Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/850/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/850/2007 AI generated

Punitive Damages Cap Inapplicable to Public Policy Wrongful Termination Tort Claim

Case Number ATAS/850/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted
Court Costs Borne by public authority

Legislator summary

AI generated

A dispute arose over the application of statutory damage caps following a judgment against a defendant for wrongful termination in violation of a public policy exception to at-will employment, where the jury awarded significant compensatory and punitive damages. The court reasoned that the statutory cap on punitive damages did not apply because the public policy exception rendered the employment contract void as a matter of law, meaning the statutory framework limiting remedies for breach of contract was inapplicable to the tort claim recognized under the public policy exception. Furthermore, the court determined that applying the punitive damage cap would undermine the strong public policy supporting the employee's claim, and thus held that the cap was unconstitutional as applied to this specific tort recovery, allowing the full punitive damage award to stand.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Punitive Damages Cap Inapplicable to Public Policy Wrongful Termination Tort Claim: The court reasoned that the statutory cap on punitive damages did not apply because the public policy exception rendered the employment contract void as a matter of law, meaning the statutory framework limiting remedies for breach of contract was inapplicable to the tort claim recognized under the public policy exception. Furthermore, the court determined that applying the punitive damage cap would undermine the strong public policy supporting the employee's claim, and thus held that the cap was unconstitutional as applied to this specific tort recovery, allowing the full punitive damage award to stand.

Keywords

AI generated
public employment law tort damages termination of a contract full employment public will matter in dispute

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited for the allocation of judicial costs in the final order.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           $%&$'&&( )$*(&$'&&+

)

 )  )    

!,  '

# -. /0 '&&+ 



 !"#$$% &!'( ( )"(  !*"(  +(  ,-("'.

(

-  --  ---* --   - (!" *  -/.!(((#011$  !'( )"(  !*"(  +(  '



                !  "#   #

   5$265  

 1 )

#7 85'9(:"#34;(5(<( ='(>(" *" &"(?@>*!'"&!( >(" "7A((("( ('B( 'B '9   -  --   --- * --   -*  -85'9- :7

$7 #$)!C#333(*(C"@* = (    ()7  -   '  .&  B  ((!( ( )" * !(" D97

E7  " %D$11;- B"((( *) ("( !(B>'( &BB()(B"@#1F7-(@*''(  (  -   B!" (( " ' "  ''(  $E '(!C $11;7  (( >  !'  & 8;E*01% B7 ' (    #333 "(" ' $11E !'" @  ;$*111 B7 ""$11E: (@) (" E%F7

;7  #$D)$114(''*G(C" @! (  >* ( (  >    !"(  (< !'(C7  BB(B#333"(( E0*111B7("(" #6*43#B7$11E ($%*E$$B7$11;7HBB(  "  !("D9)" '- 7 '( &( ' 41F$11E($%0F' $11;7  ( '"C!( @ * (   !'(C ''!( @ *(   " (& ( @  >  ( @  ( '( *) ("( 9#D$11;)(  "'7

47 "' #;!$114- (D( 79) >("&"()("('(!! )( $11#'!' BB("=(( !"( (<7(( )()("*H' !((!" 57-*&(  .BB- *(B " "( * (>(<  !'(C("'9 B 7*H ' *"(('"">  !(" D9 *)( "(" '  !'( >    'I ' $11$7 >   BB(B ( BB @ "(C  B( '   (((>> (@ ;*6;#B7'!7

07  C "  '" "@* (  '( ( E!$1147A ((   (  ""  > ( J K ! && *'  >!' (<('(8777:'='BB( & ()=  (< ! D '=  BB(  '(( ()= ! ' &(!'7A>( )>*' (<D"' >*( !)*''( >(9!"(>*@B ''(&



2312$114  5E265   D )  '   ) >  ' ' !'  !G! (L.7 )(#333D*)(( ''(78777:.(BB()!(* (  !'(C  @ ! )  !(( B&(   -      !'( !'(   !(" D9 > ( "(" )"7  ! ! M>' "(!!( " !7*='> >  (  .BB > !*( (( @ (( (7 * N && >>* (( *C  ! '9 '  ( ' @ ' (!'7   !("D9!'('!((&!(( B( D* N  (( ' @  B  !  !(" D97 (!(D)(''(5 ='(((<7'= '!*' '(*(!"(((@B( BB"(O7

A* * *)( >G("(" "7

%7     (  >("  ("! @ *   $# D $114 7  '"((  P -  B   &&  (   >" >   !(" D9 )" '  -  "(( !'(C"   ' (  *('7 >  ( '     '   B(  'C ( B ( .& 'H"7   ' (  "!'(    (  #333 @ $11;7   '"" >  "("()>!('!@!(  "'<( C7-*&( *(' @ >  H   C' ('   !." (  D( (  "B)C7.BB *BBC"$11;7"(((!) '(!C *"7 (H' *('C !5 *) >*  '( ((B 'H @ .(     ( >* B( )('' =''(7  ""' *='> BB" ( .BB  !'((7B!"> !(" D9 B( '(   B&(   !'(  ) 7   B!"*()(" )  )((B(>* H)( )((  .(  )( *   !'( ! (( ()(" *( ' (C7

67  E1 D $114  ("!  ' (  "(( B '  " #333 @ $11; > *"(( &&" @ ' 7  '9 ( "(" (!  ' = '(7

37  G(  (  #E '(!C $114    "(" '  D>*@ (  '"  *5) ("7

#17    $; ! $110 *//     * -- 5     85'9  :  B!"  C  " >* ='( !" (G( &("7

##7  " $)$11%!!>"' C* B" (( ( *) ("  (   C    *='(



2312$114  5;265   !"  BB(" '  (  '"(  .& (.'" > #1!$1107

#$7     #1 ) $11%  C   "  '  *( >' ('*  *='(!("7

#E7 (( ='(  "(" !!>" = '(  #0 ) $11%7 '9 ) '" "@*!9'B!( "('(('" " ((>>*@*=!  &'.B&( *='(  '" !! &( ) "'   '("  ()  (( '9($ ! ()!C#333.M'(( ( )  "  CD()7 *='(   > *()(" =" D>*"((K((@B(=&C!((")(!('(9& BB()! (7 !('(")(!(G((9 9(!( !"   .& )!( !'((  *((  $   ! (O!)*C "CD()&B()*='('' >* B  ( !'(    '(( (  ' *( '  (!(!7 -*H D( *C  (( '  ! *(C $111 >B('@*='(>((((C"(D(BG(  () !G!  *()("  7 .">!(  (( * ' > *!"7

#;7 "(")>"!'( ! ('*  4D $11%7A(('(('" "@".& )7 C  " "4D($11%(' "(!!( (( 7

#47 ' $#D$11%( >"!(7-> "("& "@D&7

  )

#7 B!"!( @ *(7 40 7 # (7  .7 4    &)  *&( D  8:  C (    +(  ( >  ((( '") @ Q( 40    B" "   '( &""  (     0 (C $111 8 : > ( ()@B" "Q5 ( $1!#36#8 :7

-!'"('D&  Q'9("(C7

$7 B" "'(&""  (  0(C $1118 :((")&#D)$11E(+(! B( !C '("&  ! 7- '!("'( )> (*''> (G((."@!9 ''>9&''C()&!!(R



2312$114  54265   B(D >!( "(!((' (8 /#E1$E1 7#7#S EE4 7#7$S /#$3; 7#7$S /#$%;0% 7##$0#E0  7;C("B":79& '" >(@*''>( ") 9D (")&8 /##%3E 70C##$E01  7;S  #336TE%'7E#0 7EC:7 Q''>   Q'97

E7 (D(" B!( "'")'()C8(740 @01 :7

;7 >((&*'9(  "(!(@ (( *) ("7  BB(  (" ( * ( (  (  * =   ! ("'B *C&( '( *5 ( (!'('(("7

47 -*(7#67# Q"() 8(76 :@#1F! ' ( Q  (   ( @  ( Q) ("7 Q(7 6 7 #   '" >Q( "'(" ) (" Q'("  & ((  '( > ( '"!" '!(   & "7 ( "'(" '("  & (( !( Q!C Q'( 'C(" & Q" !." ()">C"  ! Q()("(( !("( Q(((@("'.H>!('H.>(>Q'('9 ((!((! " '((=&C8(7% :7

")(= Q) (")>Q"('C(QQ"(( ') (!'")>Q'(C(=I(Q()("> '( C!( G( =&"   '9  ((!( (  !  " '((!." ()">C"8(7#0 :7

 ( @  ( '   9 >Q QH  '  Q((    (( ((!(!" C!"( Q"(( Q"( >  ")( !  " '((  Q5) (" ( "(" !"@(!7 (((!(!" (= !("D9 9  (@(8(7#37# :7

07  ( *) (" (  ''  (>  !(9 *5 ( *!(( *5) ("7 *B!(" ( *) (")( *")(>'!G!(((@(" 5  (  !( ( 5) (" *C(( @  ''"( )&( >(  (= *) ("7  * ' ( ' ' ">   C"  *C&(  '"   .>  (  !9 "' (@*")( *) ("7!9  '(  ((  '  !'!( (  ' !' =!  (= *) (" B=" ' *(    BB( C&(  "(    D(B('7



2312$114  50265   * ( <(" *")(  *) (" ' *     '( G( BB("B(((!(C((  " '*(7 ((  !  ")( ("" '  " ("  B  '( ' (!'!(&"7 ((G( ""!!  * ''"( BC ( ' )  "> '  !'( ("!( '  "' =9!8 /#$0 $66  7$ S /##3;%; 7;S)  $111U;10'7 ;1$7 7E$11#U;#1'7%E7 7E:7

%7 >')D& B  "B '( (      B( > B( *G( "(C  !9 "B(C''(!!')!CC*(5@5 >'"((  &" )!C'"' "(8 /#$0E01 74C#$4#34  7$("B"SB7 /#E1E$; 7E7$(E7E:7

>(  '"  !(()='(B" @  !"   "' ( ( "(C '  '"(    C *C)( ''B  ( *)(&( !'9(  >* '   (>*='(C((@ "(()(D& ("(&(!'>* ('!(  ( C5B "8 /#$4E4E 7EC2CC:7

67  *'9  C *( ((."   '! (!' @ )"B   ""!(' "('- '!' &"(( D(B"  >  ( (((  !(B >   !(" D9 )( "(" ' @ ((  !'(7 ' ( *(( '  C  '! *"(C >  (( "!>  ( "((  ((  '( B" '  B( =(" @ * (7 *(  >  "(" ( ' &" ((B9'.  "'<( C7 (  BB()!( ")''"  ()("  )   )( ()(" ' >   BB * !(( B(7 ( (( ()(" ( ' (C ! '    D( "!>  *( B()* (7(' *' (< C>* )G( "7

    '"   ( '' ( *((   (  *(( BB(" ' *  (  '( *")( !"   (7 *='( (.'" >  "(" ' ( @  '"( '" 7   B "  B  (( '((  * ) ("  ( ) ((" '  " > *( '   B '>  (  "&!( ((" (( "'5 )( C "7* !'!>(( ='( (G(' "() )'C(>*)G(7  *='((B(!'J*=! ! ( (@ ((*C (!"B()C *"'.!(''C(!C("



2312$114  5%265   !C  ' &G" *=(  &( ( !'9( !! *!( ) (''5'!!7*=!( !B>* ! ( !")( ** =( *  5!B!CH!"(>C!(("&!( (("7 *(    '("  () (9 H !'  *()(" >(('*='(7 '''5(5'C(9 ")(!((9"&9 !(  !(79)((B> ((*'>*!">((((C"(>* '(( ((!' *(7

(( ='( B! >  BB(" > +(  (  *='(( &&(' @* (7*")('( & "( 9' *(((@("'.H> (> (@ ( *) ("  ( > >*  ( ' )( 8(7 %   ( #6   !(":7  *( 9  ' " *=! ' )(  !' &7

37 D("7









2312$114  56265  

  ) 1  )  )    

#

  2/,

#7 ")C7

# 2/

$7 D((7

E7 >'" (&((7

;7 B!  '(   >Q ')( B!  (  '"( G(   "  E1 D 9  (B( '9  C B" " 8-.VM.B>0011;  :') !(9  ( 'CB!"!(=(76$ B" " CB" " #% D $114 8 /:S  !"!   (  >   !(B ( !H ')('(&( ( ! (S ( G(  "  C B" " ' ) '(  ' ) "(> =  (  *(7 ;$  /7  '"( G( (  '9  '  ()>"!!!H ') )(G(D(@*)7  &BB9  '" (         PW , C-

'B! '"(G(((B"='(>Q@QBBB" " ("'C>'&BB



2312$114