Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/730/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/730/2006 AI generated

Statutory Amendment Retroactivity Challenge

Case Number ATAS/730/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerns a challenge to the application of a certain statutory amendment, enacted in 2005, to transactions completed under an earlier 2004 statute, with the court finding that the 2005 amendment was not intended to be applied retroactively to actions predating its effective date. The court reasoned that while the amendment addressed a related area, there was no clear legislative directive indicating an intent to disturb past transactions governed by the prior law, and absent such explicit instruction, the presumption against retroactivity must prevail, thereby maintaining the validity of the transactions under the 2004 provisions.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory Amendment Retroactivity Challenge: The court reasoned that while the amendment addressed a related area, there was no clear legislative directive indicating an intent to disturb past transactions governed by the prior law, and absent such explicit instruction, the presumption against retroactivity must prevail, thereby maintaining the validity of the transactions under the 2004 provisions.

Keywords

AI generated
retroactivity of a law legislative amendment effective date statutory right challengeable acts statutes of limitations

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 108 al. 1 let. a LTF

Cited in the dispositive for declaring the appeal inadmissible based on a simplified procedure.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the apportionment of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



               &'()&*++, "&'-+&*++,

"

 " #"   #  #

#.  / % *0 1 *++,    

 !"""# $ %!%& 

!&%    ' (     (( ")" !"*+  "&"# ,!&-./ *00*

          ! "#! $%  6+1.6  

% 2% ,%!%%"%*/78"%+005 ' (     (( "9!%#   :;  %<!%%"& ,  9&% :; " 8"& %# %"!,"&"%%#="%,%">

+49#8%"%+005 6"!&&#,%?;%%<!=,%&&"! &9"&,%8"% %"<#!,"!!%%"%>

;%!%#&#%="&%#!@ 12341+005>

;"8"&#A#&%"% ;%%"9!%# %"<#.*%+005: <!=#&"&#>

"8%!%%"%!&#&##)=#&%;%#&;%%>

 9"& ;%#  !9"%#  %"<  # : ! B%!% ,!% ,"!,%&&"!"":&%?=B>



#   2%  !" =8!" % C!%="&"! 7"""% DE  #&# !"9"#&"&"&# ?*%!F&+00.  %"<&!%!"  !,!#  3 7=  !&  ,%#"& &  8"6,%#"&  3 ,,#& & *5 7= %D%&G*&G%&35 E 

!"=8!"%C!%="&"!7"""%DE#&#!"9"#&"&"&# ? *%!F&+00.  %"<&!%!" !,!#37= !& ,%#"&&8"6,%#"& 3,,#&&*57=%D%&G*&G%&35  E>

"&AC&"!C#&"!*57=% ,% %"<9##% +278"%+004D H*.0*05E % !"=8!"!,&# *.9#8%"%  ",!"&"!&%"&!"%%=&,%&&& %"<&!%!"  "#=%  % A &%!" 7= &"&"%     C&&&  C#&"!  !8I7=%>

 !9!%#& A ;%&G 35  G * &G     %"< &!  % !" !J&  "& ":  !&&&"! %&"8 I % !,#&"% A C%6" !" ,%#8 ,%  !" 9##% % C%6"*-%*//4 &AC%6"&!<"=&!"%,%#8,% !"9##%%C%6"&+0%*/-*D E>

!,#&,!%7=%C,?&""#&<">

;%#!<&&"9&"!>



12341+005  6.1.6   %!%&?!%8!<7&>

C"!8"&C,%%&&%K%%L>



 # "3  " #"   #  #

%

456   7  8   9: /,*  $;

*G !&&:%!%&8!<7&G

+G K%LG

.G "&:,%!#%&=%&"&G

4G 9!%  ,%&" :  ;="&   !" 9##% %  !&%& ;%  +8%" */0- &   ""&  %&" 4.  & 5-    !" 9##% % ;!%="&"!7"""%*5#<%*/4. ,%#&%%M&,&9"%;!<7&; %!% %"<9##%&%&7!%?!&"9"&"!G#!"% %!%%%#&%!"I,"% %"<&!% *-  %  !&6  *+0* ?8G  ,%#& %%M& &  ,"?  ,!"!  %!%& "8!:#!!K,%8 !"8&M&%7!"&A;8!"G  =%99"?%  %#"&O     %"6!"  N !%"P   

!,"!9!%,%#&%%M&&!&"9"#I,%&""":CAC99"9##% %,%"8#,%=%99





12341+005