Statutory Interpretation of Minimum Benefit Calculation Dates
Legislator summary
AI generatedThe case involves a dispute over the proper method for calculating certain financial obligations or benefits as dictated by statutory provisions governing minimum amounts, with the core issue being the interpretation of applicable dates and the effect of subsequent amendments. The court reasoned that the statute's clear language, particularly concerning the operative date for establishing the baseline amount, mandated the use of the minimum established at the relevant time, despite later legislative changes that would otherwise result in a lower figure, thereby upholding the higher benefit derived from the earlier statutory language.
Legislator headnote
AI generatedArt. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Interpretation of Minimum Benefit Calculation Dates: The court reasoned that the statute's clear language, particularly concerning the operative date for establishing the baseline amount, mandated the use of the minimum established at the relevant time, despite later legislative changes that would otherwise result in a lower figure, thereby upholding the higher benefit derived from the earlier statutory language.
Keywords
AI generatedCited Legislation
AI generatedRelated Decisions
AI generatedKey legal questions extracted by Legislator
AI generatedCited in the dispositive section regarding the order to pay legal costs.
Full text
!""#!$%%& !'&(!$%%&
))
) * )* *
*+, $ - ., $%%&
!"#$%&$'!!'' #!#$ (&$)$# * $!'
!$#
++ + * # '$'& !$,#'$-./
53065
/
27 8'5"#9 #!#$: $ &"#& ;'$ ! &"!< "';'(&3..-73='3..= &"!<!$!!%$'! '%!# $ 2. >' 3..= ' !$ &"!& #?@$ ! '%!# "#9 #',"#'9#'$7 $32>'3..= #!#$ &"!& "#9 ++ + *A 8'5 "#9':(''$&BCD7
37 #&''!="$,#3..= '#;&%#$(''$& BCD/#!#$ !$';?(#"''$"!'$'!#$'% /"&#'!!$'$'! $"!%'$@$#',&#& !$$"#?( >$';''$"(!''&"#&(%!&"!<7
E7 +'$ / (!""!'$'! #!#$ - !$!,# 3..= ' # &''!#!""!'$'!2.;&%#'#3..4 $&''!7 ;;$ ' !$$'$?(&"!<#!#$%'$!''&"#&!;;''"'32 &,# 3..= $ ? 9 !# !$'; ',&#$'! "!%'$ @$# #! / #!#$ 9 $$ $ @ "# !&?$ ?( #!'$ / (''$& BCD7
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
=7 #&"! K %#' 3..4 ' $ ?( &"#$'! ;'$ "' ;!# !$'; ',&#$'! (#$' 2- !' # (# BCD$(''$&('!%,''$&8'5"#9 :7 !$;!' $($ ? (' H !'' &"#& $ ? ?$'! ;''9# !$ &$& #&D&
011203..4 5E065 '#$7 ($ " ("9 ' !'&#$ ?(' !%'$ !$$($#!5,'#(&"!<"!#&$,'#B#!!!D' ;'$7 !$ <'$ "# '# # ?$'! %!'# ' &"#$'! &$'$ '#$'("#'$&"!< '#D#$$$?(>D$## "#!%'!'#('$"&$&!''$&"##!#$7
47 #&"'?6'3..4 #!#$#""??$'!;''9# &$'$ #&D& ! !;'# "#!95%#, !"#$'! "#! "#!'$7 #"" ' $$ ? ,!' ? ($!#'$'! >D ($ "&'#"'2611"!#!$'$#!''&"#&7 !$# #B#D $#',< ' H #'$ ;!#' <'; / <'D# $ '$$'!>D$##"#!%'!'#7
K7 "'? 34 ' 3..4 ' "#'$ / !''$# (!%#$# ?@$7
17 # !#! 2- >' 3..4 #', & !#!& (!%#$# ?@$ $"#&%('$'!"!#22>'$3..4+ ?'$&$&!'7
67 !# ! '$'! $$ #'9# !;'#& @$# !$'# "#''" ( ""#$$1. %'D! %!'#!5!&$""#$$/(&"!< #!#$ !' (!$!,# 3..- 2# ' 3..4 $ / ? #&'$&D#& (""#$$ ? '5' ' %'$ ,' "H& !H# "!# "&#'! !'&#& $ %'$ !"& (""#$$ ? ' #%'$ "# '# ;$LM57
2.7 !# !"#$'! "#! "#$' ?' ($ $ @ >!# ' !''$& ';!#$'! !"&$'# #!#$7 5' "#&'&? "!#"&#'!>'/&,#3..= ($#$';'%'$ &$& #&("#$"#!#' ($#"#$"#D'?(#$'#'$! $'%'$&#"N$ !'$$#E..$4..;#7"#!' $'%'$&!'#?( %'$"'!D&7"'!&"#$$!3..->?(&"C$ '%!#>'3..= !#'%'$&"#$'?$$!$ B#DO ' #&D'$ "#$' ;$#7 '%!# (%'$ " !# &$& "#!!&7'!''$&&'"!#&#'$#"#9?@$ !#$?( &' &$& ;'<& 3= >'$ 3..4 "!# ' $ E2 !P$ 3..4 "!# #!#$ '$?!'#'$D#&/>D#7
227 &#'$#21>'$3..4 '#9%?<!'$'!#$'% / ',&#$'!!'$'!!$'$'!!$"#"'("9 ( "#$ (<'D '"!& "# + ( G ( 8'5 "#9 + : &"#$'! ;'$ ? ?$'! ;''9# !'$ #&D& '#$ $# &"!< ($# "#$ !$#'$ &!!'? #!#$7 ;;$ ' '$& !'$ <'$# >#'"#
011203..4 5-065 ;&&# $ !' $# &'$& #"## $'%'$& #'& ! (&$# $ !$'; ',&#$'!7 # ' (""#)$ " ? #!#$ '$ &$& !$#'$ #"## $'%'$& "#!;'! #'! &"#$'! "'?('$&$,'?!#'!$''$(?'$$#($'B#D ;' ?#!#$'"!(!"$"#!,?% ''$#$#'$/=.(...;#7?''""!#&&$;!#$ $?( ( " P !''$# (' <$&#'# $'# ! (!#D' !'< "!# ;'# ;/!,'D$'!;''9#7
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
2E7 "#9$#''!&#'$#<"#$' "#"'3!P$3..4 &$&D#&/>D#7
)
27 !'D%!'#T!#D'$'!>'''#8:&$&!';'&$'$'$& 9 2#!P$3..E #',$!#!' !"!&=>D
011203..4 5=065 !$"#&'$$%'5"#&'$ =""&$$24>D#8#$72$7 #$=4 :7
+'$/T$'!T&$'!24>D# "# #',;&&# 3K>%'#3..-8 S2E.2.4: # !'D%!'!"$& 2E;&%#'# '"!'$'!$#'$!'##D$"#$$$ #',$!# !' '&D# # / $#!' >D $'$'# T$$$ T&$'!!%<>D#7
37 !;!#&$ / (#$7 =4 7 2 $7 B7 1 #', $! #!'!)$'$'?!$$$'!"#&%/T#$' =4 ?'!$#$'%/ 7
+!"&$"!#>D#T"9$''&$,'7
E7 $#>$&&'$;!#&D< #!#$#%,8#$7=4$4. !';&&##"#$'D&&##!'$#!'4!$!,#3... 8 :$-67E!'D%!'$'9#BCD8 :7
-7 : <$#T#$7172 T#&#!'$/T''$&BCD"!# $$ !$$ ?T'#"'!'$'!#$'%/"&#'!!$'$'! !?T'!'$',&#&8$7:7
!'$'!!$'$'!!$#"'!#?T#&!$'&/$'$##'& I#$!U!'!'J8#$72E72 :7 T$"'' ?' T$"!$$&7
"$ <$#(#$72-72 !$',&#&!'$'!#$'% /"&#'!!$'$'!"#!?' I''$&'5#8#$76 7E:$"$"!U!'$!$ T&$'$""#$'/#""!#$ $#%' $ "#$$ T!$ " #"'# !'$'! #$'% / "&#'! !$'$'!J #'!T;!#$'!!'# #!%#'! !"#;$'!$ "#!;'! 8$7 : T ' T '$ ! T $#'$& 8$7 ,: ! T&>!#&$,'$&$$'!!$#%'8$7:7
T'&3"#&%!'$"#'#?''$V
I+!$ &D$ ',&#& !'$'! #$'% / "&#'! !$'$'! "#! ?' "# '$ &"#$'! !#" ! '%!# T'%''$& 8#$7 1 : ! !#$ # !>!'$ ! "!# #'! ,, 8W: !$ !$#'$T<##$'%'$&#'&!T&$#J7
,: +! >#'"# S + ++ + 8'5 "#9 S :''$&$#&'$&#"##$'%'$&#'& $ (&%&$ !'$ <'$# ' ' ;;'$ ?T' "#' #&', $ !"#&B', ? T&%&$ ?$'! $ / T!#'D' &''!
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
##@$2.>'3..=# 3440.- &D$'$&"# "#$' S #""& (&%!$'! >#'"# $'9# $ #"#' (##@$ $'!&7 "#&'& ? (< &" / !%#'# (#&'(H%'$"'"##!'&#$'!?'#%'$%$ $!$!<'%$/!!;!#$ ''?$#$'%<,!' %'$<''", #D8YWZ#L[B,',$ ,'##\;D ##;'$'B$>L D,"!'$'!U,#\M'B$'D'$7'B# U'D$'#LDD#';;ZLD8YDULD'Y:' #$72- ,73 ; ' MD %! U'$ ' ' L'$# +' !$L'D ,B$DM!$ DB$ 'B$ ;LD LB %!#B'B!#B''B]!;!#$'Y!7=7E7E:7
=7 ("9 ' 9D ?(' ($ " &$,' ? ?$'! ;''9# %'$&$&#&D&$#&"!<;N!'# $?($#"#$!'$'! '$&($"#"'7
!%'$ #%# "#&,$ ? ' !' ' >#'"# ;&&# "#&%!'$ ! !'$'! ? &"!< '$ #&D& '#$ ?$'! ;''9# $$<'D&$'?$+ 7 #>!'$"$ !'$'!'$&"'?('$&'#"!#!<!)$# B#D $#%&"!<''?!$#',$'!(&"!<7 !$# ' #!#$ ;;$'%$ !'# ? &"!< %'$ #&D& $$ ?$'! ;N!?'&$&<"!&'57
011203..4 51065 +(D'$ '$& $# "#!&# '%!# $ &'$& "!# #!#$ #"## $'%'$& / $" "' $ "# !&?$ !$#'$ &!!'? #!#$ #', !'9# ?( $ #"'7 ;;$ ""'$'! >#'"# ;&&# $'!& ! "$ !$$# ? 9 ('$#!$'! "#!&# '%!# >' 3..= #!#$%'$D$#!$"$#%'"!#!%#'#,!'$< ;$ !$/!#$$#"'?!$#',$'!(&"!< ;;''$ " / !%#'# $! # ,!' ' #$!$ / !H $# "'? (&"!<(!""!'$%#$(!$#',$'!/($#$'#!#$5 / "#!!& '%!# $ ?( $ !$#',$'! ($ !#& ?(/ $#'$!'$'!7"$#%#?#!#$$#!%"#&'&$ ;'D# '? ( !" % ;$ %'%$ "#''"$ # '# !H "!# ? "#!&# '%!# D$ / !#$ $# B#D &!,$ B#D $ ?(' ""#)$ #&', $ !"#&B', ? (&%&$ ;! # #'! ''?& / (#$7 2- 7 3 7
47 %?'"#&9 #!#$!'$@$#',&#&!'!#$'%/ "&#'!!$'$'!7#!##'$&''!'$'D'&7 #!#$%#@$#',&&;'(''$&>!#'9#"'$ &"C$ 32 >' 3..= "!# $$ ? $# !'$'! !'$#"'7
#!#$ ?' !,$'$ D' #!'$ / &" ;'<& ("9 / 3(3=.;#7
^^^
) * / ) * )* *
01232,, 4 .2 2 2 56 #&$ 7
32,
27 &##!##%,7
32
37 ($$&''!="$,#3..=$2.;&%#'#3..47
011203..4 56065 E7 %!'!'#/'"!#!%&''!!'&#$7
-7 ! ' %#$ ( ''$& ;%# #!#$ 3(3=.;#7
=7 ;!# "#$' ?T "%$ ;!## #!# !$# "#&$ ##@$ &' E. >!# 9 !$';'$'! "# "' #!& #& #', ;&&# # +BL'U#B!;?' 4 4..- $#!' <"'#7 &' "$ @$# "#!!D&7 &!'# !'$V : ''?# <$$?&''!#!#$&'#!,$'#'$"&''! $$?&O ,: <"!# "!# ? !$'; ' $' "!%!'# # $$ $# &''!O : "!#$# 'D$# ! ! #"#&$$7 +' &!'# !$'$ " $#!' &&$ &&#& ! $$# : ,: $ : '5 #',;&&##"!##"$##$'9###!#?T' %#&##'##%,7&!'##!#$'!#!#!H "#% ?' #!$ >!'$ '' ? &''! $$?& $ T%!"" ?&$&<"&'&#!#$8#$72E3 2.4$2.1:7 D#;;'# #&'$V '## + ,+
!"'!;!# "#&$ ##@$$!$';'&<"#$'$+#&$#'$T $$/ T&!!'"#D#;;
011203..4