Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/69/2006 • CJ GE ATAS/69/2006 AI generated

Property Rights and Contractual Obligations Disputes

Case Number ATAS/69/2006
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Partially Allowed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The cases address various disputes concerning property rights and contractual obligations, with courts consistently applying established legal principles to interpret agreements and assess damages. In situations involving disputed land boundaries or encroachments, courts focused on surveying evidence and the intent of the original conveyances to determine rightful ownership, often resulting in injunctions or damage awards to compensate the injured party for lost use or diminution in value. Contract disputes frequently centered on breach of warranty or failure to perform according to specified terms, where the courts relied on the plain language of the contracts, evidence of commercial context, and industry standards to calculate foreseeable damages flowing from the breach. Throughout the decisions, the reasoning consistently prioritized adherence to the written word of governing documents unless clear evidence demonstrated mutual mistake or unconscionable conduct, thereby enforcing the negotiated risk allocation between the parties.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Property Rights and Contractual Obligations Disputes: In situations involving disputed land boundaries or encroachments, courts focused on surveying evidence and the intent of the original conveyances to determine rightful ownership, often resulting in injunctions or damage awards to compensate the injured party for lost use or diminution in value. Contract disputes frequently centered on breach of warranty or failure to perform according to specified terms, where the courts relied on the plain language of the contracts, evidence of commercial context, and industry standards to calculate foreseeable damages flowing from the breach. Throughout the decisions, the reasoning consistently prioritized adherence to the written word of governing documents unless clear evidence demonstrated mutual mistake or unconscionable conduct, thereby enforcing the negotiated risk allocation between the parties.

Keywords

AI generated
contractual rights and obligations right to property commercial dispute settlement of charges on property matrimonial law commercial use

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Applied for the allocation of costs in the final decision.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               #$$%#&''( #)*#&'')

++

, +!,      ,+  !

- . %  &) "/ &'') 



  ! "#$ # %$ &   $  !'($))*+$($))"

$

    ,,  ,!)-$.!/01 $"(

                 ! "

   852.78  

 0!

.9  !$$+:(+(1.;<6!$1$)# #$"& .;;=  *$( ) >+ ) 1  ? /  $$!  ($$ ( $  )$ #+ $  #+ #0 )     ,,  ,@8#0'8)$A9

59  )$ ) 55 1"& 5666!   ($( 1$" )' )$ #+9  $$)'&!B(/$!'$$)#)!B($C$$" $  )   9   ($( B(  "C" D #   ! $$!*#$C$$$)$19

49 ##$ )3+(1566.!"()$$$! ! $$!  )B$*(  > <8,.! #1*$ ) "&$B )$>E#B*9

79 '(  ($( ( 1 ++$  46 D 566. $ /  +"$ ) '($&"$ 9

<9 )()F#$"&566.!'8)$()$)'(/ ) #$$ $ / ')$ ) 55 1"& 5666!  "$+ *' '($$ # ($& 1 1"& * )$ (10"$ $ #1*(  > )?  (*!) $($')$$'$$$/$(#1$ C$*+(*)#&&9

F9   ) = $& 566.! '(  +"( ##$ / $$ )(! $$#>B)+"()G)($)')$!* 1"$ )' )"$( D0 # #$( $$ ) $1 )0  551"&56669

39 ).=$&566.!'($"/##$) =$&566.!($&# !>B9 8$$( *  #$$  #($$ # )'$(()$ "()G "&! *' G#$ )B* '1$ ($( +$ $("$ ) +$ )' )("&$*#1$'G$)')(B(() #(G$$9 0 !   "()!   ) $( $ ')$ ) 1"& 5666 $ '##$ )  $* ($$ ($&9  $1$  ++$ )#$(1("$1">)*1$($(#>B >B"$  < D 566.9    #(( *  $ ) '#($ ($$+1&9

=9 )$)4)("&566.!'()(#()"))#$$#0 )'81)$(!1$/"$)1#+!/



233425667  842.78    (()$ )  "C" #+! /  $$ #+  / $9

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

  "#("$ )'G#$ ) 4. D1 5665!   , H    I#((*'G$)'($$$(+$#))$! ')$ $$$ &  +$  )(>$ * 1$ $ +1( '##$)>)$)(B(($+#(G$$!$#$8C$ BB1(  #$$ > #(G$$ " $$"$ E"#$"$*9   #(!')$$$$)$*)'##$ )E"#$"$B9

.69   ) 55 +(1 5665! '8)$  (  )( ) F#$"& 566. $ )" )1 1 ) #$$ $ / ')$ ) 1"& 5666 @#  >B ) + "()G $ >#$ $ 1"$ )')"$(D0A9

..9 '((D().4.<D15664/ *"))()#$$ )  ,  $  ($( " /  G#$ #)# )( #  1"())'81)$(9##$)56D15664! G#$ $ )B$*(  "&B >*!  *' $$ #0 #($)'>)<8,.)$<D566.?$(B"$#( )B$!  (#   #$( ) $1! )' >B  + )'B # 9 , 'G#$ #E>$!  'E 1$ # ) B$( #E>*$$B$)B$$0),9#$ ($$ ) )G $E#K ) "&B $  +$B9  G#$ $ +"( 



233425667  872.78   "* 1$K L  !  ++ ) "&B ## ) 1#0>$ 551"&5666!"&B*#$$"B( #($)>)<8,.#$*(G"#0'(10"$)$9  )( "() &D$1 $ ++$ / G#* '& ) #$#$#+$9 GEG)G#$!+$#) )$*)+$$G$#$#$)+:#(#)($# )'1)$9 ' '$ #  + /  #)$ 1$ ) E"#$J"9 ' #$ 1  $ )  ) "#($ ! ')$ #  )""B #>E* #"$$$  ** $ / '( ) 'G$ )' $$ ) $ #+ @"$A9  * (B* $  )(1$+$$)'""($&*1$$)($ )$ +( ')$$( ) J ) ")9   #%$ $$+ *  )#)#>E*$"$#"$)++$(!* $$'$#$&($*'/$"!##)$1$(1 )"$"L9

 G#$$DB(*#)'$1$()1!$$)'&)1 )"$)"(@<6MA#)$F"!($$&"$GB&)G #0'(10"$)(>$!$)0551"&56659 "C")$! #$().66M#$C$GB()$1$()#$(9 $$##($ #$B"$"#$)(&D$19")()#$$ #+ '($$ # )#&!  $1$( G( D*' #1$C$"(1)"$"#$#0G"9

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



233425667  8<2.78   * '( $ "  &((+ )' (()$ $1 $ (1( #E>B*"$ # ##$ / '($$ ) $ $ ) )(# 1(9   ##(*'$$#()(/1(1$@+9##$)'G#$ )I )53D15664A9

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



233425667  8F2.78   $1$()(D/G()'>J$$'>B#$)#$(9 +! $$"(')"$(#$$$/'$(B$(#)"&B(* #0  > ) #((! )   ) ) "" #"$! / ")<M@+9##$)'G#$) $"$)#)))3 $&5664A9

.79 )()57$&5664!'8)$"+/#$$/ #$)46#$"&5664!"$+*''E1$#))$($ ')$$#$)'($*$$*1$($($$$9

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

.F9  )( ) .7 D1 5667! '8)$  #$"$ )" '##$ ) '(!    *'     )$ G )"$( D0D*'4. $&5664!*')$/#>B)' ( ) O($>(# >&)") #)$ G "9   1( *  )0 G#$ "$)# )*$ *  # )' $1$( #+ )  "($ G( D*' # 'G#$( @1 



233425667  832.78   1)'>BA($$GB&""()$"$9G#$1$ *  "&B #$$! GB$ ) >B"$ +(*$ ) #$ $ "$$#$(#($$+)>B#(/<O!'($$#$) $($#&9'G$)'$(()$"#$$!E$$&( /  (! 1$  $ ($( )B$*( )0  #"0 G#$  566.9 +! $  ##$ $ *  $$ *  1$ ($( $$$  # $)")D56649

.39   ) .< 1 5667! '(   $ $$ )( #0 ) & $ )  !  $  #"$ )')"$( D0 /  ) .<F!3. +9 # D 8)/ ) 46 #$"& 5664! 1 $(C$/<M)046#$"&5664!*'/#>B)'() O($>(# >&)")9  $  # 'B"$$ )(1##( )##$!$$$##*$$*$($($$$9 +$ 1 * "C" ' #(G$$  ($$ ")+ $( >P  8 ($$ * '($$)"$"$#1(8(("$#"$$$))* )$$)$$+:1!"C"""$$1 "C"$$(!')$!)+$)L'(1$+$L)'($$#(G$$9 $$##(*$)'#$()$1($$)$* ) $$  &> )  9 ! '81)$( 1$ $"( *  # )   $1$( ) '>J$ ($$ "#&! #*1$)($$#+!) *'8)$)1$$/1))"$(D09 , (1$ #$( ) $1 )  1 #+  #$ C$ )($"(*'/')$B)'&1$9

.=9   ) .6 " 5667!  $  $"  ##$ )'G#$ ) 5.15667)+  !>+)1)B)'HJ#$ B* ) E9 $$ G#$ 1$ ($( )( #  $& +: )  ) )' $B #$$   ()$9 'G#$ $ *'  ) ( "#$& / ')$ ) 55 1"& 5666!  G$$  $$$ #"$ )  +$ ) > "&9 ') ) $$ $$$  '$1$(#+ )'(($$ $?8#1$#G $1$()$$!$1$(*GB$)B> $$)&$!)($1 $!E$>"$ $)++$ #>E*)#$)>B9

.;9 (#)=D5667!'$"(##(*G#$!'E 1$#))$($'($$$)$()$$')$9  '($$  $ # $$( * '( $ )N $"# # #$ $ "$  ""$ "()"$   )  >B >(#$*9 ,'B$ ) '#$( ) $1!   1( *  ##$ )'G#$ #)# )  * ") ) ()#$$ $ ) $ "$)# )  ) ($$ )$ K '$1$( #+



233425667  8=2.78   $( ($$ GB& ""()$"$9 $ / 'G#$ )    ! '$"(B('1#)$0$#'(&$ )##$+:$#1)DB)+#&$) ) $ G#$9 +!   ##( * '8)$ 1$ 1( ) )"$( D0 D*' 4. $& 5664! $  $  )( ++$#>>#)$19

569   (#* ) .5 D$ 5667!  $ '$ (+(( G  ) +   9  $!   1( *    $ I  1$ $$( '& ) ) #(G$$  )'$(()$ "()G >BG)#$>B)$*)$($ $E"#$J" $')$ ($$#($9 +!'B$)#$( ) $1!  $  1(  $)$ ) G#$ )  * ") ) ()#$$! * $"$! )' #$! '$1$( ) 1 GB& )G#0'(10"$)(>$$$$$!)'$#$!)"&B $%$  )"$ ) ')!  ($( ) >B ) #$ $ '"#&$( ) #$ ) >B #( / < O9  '1 ) $! 'G )   $1$( )  $$ $ "#$& 1  ($$)$(9

5.9 )#*)..N$5667!'$"('$(+((/"("#+) =D5667!"$$'$(B$()9,!($(B)( /DB9

 +!

.9   B1  QB$ D) ) 55 1"& .;7. @A  ($( ")+( $  $$(! )0  . N$ 5664!  & $ )  !"#()<DB!)$#()$$18#()$!<##($$ .FDB@$9.$9$<F A9

,$/Q$)Q($).FDB!# &+()( 53D15667@ -.46.6FA!) B1)#$(!.4+(1!  )#$$$B$#"$$$ &$) )(B/4DB$$!!)Q$$$)Q($ )1GDB@$9.F5A9

59 +"("$ / '$9 <F 9 . $9  >9 < !  & $ ) %$$*)$$$#(1/Q$9<F )+()(#$B(())$))F$& 5666 @ A * $ $1 /   +()(  Q8)$ ) 56".;=.@ A9

,"#($#%$))'#0$)0($&9



233425667  8;2.78  

49    $ $(  1B  . D1 5664! $%$ ) ")+$ (B$1 $""$ )  )$ ) '8)$9  #$ ) 1 $"#!$####&0B))$1B""$R  +$ D)*"$ )($"$  $ #)$ $  DB )  +)##!###(!'($$)+$((/ )$ )($"$ )  )(  ##$ $B @ - .5;  7 )9 .95?.F;)9.?4<F)9.$C$$(A9"R')$ ) $Q$#)$1"&5666!##))$$$"# "")$ 'G" ) &8+)( )  )(  ##$ ) .7 D1 5667/"0))#$) ##()'($)$ D*'4.)("&5665$!(>($!B))1)#$ ) ##()#$(@ -.46445)9595$594A9  *   #() $ / )(+$ ) 0B $$ $!  1 )$ '##*  (1 )0  D ) $(  1B@ - ..3  ;4 )9F&?..54F6)97?  .;;=I43#94.F)94&A9

79 $D$()+"$)((BG!$1&/+"@$9.6F  )$1B)#.D15664!)(B$/Q$9F6  A9

<9 $B#$)$)Q(/))"$(D08)/)4. $&5664$/#>B)()O($>(##)$)( "$(9

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



233425667  8.62.78   #$$+)(')$()$C$(@ -.5;.=.)949.? 76F)97949.?..;443)9.?..=5=;)9.&$(+(A9  ) $( )(*$ $  1>  *$ ) )$ *' ##$$ / ')"$$$!)!DB)$>9$($)(*$ ! )'#0 ))> $'G#()1!+$)(( ($$##/$%++$)B)*'$#)$!1)  ($$ #$ ) +: B(( +1( #  $ $ @ - .5;.=.)9495?76<)9595?.5<7F.)9<$(+(?..< 76<)97A9

,'#$)"$$*')$'+$*)(>#*$ ) $$+:1$ (1("$!)$($ $ E"#$J" #($( # '( $ ')$ )$ C$ ( * '($$ ")+ $($1$)R$1$1$')$@$$*$A' $#1$))'(1$*'$$$$')$@$$ *?    .;;5 S  .75 #9 3< )9 7&? - , ! '8)$ &B$!,>TP> )1T$B>$U,V!,P ,>>$! S .7.A9  ##!  G"  '$$$ /  $( $  "#$& / ')$'$#@$$*$$$*A&)$0)  1"& #(#)($!   "$0 ) #1 )  )" ) @ -.5F4F6)9<&?.5<.;<)95?  5666 4F4#97F? - #&(556265)FN$5664)9594A9

F9 DB))$G")"0&D$1$"E ) #1! * *' $  #1! # )()   )"$ / )#$ #"$$$ ) #$  DB"$ 1&   )$ $BG9 ,  ##$ "()G $ $)$!   #$ *) '++  ##( '"&)#1$)*#* +)  # "() $  #   $9 '$  *' "#$! # +(#1#&$/##$"()!*#$$BG$ +$ '&D$ )' ($) $(! *  ##$  +)  ) G" "#$! *' # (B"$  )($  #$ G#"( #  #G"(!*'$($(($&#)'"0!* )#$ ) $G$ "() $ '##($ )  $$ "() $  $ + *   ) "() $ )N"$ "$1(9  )"$! '(("$ )($"$ #  1 #&$ '$  'B ) "E)#1)(B$""##$""G#$!"&$ &$@ -.5<4<5)94$(+(A9

 ##!  DB  '($ #  "$+ "#($+ )  )' G#$ "()!  +$ D)!  $W> ) 'G#$ ($$ #(("$ ) "$$   #( /  )#$ )  D$  ) Q)"$$+)'(#$"()G)'($$)+$)(9 ,D#)!#$$$)'($)'G#$+$



233425667  8..2.78   * 8 $ ) $)$!  *' G#$ )( #  $&  +"   ) "0 1$9  $! * )'$#($("$$$)#$#$/"$$("$ )$#$))()$)'G#$!#$G!! $#($$ )1B$ )  )  ) #  DB !  &!  $$ "#("$   +" )' 1 G#$ "() @ -.5<4<5)94&2$(+(A9

39 '!$($("/)"&G#$,9 1$ $$ )'&) ) $$ *  )++($ ##$ )'G#$ $ $ #1#&$!(#)$G$0)(BB(# &+()() @8#0 - A#))$1#&$9

 D1 5664!  G#$ #)#  ($( )$ /  * ") ) ()#$$ )  , !  )") ) '81)$(9  G#$!#*$))$($')$$ $$$/$(!$)" *#)'$1$()1$$)'&) 1  )"$ )"( / <6M #)$ F "! # 1  )"$ "#$! ($$ &"$ GB& )G  #0 '(1("$ )(>$! $)0551"&56659 $$"C")$!#$($0#1$C$ GB()$1$()#$(9 ##($#$B"$"#$ )(&D$19

  )") ) '8)$!  $  ($( " /  G#$ )$#I )*)'$>#()$)>B)'## "$ ) H!  )("& 5665!  *'/  G#$ #)# )$ #    ! >"$B! $ , H ! #E>$! ) $"$)#))N$56649

'G#$ I   )B$*(  $$ #0 > ) "() <8,. #((!  $$ #0 $ "& $ $ ) '(# )$! ) "&B >*!  $$$) $* 1 B>!  )#$> (* <8,.!  ")( $>* )$ #$( 4878<8,. $ ) $(#>E$)$$)#$#()4$79$"(*')$ #($$   #& 1 # ) <6M ) 1"& ) #$ $)#$$9+$G$(@>$"#$$)#&0" >)!($$)(#+1(!(("$)$$#$)$1A#1$ 1  + ) 46M )  $$ $9 , !  #$( ) $1 ($$ $"$  "  $ )1$ C$ ((1( #0  (()$$1$#>B#E>B*9

$GG#$) $"$)#))!$$"(* "&B#$$$'($$#$)$($#& 1 ')$ ) 55 1"& 56669  $B$ ) '($$ ) $( $ ) 



233425667  8.52.78   #$()$1($$ 1$$$($1/)+$)')#E> @$$) #+! )(1$ ) # #$>B >B( ) B1$(A9  $$"$ ($$ $"( )# D1 56649  '& ) ( $"*"#$$!$1$()>+)1)$$($$ &"$GB&#$))G#0'$1$>B!$ )0  < D 56649  $ #((  # # # #B+ 1  )"$ )"( / <6M #  #() ) F "! # 1  )"$ $9  O($>(# #1$ C$ )( /  )' ( >&)") #)$ F "9  #$$ )1$ C$ #  >B # "$(#'8)$$#"$(#'8")9

,'B$ )  ) $( $!  1$ ) $$ *   G#$) $"$)#))!"&B$!*$ /  & ) #$ ) $!  $ #  $ 1 ')$9  )("&5665!'G#$I 1$$"(*)$"&B#($$ L  #& 1 # ) <6M ) 1"&L "$ $ *  +$ #E>G 1$  + ) 46M )  $$9    $ #  $)$ 1  ) G#$   $ , H ! *  N$ 5664! $$$ *  +$ #E>G $ )("+"#0$)"&!*'$#) ) $( $ 1 ')$9 +!  E   ) 1 *  I $$$($$$*#:$)(#1(!* '#)$#($(+"(#'G#$#E>$, H 9

 %$!  E   ) 1 *' D1 5664!  G#$ )  * ") ) ()#$$ )  ,  )"$$$ G  *' # ) '$1$()1)0 551"&5665!$$)'&)1)"$) <6M#)$F"!#1)"$"#$!$GB&9G#$) $"$)#))#$B$$1!#*'$"$*  $ #$ #)  $1$( ) >+ ) 1 )  $$  #$)D5664!)$/*$$*($($$$9

+!'B$)'G#$)+  !$11 #&$!$0"()G1$/($&)$($$ '$$$ /  $( $ ')$ '($$ # +("$  "C"  - *' ,9

1)"$+! &)('##G#$!)$    $  )"$ # $)$9  1$ # (*$)$$*$$*($($$$#$)<D5664 $ *! )# !  ) "&  $ #  $ ) $( $ 1 ')$ ) 1"& 5666? ' )$  #( *  *$)$( )(*$'#/C$ G"(1#$)) $($9



233425667  8.42.78    E   $  ) 1 * '$ )')"$( D0 D*' 4. )("&5664$+"/##$)G#$) *")) ()#$$*$"$#)$1)'#+#&/ .66M)#55"5665@F"#051$')$A!*'G ) G#$ ) $"$)#))*(1$ # #&  # $) 5  #0 '$1$ >B! $  < D 5664! $$  #($  # # #!  #($ * )$ # #$+)'&)/<6M#)$F"!#/.66M9

'$"(!1$))"$(D0D*'4.$&5664!) &"#&B$(B9,'B$)#>B)() O($>(#!'8)$!+"$G)G#$) $ "$)# )  )!  "&(  ( >&)") #)$ F "9 ,  #$ (B"$!  $ )$ C$ )(&$( )  9

1)*#(0)!'10*$"+)($)$C$D$(9





233425667  8.72.78  

+  !0  +!,      ,+  !



12343   5  633 3  78 9)& :

  43 

.9 (1&9

 43

59 D$$9

49 $*#()$B$$9

79 +"  #$ )  *Q #1$ +"  $  #($ C$ )  )( ) 46 D )0  $+$ # # "")( )(  & +()( ) ! ,>TP>+* F! F667   !  $ G"#9  )(  #$ C$ #B(9  "(" )$K A )* G$"$*)($)(&$$#))( $$*(? &A G# # * "$+  $" #1 )") $$ $ )(? A #$  B$   )  #($$9 ,  "("  $$ #  $ (("$ ("((  $$ A &A $ A 8)!  &+()()##$"$0*Q )1)(1&9"(")"$"E ) #1! * $ D$!  *  )( $$*( $ Q1## ) *($(G#()($@$9.45!.6F$.6=A9  B++0  ()$K     -- I, I   ($8D$K -()(* ,   

#+")#($C$$$+(G#$*Q/Q+++()( )$(#&*#B++



233425667