Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/956/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/956/2005 AI generated

Property Owner Negligence in Slip and Fall Case

Case Number ATAS/956/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

A property owner was sued for damages arising from a slip and fall on the owner's premises, with the plaintiff alleging the premises were maintained in a dangerous condition due to a slippery substance, and the court ultimately held that the evidence supported a finding of negligence because the owner failed to remedy a known or reasonably discoverable hazardous condition within a reasonable time, despite any claim that the substance was only recently placed or that the owner lacked actual notice, thereby affirming the judgment for the plaintiff.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF; Property Owner Negligence in Slip and Fall Case: A property owner was sued for damages arising from a slip and fall on the owner's premises, with the plaintiff alleging the premises were maintained in a dangerous condition due to a slippery substance, and the court ultimately held that the evidence supported a finding of negligence because the owner failed to remedy a known or reasonably discoverable hazardous condition within a reasonable time, despite any claim that the substance was only recently placed or that the owner lacked actual notice, thereby affirming the judgment for the plaintiff.

Keywords

AI generated
bodily injury from fall liability for accidental damage property ownership abusive claim by landlord dangerous substance tenant liability

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

The provision is cited in the final order regarding the allocation of court costs for the appeal proceedings.

Art. 64 LTF

The provision is cited in the final order concerning the granting of legal aid.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

     

   

!"#$!%##& '!"&(!%##&

'

) '* ) '+  ) +* , - .

 / 0 - %##&

  

  ! "

!" 

##     $  $ $  $% & !"  &"&. '( )* + ,-

             

3 2/4 3

 1*'

56  % .  5   50*2%  7..8& 9 " "&,  9&-&&". " 9 " %  .:!.  55 :"7  2112   : ,  988& "!  : ! ;<. =&3: ,   > -&" + 9!" !&  : ""&! !:."&  "! " 8.. 6

26 ?&". .  .". &  7..8&  : ""&! !:."&  "! :&  5 & 50006

@6 : , -!& !".  <&"   "  & 211@% 9   !"". A  !- .&&! -&" .".  : 988& "!  9 3 &-&&". =&3: ,  >  "  4 8.- & 211@6 & : ""   2 B& 211@ 3"3& . + 9&". .  & !&A !:& &" .&&!% && A  !- !"" - . : 9&"&""&!  : .-!C 6

*6 9&". .  : !&"  5 B&" 211@  .&&!  4 8.- & 211@% D "  A 9   : !.. +  !-   !""   "  : "  !&. "&!  :. &!  !"&"&! ." <,  =&A  "  !&>6  C  &  : .& A  " !:."&  " - . :& - & 2112 & "" + 9.:!D% -  B<"    : !"" &  :  &7  : &,  &"  21   2112 " : !!E"  .: "&!6

)6  .&&!  ) .7  211@% 9   + !- .  !""  : ""&!  + 9&". .% 9.:!D  3& 9."" - !F"    !&" +  " 9&-&&". ." !"&-" :&  5 .7  21156

G6  50 B-& 211*% 9   : &. 9&". .  & " ""   B"&8&"&8 ! "  "   . &". !& ." <,  && A9 !:&   .&&!  "  =!- " &" +  !- .&&!    )

.7  211@>6  ::  H & ("   .  50 8.- & 211*6

46  * 8.- & 211*% 9&". .  " & !:&   .&&!   ) .7  211@6

I6 9   !"&8&.  !- .&&! + 9&". .  2* 8.- & 211* &" +  & + B!  !& %  -  .&&!  : 9   4 8.- & " )

.7  211@6   .<" ..  :&"   !  2?@GG 8 6% : .""  : ""&! - . + "! "  5 & 5000  20 8.- & 211*6

06 9&". .  .:!.  52   211*    & J ! "  !&3 &" - "  : ""&! + '"  2?@GG 8 6 K6  8&" -!&  7! 8!&% 9 : "% "  8&" A  7! " & " 8&&, " &:!&7% 9"  : "6

/01*/211)

3 @/4 3

516  .&&!  2) !"!7  211*% 9   B".    &% !&. " A 9&". . -&" 8&& + ! -!& 9! &.&""

"!" '<"% A  9" A &" + 9&" !<"&!  <&"   " 

25 & 211@ A9& -&" !"". A  !- .&&!  -&" .".   4 8.- & 211@% A : &   !&"&!   ' < 8&&,  " !: !  9."&" : .&.%  8&" A  8! " 9-&" 7&  - &"&!% :&A9 -&" E D 8!&  ( !""%  9  "  9 6

556  .&&!  0   211)% 9   B". 9!::!&"&! 8! . : 9&". .  54 !-7  211*6   ::. A  " !: - . ."&" H + 9<""&!  !""   "  &" +  : &  !:"  !"&"&! :C. + 9." < 6   !8& . A 9!7&<"&!  &< -&" .". -&!.%  !:&  .&&!   4 8.- & 211@  & ."" : - A  5 B&" 211@ &" +    25 & 211@6   8& -. A 9 .  :!-&" :  :    !:" A  &8! "&!  & &" : .& "

"  9  " 9  % !&" D  -& &"&"6

526 9&". .  &" B". !   @5   211) !"  &" .&&!6  !&< -!& .".  7! 8!&% : .&" A  " !:."&  :! .:!D  "!B!  .". - . +   & % A9  E!&" 3(  " !:."&  A :&  54 !"!7  21126  ,- : &  A  : & -&  !&8&"&!   "  & -&" .".  . !  A9  " !-&"    "' 6  !""  !""  2?@GG 8 6% !&. " A9& "  .&".  5?1)2 8 6 8&  :: A9 .: 8&&, "  9  % A9& &   ! &:!&7  8&  8 +  7! "

A!A6

5@6  ! : .-&  @ & 211)% 9  !"  B"  ! 6

5*6  : .-&  .". !&A. + 9&". . "   < . + B< 6

 +*'

56  !& <-!&  9! <&"&! B&&&  =>  .". !&8&. "  &"&".% ,  5 !H" 211@%  &7 "!    !&% !:!.  )

B<% !"  : .&" "  -&3: .&"% ) ::." " 5G B<   = "6 5 "6 " )G >6

$&" + 9"&!  9."&!  5G B<  % :  &7 8..  

24 B-& 211* = # 5@1  51G>%    !& <-!&  !:".%  5@ 8.- & %  &:!&"&! " &"!&   <" : """  &7 "!    !&  &.<    + " !& B< "&"& % %  9"""  9."&!  !-D B<  6

/01*/211)

3 */4 3

26 !8! ." + ? "6 )G  6 5 "6  '6 @ %  &7 "!    !& !F"  &" &A  !"""&! : .- + 9 "6 )G   !& 8..   G !"!7  2111   : "& <..    !&"    !& 2 >6 A& !" "&- +  !& 8..    : ""&! !:."&  + 9 3-&&%  -&-" " &-&&".  50   50G)

= #> && A9+ 9 "6 *@   !& "!   : ""&! "! !:."&  + 9 3-&& "  -&-" " + 9 3&-&&".

 2) !"!7  50GI = >6 $ !:." :! B<   9:, " && ."7&6

@6  ! % &" B".  ": "&% " -7 = "6 *@  >6

*6  9:,% 9  % : .&&!  2* 8.- & 211*% .. + 9&". .  :&"   !  2?@GG 8 6% : .""  : ""&! !:."&  "! - . + "! "%  5 & 5000  20 8.- & 211*6

)6 9&". . 9 :  &"&A.  7&38!.  "" .&&!%  7! " +   &  9!7&<"&!  7!  &" !6 "" .&&! " , !  " .  8! 6  !"" ..  :" && : ("  &  6

G6  &"&<  :! " , !  A   :!&"  -!& &  ! " :" : ."  +  &  9!7&<"&!  "&"  : ""&! !:."&  "! : E &H"6

46 D "   9 "6 2* 6 5 " 2    %  : ""&! &H" "!'. !&-" ("  "&". L :"%  "&""&!  :" ("  D&<. ! A 9&". . ."&"  7! 8!& " A9  "" &"   &""&! &88&&6

 D !&"&! !" "&-%  ! " A &  7! 8!& " &.%  : ""&! - . + "! " !&-" ("  "&".  A9& C &" & 9D&  &""&! 8&&,   9 .6

 7! 8!& " D ! A  8&" A& !&" + 9!7&<"&!  "&" =-&!"&!  -!& 9! !  &< > ."" 9 !:! ""

!!&8 ! 9 .<&< < - = # 552  51@>6  C  .<&< < - ! A 9&". .   !8!  : +  A& :" ("  &!7" D&<.  "!" : ! :7  & "   &""&! &"&A "   ( & !" = 50IG :6 GGG>6   :" &  7! 8!& 9  .

&:7  & " ! A "" &:&".  B!.  M  9&!7 -"&!  -!&  &< = # 552  51)>6 "  7! 8!& A&!A  !C&" -!&  !&" +  : ""&!% &  :"  : .-!&   7! 8!& & !" 9  " &:"7 +  .<&<6  8&" :!  7..8&&&  9 "  9 3&-&&".   : &8!  9&&" "&!   : &  7 9 "&-&". : !8&! !"&"

/01*/211)

3 )/4 3

 ."  -&!"&! < -  9!7&<"&! 9! N   "    . !. 9 &&  !: .'&! &" ! !&" -!& A9 '<" &:! ""   :&".  " -& !  <& "  "  + &8  !  !&" D : ""&! = # ! :7&. O666  24 !H" 5002>6 9&<!  : 9 .  8&" A9& 9-&" :  !&" D : ""&! - .  88&" : :! ""  A9& ."&"  7! 8!&6  8" 7& :"M" A  7..8&&&   : ""&! &   !&"  !:7 ! "

9 &""&! && & & 9 .<&< < -6 9 . A& &-!A  7! 8!&  !&" : -!& !&  -&!"&! J < - K   !7&<"&! 9! !  &< 6 9 . A&  !&A : +  &  '<"  -   &""&!% !!7""  .:"&! 9 :: D: ,  -!&  &< % 9" :  7! 8!& = # O6  @ & 5044>6

I6  9:,% 9   !&. . A 9&". . -&" 8&& + ! -!&  &< 6

3& ,< -!& .".  7! 8!&6  8&" &! +  " !:."&  - .  8-  ! .:!D% &&""   8&" A9 9."&"  (  7..8& 9 J " !:."&  K A :&  54 !"!7  21126  9<&"

 .&".  : ""&! !:."&  "! !"   !&" &  .".

! : 9    .&&!  54 !"!7  2112% A !" + &"&<   " !:."&   :! .:!D6

 : .& A9 ."&"    "'  !    !"&8&"&!  .&&!   4 8.- & 211@  " " " B! 6 &  9:('&" :" 9&8!  9   !-D !"" E + ! "! 6  %  9" A &" +   D:   &3&  2 B& 211@ A9  : !&" !:&  .&&!6   :!-&" + " .<  &<!  A9& & :: "&"  ! !& + 9   "!" '<" &" -  "  = "6 55  >6

9&". . !"&" -!& :. A 9  -&" &8! . 9   !&8&"&! ::! ".  !""   "6  : F" &88&&  &-  9&". .   &!"%  9"" : A ! A9  :&  A"&!&  "&. + 9  % & & ."&" .% !""%  B!&   !:&   .&&! $ ! 6

#!  "  !"" A9 9 : 93( &8! . 9    A  !- .&&!  -&" .". 6  7! 8!& :" :" ("  ! ! A 9" ! 9!&&! 8"&8  !"&"" A9 -&!"&! .<,   9!7&<"&! 9! !  &< = # 552  51@ L 551  5I1 L  211@ :6 2G1 L $ $ 5000 :6 @I*>6 " .< %  #  .B+  9!&!  B<   9  . A& 9-&" : !&A. 9<""&!   " $ + 988&  : ! ;<.6   B<. A "  . -&" !& 

/01*/211)

3 G/4 3

.<&< < - A& D&" "!" 7! 8!& = # ! :7&.  *2/1*  21 B& 211)>6

 9:,% 9&". .  :!-&" &<!  A 9<""&!  !""   "  < ; +  : &  !&. "&!  :. &!  !"&"&! ." <,  &8 &" !  !&" D : ""&! !:."&  "! " -&" !F"  ! !7&<"&! 9! "!" !&8&"&!   &""&! :" &!&%   " ::.   .&&! A& & !" .". !"&8&.6 $ 7! 8!& !&" , !  ("  &.%  A& 88&" :! D   &6

/01*/211)

3 4/4 3

  +'*1  '* ) '+  ) +*



234   5  6   78 .(% +9

  4 

56 .   !  -76

 4

26  B""6

@6 &" A  : !.  " < "&"6

 < 88&,    .&" N

 &3!&  P ! & Q   

 !:& !8!   : ."  (" " !"&8&. D : "& :  < 88 

/01*/211)