Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/782/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/782/2007 AI generated

Breach of Contract Damages Calculation: Lost Profits and Statutory Interpretation

Case Number ATAS/782/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerned the proper calculation of damages in a breach of contract action, specifically regarding the appropriate measure for lost profits and the application of certain statutory provisions governing commercial transactions. The court reasoned that the trial court erred in relying on an outdated statutory schedule for calculating damages, finding that the evidence supported a calculation based on the prevailing market rates and documented historical performance of the injured party. Consequently, the verdict was modified to reflect the higher, evidence-supported measure of damages, affirming the principle that actual, foreseeable losses should govern recovery in such commercial disputes unless explicitly limited by the contract.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Breach of Contract Damages Calculation: Lost Profits and Statutory Interpretation: The court reasoned that the trial court erred in relying on an outdated statutory schedule for calculating damages, finding that the evidence supported a calculation based on the prevailing market rates and documented historical performance of the injured party. Consequently, the verdict was modified to reflect the higher, evidence-supported measure of damages, affirming the principle that actual, foreseeable losses should govern recovery in such commercial disputes unless explicitly limited by the contract.

Keywords

AI generated
calculation of damages contract interpretation loss of profits statutory limits contractor liability contractual penalty clause

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Imposed court costs for the federal court proceedings.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           '()*'*++, !',-*'*++,

!

 ! !"    " 

./ )

 0 1 22 *++, 

   ! "    #

 #   !$  " $

%#

&    $$ '$$ (% !,#  

$$ $ $ $ " $  $ $ " $ %" $  )$  $ #$%*+ 

            !" #$  %   &

  .)*  

 #!

12 # 34%  11 35 # .//0  1-6 78#  # 8  (# 6# %(#! 5#!190.% # !1901# !%11(%8#1990 :%'5 #2

.2 $7 ,,#1/34%(#! %! # 8(# 6# %#!  (#%4 (#  % !  5 #  (#!5; (#,  <  (# 7 !(=#%# 42

>2  34%   5# % 5 !,  % ,  1- ,!5# # .//0 %  !%! %#  ',,  # 8!.1 5%(#=!% (#%42

?2  @ (#!!A' %#% 2$## # %  $ .-#.//0<46#  ( (#$!7# $ (#(#$!7#%"##  (#%%  8#(4 !(##A% 5#%*-'1*>,#2>/2

*2   <  #  #    %#@%#(#   (#!5; (#,  B C  ,#!  # 8  !  * 5#  .//0 5 # %#,!#!(#%% #% !(###%(!# 1# 3 %.//>>13 %.//?A&%  8#(4'$$ 2 @  (# %(#%%  8#(4  (#!5;D# 7  '5#>'9,#21*.+3 %.//>2 (#%% #% A %  # 4 '!% % #4 %#!2  &%  % 5    D# 7 (4  '# #  5   , % 5 #  1+ 5#  .//0  # 8  !<(#%%  8#(4%#,!#!A 5 %!%!! 1# .//1>/5# .//>2(# %!4%(#%%  8# (4  -11 ,#2 0/      #!5;   %#%     652$## #. .//0 &%  8#(4'$ $ (#%%  8#(4#'!65A9'/0?,#20/A%  5#29 .//0  %45 (% %#   # 8!#8%(% $#2#!%  =@  <  #  ! A % #  %8# .///    !%!'  %#%2

-2  ..   .//0  # 8  !  ,#!  =@!(= <  (#%4 # ,,%!#8'5 #5  *-'1*>,#2>/(##% 9'/0?,#20/(##2! 1.3 .//0#!%! (#% (# !%# ##%%2

02 # ## #1/3 .//0# , %(#% # 8!  !##   5 # (#%4#  (#%%    8# (4 5  =@!(= %%%%%'5 #(%%!34% 5#2

    )-*.).//0 >)*  

+2 $#!%!4#!A34#2



 "!

12 '#%2.* ,!!## 8#(4(#!5;(#, 

5  #5 5%% 5  %!10!8#199>B&C%#!5 4# 1#35 #.///#64(#!# 5#2#<3 %% (E##(#%% #% A(#%4#B#%21..%1.>  5 @ C 34  5#(!%%'#%20>21 ,!!## (#!5; (#,   .* 3  19+. BC  % A 65  # 8 %# ( 1#F%.//> %(#6<',, #   !%!%# B#%21?. C=!%#',, (#%4#8 ! #!(#% % !%# !(#34 5#2

.2 $'#%2..&B5%#5 4#( 1#35 #.///C   5#  (#%%   #%  <  #%  # 4 % (#%4! ,#!% =#%21..1.>1?1%1?. G#%2>A* &'(( <% (#4 %%A%#,!##B21C2#7<3 %(#%%  #% A(#%4###(A ,,!#%#(#%% #% 4%!  5 #   8# (4 = %% !5%%  %   5# %  (#%% #% 4%!5 # 8#(4= %%!5%% % # 4B,2#%2.?&C2#3% A  (#%%   #%  % A '5 #   8# (4 = %%  %      # 4  %!#H%   %   5# B & 1.+  .>/G &1.9???C2

>2  E(6  34  (# 6# %  #!  (#%4 (#  % !  (#%%   #%  <  #%  # 4 (#  #2  % (#% %%E(#%# 411(%8#1990E%#(#% 1-,!5# #.//0%A<34% 5#%5=!% #2

### #1/3 .//0#%!#!(#% %  (#%% #% =@!(=! !(# # 8(# 6# % 34% !< %82 %, #5! @ # 8!% ! (# !  34  5#2#!<%# (%( %%#   (#!% (#!#   %!  (#%4 #! (#  34%  # 8  (# 6# %  11 35 # .//0 <  <  ,#734!2

?2 $# 4%#  (#%% < (%# 4(# #%9'/0?,#20/% <!(##%   *-'1*> ,#2 >/  %!#H% ;% !3A !%! ! (#  % %%  

    )-*.).//0 ?)*  

(#!5;!,#2  # %A=@!(%% ?'*>0,#2>*B9'/0?,#20/I.C%@   %%%.+'/0-,#2-*B*-'1*> ,#2>/I.C#%<E%#<  %# .>'*>9,#2>/2

*2 ,#!% A  3# (# (   3# !%# % (#  (#%4 3<'%%#,#%(#%% #% #3 %  5#!8!!,   #%%(#%% # %A %!#H%(% ## %%@ 2  %!#H%%!%=  !4'#%21. '##(#!5;(#, 5  #5 5%% 5  %!  1+ 5#  19+? B .C    %= #!4% #    @  % (!# # B &1.9. 2>C2

-2  !%  # (#J  (#!# !%% 4#% % B#%2 0> 2 .  % +9"21 #(#!#  %#% 51.(%8#19+*C2



KKK



    )-*.).//0 *)*  

  "!#  ! !"    " 

12 5 %     (   (#  $!7# $  (#  (#  $!7#$ %"##  A%#,!##(%! 190..>'*>9,#2>/A&%  8#(4'$$  ,5#2(% 8#(4 L  < %!#H%(% # !#%61-,!5# #.//03<' %%#,#%2

.2 E;%%<8 2

>2  %<(#!#%4#% %2

?2 ,#  (#%    <E (5% ,## ## %#  (#!% ##H%   !   >/ 3# 6  % , %  (#6  # 8 ,!!# B$7M N#7,< --//?  C(#5 ##% 6## % (8 ,#!%=#%2+. ,!!## # 8,!!#10 3  .//* B &CG  ! #  ##  %  <#    % , % ;(#5%(#%# 4%###%% #G  % H%# #!  # 8 ,!!# (# 5  (%  (# 5  !%# < =  %   '#%2 ?.  &2  (#!% ##H% %  ( 6  (   ##% 5<!;(#5 5%H%#3 %A'5 2  4#,, 6#  #! %I          # "  $ ;   

( ,#(#!%##H%%% , !=(#%   <EAE,, ,!!# # (#4#,,

    )-*.).//0