Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/968/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/968/2005 AI generated

Property Sale Agreement Supersession and Financing Contingency Waiver

Case Number ATAS/968/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appeal concerned a dispute over the enforcement of an agreement to sell property, where the transaction was contingent upon obtaining financing, and the initial agreement was later superseded by a second agreement that allegedly failed to incorporate all prior terms, leading to a dispute over whether the initial financing contingency remained binding or was waived. The court reasoned that the second agreement, which made no mention of the financing contingency from the first, evidenced an intent to substitute the new agreement for the old one, thereby waiving the earlier condition, and affirmed the lower court's decision in favor of the party seeking enforcement of the second, unconditional agreement.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Sale Agreement Supersession and Financing Contingency Waiver: The court reasoned that the second agreement, which made no mention of the financing contingency from the first, evidenced an intent to substitute the new agreement for the old one, thereby waiving the earlier condition, and affirmed the lower court's decision in favor of the party seeking enforcement of the second, unconditional agreement.

Keywords

AI generated
terms of sale real estate transaction enforcement decision easement agreement proceedings relating to a contract consignment contract

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Costs awarded against the appellant in the event of rejection of the appeal.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

                !"#""$ %!&#""$

 '('(

) ')( (*(  )( *'

+ , -  # ./., #""$ 



 !"#$#"%&   $  ! '(



$

) % !*"$+#$,,*- $, $*# ,.$/$0 %



                 

   75167  

$$,  8$ 9     $+# "  #$# )  %   9$# , ,$! #$# ,$     #$# $8*#  ) % "$:

; ,$ , 55 * 5446! ;#    / $ ,  ,;,*,"*$,<#$) % :

; =" + $# " 9;  ,+$ "> , ,=>* "! "9; ;$,?+9338'@4"*$",A4@8'56:

;,*,,>B9,@5C8'64$*/#:

;+$# B  ,#$*!  #$# ) % ! ,  #" , A2 D 5446!B;+/$#,,*,*$89 /;$*"#$$ 9 ;<$ , $$$ ""$ $$$ , "#+(! *"( $ ($,$$9;$,>.$,;$<""$*"(#B *"(:



,#$  ,$ 9   <+  ;<$ D, EF  #$# *,8#$$$#!,>A?$544G! /$,! *"# , 6 D<! ,$  "#,$ $  +7"#,$! 6 ""#$ $ A3 D< E$'A$'$63 F:

$B;$,;#$,A3D<!" /8#,# 52D+544CE HAG4A43F!, <+,"$#!AG8#+! ,"$$$<$"*$$$ /$, , #<   B $ D< $$! ! , ;$$$ , ;#$ , +=D<:

-= $* , -$' 2G ' A ,   8#,#   "#+( "8! +! ++$ $ +,$# , 56 D AI@5EF! J9 $ ,#<  / 9 .$!  ,> $ $! , $$$ ""$ $$$,"#+(!*"($($,$:

 $$ ,"$ -""9 ,- "$ = $$$ , "#+( <$# , ,$ "+#  , ,$ "/ 7  /   9   "$$ **/<$9-9"$$-#$,$7,BE$'CI '5F7$!,-$"$!=8,$,"#+(8+," <$#! ,  ,* , "$$ 9 ,#"$  *** /<$ E$'@I/'3 : HA55G5G,'5F:



123415446  7G167   -B>+!8*#*$B-$'63'A$'/!-$ /$,   9 .$  $ 9 , $$$ $+ B  "#+( "8 ""$ $$$ , "#+(! *"( $ ($ ,$!(*",,+!9;="#$$"/$#E$'GGAB GGA,,,/<$:$'65!63!'A$$'2G:$'AC5,+F:

  / 8#,# ,  E H F  ,#DB  - , "# 9  *"#$,$$#+#"-$'2G$,/*$,#8K-$!$$ ,-/,!9$B$,$<K8$9$$$$"$"$ , 9$ "#89 ,  "#+( "8!   #$$    <:

$,""*$,$<9"$$,"$$,-! ,"$$,/"<$,$$:

- +J!  + , ,$ , -$' 2G   $ " +$ 9  $$$8,*$D,9$9"#+("8!*L*  ,+$ + , 88$ +$ , ,$ , ,$ "#+( E H A56  A3@ ,'5!A55G5G,'5/$#8#F:

$$*"#$$",$#<*$*$#"8$9,#<, *>  #9+9  "$ "+$ L$ # B  $$$! B +  $$$ , "#+(!  *"( $  ($ ,$ E $$ 9$! +  & 7 % !  J$M< J ,* ! % NA43O AI@2  "' 3A4' : % PQ 0  P7P P  !  J$"8< J ,* ! % % AI@G "'A2CF:

*"#$,D,$,#<#B-$'2G$,#9 $<""*"($*"(#$>+9$"#89!#$$ <!,,$,"#+("8:

-$$$$*"($($,$"$"$!"$! +*$,$$"-*"(B-$$$,"#+(E$'33'A$ GF:

 ,  $ !   $ "  D,$ , ",-J 9 $ *"#$$ *  D< ,#<#  +$ , -$' 2G ! *L*   9$ , -=$ ,- $$ , $+ $  "$ ,$ L$ $J# B $$ "#D, E HA545I,'5$#8#F:

    " *$  *$$ , $$ * #<*$  "",-/<$,$!97,#,$$,$+,,$ "/E  !J$,/8J<,%JMR"'A52F:



123415446  7C167   --">!$$,- H "/#G31II,A6*5444!$< "$   9$ "#89 B  "#+( "8 ,>  9-  8*$"/D$+*$,$$:

--$9->+,, /$,:

-,$,-+/$#+#",#8,,$,L$#$#:



123415446  76167     *'0  ')( (*(  )( *'

  / 

1/.2.   3  4.. .  56 7!# *8

A' #,*,+/'

5' #+8,'

G' 8*  "$ ,  9; "+$ 8*  $  "#$ L$ ,  ,# , A4 D ,>  $8$ " " ,# ,#  / 8#,# , ! %JMRJ89 3! 344C   !  $ =*"'  ,#  "$ L$ "<#'  *#* ,$K F ,9 =$*$9,#$,#/$$",,# $$9#: /F =" " 9 *$8  $* "+ ,*, $$ $ ,#: F "$  <$   ,  "#$$' %  *#*  $$ "  $ ##*$ #*##  $$ F /F $ F 7,!  /8#,#,""$*$>9; ,+,#+/'*#*,*$*( , "+! 9 $ D$!  9  ,# $$9# $ ;+"" , 9#$#="#,#$E$'AG5!A43$A4@F'   <88>  #,$K       HH S% S



"8*,"#$L$$$8#="$9;B;888#,# ,"<88



123415446