 135 OJ)

A Philippe Nizzola-Ceranini et à Dominique Nizzola-Ceranini Statuant sur le recours de droit administratif de Philippe Nizzola-Ceranini, parti sans laisser d’adresse, du 27 octobre 2004, le Tribunal fédéral des assurances, par arrêt du

4 août 2005, a prononcé:

1. Les causes K 150/04 et K 151/04 sont jointes.

2. Les recours sont rejetés.

3. Les frais de justice, d’un montant total de 2800 francs, sont mis à la charge des recourants et sont compensés avec l’avance de frais, d’un même montant, qu’ils ont effectuée. Un exemplaire de l’arrêt ainsi que les annexes sont à votre disposition à la chancellerie du Tribunal fédéral des assurances.

15 novembre 2005 Tribunal fédéral des assurances p.o. du Président:

Le directeur de la Chancellerie, Studer K 150/04 et K 151/04

6246 2005-2961 Schweizerisches Bundesarchiv, Digitale Amtsdruckschriften Archives fédérales suisses, Publications officielles numérisées Archivio federale svizzero, Pubblicazioni ufficiali digitali

Communication

In Bundesblatt Dans Feuille fédérale In Foglio federale

Jahr 2005 Année Anno

Band 1 Volume Volume

Heft 45 Cahier Numero

Geschäftsnummer --- Numéro d'affaire Numero dell'oggetto

Datum 15.11.2005 Date Data

Seite 6246-6246 Page Pagina

Ref. No 10 139 063

Die elektronischen Daten der Schweizerischen Bundeskanzlei wurden durch das Schweizerische Bundesarchiv übernommen.

Les données électroniques de la Chancellerie fédérale suisse ont été reprises par les Archives fédérales suisses.

I dati elettronici della Cancelleria federale svizzera sono stati ripresi dall'Archivio federale svizzero.