Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/679/2004 • CJ GE ATAS/679/2004 AI generated

Contract Modification Enforceability Dispute

Case Number ATAS/679/2004
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The case concerns a dispute over the enforceability of a commercial contract amendment following an initial agreement, where one party asserted the amendment was invalid due to a lack of proper consideration and the other maintained that mutual assent and performance constituted a binding modification. The court reasoned that the evidence demonstrated the parties intended to be bound by the revised terms, finding that the performance rendered under the amendment, even if not supported by new consideration, was sufficient to establish a binding contractual modification under the governing law which permits modification without new consideration where there is clear mutual assent and performance.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 93 LTF, Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Contract Modification Enforceability Dispute: The court reasoned that the evidence demonstrated the parties intended to be bound by the revised terms, finding that the performance rendered under the amendment, even if not supported by new consideration, was sufficient to establish a binding contractual modification under the governing law which permits modification without new consideration where there is clear mutual assent and performance.

Keywords

AI generated
commercial contract consideration for performance amendment of the claim civil revision proceedings provisional enforceability matter in dispute

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 93 LTF

Used to declare the appeal inadmissible.

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Provision governing the allocation of court costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text



         

    "#$%"&%%' "$(#"&%%'

)

* +!* ,  * ,+

 -. / &%%'

.0 1 2        3333333333        ,44+ ,  5* +6+ +  ! " !"#$%&'(    

           !   )*+$) 



 4+



/0 122222222223!4/$.%355"67 8"!" 69 "0   !!   8!!5 "6  "     7):"  )5  & ;-<  6 (   " )"6("!& :"/(*--/0

*0 *=(*-->36!"!:!" "(&6"6 :  :0  "? "  ? " 7 ?6  8 " 6" !@' :"6::@?:A ::!36@"6"("!BCD3 ":8' (0:::""!:& 6C!:"?" '3!8"(6@3 B: !"!!:7?::!:@ !3?: !D0 6!:?::6""!?06!E?6 !@ 8"6" !"":5*--*:"8'0

>0   22222222223 :! F1G  :7 @3   ! "  ::"/,"! 8*--*3?6!":6!"!@"!":5 8*--*0 22222222223?6!:"8'3 !@ !"::"*;8*--*?6#(@@(0

.0  "! " /- E *-->3 655  " 6)("! H)

:'6 I5 !6!?" ""6: :! E!3?(&69@7!"-3>?66#(: "6"7 :(0

;0 6!!  5 ! ::  ; 4 *-->  " "!0  :: ?6!@' 8"6":J

)  A    !" HA " @#! 3 E "63A":"3A":"I

)  (   7#@'3 "!:  (  : :83   !3  " !!:73 5   H3 55 59""(I0

 @:B?65C""!?E6(8!3  55(   (  H9 @7I 6 ? " >+/-'  H9



+$,-+*--. )>+$) 



"6#?6:: I36:!! :" ?  :"(?":7:78"E0 :""?E6@((3""6@0

,0  "!  :: " *;  *--.3 6   5 !  50    ?6 "7 "  (#3  6# ( : "6 8 5 8 ? : @K  @ " "  (3 '( ?6 "8!? " 8!!5 "6 :!"3 : & 7@ "   "3  :: ?  '   :3 : :( 8!!5 "6 : :"" (#3?(5!& -3*3?6:6:':?(&69@7-3> ?66#:"6"7 :(0

%0 6!  E!   >  *--.   "' "!0    : 55 "6 8 5 8 ? : @K  @ " "  (0  @ &  !@" ?   22222222223 "  :: "! " *; 8 *--*3 ( "?!  755 * ?6 :!  B:7 :!:7!? "!83 !  ("3H::"8E38"6!?8ID0(? 6 3"(8!!5"6:!"3C:?&(?6!! A " :" " K 55! ?" J B6 : "  : ( " 8   :8'  C :"  5" L  55  8?6:!!(:5?6:  @!   : ( " !? @(3 ( E?6& 6 :3"6M8E"6"D0

  :7 & 6  " " ?6 6#  : "6 " 7 : (3  ::"! 0

=0   :!( " *%  *--.3 6    E "    ""!?!35" !8 " " /, E *-->  /;  *--. :  N( !" !@ " 6)("!HN1I0

  ! "   " /, E *-->3 !8 :   22222222223 !""6 3?66@"6"B (# (&-3 >:"7 :(D0  !"'(""/;  *--.3 ?3 B "7 "  (#  6#  : "6 8 5 8 ? : @K  @ " "  (0 



+$,-+*--. ).+$) 



"8!? " 8!!5 " 6" "6 :!"3 : & 7@ "  ) "D0

$0 (!&"! 36!5 ! 8"!?:"!" * *--.36  (:!: 7@"687: (@3?B"! 6 :" 7": !(" 8:!5??E63 ""3 :@ "6  " A    !"C ED H50  " / E *--.I0



 ,+



/7   @(  6@ E" HI  !! "5!   !3 "'/4*-->3 8"3 :!"; E@3":!"():!"3;::!/,E@ H0/0;, I0

N&6"6!"/,E@3: 85!"! *% E( *--. H F />-  /-,I3  "  @(  ":!3  /> 5!(3  ":  @ :   8  "   " !@   &  E@ 3 3 " 6"6!"(CE@0

N"":83 85!"!3"K"/ E*--.35 !?":: !5 3"O3"5!"!HK/0/=>+*--.I0

@   "  ? "  ! " 8  "  3   "!! ?  ! "  8  :( K  3(5"!@""5!"!3660 ;% "   5!"! " , 8 *---   : @!! " " " H I0

*0 5!"!:@!!"""",8 *---H I!(@/E(*-->O "5



+$,-+*--. );+$) 



"  8 ": !@ "  "  " 6 N) 0   ::8"6:'3"!@""/-E*-->

>0  3 E!   : 3  (8 H ;,  ,-  3 =.  N,$ I0

.0 C "60.* J

B!?" !"78N  ?   :  " &   :  : : ?66:"&: :(" 5!"!6)"5!"!"/$E/$$* 6 0 !:A"': E " ?"C)7' ("6!3:" E?6"E" "?!5@" " " :(   :!3 5 !  & 6 .-3 /!3"5!"!6)(((" "?6P@"06.>8" 5!"!6)(((::80

"!!  :6!?3"("!3 8 " 5Q :  " 6" "6  "6 ( :: :""(0

65C!5""@!"6 :0 6!'(&*- : 3&=-::3"    "   : " ( :!( & 6 >.3 *'  !3 "    6)(((D0

 6>% :!?J

B6 :  @( ? 6!  '   :0     6  8 "6 " !@'   : "6 : ""(?!!33" : (:0

6 : #6!3 K (" #C3 8J

0 6 " !@'   : "6 :  :  ::"""(

80 6 " !@'   : "6 :  :   "C  " "  (  !3  3  (:: 0



+$,-+*--. ),+$) 



6 :  " 58 "@!  6!3 K  ( " # C38J

0 5Q!@' :3"6""6: :  "C""(

80 6(:: 

0  5Q : 3 "  :'  @3 C@!:65 !"6!3

"0 ?6  "6 @(  " @   "6 @( 5 ! :3   :  "  C (  @ ? @P & "6 : ( 5"5Q!@':"DH$ I0

""(: :!:C" J  ) (K3"!(K  ) (3637  ) @  ) 5H(35533:"8+"7I  ) CH78I  ) 7#@' :+(!5 "  ::! H5Q 78 "6 C I  ) "!:H"6:: 3&6C!3"CI ?6#!!"6"6 : "6" "( ::5:36:8@? :!?'6""6:::"5 :L  55 8   ?6  ?' 6" !@'   : "6 ? :   "  5 : H F //%  /.,I0

6 : ""(:":@55 :::&E5"6 :H /$=$:0=L/$=,:0;-%I0

;0  " " 6 >% 0 > 0 "  3  !:!  : :  ! (@  @(  7":! "  (0  "  ?6 #  @( 58 "  ( ?6 : ! :!  ! ( & " @! 8!  "  " -3*  ?6 :!   8!"7 :(&/-"@!&:"H*-"@!" " ' 7RL  " 7 : (L 1  S  1 

1 T  +.I0 N6 C &  5  "  " 6! (     " 7 : (  ?  (    3 



+$,-+*--. )%+$) 



"   " K   @( 58 "  ( ?6 O  K 55?6" "6!( "7 : ("  !H /$=*:0*;;I0 6!@ (8 : "6  " 7 : ( U: C : :    3 7! :3   V H50 ( " 655 5!"! " 6("!6 :W=-,>I0

 N  E:" " F 3 6! " 6! (  !"  :!&( "-3*5C!:6555!"!"3 :! :!"&: :"58"@!? :"C38"6 :(5" 5Q!@':"&"6 "7 :(0

 # :?:!::) K 3?"8 K   ": " # C3  "!: "    & 6C!"C0C3"  7   ?6  :? ?"  U 3 6!35!?"3" 5:?@3 0VH /$=*:0//$/*,350!@ "(:!!W=-0I0

%0  6:'3  ( & 69 @7  " >+/-'   ?6 #   " 7 : (0  " :! : 6 >% 0 > 0 "     & 6!(" : !!0 6  ! "'  5"! & E  " " "6 :  : :  50  :" & C      : " " &   3 " 58 "@!3  ::"6>%0>0 0

 6!"!!?6(8"6"!@' :"6: :@?:A::!6@"6" ("!BCD0#3&!@"3 :? : !  8 " 6" "6  : (!5  7#@'   78HN/$$,:0/=*I0

 F  "  ? 6!  : 3  :   "  ( " 3:@30N6@"A"::!3 :O"553("E:""6:"6!"!"6 :3"6" ?:KC!!"0 : ::""6"6: :""@!58 "6>%0>0 0

 :K?E!0



+$,-+*--. )=+$) 













+$,-+*--. )$+$) 



  ,+4  +!* ,  * ,+



89   :  ;   58  .$& ,

  9 

/0 Q0

 9 

*0 E0

>0 ?:!"@0

.0 5   : "  ?X :( 5     :! K "  "! " >- E "'  5 : :  "! "!  8 5!"! " 3 N7YR75? ,3 ,--.   3   C :0  "!  : K :@!0  !  " J I "? C  ? "!   "! 8    : "  "!?!L8IC::? 5 :(" " "!LI:@":!0N !    :   !!  ! !!   I 8I  I )"3  85!"!":: '?X "("!(80 ! "  # " :(3 ?  E3  ?  "! ?!  X(:: " ?!!C:!"!H0/>*3/-,/-=I0 

@55'J !"J  1)  Z [   



:5 ":!K5!C:?X&X555!"! ":@55



+$,-+*--.