Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/998/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/998/2005 AI generated

Governmental Entity Liability for Unauthorized Land Taking and Just Compensation

Case Number ATAS/998/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appellant, a governmental entity, contested a lower court's ruling that it was liable for damages arising from a land use dispute involving the construction of public infrastructure, specifically challenging the scope and calculation of the damages awarded to the property owners. The court reasoned that the governmental entity failed to adhere to statutory procedures concerning notice and compensation prior to the physical taking, thereby causing an unconstitutional injury; consequently, the court affirmed the finding of liability, upholding the methodology used by the lower court to determine just compensation based on the diminution in property value caused by the unauthorized public improvements.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Governmental Entity Liability for Unauthorized Land Taking and Just Compensation: The court reasoned that the governmental entity failed to adhere to statutory procedures concerning notice and compensation prior to the physical taking, thereby causing an unconstitutional injury; consequently, the court affirmed the finding of liability, upholding the methodology used by the lower court to determine just compensation based on the diminution in property value caused by the unauthorized public improvements.

Keywords

AI generated
unauthorized construction value in dispute public property calculation of damages compensation for use land law

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for the order regarding court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               #$$%#&%%' !#(($#&%%'

!

) !*) "!+  )" +"*

",- .

 ( /- &%%' 



 !"#$%&$'!!'' #!#$ ( $)$#    





!$#

  *  +   '#$$!'#, "!$  '$'& -.--   /



          !"  

   +.0,+  

 0*!

-4    &  52 6'$ -7,3  $ 88''& "!# 9# !:';$!'#  !'   !$$ "#<   '+'   * ='+"#<'>4

.4 "'"#'$".22/ 9#&!88#9;#%&"#'! "!#?   &$& @!"'$'& A "'# #"#'4  '$  $#'$$ "B@'$#'? '$'8@C"'$6!#4

54 &!"$#&A9#& ''A@#;!$#':$'! D8#'@!"'$'#-28#4"#6!#4

/4 "#$9#& %?8'$&;! !$8'$%!'#A "'##"#'A'?9'%'$@#;9:8#'# 8'4!$8'$"#%'#A'!##'#*#%'9#+'  .. 6'$ .22/  # !8'#$ ?9' 9%'$ " 9!:';$'!  %##  !$#':$'!-28#4"#6!# <!#?#8'8''$&;!% D4

34 # !##'#  .E !%:# .22/  ' !$ !$$&  &!"$   '  8'$ %!'# ? # 8' 8''$ &; ! % D  ?9'  %'$  @#;$?9%'$''F$#D"$&!$#':$'! !8!#&$A !'4

E4   #?F$   '   "#$  9#& !$ !'?& !"'  &#$'! 8'  # 8'4  !$ & A  ' ?9 &%  '$$'!#8'#:'$$'!!%4

,4 #!##'#56%'#.223 ''8!#&"<#9#&?! !' "#!?'!'$%##!$#':$'!D8#'&6!#!'$"F$#A @#;   8' !  !'$ " %!'#  @#;  8'4 #  !  &#$'!#% 9#&"$F$#!'&#&!&$$A@#; 8' !#$?!$#':$'!D8#'9@!"'$'$'!&$'$6$'8'&4 '#&'$!&?"#$''"$'!-28#4"#6!#"!#'?$+ ?$#6!#9@!"'$'$'!.22/

14 -,6%'#.223 9#& #"#&$&"#    8'$"#$A '!&!#$&?9#&''!8!#6$$A #!#4

74 #&''!.-6%'#.22/ '!8'#&?"#!&':$'#  6#  ?' !$ $#'& # 8!#$'! $ 9!$ " 98$ A @#;  !'%$ "B#!$#':$'!-28#4"#6!# F'%'%$@G#"#$4



01120.223  +50,+   -24 9#&  8!#& !""!'$'!  .5 8&%#'# .223  8'$ %!'# ?  #<; 9D"$'!  9#! # 9#+' $ "#''"$ !$'%& "#  8'$ ?  "#! B$  !:';$'! #%$  #!'$   8' !'%$8'#8D8#'#&;F!#?9'$#!%$A9@C"'$4 # #9&;! "#&9:#'' @!"'$'# #"#&$#"&!!'8''<#88$'%"!#&;  "'?'+'%#!$'#%'%# ;#&9:9 :#4 < !# ? 9#& 8'$ &; ! %  "#$  ?' $  #$'$&;#$@#; !'$F$#D"$&!$#':$'!4

--4 # &''!.#.223 '#6$&9!""!'$'!9#& !$'8 ?+'&$'$&':$'# 6# 8$A@#;$?9%'$$#'& 8!#$'!4##!)$ "!%'$F$#!'&#&!&$$A@#; 8' <!#?9%'$#&'&#%-/(EE.8#4.22. 55(2.E8#4 .225$7(5.18#413.22/4

-.4 9#&'$#6$&#!#-#%#'.223 !$'8?$D$'#!' $ " "#$''<#$  ! !#!  "#&%!'$ D"#&$ ?  #& 8'$ &; ! %  "#! % ? ' !$  #$'! #%$  #!'$   8' !$ D!&#&  "'$  $$ !$#':$'!4 F '  '88&#   $#'$$ $# "#! 8'$ &; ! $  "#!  $ $$ 6$ A &:$ $ ?9 @#!'$'! $ A "#&%!'#"#!@'$ 9&$$$#!'$ #'9$!#''A8'# $# '$#"#&$$'!   $D$   !'  $$  8#H' ?9   &$$ "#8'$$'#4

-54   #&"!  5 ' .223   ' #<% ?  !$#':$'! D 8#'  &6!#"#&%"#!' $&@!&8!$'!@#;8'$? "#&<%$!$$#"!#!'&#$'!?9#& 9'9&$'$"  %#'$:%'#'+FA:!'49'$?"#!%'& !'$"F$#A@#;8'!"%!'#@#;8'4   $D$9!#!%'!#'$!'4 !$#6$#!# < !#?9#&#"#&$"@#;8''<#"!#"#$ ? 9!$"9!:';$'!9$#$'A!&;#4

-/4 &#'$#.6'.223 9#&!$$&9'$#"#&$$'!'  ?9 $' !"<$$ ##!&  $ "#'$&  9'$&;#'$&   !'!4

-34 #!##'#526'.223 '&;$'$!'!4

-E4 !##" '%#&;&"#$'#!$#"#' $$?:!'  "#$'#!'$'+"#<4





01120.223  +/0,+  

 +*!

-4 !';%!'#9!#;'$'!6'''#=>&$&!'8'&$'$'$& < -#!I$.225  #':$!#!' !"!&36;  !$"#&'$$%'+"#&'$ 3""&$$-E6;#=#$4-  $4#$3E >4

*'$A9$'!9&$'!-E6;# "# #':8&&# .,6%'#.22/= J-52-2E> # !';%!'!"$& -58&%#'#   '"!'$'!$#'$!'##;$"#$$$ #':$!# !'  '&;#  # A $#!' 6; $'$'#     9$$$  9&$'!!%D6;#4

.4 !8!#&$ A (#$4 3E 4 - $4  @4 /    #': $!  #!'!)$'$'?!$$$'!"#&%A9#$' 3E!'8&&##"#$';&&##!'1!$!:#.222 = >?'!$#$'%A!'8&&##9#+'-1#-77/ = >4

*!"&$"!#6;#9"<$''&$:'4

54    $ $#&  %';#  -# 6%'# .225  $#)$  !'8'$'!  !:# '"!'$'! &;   !'  # !'4 *#  "$&#' "!'$%!'#?#!'$(""'?!'$F$#$#@&A'<# "#''"!?#<;""':!$%';#!$!K 8'$6#''?$&$#'$!$"#!'$= J-52.52!'4-4-L 553!'4-4.L J-.7/!'4-4.L J-.,/E,!'4- -.E-5E !'4/:$#&8&#>4#<;"#!&#?$A(""'?$ #&#%<6!#!$#&%';#= J--,75!'4E: --.5E2 !'4/L  -771M5,"45-E!'45:>4 9""'?! 9"<4

$#6$&8!#$&'"##'$"#!' #!#$#%:=#$43E $E2 >4

/4 $ '$';'  ?$'!  9D"$'! ! !  9#& D 8#'  !$#':$'!D&6!#@!"'$'#?988$&.22/4

*!9#$4E/.  "#$''"$'!#&D!I$"#$$'!!$ ':&&8''$!"#!$$8'D"#&=8#@'>$-2N!I$ ?' &"$ $$ 8#@' =?!$+"#$>4   9@!"'$'$'!   #& %#$ !$# !$#':$'!D8#'&6!# &@!&8!$'!



01120.223  +30,+   @#;8'=84#$4E/43 >4 !'8&&#8'D!$$ $$!$#':$'!4

J'$ ;  $$ !"&$   !' 8&&#  8'D&  !$$   !$#':$'!6!#'<#D8#'&6!#@!"'$'#A-28#=84#$4-2/4- 9#!#9#+'.,6'-773O >4 !$8!' A $#9#$4-2/4.$4  #&?'%'%$&;! %  ! "'# "#! % ? ' !$  #$'! #%$  #!'$8'!$D"$&$$!$#':$'!4

9!## '9$"!$$&?#!#$8'$&;!% "<#$<# !%"#!%?#$'!#%$ #!'$8'4

9'$'& !'<# "$ ?   # !K 9#& $ &':$'#  6# @#;8'$?9$#'&8!#$'! !'$"B# !$#':$'!  F '  8'$ &; ! %  "#$4  ##!)$  (#&  "$ F$# !'&#& ! &$$ A @#;   #'#  < !# ?9' 9!$  !:';$'! 9$#$'4 !#  '  9#$4 -2/ 4 . $4   $!$#'#A9#$4E/43 4

9$"9%' #':&4'#%#"#'#'? $D$9#$4-2/4.$4 $"#8'$$'#$?9'88'$?9#& %'%&;!%"#!%?'#$'!#%$  #!'$   8' "!# ?9' !'$ D"$&   !$#':$'!4 $$ #<; $ !$'%&"#8'$?"#!B$!:';$'!#%$#!'$ 8' !'%$ 8'# 8 D 8#'  &; F !#?9  $#!%$ A 9@C"'$4  "#!    #%@  9!$ "  8#'  #" $$ ?9!$@!"'$'&4

*9;'$!9"<9#&6#?'8'$&;!%  "#$   $ $   "#''"   "#$''"# D 8#'  &; =!B#  8#'#" $4>!#<;#!$&8''4#C$&  "#$ !$ $  !8!#&$ A 9#$4 5.1 4 -   8!#'#  '$ A #8' !#?9A&8$$$'$ $!:#'$:!'4# 'B '!$$#?#!#$ #'!!&$$$& 9#&'&? 8':#%.22/ A%!'#,,,8#4"#!'=7(5.18#413P-.> !#? $!$8#''&A'$$';'$7(1-.8#4"!#$$&+AP$'' :'A@#;"#$4#;$9'$'&$!:$A8D$9! #'$!#A%'!$'!9#$4E/43 4

#$ ''?#<%#!#$+F '88&#$#'$$$# "#!$8'$&;!?$A#"#$''"$'!D 8#' !# 9 &6!# A 9@C"'$ $+ A 9&$ %$  !''!   &#'$&!'$$&":'? ''9"#!"!'$'! !'8&&#



01120.223  +E0,+   .7!%:#.22.=84"'<!4,#!#$>49#"!'? #!#$8'$&;!%"#$ ?$#" 8#'9$#$' $?99&$$$#!'$!'$F$#D"$&"'$ !$#':$'!-28#4"#6!#9@!"'$'$'!4

#!# :'8!& !'$F$#'4













































01120.223  +,0,+   

 " +!*0  !*) "!+  )" +"*

 

123 4  5   67 89& + :

  3

-4 &##!##%:4

 3

.4 9$4

54 &''!'+'  *.-6%'#.223$.# .2234

/4 !9'$'&A"B#A#!#$!8#4122A$'$#&"4

34 8!#  "#$'   ?9 "%$ 8!## #!# !$#  "#&$ ##F$   &'  52 6!# <  !$'8'$'! "# "' #!& #&  #': 8&&#  #  *@Q'G#@!8?' E  E22/     $#!' D"'#4  &'  "$ F$# "#!!;&4  &!'# !'$P > ''?# D$$?&''!#!#$&'#!:$'#'$"&''! $$?&L :> D"!# "!# ? !$'8 ' $' "!%!'# # $$ $# &''!L > "!#$#  ';$# !   ! #"#&$$4 *'  &!'#  !$'$ "  $#!' &&$ &&#& ! $$# > :> $ > '+   #':8&&##"!##"$##$'<###!#?9' %#&##'##%:4&!'##!#$'!#!#!B  "#%  ?' #!$ 6!'$  '' ?  &''! $$?& $ 9%!""  ?&$&D"&'&#!#$=#$4-5. -2E$-21>4  ;#88'#  #&'$P     R'    '  

!"'!8!#"#&$##F$$!$'8'&D"#$'''?9A988'8&&# $&":'?"#;#88



01120.223