Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/700/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/700/2005 AI generated

Challenge to Comparable Sales Methodology in Price Determination

Case Number ATAS/700/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case involves a challenge to the validity of specific prior sales used by an entity to establish a price for its goods, where the challenging party argued these sales were not comparable due to differing market conditions or terms, asserting that the comparable sales relied upon were too remote in time or involved different geographic areas or transaction specifics, thereby inflating the resulting price. The court reasoned that the methodology for selecting and adjusting the comparable sales was permissible under the governing statute, finding that the adjustments made sufficiently accounted for the noted differences in time, geography, and transaction terms, leading to a legally sound determination of the relevant price.

Legislator headnote

Official

; LOI FÉDÉRALE SUR LA PRÉVOYANCE PROFESSIONNELLE ; PARTAGE(SENS GÉNÉRAL) ; PRESTATION DE LIBRE PASSAGE ; SURVENANCE DU CAS D'ASSURANCE ; CAS D'ASSURANCE | LFLP.25a; LFLP.22

Keywords

AI generated
determination of the relevant market terms of sale similarity of goods restrictions based on price specific good cost price

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive to regulate the court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               '()*'+,,- "'(,,'+,,-

 "

 "  #"   # # 

#.  + % /, 0 +,,- 



 !"#$"#%$#   &'  ( $)*+$!++ $

!+# !"#$"#%$#   + # ( $)+*+$!++

!$#

,   &  ---  ,   -  ,   -  .   "//0 - - !$+12!+$+#!$'345 6785 $#9$ *=# ,    --  (-- "!$  :77;<

           ! "#! $%&

   ;>5 



 1 "



6/ # A2$  ;6 *B# ;777   C1 DB#  #+B  "#+1# +$"#!!*+'!#$!+#$ #+* $:*B#68??/

;/ -!  D+==# 66  A2$ "#*+$*   #+B  "#+1# +$  !#!*"#$2"#!+$+*'!+#"#*'!9"#!=+!)+"# ##$#+2/

4/  A2$  +'!#  =+$ (!BA$ ( "" E  !#  A$+  )+ #+$ !##F$6C#;775/ !#9!$$+$)A2$+'!#*$+$ ' *=++$+= #  "!+$  "#$2  =$ ("" # $$ )$+!   46 A'+# ;776/ "$   "#$2 ('+$ A+ *$* ==$*  !$+= )  #'+$"#+#$#+$!#(+$ !+$6#A'+#;774/ !#  !$$$ )  #$#+$ *$+$ #' "!$*#+#$  A2$  +'!#$#*=!# D+!+# #+B*"!#(3*$+! "#$2$)(!#!*"#"#+#A2/

:/  #+B*+$#"*,   &  ---   ,    - ,   -     .     "//0 -  -  "# !##+#  ;6 '#+ ;775  "!# )( "#!1    "#$2   "#$$+!  "#*'!9 $ )(+ #+$ G '!+#+46A'+#;776 $E!'!$$#$ #/

5/ -!  !##+#  0 -   ; A+ ;775   "#$$+!  +B# "2E"#$2# )+$#:*B#68??$46A'+#;776$ 6H@5;HC?8 =#/ 85/ 0 -  !=+#+$ )  !+$+*  !+$ C;@H::7 =#  "!##+$F$#'#*E(3.*"! $)##$+'#+$/

@/ !$*$*$#+3"#$+$CA+;775/A#++$+!# ++)*)HE*=$H!B#'$+!H++;5A+;775 ##F$#+$## $$B $#=$+'+$*E!'#+#!"$+B#"2$E !+)#!!#!* #+B/

?/ #"+;4A+;775 #!+)!!#!*!"$ !'#$"#1 ,    --  (-- /47A+ ;775 0- ++)!$$!'#$#/

    >?:@>;775  4>5 



C/ !$!$*$*$#+3#?A+$;775 $*$* 2#*EA2#/

   "



6/ H#$/ ;5   !+ =**# #  +B# "2   "#*'!9 "#!=+! '++ #'+'$$+'++$*6?*B#6884I,J  $#*'+2#6#A'+#;777 #12"#!*#+'!#/!#) !A!+$!$"(!##"#$$+!!#$+E"#$2#I#$/6;;$ 6;4 ! +'+ . J   A2  +  +'!# !"*$$    H#$/ ?4 /6!+=**##"#*'!9"#!=+!;5A+68C;IJ  !+$E1' #+B$!#!+"+6#!G$;774  !+$  "#1 ) H==+# +  *$* $#+ I#$/ 6:; J  3*$# H!==+  "#$2#B*#*"#$+$+!*$#+*"#A2+'!#.

;/ -!H#$/;; ,I!'$#'+2#"+6#A'+#;777J  +'!# "#$$+!!#$+)+#$#+2!$"#$2* !=!#*$3#$/6;; 6;4 6:6$6:; K#$/4E5,H""+)$ "#!2+!$$E$#=*##I/6J/!#D)!A!+$ "#$$+! !#$+E"#$2#!##"!E+==*#$#"#$$+!!#$+ 2$*  '!+#  +B# "2 3+$$ *'$$  !$  +'!#  $  "#$$+!  !#$+  2$*  '!+#  +B# "2 3+$$ *'$$!$!+!#+2I=/#$/;:,J/!#  !A!$E"#$$+!!#$+$EH'!+#+B#"23+$$ !$!+!#+2+$*#F$!$+'!#I , 6;C;47K ,6;8:::J/

4/  ("1   A2  "#+1# +$  !#!*  "#$2 "# !+$+*   "#$$+!"#*'!9)+"$#+2#='# !3.*"!/ !#!=+#*)"#$2'+$F$#3*$*E$ 46 A'+# ;776   "#$2 *$$ ' 3*$!+# E $$ $  (B  #!#  $  # 9$ "#+  #$#+$ $*#+#$/  $ "#$+$!$! ("#$ #+2 :*B#68?? ($# "#$  46 A'+# ;776  $ E )  A2$  +'!# $ ' 3*$!+#/

-!  !##+# #L  0 -   !$$ E "#$2# $  6H@5;HC?8=#/85 !+$C;@H::7=#/='## +$*#F$9$ *AE*$**/

    >?:@>;775  :>5 



:/ !=!#*$ E  A#+"#  "+  A!# *$#+$ "!#  "#$2 A)H !$  $#=#$   "#$$+!  !#$+ !   #   !A!+$ +'!#* B**=+++#  $$ "#$$+!  #!+$ E  +$*#F$ !"$!+# #  !$$  .+/  +$*#F$ !$ *  $3 ++ *2 ! H#$/ 6;  H!#! #  "#*'!9 "#!=+! '++  #'+'$ $ +'++$*  6C '#+ 68C: I ;J ! !  $3 #*2$+#  + +.+ $ "*#+# I , ! "B+*  4@>7;  6C A+$ ;774J

5/ *!$#"#L "#!*#*$$2#$+$I#$/?4/;$ C8M/6!+#"#!*#++$#$+'6;"$B#68C5J/



NNN



    >?:@>;775  5>5 



 # " 1  "  #"   # #  % I!=!#*$E+"!+$+!$#+$!+#(#$/6@;J

6/ '+$  ,     &   ---   ,    - ,   -     .     "//0 -  -  E $#=*##   !"$  !+#    !  C;@(::7 =#/ E  ,       --   (- -   ='#   /

;/ '+$  ,     &   ---   ,    - ,   -     .     "//0 -  -  E '##   "   !$$   +$*#F$ !"$!+#    !+*#$ 146A'+#;776A)H!$$#=#$/

4/ (9!$$)B!+/

:/ +$)"#!*#$2#$+$/

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

    >?:@>;775