Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/983/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/983/2007 AI generated

Insurance Coverage Duty to Defend Interpretation of Exclusion Clause

Case Number ATAS/983/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case involves a dispute over insurance coverage where the appellant argued that their policy did not cover damages because the loss was not caused by an event listed in the policy, contending that the trial court erred in its interpretation of the exclusion clause concerning ongoing or recurring losses and the resulting duty to defend. The court reasoned that the policy's language, particularly regarding the time frame of covered losses and the definition of continuous or recurring damages, dictated coverage, and found that the underlying claim presented a factual scenario that could potentially fall within the scope of coverage, thereby triggering the insurer's duty to defend, even though some claims within the suit were clearly excluded.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Insurance Coverage Duty to Defend Interpretation of Exclusion Clause: The court reasoned that the policy's language, particularly regarding the time frame of covered losses and the definition of continuous or recurring damages, dictated coverage, and found that the underlying claim presented a factual scenario that could potentially fall within the scope of coverage, thereby triggering the insurer's duty to defend, even though some claims within the suit were clearly excluded.

Keywords

AI generated
insurance exclusion clause scope of insurance cover over-insurance breach of insurer duty excluded cases insured risk

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the final order to regulate court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



            !" #  $!" #

%%

&' %()'* * * & '%* (

+,  !

 -! .+,  " # 



 !"#$#%  ! 

 ! !"#$&'()

*

++, +  +  "7  - + .. +/ . -  +       0)  +*12'34*#56 

                

  $89  

* /(

#. :2!* #3:)$&&59(!;!0  0 4!(* 4" )  !"##%69*    "  #%96 < ="** !"  *  #5 4*!0#%35.

$. ;77#'  4*7 :2!*4"*" 0 4!(*  "4*24!*" ) 4")>47<4 ; "4? *!2.

'.  :2!*  ) * ) "7*7  $@ 7") $&&5 *  "*" *! =77 0 "6!$&&54?"* 4*2.

@.  0 "*" 4*! *** 4")> 4*4"*** "7 4* !!< !**  )   4* < *  !2 * *  #54*!0#%35*$@7")$&&5.

9. +=2*  ! *44A

1  <=  *: "*" 77" B  ++  ,   +   +   - +        +/  +-  +        C  D E <  ) =")* B @=5$# 7. 6&  !!*  !2  < 4"**  !!*  ) !4* *  *"F* *!2!! %=96#7.%9!!*  )E <  ) ** =")*  !!*  ) B #59='@&7.'&.

6. * ! =*)""A

1 <= * "2!* 77" B  ++  ,   +   +   - +        +/  +-  +         C(D 4  #  4*!0 #%55E <  ) =")* B 56=36# 7. 5&  !!*  !2  < 4"**  !!*  ) !4* *  *"F*  *  !2  !!  #99=696 7. 99  !!*  )E <  ) ** =")*  !!*  )B@9@=5597.



    8%&'8$&&5 '89  

5.  !**"*"*!?4* * $'G*$&&5.: *  <"<=B "7* =0)* 4*F**  0.

3. =0 =0:*  "7?""*"2 "B:2.

* &%(

#. =*.$9 7" "042 4")>47 )))**) *" #5 "!0#%%'C/D*")2 #:)$&&&(24"   ).<:** 4 - 4** *B4*2C*.#$$*#$'   )1 D :2   )!4"** =*.5'.# 7" " 4")> 47  $9 : #%3$ CD * B ()  0 *  4#G*$&&' *4(<=77  "*"*!C*.#@$ D?"* =774*20  "  "4** "*!"4:2  ).

$. +=*.$$/C)*)2 4#:)$&&&D  )  4**  * < *  !2 * 4*2" 7!"!* ?*.#$$#$'#@#*#@$ E*.'B9 /=44<* 42!**B*7"C.#D.;<:*4**  *B4*24 B 77"*4** *2!*"  )  0 42 ?** ")*!*  !!*  ) *  4** *2!*" ) 042?**")*!* !!*  !2C7.*.$@/D.:* B  4**  * * B =)  0 42 ?**  !!*     !2  *"F*   !!*  ) C / #$3  $'&E /#$%@@@D.

 -4(  :2  4!( *   "  4*2 4 !*"  4**  * < *  !2 4  ! .  * 4*** -4* !2#54*!0#%35 -*4* $@7")$&&5 *B<:2!*  )* )?"*.

'. +  !* 4 *  4** < 4 *  !2 4  ! * $%%=##37.@9C@9@=5591#99=696.99D* <<4  !  *  #69=553 7. '9 C#59='@&.'& 1 %=96#.%9D  *"F* >* ":B "*" " 4  ***  4")> "7 .   !  *B?1"4!** #@%=99%7.$9C$%%=##3.@9A$D <=  *  !!  3$=33% 7. $& C#69=553.'9 A $D  * < -*  "7*) ! < *B?1"4!** 66=65&7.&9.

    8%&'8$&&5 @89  

@. 7!"!* B  :4  4  : "*!* 4  4*2 :<=!!* *7* 4** *  !:* )"0""7 4** *B *"F*!4* !** 1. *"F**"*?!!!"2=*.#$ = 4")>47)))**) *"  #3 ) #%3@ C $D    *? "2!*  1 * 4" C /40"'68&$ #3:*$&&'D.

9.  "!!*   4H  4"  "** 2** C*. 5' . $  * 3%I.# 4"  !**) #$4*!0#%39D.



JJJ



    8%&'8$&&5 989  

%  0 (/  %()'* * * & '%* (



#. )*  ++  ,   +   +   - +        + /  +  -  +          C  D B *7"  !4* !! 66=65&7.&9B ++ ,   +   +   - +        + /  +  -  +          C  D  7)   !  " #  <  *"F* !4*     "* (#!$&&5:<=!!* *7*.

$. -> !**< 0.

'. *<4" *2**.

@. 7!  4*   <- 4)* 7!  *  4"* F*   "  '& : (  *7* 4(  0 7" " C+;KL;7<66&&@  D4) !*(  * 407!"!*?*.3$ 7" " 07" " #5 : $&&9 C /DE  !"!   *  <   !*7 * !> 4)*4*2* * ! *E * F*  "  0 7" " 4 ) 4*  4 ) "*< ?  *  =*. @$  /.  4"* F* *  4(  4  *)<"!!!> 4) )*F*:*B=).  277(  " *A             // M+  M 47! 4"*F***7"?4*<-B-777" " 4277

    8%&'8$&&5