Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/888/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/888/2006 AI generated

Expert Testimony Admissibility in Product Liability Causation Dispute

Case Number ATAS/888/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed
Court Costs Borne by appellant

Legislator summary

AI generated

The dispute concerns a request for the admission of expert testimony regarding causation and damages in a product liability case, where the trial court initially excluded the expert's findings based on the insufficiency of the underlying scientific literature to support the opinions, leading to a subsequent grant of summary judgment for the defendant. The appellate court determined that the trial court's exclusion of the expert testimony was reversible error because the expert had adequately correlated the product's alleged defect with the resulting harm using sufficient scientific support, citing literature that supported the mechanism of injury, even if not perfectly identical to the facts of the case, thereby satisfying the required standard for admitting scientific testimony on causation.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF, Art. 64 LTF, Art. 93 LTF; Expert Testimony Admissibility in Product Liability Causation Dispute: The appellate court determined that the trial court's exclusion of the expert testimony was reversible error because the expert had adequately correlated the product's alleged defect with the resulting harm using sufficient scientific support, citing literature that supported the mechanism of injury, even if not perfectly identical to the facts of the case, thereby satisfying the required standard for admitting scientific testimony on causation.

Keywords

AI generated
product liability expert opinion proof of causation expert witness compensation exclusion of facts accident causation

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive for ordering the appellant to pay the court fees.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive concerning the allocation of costs (legal aid).

Art. 93 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to declare the appeal inadmissible.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



               "#$%"&''( )""&''(

)

 )+ +)+  +   

,- .

 $$ /0/ &''( 

 !"#$%&%& '  ( "#"

"#  !"#$)* +%&,%  !#-./$.""#0$."" 1.   .



.

22  '   2 2  (   "$?" 3 22  !"2.'456   

  222 3    22  &    !-.78&9!7:;4<= >



           !

  &),  

+ 1)

%* @A#."&4@/&::4!9B#C#D" D"-#B.  -$  "/ " "#  ! $   %97:! .   !$%954!E0$..#$"."&,-.#D%999*

&* 2C??,"@A#.! D"-#B."$.F -."E0-.A.-#.$-.."."0... "-$/G"0$-F*

;* @A#.""/."/"$?.?;#&::4.$.$.#"0??  D"$%,#&::4*

,*  $."/.A." D"$E"#""-"0 -.. " . #$ -".  #A " ,;04;; ?* %8 -B "  22   '   2    (   3 22   H  I!"&7@&::4"'*

8* &4@.&::4! D"$?#$$-FE!! --." 6 0... " -$/G -? " "#" " .?$  ## " &%07%4 ?* 4:   #-. " D -A "  "#"*  $-F   . - "$.#$   ! "  "$ #-.%%-.#D&::4*

4*  %% J. &::4!  "#"  ##E$  D " $  "$"#-."D-A-B"   222 *

5* 2!$.$.6@A*

+ )

%* 0.*&8"?$"$D-A"-$/G-?! /!//../".$"%5"$#D%99;H3I!.$/A %@/&:::!BA-$"""/*E@.. -"K"-..".6-.AH.*%&&.%&; " /' I! @A"""/#-$.."0.*5;*%"?$"$ -$/G -? " &8 @ %97& HI! . 6 B/  D .""-%J.&::;!".!-BE0??  $.$.#H.*%,& I!F$."0??-.AD" $" $-.."$.#$-@A""/*

    )9%,)&::4 ;),  

&* 20.*&&3H/./A"-%@/&:::I! " "/!  -.. " . E ".  #A . -.A$ ?#$#. F.*%&&!%&;!%,%.%,& +.*;68 30--E. -A#..6.?$H*%I*CE@.!-.." .6-.A-"6"??$.-..".!A#.$ " / " D -A F.. $/.#.  ##. " "/! .  -..".!A#.$"/"D-AF..$/.#. ##.""#AH?*.*&,3I*!@. 6  -.. " . . 6 0/ " D -A F..  ##. "   " #A  .$L. "  ##. " "/ H 3 %&7  &;:+ 3%&9,,,I*

K-B!@A"-#B."$.FF'$-F"-.A- #.$ "  -.. " . /.  "#" "  ... " -$/G*  ". -.. .! "K -.!  " #A!  &, -.#D %999! . "K. -.  ; # &::4! ". 6 E  @A#. " "/."/F$.*

;* 2A#.!-..E-".#A- "#" . " ,;04;; ?* %8 -B "   !  .$L. G. "$@6 $.$ $-'* "#"".6F'$-#.."&%07%4 ?*4:*

,* ?#$#. 6  @-"! "-  @ "$.#. -  -.A @E0##.".?."-..".""#!@. "/$D$$?"..-..".6".$L.#-. #.."'* .$L..$.F###$A0.*%& "0"-$/G-?/!//../".$ " %7 / %97, H &I    .F $A#.!  ' . -$ H 3-D$;4):&"%7@.&::;I

8*  $##.   -M!  -$" $.. A.. H.* 5; * &  . 79>*%"-$""#../"%&-.#D%978I*



NNN



    )9%,)&::4 ,),  

  )1  )+ +)+  +   



20/3/-- 4  5// /  6! $(& 7

%* /.  22   '   2 2    (   3 22  6.?$!"#-." ! 2 O 4;%*54*,%,*&8;!  ## " &%07%4 ?* 4:     222 ! 3       22   &B#  ! O   ,759 . #-. O 9,::848'97'%:!  ?/ " "#   !  E  .$L. #-.""$.!"B;#&::4@E0##." .?.*

&* KG"#..E"D*

;* .E-$".A..*

,* ?#  -. "  E0 -/. ?#  .  -$. L. "  "$ " ;: @ "B  .?. - - ##"$ "$  D ?$"$ " ! 2CPQC?E 4! 4::,   !  . F#-*  "$  -. L. -A$*  #$# ". R I "E F.#. E "$  . "$ D.   . - "  "$..E$+DIF--E#.?.#-/"#".. ."$+I-.A."-$..*2#$#  .. -  . $$#. $#$$  .. I DI . I '"!  D?$"$"--.#.BE0 "/"$/D*#$#"#.#G " -/! E . @.!  E  "$ ..E$ . 0/-- " E$.$F-$"$.H.*%;&!%:4.%:7I*  A??B  $".R           (S < G    -?#"-$.L...?$F-.EK6K???$"$ "-A??

    )9%,)&::4