Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/830/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/830/2005 AI generated

Issue Preclusion and Legal Capacity of Entity

Case Number ATAS/830/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted
Court Costs Borne by public authority

Legislator summary

AI generated

The dispute concerned whether prior rulings related to the legal capacity of an entity to engage in certain transactions were binding on a subsequent proceeding involving the same entity, given the entity's argument that it had been mischaracterized in the earlier cases. The court reasoned that the prior adjudications, which specifically addressed the entity's status and ability to contract, were dispositive of the issue in the present case under the doctrine of issue preclusion, as the essential legal question had already been litigated and necessarily determined by a court of competent jurisdiction, even if the factual presentation in the current matter differed slightly.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Issue Preclusion and Legal Capacity of Entity: The court reasoned that the prior adjudications, which specifically addressed the entity's status and ability to contract, were dispositive of the issue in the present case under the doctrine of issue preclusion, as the essential legal question had already been litigated and necessarily determined by a court of competent jurisdiction, even if the factual presentation in the current matter differed slightly.

Keywords

AI generated
capacity to contract matter in dispute legal entity legal doctrine applicability of pre-emption rights determination of jurisdiction

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section regarding the allocation of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

     

   

!"#$!%##& '!($#!%##&

'

) '*) '+  )  + *

, - .

 %/ 0 - %##&

  

  ! "#$# " %$     $ &#$' '(  #$ ')

$

       *  +   ! +, ' $)# *-)'! $ ' .$/ 01!  "$ 0122! 3133 4, 0

             

- 1537 -

 1*'

39 4  1 , 1773!   ": ' ')$# ;4 ' &-<=)> ' 81? @9 37 "#$$  )$$ ) $ ' 0*262 @9 22 A" 11 ;B9 + '$  <=)>  " @  3 , 17789 "$ ' $$ '$ $ ;(& 83 $C 1778!   C##@# '& ")$ "4 ' D + E $$ ' ) ' $ '&)"9  $$ $,$#!   ) $ &#,$ E 2*F32 @9 729

19  87 , 177F!  +, ' &-)' ' $ ' 4, A-"4 + B  '# E &# $ E  @))  C' "$ ' 07 @9 " ) " &# 177F   )$$ '  ") ) ' &-)' C>$9

89   :  1F ,)C 177F! &#  ')'#  +   C' " &# 1772  ,($ &;$$)$ '  #" E &- <=)> '"  1 $C 17789

F9  16 ,)C 177F!  +    #"' (  C' 1772 #$$ $G# '&"4 &, ' $/$ @ 1778 $ (   , '#$)$ $$ '  C4) @/# "   '& $$!  ,$ $)$()$  $$$$ ' C' '  "$ ' &')$$ @9  $!   "## (&  H  $$  $ $C)$ "#;# " ""$ E  '#$ '&)"=$ 1778!  "$ "#$  ')' "# ' C' '4  ) ' ) 17729

29  -)' +I  @/# " &# 1772  ") ) ' &-)' C>$ E 13? @9 J7 " &# $ E 10F @9 67 "  #"9

09  32 ;, 1772! &#  @)#  ')' ' C' $#>  ;>$  , ' $/$ @ 1778 $  "## (& #$$  , '"  83 $C 1778! G$ #"#  '$  <=)>9

J9  C' @ 1778 ' &#! )  1F ;, 1772! $$  , )"C   " $ $ )) ' 7 @9  (& @$ )"C ' 1J7*162 @9 $ E &, ' $/$ $@ /'$ )"=$!  @$ #$$ '& , C$ ' JF*308 @9  ( '& @$ ))C4 ' 27*??7 @9 $ '& @$ )C4 ' 233*12F @9! $ '& @$ C$ $$ ' 201*38F @9

?9   ' 1F ;, 1772!  +   ;$#  ')' ' &# ' C' $#> " &# 1772  )$@ (   " C##@ ' "$$ )"#)$ E & +5  $  "  C##@ ' &'

567851772

- 8537 -

 $ '$ E  C' #> E &$#>$# '  ") ) ' & )' C>$9

69  1? ;, 1772!  +   ')'# E &# '  '  C' '&)"=$ $ &, ' $/$ 1778 '#@$@ $ )"$! @ ' '#$)  '$  C' 17729  1 @#, 1772! &#  @)#  +  (  ' #$$ '#;E  " ' ')$ ')'#! ) (&   ,G$9

379  '# ' F ) 1772!  +   ;$#  ')' ' C' " 1772  )$@ ( $$  @$ C$ ' &# (  , '#$)$ #$$ "# E  )$ "# "  #>$ $9

339  16 ) 1772! &#  @)# ""$ E '$ '# $  $ (  ", @ #$C$  ($# '&# ' '$ )'$ $  "#;$ '  $$ #)(9   "## (! " )K) !  '$  )#) '   C $ '   @ (& $<  $>9

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

389 &$)#  '  '#  ""$  2 , 17729   @)#  "$9

3F9    ' 38 , 1772 '#  C ' #!  $  @)# &"" E  '# ' F ) 1772 $  ')'# (& $ $$#    ' F , 17729

329   #" ' 1 ) 1772! &$)# "'   @'  >)$ ,(# "##'))$9  $!  4, (  $ & " @)#  $  '#  ""$ ' 2 , 1772! ) $  '# '

567851772

- F537 -

F ) 17729  $! E  @)! E &,C$# '  $!  @'!  ;$ ' 9

309  13 "$)C 1772!  $  @)#  C ' # (& ,$ #$# )  C##@ ' "$$ ' &$ "C( '"  '#C$ ' ) ' "$)C 1772 L (  ") ' &-)' ',$  K$ $#>)$ "  <> "  + 9

 +*'

39   >,  &>$ ;' AB  #$# )'@# $  $$#!

'4  3 M$ 1778!  C $ '  ! )"# ' 2 ;>! '$  "#'$ $  ,-"#'$! 2 ""#$ $ 30 ;>  A$9 3 $9  $ 20 B9

+$ E &$ ' &#$ ' 30 ;> ! "  C @#'#  1J ;, 177F A . 387  370B!  '  >,  '"$#!  38 @#,!  '"$ $$ >$ ")$$$  C $ '   ' #>   E $ ;> $$! ! ' &$$$ ' &#$ ' ,/ ;> 9

19 @)#)$ E *$9 20  9 3 $9  <9 F !  C $ '   %$  $ ( ' $$$ $, E   @#'#  &-)' ' 3? ) 366F A B9

 )"#$ ' C ' # " ;> '  '&"4 $  #$C9

89 &$)# $$ (   @)#  F , 1772 $ ,C  $$ (& $ '># $  '# ' F ) 1772 $  " $  '#  ""$ ' 2 , 17729

&$9 80 '   >, '&""$ '   @#'#  &- )' ' 16 ) 366J A B "#,$ (  '#  ""$ ' +  ",$ @ &C;$ '&  "4 ' C $ '   '  '# ' 87 ; E "$ '  $@$9

 &"4!  $ , (  $  $;$#  $  '# ' F ) 1772! " $ ' F , 17729   @$ " ' '$ (   #$$ "#)$# $ "$$ ,C '  ) H!  &$9 80  !

  '#  ""$ ",$ @ &C;$ '&  "4 ' C ' #9

567851772

- 2537 -

$@! '   ' 38 , 1772 '#  C ' #!  $  @)# &"" E  '# ' F ) 1772 $  ')'# (& $ $$#    ' F , 17729   C( N  O '  !   '(# N  $  )$,# APB E &$ '  '# ' F ) 1772 ' , ' & )'9  E  '#  ""$ ' +  $$ ' 2 , 17729 O9 $$ ))$ $ ",  C ' # '  '# #> ' $$ ; '4  $@$ '  '#  ""$ ' 2 , 17729  >' ' '$ "$#  #@# '  !  $  )@$#  $$ '   $  '#  ""$ ' 2 , 17729 4 !  $ @ ", '& @)) /@ ( ' '# (  $ & "  $  '#  ""$ ' 2 , 17729  @) ( "   #$$ #>)$ "$#!  ,$ " #($ ' '#   )) ,C9

F9  "#$ $> "$   ($ ' ,   $  '$! " &# 1772! E ' C' $@ / ") ' *-)' C>$9

29 / $) ' *$9 02  !  $ '$ ' #'$ ' ") / # ' '$ #)( )'$ A9 3BL  #'$ $ @/# ' $ )4 (  C'  '  @#'#$ $ ' $   ' *$9 00   $  "" ,# $#>)$ A9 1B9 *$! "  $ ' 4,! ' C'  $$ '  #'$ ' ") ' *- )' C>$ $ "#, / $9 36 E 8F '   $ >, '*""$ '   @#'#  * )' ' 16 ) 366J A B9  $9 36    $ ' '"$ '*""$ ' $9 02 $ 02   A . ' 8 ) 1772! Q 30257F! '9 891B9

 ;"' '4 (  $ ;$ '* >' C$# ' *)#>)$ '  #'$ ' ")! '  ) H  ",$ '#@ ' )4 $)  (* @$ $' " N '$ #)( )'$O9  @@$!  '$ /( $ )  #'$ ' ")  $ " #># "  '$ @#'#! ' ))$ (  #>$  # E "#  $ '*N# ' '$ #)( )'$O9   C @#'# '  -$- ;># (  4> #'$# "  $  )$4 ' #'$ ' ") ' *-)' $$$ ' '$ $ $) A . 31F  36L   3666  Q 20 "9 3L ,  . 312  3?2 '9 1C! 311  8F8 $ . ' 8 ) 1772! Q 30257F '9 89191B9

09 + *$9 36 9 3  ! * $$ ' 4, ' ' C' '$# E  ,$ $$  "$ ' ") ' *-)' ' # ' '$ #)( )'$9  C' '$# E  ,$ $$ '  ") $ #,# / C##@ ' "$$ ' &@@ $ ' " R># A-"4   B  (&/ C##@ ' "$$

567851772

- 0537 -

'&$  '&'  ' &S" >## A$9 11 9 09  B9  ,<!  &# ' '$ #)( )'$  $< " ' "$$ ' &   ' &S" >##!  & '$ (&E  C' '$# E  ,$ "$ '  ") A$9 13 9 3  B9   !

 )$$ ' C' $ @/#  $ " ">@ A$9 11 9 F  B9 + &$9 33 9 3 ' 4>)$ '&/#$ '   '&""$ '   @#'#  &-)' ' 32 '#)C 36?J A B! "  # '$  , '#$)$ @$ "$ ' >" !  C' ) $ ' ?7 @9! " / ' >" !  $ ' 07 @9! @ " / ' >" !

 $ ' 87 @9

  # ' '$ #)( )'$  $<$ " ' "$$ ' &   ' &S" >##!  #>$ '$> $  # G$  ,   @$ C$ )"$$ ( $ "#)#  " K$ ' '$ #)( )'$ $  # &G$ " ' $ ,  @$ C$ A$9 17 9 3 $9  $ 9 1  B9 +  $9 13 9 3   $ 37  B!  # &G$ " ' ,  @$ C$ )"$$ $ '$ / C' " $$ (  , '#$)$  '#" "  )$ @/# "   '& $$ " & ' $ >" A>" T 38*777 @9 "  # ! 36*777 @9 "  " L >"  T 12*777 @9 "  # ! 8?*777 @9 "  " L >" T 82*777 @9 "  # ! 27*777 @9 "  "B9  )$ $ );# ' 0*777 @9 " <> #> A$9 37 9 1  B9  , '#$)$ $  ,  $ '#$)$  $/ '&)"=$   " $ $ )) A,$  '#'$ " "#, "  #>$ $ @B >)$# '& (U4) '  @$ $$ '#$)$  $/ '&)"=$ A$9 37  B9

&')$$ @ $ $)$ $)$()$  +   $ ' $CC )"$  '$ #$C   C '  '4 $/$ @ A$9 18 9 3  B E <> "  +  '&#$C  $$$$  @, ' C##@ A$9 18 9 F  B9

 " ( "4'$  @$ C$ /#'$ 127*777 @9   ,  C$ /#'$ 327*777 @9 $ "#)#  " K$ ' '$ #)( )'$ A$9 37 9 3 $ 1  B9 $$ "#)"$ #> "$ K$ ,# "  ')' 'M)$ )$,# )"># ' "4 ;$@$, #$C$  ", ' $9 $@! &C$$ '& C' $ #,# /  " '$  , C$ $! "4 '#'$ @@$ ' 17V! >)$# ' (U4) '  @$ C$  '#" "  )$ ' , @/# A$9 37 9 8  B9

J9 (  $$ #)( ' &# &$ 'C)$ >>,# $  ))$ '  $/$ @ $  H $ '#  C'!  "$

567851772

- J537 -

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

?9  &"4!  $  $<  "$$ ' &  !  '  ' &S" >##! ' $ (! $)$ E  (& "#$'!  & " '$ E  C' '$# E  ,$ $$ '  ") ' & )' C>$9

 "!  $/$ @ 1778 @$ #$$ '& @$ C$ ' 201*38F @9! $  )$$ '#"$ >)$  )$ @/# " &$9 37 9 3  9  #(!  $ $ "#)#  " K$  # ' '$ #)( )'$9  ,$  '&/) & )"$  '$  ")$$$ ' , $$ "#)"$9 +  $/$ @ 1778!  , C$ $ ' JF*308 @9 $! "4 '#'$ @@$ ' 17V!  &#$C$ E 26*887 @9 AJF*308 W 3F*?88B9  $!  (U4) '  @$ C$ &#4, E 8J*FJ0 @9  #$ ' &''$ '  '/ )$$  $$ ' 67*?70 @9 A26*887 X 8J*FJ0B ( $ >)$ "#  )$$ )/)) ' >" "  "9  C ' #  "$ ' ( @)  '#  ""$ ' 32 , 1772   '/ ($9

 ,<! ' '$ '#  ""$! &$)# & " /)#   '$ " ')$$  >>,$ '  $$ #)( ' $ '"  $/$ @ ' 1778 $ ##9  &"4!   '#$ @ ' 177F!  , C$ ' $ $ '  #" &#4, E 01*F76 @9 $! "4 '#'$ @@$ ' 17V!  &#$C$ E F6*61J @9 A01*F76-31*F?1B /(  @$ ;$  (U4) '  @$ $$ )"C! $ 1*812 @9 A8F*?J3 T 32B9  #$ '   (  , '#$)$ ' $ $ '

567851772

- ?537 -

21*121 @9 AF6*61J X 1*812B! $ #>4)$ "# E  )$ "  " ' >" 9 $@!  ' '#C$ ")$!  '#"$# $ "## (  $/$ E    "' "  )"$ $ '#'$ $ (& ""$$  +  ' $$  '4 @ ' ##(C  $/$ A#) ' ' !  366J 135 8716B9  #(!  ""%$ (  , '#$)$ ' $ ' 21*121 @9 $ "$C '&K$ @# E  )$ ' >" "4 ##(C> '  $/$!

"$,)$ ""$ ' '#'$ (  $ " "  )"$  '  $/$ E  9 4 !  C ' # ,  ' E &$)# @ (& '#$)  , '#$)$ ' $   "#'  )$4 '&)"$ E   "4 $$$ ' $ '#'$ $ (& '  '#   "$9

69  $ $ #>)$ E  ')$ ' &$)# E  "  <> ' @ ' "$ $@ / ") )"G# ' &-)' C>$9

*C;$ ' $> '  "#' ')$$, C#($ $  ""$ ;'( ( - '  ' ' *C;$ '  $$$ '#$)# "  '#

- $$! '*"4   ' ! *C;$ '  '# @@$,)$ $$(# A . 312  F3F 9 '9 3C $ 1 $  #@# $#B9   "#' ;'$ ')$$,!  ",$ K$ /)# $ ;>#!  ""! (  ""$ ;'( E "" '( *$$# ')$$, )"#$$ *$ "# "#C)$ '* )4 (  !   @) '* '#9  $$ )!  '# '#$) *C;$ '  $$$ ( "$ K$ '#@##  ;$ " , ' 9  ,<! '  ) H  '# * #$# '!  $$$ * " '*C;$! $  ;>)$   @'  "$ " K$ ' A . 312  F3F '9 3! 336 C 80 '9 3C $  #@# $#B9

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

567851772

- 6537 -

'4  "'$ " & '& $ ' '#@$ ' C A$9 37 9 F  B   ')' ' & '4 (  +  $$ &,C$# $ ' &# A$9 37 9 2  B9

 &"4!  ($ '  "  <> ' @ ' "$ $  "#' $ & $  + ! $  $$ $ "#' (  "#$ $> (   $ $  + 9  #(! $$ ($  @$ " "$ ' &C;$ ' $> $  C ' #  "$ " $  )$4  $$  ( $ ,C9

379  13 "$)C 1772!  $  @)#  C ' # (& ,$ #$# )  C##@ ' &'  E "$ ' "$)C 17729

 ,$ E $ #>' ' "" (   ;"' $$!  ;> '   ""#  #>$# ' '# $$(#!  4> >##! '&"4 &#$$ ' @$ /$$  ))$ H  '# $>  #$# ' A . 313  800 '9 3C $  K$ $#B9  @$ , "$#)$! $ ( $ )'@# $$ $$! ',$ ))$ @ &C;$ '& , '# ')$$, A . 313  800 '9 3C $  #@#B9  @$ , "$#)$ ',$ "'$ K$ "  '#$ '  ) H  $ #$$)$ # E *C;$ ' $> $ ' $ E @ *""#$  ))$ H  '# $$(#  #$# ' A . 66  371B9

4 ! &$ ' &'  '4 "$)C 1772 & " '&'   "#$ $> "  "#' ' 3 ;, E @ M$ 1772!  " (  &G  "  '& $ )"$9

567851772

- 37537 -

  +'*1  '*) '+  )  + *



234   5  0   67 .8% +9

  4 

39 #   ,C9

 4

19 &')$ "$)$9

89   '# ' +  ' F ) 1772 $ ' 2 , 1772  $$ (& &$ " /)#  ($ ' &>>,$ '  $$ #)( ' $ '"  $/$ @ ' 17789

F9 ,   E &$)# " )"#)$ '&$$ $ , '#9

29 ') &$)# E ,  $  )) ' 327 @9! E $$ ' "$"$ E  @ $ '#"9

09 @) '$ '# "  "9

J9 $ (  "#' $ >$$9

 >@@4  #'$ T

-  Z  I   

 #$-;$ T <""    [

 " @) ' "#$ K$ $ $@# / "$ "  >@@ 

567851772