Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/686/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/686/2007 AI generated

Law of the Case Doctrine and Interlocutory Modification of Judgment

Case Number ATAS/686/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The court considered whether a ruling regarding an earlier set of findings and conclusions, which modified a judgment in part, precluded the party from raising certain issues regarding the original judgment in a subsequent appeal, particularly concerning the application of a specific legal standard to the admitted facts. The court reasoned that because the earlier ruling was an interlocutory modification that did not address all the issues currently being appealed, and the issues raised in the current appeal were not fully decided or waived in the prior proceedings, the party was not barred by the law of the case doctrine from challenging the specific aspects of the original judgment related to the legal standard applied to the established factual record.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Law of the Case Doctrine and Interlocutory Modification of Judgment: The court reasoned that because the earlier ruling was an interlocutory modification that did not address all the issues currently being appealed, and the issues raised in the current appeal were not fully decided or waived in the prior proceedings, the party was not barred by the law of the case doctrine from challenging the specific aspects of the original judgment related to the legal standard applied to the established factual record.

Keywords

AI generated
legal doctrine appealability of interlocutory decision legal aspects revision of a judgment effects of a preliminary ruling judicial duty to question

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

This provision was cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           #$%&#&''( )#$*$#&''(

 )

 )  )+     +  

,  &  -. / &''( 



  !"#$$%&  ' & ( 

(

&&  &    &  &)*!(((+,(+#-. '#/ (!" 011   0 && /    23 4,(+$-#$## #.



                 ! "   

   /$5./  

  "  ( (8" 9 :  ;/,<  (= , 011     0 && /    ;/,<  =  $$ >?$%%3

    $% 8"? $%%3 , @  ( !  @   ( "A!"((@?B8(!(

  ",  0   $. ! $%%3  "(   !! C!,<(!(!,")BD((@0,( (

 0,,       !,( (!" ,    $6 ? $%%7

A,(8,/(, #3?$%%3

(( @0(@( ("(""9?  8( @  ",  "(" !  B""8 0 ( 0? (" (<   ?(," ,((E ?

    B  (  #2 ? $%%3  8A(  " ,  @0((( 03!$%%3

(( @(0,"E  "8A"

0 ?(  (( @    !,(  " (( A,( (( ((@A,(0(,!"  ((( ,( (

0?( 0, (( 4 F"(( ? B>(:







56+%5$%%7  /.5./  

   +) 1  )  )+     +   

#: ((@( ?B>(:

$: 4 F:

.: 8!,( @G,?(8!(,"(H(   "  .% > <  (8( ,<  B 8" " ;&)IJ)8@77%%+  =,? !(<  ( ,B8!"!(A(:6$ 8" " B8" " #3 > $%%- ; 1=K  !"!   (  @   !(8 ( !4 ,?(,(E( ( ! (K ( H(  "  B 8" " , ? ,(  , ? "(@ A  ( 0(:+$ 1:,"(H((,<, ( ?@"!!!4 ,? ?(H(>(90?:



 E88  " (L             & B& 





,8! ,"(H(((8"A,(,E88



56+%5$%%7