Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/925/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/925/2004 AI generated

Contract Breach and Timeliness of Accounting Claim in Fiduciary Relationship

Case Number ATAS/925/2004
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted
Court Costs Borne by public authority

Legislator summary

AI generated

A party sued an organization for breach of contract and asserted a claim for an accounting based on a written agreement granting the party an exclusive right to exploit a resource in exchange for fixed payments and a share of the net profits, with the defense asserting that the claim for accounting was time-barred under the applicable statute of limitations because the party was aware of the relevant transactions, which was refuted because the claim for an accounting arises from a fiduciary relationship, which tolls the statute of limitations until the fiduciary duty is repudiated or there is an open disavowal of the relationship, and since the organization did not provide a clear renunciation of its fiduciary obligations, the court held that the cause of action for accounting accrued at the time of the final accounting, not when the initial breach or transaction occurred, thereby affirming the lower court's finding that the claim was timely filed.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Breach and Timeliness of Accounting Claim in Fiduciary Relationship: A party sued an organization for breach of contract and asserted a claim for an accounting based on a written agreement granting the party an exclusive right to exploit a resource in exchange for fixed payments and a share of the net profits, with the defense asserting that the claim for accounting was time-barred under the applicable statute of limitations because the party was aware of the relevant transactions, which was refuted because the claim for an accounting arises from a fiduciary relationship, which tolls the statute of limitations until the fiduciary duty is repudiated or there is an open disavowal of the relationship, and since the organization did not provide a clear renunciation of its fiduciary obligations, the court held that the cause of action for accounting accrued at the time of the final accounting, not when the initial breach or transaction occurred, thereby affirming the lower court's finding that the claim was timely filed.

Keywords

AI generated
fiduciary contract breach of duty statute of limitations claim to profit cause of action contractual damages

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the distribution of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               #$%$#&''( #%&)#&''(



 *+ +  * +

,-  .  ! /) 01  &''( 



0! 2222222222 ! ""#$%&'!(  ! ()#'#!(##



! 

33 +  +4*5+ ( #!#' *+,-./



                !"

   410564  

 3

57 "#  8888888888  !#!  !9# '  :# 5+;1 !  #/'  <#  ='/ #  5+6>7   ? '   =# ( @ -  A8888888888 (  #? ( 5  :/#  5++5  B5 :#! 5++>7   99'  5++; >BCB33 = 7 ;2 5B.#  #D=7)!##  &* (+!E 5++,F7< !* # #!99'5++,>;C262= 7E !7

17  (! ( 11 G! 5++, & '  (''  (( (  !!# ( & 4#/#(#!' #((#!H#'!9'E# !(&#!#) 9H /#! -   #!!#  =# ! -  ! (  / =#7

B7 & '  (''  (! ( 16 !E  5++6  (?#. (( (  !!# ( & 4#/#(#!'    I ==!# /   (  /#9#!/#!!: - !(/ =#7

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

;7    ! #! '(##  ( > :#! 1222    8888888888  '  (#9!# #/!L E9# !  /#9# '#(#/!M *(  94 #!#= ; (#!H# B43  !H  34; ! ;4<5 ! E ( &H  ( !* (' #= ! ! E (   !# (  7 &'!! ( !' '!#! :9'

  0,+,01223  4B0564   !!## 7 ! #!! !#!( < !!9#)##) (!#4 ('  7&##!''!#!!: !!(#5 !E 5++6  ( '#('! #'7'(# '#')&#'!#!##!)! !# !)!#!'!#!!#/'   # ! =#7 & '/#!!# #!##(!1H  : ! !  #!# (E! (! > H    :   ! M &!  ( #!##0(E!&! (#!##0(E!0 H    -#( /# B$##)/! ''!#!#=(E (( '!#!#EM&!##!#((?E !((?#'!#!.!!# /#!/  ! (' (H 9(;$97  /H#/#! !#   I #!# (   (! 9! #  #!# - 9?   #M&###(E!=#!(E# ! /#H!    'H ## )  ('!    # '9#    ! '!#!  H#E'7=#!'9!'/#! /# ! !(#. 7  =#'(!#  !(H 9'!#!(!'7

>7   (?#.  ! #! '(##  ( 5+ :# 1225    8888888888  #(#)')&'!!(!'(!#!'!#!!!##  !##H9'7  (#9!# '!#!  #/!L E9#  /#9# ! ! E (   !# (  7 &'!! ( !'  &'!#!  (#=#' ( =@ !E  #&'!#!!#!#&*/#!E (!  #! ! &? ##)7  ! #!!     !#! &(##! !# (&!#('  (& <!(* ?!7! E*H#) '!'  #!'#!' #H 9*H#! #))# !#!(&#!' I!HN !#!)#'!#! # !#/'   #(! /#7

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

67   ! ( 55 ='/ #  122B    T8888888888 '(# # ( & 4#/#(#!'!')&#&*/#!(! E*H#! #)!E (H (*( ( ?)#IH#!& '(! /# 7 /#! 

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

527    #  ( 16 # 122B & '  = ' #!# !  !! ('## '9! )  &? !# ( "  #  /#! ?    !#/#!' (!' -  ##!!# =!# )&- ;2 P7   '9! !!'  / /! !  . #/#(#!' !   &      # ( /7< /#/#(#!' #!'/'->,C,22= 7!  //#/#(#!'-15C1;2= 7)#  '!#!!?(&#/#(#!'( >++ P / ! ( #! -  ! !#.  (&#/#(#!'7   !  :#! -  #!# # ( 8888888888(5+#122B) #! /!#H#  9#  H ## /#!'!'('#('7&'!!(' #=

  0,+,01223  4>0564   (!#!&'!#!'9!': '! (!!#(5>#122B# /#! #=!' ( #(' ##(# 7   (#!#   #  H 9 *H#! #)&##!!& '/#! !#' !#=7 !##! )#!'(! /#(!#!&'/#!?#-;2P7

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

517    ! '(# ( 53 /E  122B    "8888888888 *H#!  ! #!!(#9!#)'! E!= (#5++>7&##!'&'/#! -1;P(#53/E 122B!&'!!(!'&'# #!7&##!'( ! /#'!#!(-( ##4'#):! )&- ==!#H*#)!7

5B7    #  ( 13 ='/ #  1223 - &     8888888888  (#9!#)'( /#4E H#9#( #!MQ<%R( #!L!(##!( ! 4'#?  (#9!# (   8888888888  !H'(#!M  H # E## / #/#  H#  9# (#9!#/ ? %K#!? #/ #!#  9/# (5;#122B-!E 122B' !#+!E 122BM!H9# H' W(#  '#!!  EE!  #! /!# H#  9#7  !#! )#  '!#!  '!! (' #= '(! E#  =(  D!#('  F &'!#! ('!E##' '!!(#('( '!#!##(# /9!!# (&9#)(( /#!!#/'"12#122B7'!#!

  0,+,01223  4,0564   !!  ! #!! HN    "8888888888 *H#!  !  !#('  7

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

5,7  '/#(56#1223& ! :!(  &! '=' ' -('###!#9###)&?#.((# 7

 *

5"   # 9/#   & 9#!# :(###  DF  '!' (#=#' !  #!#!' (.5 G!122B #E!( #'(; :9(! '#(!!/#4 '#(!;'!!5>:9  D !75!7 !;> F7

<#!-&!#(&'!#(5>:9   #E='('  1, :/#  1223 D O 5B2  52>F   ( # 9/#  (!'  5B ='/ #   (##!# ! #!#   9!  !!!  #E ! (   # ( #'9     - ! # :9 !#!#   ( &!!!(&'!#(/?:9 7

<!!!   (( #!E# #E='(' ( I!(5  :#!1223=# ')(##!#! #!# !#!#!!# !#!'!#!= (  X!( #!='(' D O5B211>F7

17 = '!-C !7;>75!7H71(#9/# & 9#!# :(### DF #E!( #X!#! #)(!!!# '/-& !7;>(#='('   !#9'' 

  0,+,01223  4+0564   (( #!( #(>!E 1222D F)#! !#/- #='('  & 4#/#(#!'(5+:#5+;+D F7

B7  #E('!!! )  #! :!'(= ! ('#'9?! /E-= = '!-& !7>2 7

37  !! '/#9 5 :/# 122B!! X'(#=#!#( E (##!#((#(& 4#/#(#!'7'9#!#  /#9  :)& B5 ('E  1221 (  !!=# ('! #!  &.7  ==! (& .  : # (  '9#!# #E   ( H9!( .9(( #! !)#'!#!/#9  ( '#!# ( &'!! ( =#! )# (#! I!   '#' : #(#)!  )#  ( ') : #(#)D O51;3>,#(75M51>5>>#(73EF=#! ) &! #!' (   ! I!  ' -     (  (  (&  '(  (   ( ( #! (##! !#= '!!   #  ? )#  !  (#! :)& ! (  ('## (##! !#/ #!#9# D O 515  B>>#(75EF7 &!#E)&?(##!# !  '(   *!'!'#! :!'(/! #E('5+/ # 12237(##!#(  !(#!'( ! /#9  B5('E 12217

;7 ? !  ( C !7 3   C#/#(#!' !  (##!# (  #!' ( 9#  ''  !  ( 9 ( ' )# '! (C !!#! -  !' H*#)! /!(C#=# #!'9'#!(C(#(C #(!7

*#( '# ): # (!#(&#/#(#!'( ( #!( #!!#'#)!'(#M!  ') '#) E:!#/ ( &##!' =!# )&# # !(&'/ D O5521,;#(73M52;12,#(71F7 )& #(&#!#/#!'(& '(''#)=!('=!#*# (=(  ('(& ( '(#( V !!! (&'/   #!' ( ! /# ( &#!' ' ( ( !#/#!' #E! ?#9#ED O55;5BB#(71M52;5;6#(75F7

 /#  (9 '(&#/#(#!'&(##! !#D:9&#*   FE#((!)'(#'/!!#(&!  '##! (#/! # = # 7  !SH ( '(# #! -  !   :9!   &'!! ( !' ! - #(#)  ( )   !   ) !#/#!' & ' ! #E ( ! /# 7  !   (' '(# !#!!  ''! !#   ('! #  ) ! /?  !   #E!?#9 (& 'D O51;1>5#(73M55;5B3#(7 1M553B53#(7BM52;5;6#(75F7

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

<  : # ( ( ! E !=  ( ? /! (  !# # ! (#  -  ##!' ( ! /# D O 512  55+ #(710M " 5++>1;>715,7#(7;!>F7!! E ! !(!'9 #(==!#*H#) )? !# *H#! #) !   ## '#  )( # C9#! (       C##!'(! /#)C#!!#E(C! X D<122275>2#(7 3EM I!7(51 1223(!#'-E#!#>6B02B#(717171!   I! #!'F7 ! ! ( (#==#!'  !#.  (  / - '!E#  C?#!(( ##!E:!#/(C '==#!   :!#=#   #/#(#!' D!#.    !#F7   (  ( C? ( ( #! ?  !!# ( C  # C'9!# ( (  (#! I!  =# '   ( E /!# '(# ! - ('=! ( )#   '#!#(( #!? !!#!I!  '(#. =  -C'9#!'(! #!!( 'D I!7 '#!'#(717171F7

  !(C? !#!!!! '(C!!#!*H#)*!/  ( (# 4 ! ( ! E !=  ( ? 4 !  (#!# : #(#) '#  #  !#!     E ==#!   ) C#(!! )C##!!#(#!'(! /# /I! !.  #/#(!D I!7 '#!'#(71717BM #H"* 4  H!E9 #== (  E#!=ZH#9$#! ( # (!9 # (  <N#/ #H 9 !#H=[ ( #$/ 9#H#( /#(#!Z!E9#L' <H==H 0O N <H # D'(7F <H N ( E#!=ZH#9$#! <!7  122B 7 >3 7 ! ! +BF7   ==!   : # (  ! E !=  ( ?  #!! C! X!   .9 9''  

  0,+,01223  4550564   ##!!# ( 9 ( ' (  #!' ( ! /# /! (#  -  #/#(#!'(C !7375 D/#  #!"* 4 7#!77 ,>7'77657F7?!#- ##!(#( V  C!#!# ( '(#  ! E !=  ( ?  #=!! /  ! '/' #!' ) (C #! ( / E:!#=  #  /  (  #!' ( ! /#  !  !#)! 4  ' / (  ( #!#  (C?9' !# D< 122B   5 7 1 #(7 BE0EEM /#  # "* 4  7 #!7 7 6B '7 6, 7F 4  #E! I!  ?#9' ( C '  )C  #! I # !E    #'!' D O 521  5>;M <122571137#(71E! '=' M I!7 '#!'#(71717B!  I!#!'M=7# O51,1+6#(73#=#F7

.   )C CE ( '!!     !#)   (#9!# ( ! E !=  ( ?  ==#!    :!#=#   ( #! - (  !!# (C  # # #E - C? ! *H#!  (  (   9(?(C#(#) -C(##! !#D!:9(#!#9F#! ( )     ' (# (   *H#) )# 4  '9 ( '9! ?  #!.  !#'    : # ( 4 #  !!! (  ! ( 7C9#! #(C'!E# (#. E:!#/#! !(!#!!#*H#)C '!?  !#/#!'  H' (! /#9 '( )C# !D=7 I!7(51 1223(!#'- E#!#>6B02B#(7171737! I!#!'F7

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

  0,+,01223  4510564   (##E!((?!# !. ?#9#E(C == ! ( /!'  / (  !   (  ! (  '#!'9 !# (    ( ! /#  ( H)  #!   ' #=! (C  E#!' *H#! #) (C #!' ! (C ( ' # !! #!   (C!  #!.  '!! !##!#!'!!7  D5F ( ==!#    H #)  (C   (#= C'!(!   # ' '##( ED1F(C !(C#!'9 !##( !!  #=!!# (  /# DBF (C '!! *H#)  #!#'  '/!# #E   !H' !#)  )! #!'! C'H !  #E' !#( ( '!#(=#!*H#)D =#! ## !# '(  (#F  =# D3F ( C'H ( ! #!! E!#   !!##  = ? .9(C !!( ( 'HE##!!#('#!( !#/!# ! ( == ! (     '    !   ==! ( ! E!= ( ?D<122275;;#(71M I!7 '#!' #(71717B#=#M"* 4 7#!77,>7'7627F7

! -   E#(#!' *H#! #) 4# &! (#   ( '!! (' #= ) # ?4# /! I!  )#=#'   !!#! *H#) #('(! ( ! E !=  ( ? #   &#  '/.!I!  E(& '#!#((# '(#(#=!!# D '!#/F(&9!(! ED O (51 1223>6B02B (!#'-E#!#! O E#'(6:#122316102B!16B02BF7

>7  &  (  ! #  ! - &   '(# ! #!!    8888888888 !# )  !#!  '!  #!' !! ( ! /#(!#/#!''9. !!#!!!#! /#( #   /#7

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

  0,+,01223  45B0564   E# '(!#(1;P# !(&'5++6(!-) & ''!#! #/'! ( !!#(& 4HK97

 (    !:#!!!!!#( 8888888888 (#122B)#! /!#H#  9#  H ##  /#! '!' ('#(' ! ) &'!! (' #= (  !#! &'!#! ': 'M  ( #  /#!#=!'(#('##(#  (!!#(5>#122B7.  & ''!#!#/# *H#!  "8888888888)#(#9!#)' ! E!= (#5++>=# (!#-! E(' #=7 <  '(# &##!' (  !#! &'/#! - 1;P (#  53 /E  122B ! &'!! ( !' &'# #!7 !! ##!' '!#! ( - ( ##4'#):! )&-==!#H*#) !7

=# /#'(# '9#(& 4#/#(#!'D#4 .<" 'F  ! E ( &H  ( !* (' #=    :#! 1222  #!  (# X!  #(! # & ' /#!  !! #)'  ! #!!7 < '(# ! #!! #4I ##!  #!' ( ! /# .!(!#/#!'(!'7 )# #!&' !#(H # /(3->#'!#!==#!/!(  ( ! /#  !## (!#/#!''9. 7

,7  &9#! #!! ( ('! #     E (  ''! '(#? #  ! E!= ( ?) '!  !/ ((# (& 4#/#(#!'7

.9(? !( " (!  !/  E!( : # (##)*H#! )#?#'  !!#!) ( #  '! !'!!(' #=#!E##'! #!!7

!  *H#!  ! #!!   ! #  (#9!#)  ! E (' #= # #)!  ! E !=  ( ?7  !# ) &'!! ( !' &'#  ! ) &##!' &'./ - 1;P !7 (#! ##!'!(-( ##4'#):! )&- ==!#H*#)!7

 !   #!.  (   E#(#!' *H#! #) # &! (  &   #7  !    ( &? !# !#(####   H!9 )# /#! ?#' & ' /#! !#' ) (& #! ( / H!9#)   !  !! ! ( ' # =!# (  ( #!'(! /#(&? !#'/#!I! '/'-,2P( !#/#!'(!'7.9('(#'!#! #/'-#)& '  '!#!  #!' ( ;2P  !! ! !! ( ! E *H#! #))##'!'!#'#4(/!/# / 

  0,+,01223  4530564   (  E#(#!' #)&# ! #' ? ! E !=  ( ? *H#! ! #!!(!#!#4I7

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

##  / ( #(' !# )#  '.(! =  ! ( !!  )   (#9!#(! E!= ( ?==#! :!#=# ( #! - (  !!# (&  # ! ) & '  #!   !   #!.  '!E#    O    X!  (#! ! E  *!   !.  #/#(!7  /#! ( (   )   !  '!  #!' ( ! /# !! (  !#/#!' (!' !! ! (  ##!!#=!#7

>7  *    ')! (.   # (  '(  -   # ( / /! !  . #/#(#!' =# ( ('! #   !? (&#/#(#!' (  !7  /#! ( !#   (! ('! #!  (! (   #.  ('## #!#9# ( &  #)  ! & '!' / '7 !! ('## (!

  0,+,01223  45;0564   (&/ # 122B ! &! ( &' 122B )#   ' ( '='    &'/!#( /7

?! (& !7161 HN '!#=(9 '(&#/#(#!'(#! I! ('! #' E(& #( /7  /( ! /# ) &#/#(  #! E!#   ? @! &!#/#!' )& ! #E! !!(  ( #  . ?'!# '/! (   ( '(!!# ! ! ! (& #!!# ')##E ' (  H' ( ! /# !  ' /)&# #!E!# &#&'!#!#/#(7 # ( / &==!  .9 9''   H#== ! # ?!! ) #E!!((? /= !!&/&!  (#=='   !!! (    !? (&#/#(#!'7     V  /  /! I!  H#== ' ?!! # (#/! I!  !#' (& .  ''!  (    !##   . )# &   !    /  ?#!#/##E!7 //!#/#(#!'(#/! I!  ('! #'    ! -  I ! !  (#=#!# (  /!#E(&#= ( #!- ! /:)&! V('##! ((#/!I!  #!D O51+111!516 5,3F7

 !  / /! #/#(#!' # *  # (  '='    )!##    &*  ( + !E  5++, '!E#    A8888888888  (  #? < /!#HK9(&*')  !99' 5++;'.!(&!#/#!'>BCB33= 7;27 5++,# #!99' * >;C262= 7*#( '!# # (5++,-&'122B #(##? !'9 #E(! /# !!?! =#!& -&#(##( #?-!#D'122B [ '=75+;6](#/#' '5++,[ '=75656]U52,,052,,?>;C262U,2C2+5 = 7,2F7

!  #  (&#/#( # =!  '='   ? #  ?) /!  '!( 1221H==!!(!#/#!'#! ''!#!#/(  !   #/' - /#  3C;;, = 7   # D=7 ==# ='('  (  !!#!#) )I!# ! ! (# 1221 5#/()#=#!#3F ! ! ( =#! )   ! ! - I (&?   (  !#! !!#  ! /# (  #   (   /#  !! !#/#!'  !!!&! (#!##4(E!/!##!#((?E ! ((?#.!'(#! #!!7 # E ! !( (#' !#! ! (& H #  ( 32 H  #! (& ( ' HE((#  #=' #  -  *  (  !  #  1225 D( #. ('(##EL'1225H # (! /#HE((# (35, H F!!(#!I!  !'-3,;2= 7,2#!-# (;,C226 = 7 2;7  !! (#! I!  ''/'   &' 122B D' 122B \ '=7

  0,+,01223  45>0564   5+;6](#/#'   ' 1221 \ '=7 5+BB] U 5251+ 0 5251+ ? ;,C226 = 7 2; U ;,C,3;= 7B; F7

(!: # (( O !!(&#/#(E!   'H'!   '(#!  =!# ( IH!    #' -    ( &#/#(    ?  !# ##!!# #' ? H(#-&S9-!##!'-!'9 #( #(': !? (&!#7  &*  !!=#  # (&'   ( ('(!# (#!#!   H(=! ! !#(' !###/#!!K!( '( - '/!#9E(==!(=!   /(&#/#(! ! ( &E ( # ! (   !7  : # ( &(! (('(!#9E' # -1;PD O51>,6#(7;F7

&   !!'5+;1#/#!(;5122B7! E''=# (& ! #!# (&'!E#! ( !*  ! (& ?' #  =#)#<#(#5+6>7<##!!#=!#D ( ! /# ##)!   ! ( H 9 #9#=#!#/  ( ! /#  ## #' '(! /##!##=#?F##)S9:!#=#! E!!!?#(12P7 !!(!! '(!#(12P /  .#/#(#!'&'./-3>C5+>= 7B2D62P(;,C,3;= 7B;F7

 #( /('! #!/!! .#/#(#!'(#!##- !# !?(&#/#(#!'(B32+P)#&/ ( #!- !L D,2C2+5,243>C5+>B2F?522 UB32+P7 ,2C2+5,2  *  # ( #9  ) I #  #E ( ' /#! #)'  '(!# ?# ! #'    O  ( 1;P  (9 ' (&#/#(#!'   #! '/'-B615P!?!: #==#! &! #(& !7

! ! =#& !75,75 & '( #! ! (  /  =# #  #/#(#!' ( '#   !!# #!'( 9#! ## !!/ #EI!  /9 ('  '# ' ( #.  !E7 <! #(' '   ! (= !#(!#'-( ')#!E#  # (   #/#(#!'  . H./! (& = !#  =# ##!#   .  ('E! ( &? # (& !#/#!'  !#/  = !#  'E   #!#     '#   #E!   #!' ( 9# D !7 > 7 5 ( .9!   & 4#/#(#!' ( 5, :/#  5+>5F7  =!   ) &#/#(#!' #! (&  !# 9 /#!'M   : # ( !! (#!# ! ('  ) & ' E#! ( &!#/#!'   ?#9#E  !  = !#  =#   ! ( 9# ( E   ! ( ))12PD O513552#(75E! '=' F7

  0,+,01223  45,0564    &    !  ( ( #! - (   ( !  =# 9 '   ( !#/!# )&# E /#      # (&!#/#!' =#7 (!!!(=#!)&S9'(;5  ! !   '   ?#!   #!' ( ! /#  5;  /! (&!!#( &S9( ! #!# X!)( (& (  =# !#(#)'7

/#( (( /* -& =#)&#('! #  ( !#?(!'  !7

  !)#E!#! !#!9#( ( #!-(('7

  0,+,01223  4560564     <" O<        < <<  <<   <L !

6070   8  900 0  4" /,& +

  70 

57 '    /EM

! 70

17 &(! !#!M

B7 ('##(& (1+/ #122B!5, 1223!!)& =!!! ( !M

37 =#   M

;7 /#(# -& =#)&#('! # ( ! (!'  !M

>7 (& -/    !#(#!'(,22= 7

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

  0,+,01223