Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/85/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/85/2005 AI generated

Fraudulent Misrepresentation Summary Judgment Reversal

Case Number ATAS/85/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The lower court erred in granting summary judgment against the plaintiff who alleged fraudulent misrepresentation regarding the nature of a financial investment, as there were genuine issues of material fact concerning the defendant's knowledge of the falsity of representations, the intent to induce reliance, and the reasonableness of the plaintiff's reliance, which precluded a finding as a matter of law that the elements of fraud were not met. The court found that the evidence presented raised triable issues regarding whether the defendant made false statements with the requisite scienter and whether the plaintiff reasonably relied on those statements to their detriment, thus requiring a trial on the merits.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Fraudulent Misrepresentation Summary Judgment Reversal: The court found that the evidence presented raised triable issues regarding whether the defendant made false statements with the requisite scienter and whether the plaintiff reasonably relied on those statements to their detriment, thus requiring a trial on the merits.

Keywords

AI generated
investment fraud interpretation of a judgment fraudulent concealment of defects false accusation misleading the judicial authorities legal malpractice

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited for the allocation of court costs for the federal court proceedings.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               %&'%('') %*)%('')

!!

+ !,+   +!  

# - ./ ('')

-0  12 3 



# 4444444444 

 !



54444444444 "#

       

        ! "#$

   )'$*)  

 #  . 6# +  ,  -' ./, '&&( 0 , 1111111111 2! " ,3"!4

5  +"! .  ,,! / ! ,! #,  /  ,#   2"/!,!" 2 ,#!,  6 2!, -(-    +" 7, + ,! / , "!"  , + 811111111119  ##!  7 :1111111111  ! #,! +!,,+, ";;"3""#,!<=< ,,   # >+  -&*?  '&&<@9 +, 7! " "!,/", !, !2"!" /"9A

    7   , 2,+    ,   ,  +,   3,;!, 2,B!/"6"C

2 + 2;,!  2!, -(-    +" ,/ 7" +   ! ,  /,!  ++ 7 !! ,+ ,!,  +,!  2+, !   2 , 7,  , 2,D,!  !,! ,,!    + +##,!, #, +,,!, #,!/, 2 !,!  # !"     ! 2 ,, "!," 6  ! +".,,3 6  ,!"E! +",,  6 B 2 !, >!!,! !, B ,!"E!+",,2!,@C

   ,   +"!  ,3 !     ,  ! """ 6 2!9 (F    ,  ''  /3 -G*-  2 ;,!,  .,,, >@C

2,2;,!4 ,"-4 @   !!!,  +"/ 6 H!, (F    , #""   +!, ;""   ,! ,F ! 3'&&&7, !!,/64 -I ,#""H)/,,!/,/!'&"3-G*F 'I ,#""H),/,,!"-G.,-G(G <I  , #""   +!!,   +"!, 6 H)/,, /,/!!,/,,!"-G-GF( *I ,#""H),-=-GG* (I ,#""H),!'&-G=- FI ,#""H),,!,-G.,-GG' %I  , #""   ";,   !,  +  +!  ;,  #/  + /!H"/,,/, + !!, ,/, '(+!3-G(' =I  , #""  H)DJ; 3,;! , ! H,,!"   H, /3,,!"'(.,-G=' GI ,#"" !, #,,H;,!'&.,-G('9



$%&$'&&(  )<$*)   3@  !!!, !,/6+"/ K+ #,  ++ !,!,!!,  +"/ K+ K!K! ,!K +,,/ ,,7HB +"!!, + 3,,!">!,<<-6<<-  3,;!, C!, ('(F,"-!!,%< ,#""+"/ K+ #,  /,,/,/!!,/,,!"'(.,-G='C!,-*' ,/,@C @   !!!,  !,/ B   +"!, 6 H),  , +"/ +   , #""  H),  -=  -GG* ! 6 H),! 3,;! ,+"/+ ,#""H),! '&-G=-9 ,"'4 @   !!!,  +"/ 6 H!, *<    , !    +!!,  !   +"!, 6 H)/,, ! /,/! ! 6 H)

,/,,!"'( ! 3-GF=C 3@  !!!, +"/6H!,*G,"< ,! !,L DJ;  --  /3 -G=<  !,L  +!!,  !   +"!,C @   !!!,  +"/ 6 H!, ==  ," -    , !   H ,!!,   # !,  + #,  !  !/,  . ;  '- ., -G=(C @   !!!,  +"/ 6 H!, <=    , !    +!!,  !  "BDJ#, ,!-= /3-GG*C @   !!!,  +"/ 6 H!, <=     , !     !,  #,,--GGFC #@   !!!,  +"/ 6 H!, -G     , !   H !,!"-*"3'&&&9

# ! !!7 ,3! 2!+ +"!! + !,!+,!+""+ "+2"C

2,KL ,"2",/3+ ,!C





$%&$'&&(  )*$*)  

!  7  !,+   +!  

#

81.   9  :   ;$ <=( >?

-9 .!! C

'9 ",/3+ +C

<9 #   +!,   7H +/! #     !  +"! E!   ",  <& .  L   !,#,!,  + +,  " "  ,3 #""   MDN,OD #7, F F&&*     ! , B+,9  ",  +! E! +  ;"9  " ,  ,! 4 @ ,,7 B!!7",,  !", 3!,,!+",,  !!7"C 3@ B+  +  7  !,# , !, + / ,  !! ! ",, C @ + !  ,;!      +"!!9 M,  " ,   !,! +  ! , ""! """   !! @ 3@ ! @ ,)  ,3#""+ +!!,L 7H, /",/39" , !,   K  +/ 7,  ! . ,! ,, 7  ",,  !!7" ! H/ ++  7"!"B+"," !>!9-<'-&F!-&=@9



  ;##,L4  ",!4     ,PP Q,M Q  



 +, # +"!E!! !,#,"B+!,,,7262##,#""  ,+;##



$%&$'&&(