Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/666/2007 • CJ GE ATAS/666/2007 AI generated

Security Interest Validity and Collateral Estoppel

Case Number ATAS/666/2007
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Allowed / Granted

Legislator summary

AI generated

The dispute concerned the application of preclusive effect to a prior judicial determination regarding the validity of a security interest. The court reasoned that the prior ruling, which involved the same parties and addressed the precise issue of the security interest's validity, barred relitigation of that issue under principles of collateral estoppel, notwithstanding the prior court's failure to address all underlying claims in the subsequent matter, because the validity determination was necessary to the first judgment and the current suit presented an opportunity to raise new arguments concerning that already decided matter.

Legislator headnote

Official

; FIXATION DES COTISATIONS ; COTISATION AVS/AI/APG ; PAIEMENT DE L'ARRIÉRÉ; PERCEPTION DES PRIMES ; DÉCISION DE COTISATIONS ; INTÉRÊT MORATOIRE ; BASE DE CALCUL ; CALCUL | LPGA26; RAVS41bis

Keywords

AI generated
issue of securities matter in dispute effects of the judgment current interest rulings determining validity reasoned argument

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of costs.

Art. 64 LTF

Cited in the dispositive regarding the allocation of legal aid.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

           $'()*')++, $$'---')++,

$"

  %$! $%%$! " $$%"  $!"

./  )

 0) 1  )++, 



 !"###$%&%%'() !



!

*+  %,-.%+ // *//  #"$ 0 / *   ///#+ 123!4&52%&%% %%



             !!" #!!"$%% &     

   +&6-+  

"% $ 

%. !#7#+3'!899##$:#$ 0# $3  3'    # #3!9#! /   *$ $#! !"  *+  7#+3'#8.3;$ !"3 !##! /6 6 3! "!!3!0$&,,< &-0<2&9.&,.

&. /# =  !""##! 9# *  0 "###! 9# ! 3! 0$ &,,<  #  9#>$ 3 $##!  &5 !!? &,,-  !##! 3! /6 6  &,,<  ! =  "!  240--< 9. <,.  3#" ! 3(=#&2!("?&,,5.

).  $##!  ), !("? &,,-  #  !""#:$   !  "!  #$@ "!!#  &0-1- 9. %, !  !##! 3!3!0$&,,<.

<. !9!"$!33!##!  &- $"?&,,-.# #:$: 'A  "#' 0 !# $# 0? 0#$@.  !$:  33#! 0#$@ (# @ #3$$ ##(".  3 !  ! 0. <% ?# . 9  / 3$(!;#  9B# 0#$@ 0 "!# &4C > !##! 99#(" .   3 !$: ! : D0#$@ # E @ $   "!  )505-- 9. %, 7410%2& 9. &, "!#  9B# &%0<%-9.%,8#!" 0$(# $A#$ #" 0 #3$#!##( 0 #3!##!$A3!>3#!='AD.

4.  $##!!33!##! &9$(#&,,5#!9#"$ $##! ), !("?&,,-.!:0.<%?#.% /$#?#33#?   03'.

-.   2"&,,5!#F$!3'  #?! !#7#+3' #?8.!=0#!  $##!  !33!##!  & 9$(# &,,5   (!#    =  # 3! :0 3  !( $##! #( > #$@ "!!#    : >+#!#3G"! )505--9.%,! 410%2&9.&,. # #:$ : ! ! !(#  :#!  3##3 = (!#   0# 0#$@"!!# 0.<%?#.9 /.3$#$:# #HD= # 0.<%?#9 /$A#!# ' : 3!  3 0>$  3 &4C   !##!   :# 0# 3 $$ !(3 !"3#3;(!# A## .!$:!: 0#$@"!!# !#@3G!# $9#:#$@"!!#  :0= !"3  A# #  #  3 @  !"3   3"#' B  &4C   !##!. !  #3$#! # 3 # !#  3##3 0$A#$  #" 3#:0 ##  "#' ## !##!!( ##!#"##D.



61&46&,,5  +)6-+  

5.   $3!  &- (# &,,5  #  3#$   !#!  (!;$>!# $  $##!##A#.

2.   <"#&,,5$$A $=FA.







"%  

%. !9!"$"=0.4-.%.B.% !#A(!#I!A##! F ### &&!("?%1<%78 #?! !# !##: !#!3$(=0.4- !#9$ $   3# A$$  !#   !#  - !!? &,,, 7 8 :# ! #( =  !# 9$ $  0+(##  (#(  &, $"?%1<-7 /8..

/!"3$3!FA  I3'##$?#.

&. !#9$ $3#A$$  !# !# -!!? &,,,7 8$(#A%F(#&,,)"! #9##! !"? #3!##!$A  !"# !#./ 3"$#3!# (!#: !#033#: !#@B$="#' 3##3!:'A33#?!(#A"!"!J 9#F# #:" $"#!3! #7 *%),&),!# .%.%K ))4!# .%.&K *%&1<!# .%.&K *%&5<-5!# .%%&-%)- !# .<?$9$8.'A 3!$ :=033#: $( 'F! !$(#A7 *%%51)!# .-?%%&)-, !# .<K  %112L)53.)%-!# .)?8. I33#: !  I3'.

). /!0.-,.%  $# ! ),F! '!#9##!   $##!:$. $##!!33!##!  &9$(#&,,5! 2"&,,5./!! $##!#$$!#9#$-9$(#&,,5. /:#!## #:$: $##!(##"$$ $ !3!#! ##:0!#3 $# !. !$:  !  2 "  $$ 9!"$  "3 #. F$ $A" 9!"3$(3!#!(?( .4-  .



61&46&,,5  +<6-+   <. ##A3!:#! (!##! !# #$@"!!# 3# !##!3!&,,< 099#"#(:0 ? .

4. /! 0. &- . %    $  !##! $B ! !"# =  33#! 0#$@"!!#.

0. &4  'A"  0+(##  (#(  )% !!? %1<5 7 /8 3$(!# = ! 3"# #$ : D #  !"3#! 9#>  !##!  3! I$  !##!   $##!  !##!  $?#! !##! !"3($D.

>" 0.<%?#.%.9 / !#(3; #$@"!!#D 3! >G  #(#$ #( # $3   3!  #(#$ #(#$ !0"3!;03 3; !##! !##!=3;?  $!"3!:!"3($$# #9$# 0"!#&4C>!##!99#(" :!##! 0!3$$($F:0%F(#3'9# 0$#(#:##0$  !##! '  % F(# 3'  9#  0$ #(# :# # 0$  !##!D.

 #$@ "!!# !  > 0$'( = 4 C 3 $   !# !:  !##! ! #$A" 3;$ !:  $!"3 $?#  ?! 9!"3(#=# !"3#!!= $9=   9#!7.<%?#.&<&.& /8.!##!!$3$3;$ !:03(#=# !"3#!79..<&.% /8.

-.   !"#  !##!  #$@ "!!# !  #$@ !"3!# #$=!"3?$$9#: $?#$#3;  #("!##!(3$F #?#3$#.?  !"39#: $?#!?# #$@#! 3#" #99$$ (A !  3$#$" 3#($  $#.  #$@ "!!# !  "@"# I#"3?#=9 # !"3#!#=  9  I$ 7B#99 %,,%   ##   #$@ "!!#  $"$!#K %11&3.%558. # $? ! #$@"!!# +# # $3   "!#9 3! :  !##! I! 3 $$ 3;$ = "3.

5. 03'!3;$ !"3 !##!3!0$&,,<  &-0<2&9.&,!:!##!$" 3!$0$'(= 240--<9.<,.'!:!"3($$##9$# 0"!#&4C > !##! 99#("  0 = F # :  #  $  #$@"!!#!9!"$"> #3!##!$A %F(#&,,- &2!("?&,,- =:3#"3(=#.# 999:!3#"!#=# 0!"3!"" -<0&<29.



61&46&,,5  +46-+   ),3!:0#!#3 3; #$@"!!#. !:"!   $F=$$!9#"$3 #? $79. /62&,6&,,- &, 3"?&,,-K /6-546&,,- &-F#&,,-8.

 !#$@"!!#! $? !  !##!  79. >   ##   #$@ "!!#  $"$!#

7 8 0 /   099#9$ $ !#7* /8 %F(#&,,-!033##! 0.<%?#.%.9 /8. !$:0?#"! 410%2&9.&,7!#240--<9.<,+&-0<2&9.&,8 :# !#@3#!"3!3)505--9.%,7!#410%2&9.&,+&%0<%-9. %,8 !""  (! #  !  'A"  3$(!;  99 3  9B#.

2. ( :#3$' !"9! $ !#@F$.



61&46&,,5  +-6-+  

$ "   !"  %$! $%%$! " $$%"  $!"

 

$  2/

%. $!(?.

$ 2

&. F.

). #:3!$ A#.

<. 9!"  3#   :I 3( 9!" ! !  3$ @   $#  ), F! '  !#9##! 3'  #? 9$ $ 7/BM#NB!9:#--,,<  83(!# !"#'  !# 3?#!9!"$">.2& !#9$ $ #?9$ $ %5 F# &,,4 7 *8K  "$"!#  ! !# # #:  !#! "!#9  "!; 3(3!#A !! !" #K# !# @  $  #? 9$ $ 3 (!# 3! ! 3 (!# $!#: > ! ##!  0. <&  *.  3$ @   3#'  3!#!  !#(!:$!"""!; 3( !#(@F!#=0(!#.  A99#H  $# H         #/ ?/



!3#!9!" 3$@!#9#$>3###:I=I99#9$ $ !#3A99





61&46&,,5