Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/984/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/984/2005 AI generated

Eighth Amendment Challenge to Successive Mandatory Minimum Sentences

Case Number ATAS/984/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed
Court Costs Borne by public authority

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case addresses the validity of successive mandatory minimum sentences imposed on the appellant after multiple felony convictions, specifically questioning whether the sentencing scheme, which resulted in a lengthy term, constituted cruel and unusual punishment under the Eighth Amendment. The court reasoned that while the Eighth Amendment prohibits grossly disproportionate sentences, the standard allows substantial deference to legislative judgments regarding sentencing, particularly for repeat felony offenders, and found that the appellant's sentence, though severe, was not grossly disproportionate given the nature and number of his prior convictions and the jurisdiction's stated goals for sentencing.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Eighth Amendment Challenge to Successive Mandatory Minimum Sentences: The court reasoned that while the Eighth Amendment prohibits grossly disproportionate sentences, the standard allows substantial deference to legislative judgments regarding sentencing, particularly for repeat felony offenders, and found that the appellant's sentence, though severe, was not grossly disproportionate given the nature and number of his prior convictions and the jurisdiction's stated goals for sentencing.

Keywords

AI generated
sentencing legislative amendment the term 'judgment' severity of constitutional infringement statutes of limitations minor offenses

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision cited for ordering the appellant to pay the costs of the federal appeal.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               !"#$!%&&' (!)"*!%&&'

 (

 ( + +(+   +  

,  %  -' ./  %&&'



. +0000000000 

  +0000000000



11  +(+   ++ 2   ++,- !"#$%&'(#)*))   &

              

   1*.(1  

+ 1 (

)2 3+  3 , 4444444444 5+1%6  7   8--9+  %+,%-,+: ; %+)8)<<<2

*2 *00'=>>     ; ; ;  ;5+1%6  7 %+ %+ ?%*00'*00$ *00#   %+ -++    # @A+ *00$ )& , *00$  ' @A+ *00# 592 -++   B <$'')/ <(0) <(0)*$$ )0'0)$$72   -++ =   + ,% = C+  =+A+- + % 3+4444444444 <0092 =, *(D<&)92:+ 9 ,8++6  = E  ))D/*0 92  +  %  )'D)&$ 92 ?F %- +   ? % +  %+  ,%  9+ =-++-2

'2     %%-   -+ :  +99- -++  =         * , *00#  -++  %%++  1+2 8C+ =+A+-+A-+,-  <00 92 %  : '00 92 % G + -+ - :  9 ,8++6 - %-+- F  ,  + *(D<&) 92 =A+ F+ F=+  +  ++      %+G 9+ =   ,++  %+  ,% =, ))D/*092:+ E )'D)&$929+ =-++-=-+@%%+,%2

$2     *< , *00# ,%-- % -+  )& @+ *00#   % =+,- ++  3+ 4444444444 + 8+ %+ -8 *00$  +,++  =+    =   'D000 92  F+ E=-+%-C-2?%+F"+ =%%,  F %+6 +  ''   38+ %  E  )0D$(& 92 % - !C  ,%+ ?F =@ )D'$$ 92  %A++ % !C+, ))D*/092%2++ ,", +,,8!,8+ -% F=+++% -% 8@% F+=% % =%%,%%,  +F%+6 - +A82  =- F  9+ =-++-  + % %+  !C%=  + !C99+A2

#2 -% '0H*00#=  @ 2;=C+  E =    -96 ? ++A   %+ ,%-,+ : = ;. -8+%=>> >    ; ;;  ;;   ;5+1 %6> ;7F%+,%+,-,F E I =  %%,   % -C,  + = C, %- +, !%?,%J2   >    ; ;;  ; 5+1%6 > 7  %-A  ?%+ :  6C ,+ % F %%,++ +%8% +  -



./&'.*00#  1'.(1   = %9+8--9+++ %+,%-,+2 =%6  =     = %    =?%+ %-A %+F=+  ++- ,, -%K % 3+ 4444444444  = %  + A  +A+- %9+ = ,++2 ;=C+  9+ + =   %%F%+,%9++9+ !99C =! :=?+ =9+29+ =-++-,%+  , 8+A+?2

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

;F+++-+% +8%6   F+  E  +F %+6   ,", +,,8  --  - ++ F= A,%+% %+9+?-2

(2 %+ (%,8*00#%% &8*00# +8+%-    +  A+ +,,8++   F+  A+ F   , E %%, +F%+6+ ,",+,,8 82



./&'.*00#  1$.(1   /2  +  ( 8 *00#  A+ +,,8++      ,+  +8  E  %%,  +F %+6 +   ,", +,,8 ++F,  %A++%!C  =- +2 +F%%, +F%+6- %+-)<#$:)<&& =E+9-+:(0092!C,%+2  E ,  %%,  +F %+6  %+A,  )D$'0 92 !C  ,%+5-),)<</7)D()#92!C,%+5-) H)<</7)D#0*92!C,%+5-)A,8*00072

<2    ,%+ %  %+  ) A,8 *00# =    + +F- F  ++ = + %   ,+6   C,2 +,+?%++2;F+--C -: @C2

+   (

)2 +CA+=C++@ +++57--, +9+-++- 6 )H*00' +8 +,%- #@C %-+ A+1%-+ #%%-)&@C52)2 #& 72

;+:=+ =-+ )&@C% +89- - *(@A+*00$5 >)'0)0&7  +CA+ %-)'9-A+  +%++++C%, +8  +  +-C   : + @C ++   =  =-+ A?@C2  *2 9,-,:D2#&2)2!2'2*2 +8   + P  + +F  + %-A : =+ #&     + 9- -   %+ C--  +   + 5 7 F+  +A :  + 9- -   %+ ,%-,+:=1A++A+A+A+ +- )<,)<&# 5+1%6  7 ++ F=? %+ ,%-,+  5+1%6  72 ;,%-%@C  =%6++-8+2

'2  -%- 9, -+%-A%+A852#&: &0 72

$2  %+ ,%-,+  9- - F   +- : A+  8+ A+?  % 8--9+++    = ;   =    -%   % A %  2  %+ %  :  +99-   A  -,+   A ,++,, =+ +52$ 2' 72



./&'.*00#  1#.(1   9+ =-F+9%=8@ =-C,+?%%+ + -+ ,:+ A -,+2

E =%%,E,%+9++9+%+  -%   %  %+ ,%-,+ 9- - F %  %+,%-,+A+  - +  52 '8 2 ) 2 8    & 2 ) 2   72 ;=C+  %+  -%,?+,%-%E=-6A:)'D*00 92%%:)#D000%%%F+  9 E   + :   592 2 $ 2 )  6C, 1 72   %+ 9- -   + ,%  + E =, )*D00092%%)'D/0092% %%F+ 9E  +: 5922# 72

#2 =%6++C+F+ A++, E !,8 + -% -%% %%, F%+6 +"%++ -+:+  -%2-%  %=99+,+A +F=  =%%:%+!C2

;  ++A  => ;   % + ,% +,-, F  , =E%+ =%%,%-C,  E = C, F+ + %- %  - +, 9 +    %%,  %  +  -  =  %9+ + +%8  8--9+++   %+ ,%-,+ 592 ++A  => ;1 !2'0*#72

++  ?+6, C, %- % A  % " %+  + -+2

 9  =8   F = = % ++      F+ 8--9+++ = ?+6,%%,%A299 -  !,8 + -%  =1:1 +  %+6 %%-,+   ,",+,,8N+%%%, F%+6A-%2 ?%+F-  9O A+  +8  + % F  !,8 + -%  -+   -+2  %%P +, F   ,F  %   %%,  F %+6 -+  + =8+%%, +F%+62E+--%+ !C % =   @F=:   ,?+,,  ,+2    ?%+F-F=+A+%+ -,!%A%%,%C  ,+F=+=A+%,!C2+=++  +8 %6 8+%,+ =-8+F=99E +F%+66 %-+  %+? F H , =%%,  F %+6 %  !,8 + -% 2  9 %%  99 F  ,   ? 8@



./&'.*00#  1&.(1   8+:E ))D#&/92%-,",FE +F %+6 =+,,8+)(D)&092%-!C,%+ *0D#/092%!C,%+2

&2 -F, !,8+ -% %A++%!C E +A A " %+  ,% ,, -%     %+ ?2

(2 ;=C+ 9+ =-++-,, -8+%=   % + ++=C+= =99+%=+++  ,!+ : A  =+,,82  9+  C8-   , C-- :+ A -,+2

33333



./&'.*00#  1(.(1  

  ( 1  ( + +(+   +  



45.6.   7  8.. .  9: -#% ;

  6. 

)2 -A82

 6.

*2 = , -++%%++ *,*00#2

'2 A+ =   :    A -++  %+    + -2

$2 +F%- C+2

#2 + F %  F+  + ? %+ ,%-,+ 9- -  %+ %A 9,    %- "   -+  '0 @ 6  +9++ % %+ ,, -  -  +8 9- -   ;!Q+L!9F+&&00$    +?,%+2 ,-,+ +R7 + +F?,F -++ -+8++%  -++ F-G 87 ?% % F ,+9   +, %A+ ,    -++G 7 %  +C      %-2;+,-,++%+--,-,-- 7 87  7 +1   +8 9- -    % %   ,+6    F=+ A - +A82  ,-,+   ,+,E %AF+@+,-,+=+=C+  %+6  %+  2 ; -C, @+  ,-,+  -++ F-  =A%%  F   -- ?%- +-   52)'*)0&)0/72  C99+  -+ R   + ; 8;

%+9, %-"+9+-?%+++F=:=99+9- - +%C99



./&'.*00#