Legislator Case Law & Legislation
ATAS/663/2005 • CJ GE ATAS/663/2005 AI generated

Statutory vs. Contractual Post-Judgment Interest Rate Calculation

Case Number ATAS/663/2005
Court / Authority
Jurisdiction Switzerland · Canton of Geneva (CH-GE)
Decision Date
Outcome Dismissed

Legislator summary

AI generated

The appellant challenged a decision related to the calculation of interest on a judgment, specifically arguing that the statutory interest rate applied post-judgment should have been the contract rate based on the wording of the controlling statute. The court reasoned that while the statute permitted the use of the contract rate for pre-judgment interest, it explicitly mandated the application of the statutory post-judgment interest rate for the period following the entry of judgment, thereby affirming the lower court's application of the statutory rate despite the existence of a higher contract rate.

Legislator headnote

AI generated

Art. 66 al. 1 LTF; Statutory vs. Contractual Post-Judgment Interest Rate Calculation: The court reasoned that while the statute permitted the use of the contract rate for pre-judgment interest, it explicitly mandated the application of the statutory post-judgment interest rate for the period following the entry of judgment, thereby affirming the lower court's application of the statutory rate despite the existence of a higher contract rate.

Keywords

AI generated
calculation of interest statutory default interest action for a declaratory judgment procedural interpretation of judgment reasoned decision repayment of loan

Cited Legislation

AI generated
AI generated

Key legal questions extracted by Legislator

AI generated
Art. 66 al. 1 LTF

Cited in the dispositive section concerning the imposition of appeal costs.

Need to analyze how this precedent applies to your matter?

Cross-reference this judgment against statutes, commentaries, and subsequent citing case law inside Legislator AI.

Open in Legislator →

Full text

               $%&&$'(()  $%%*$'(()



+ ,+ ! -  +! -!,

!. / 0  1& 2 '(() 



 !"!#$#"!%$!   $&  ! ' $(#&$)&&

)&!



)$!

&"&)"!) *  + , -. #6! +/)!011 !&23 2445  

&"&) , ,   --)6$!73  8992  



                !  "#

  4  



 3,

2. ! ;0$  < 6#=!&! 4998   23> -/!  !&/  "!&>! &$  "!))#  &)$&)  !&0 )$!$#  49 "$/! 2??3 @ >= "!    #   6#=!&! 2?53 $ )&! #6#=!&!2?3?.

4. ,)  -&66! ?  &")&$&6  ;0$ "!#&$#   !&/  "!&>! &$)!)#"!$0"!)&$&#=)&!"!#=)A"!)6&) (& "! -  #")B !$  !&0 $ $!&    !&/ $)!)&.

<. ;0$&=)!$=#6&&$&67!4998.

C.  !&/  #  )&&$#  "!$&  )  ! &$&$$&)  "!#=)A  "&  &$!"#  &$&$$&) #6!   "!&$  & )&(!  )$$  =)&!   "!$& (& !$  !&0  )&$49"$/!2??37!4998.

8. <&4998  &"&) , ,  )&(# !&/ #)$$"!$$&))!$&(&"!)&! )$!&00$#&$#!D$;('&=)! )&$<E5946!. C9 &&(&"!$$&))!$&)$&=)! )&$7E8946!. 59.

3. ,'0&$=)&!"!#=)A &=$&0$&) # "!  !&/  # )$ "!& '#$/&! (' &") ' "!$$&)  &/! "0 "!>   &  "&)  "!)   +   *  ,   2CE<42 6!. 98 @  $  7 ! 4998.  "!$$&)&/!"0'#$#(&)$!&0.

5. )$)$#$#$!&B"!$&$C&$2?;&$4998$ #&!#$#&"!$&")!6&!"!$')/!=$&)#=$.

7. E/E)/;$&)#&6&B# #$#0!#@;0!.



 -,

2. E!$. 48   )& 6##! !  &/! "0   "!#=)A "!)6&) =&& !=&=$$&=&&$#25#/!2??<F+G  $!#=&0!2!;=&!4999 !>0"!)#!&=)!.)!(

    :355:4998 <  



);)&$)$"')!!"!$$&))!$&@"!$0!F!$.244$ 24< ) &=&1 G ;0&&=)!)"#$$E!$.5<. 2)&6##!!"!#=)A"!)6&)48;&2?74FG )&$@ >= !&/$)!)&"&2!)H$499< )&$  "!>(E66&!&#$#$!&F!$.2C4 G B#$!E)66&"!$0! /#!#"!$&$&)#$!&#"!;0&=)!.

4. ,)E!$.44 +F)=$!=&0!"&2!;=&!4999G  &=)! "!$$&))!$&(&!$!&0)$"!$0# )6)!#$B!$.244 24< 2C2$2C4 I!$.<@8+E""&($ "!)0&)$$@$!6#!!F.2G.)!-();)&$ "!$$&) )!$&@"!$0!)!!")@&66#!$!"!$$&))!$& 0$#  =)&!  &/! "0 B&$$ #=$$  )$  &=)!  $  "!$$&)  )!$&  0$#  =)&!  &/! "0 B&$$ #=$$)$)&)!&0F6.!$.4C+G.)!  );)$@"!$$&))!$&$@E=)&!&/!"0B&$$ )$)&)!&0&$#!D$)$&=)!F + 2474<9I +24?CCCG.

<.  '">   ;0  "!&>! &$  )!)#  "!$0 "! )&$&#  =)&!"!#=)A#"!-#")B!$!&0 )&$ 49 "$/! 2??3  7 ! 4998  $ @ (  ;0$  &=)! $ =B#$)&!.

,)  )$ "!)&$   "!$$&) (& "$  !&0 "! )&!  $  7E894 6!. 58  )$ & )=&$  #&!  "!$$&)('&=&$(&)$!&0 0$#&$#!D$ ;('&=)! )&$<E5946!.<9 &$#!D$A$#$##"!'&$&$$&) #6!."!$$&)&/!"0@"!$0!'#>=@CE7996!.<9 )$ )&$&#!=&$@)B1#") )&$4EC996!.28.

  &") ' "!$$&)  &/! "0  $&>!$ (& "$  !&0  "!>   &  "&)   *   +  ,   2CE<42 6!. 98  7 ! 4998  )$  )&$&#  )&$ 5'239 6!.89 !=&$@)B1#")B.

)#( !)&$@)B1#")B)CE5396!.<8 F5E239 89J4EC99 28G.

C. )6)!#$ @  ;!&"!  "&  ;)! #$!&$ ")!  "!$0 ;(E )$  $!6!$   "!$$&)  )!$& )   !   );)&$ &=)!# /##6&&&!  $$ "!$$&)  !)&$ @  &$#!D$

    :355:4998 C  



)"$)&! !  )$$  1&.  &$#!D$ )$ #  $B && #0 ) E!$. 24  E)!) !  "!#=)A "!)6&) =&&  !=&=$ $ &=&&$#  27 =!& 2?7C F 4G ) )  $B !#0$&!  & &1& $ "#!&! F + ) "/&#  <3:94  27 ;&$ 499<G

8. #)$!"!K "!)#!#$$0!$&$F!$.5<.4$ 7?L.2)&!"!)#!&&$!$&=24"$/!2?78G.

MMM



    :355:4998 8  



 ! - ,3  ,+ ! -  +! -!,



456   7  8   9# 1%' -:

2. =&$ &"&)"!) + , @$!6#!! )"$      )  C'539 6!.<8 @  &  "&)  , ,  6=!)&!.

4. =&$ &"&)"!) + , @=!! " )$$ &$#!D$)"$)&!)&#!$ >7!4998 ;(E)$$!6!$.

<. 'A)$$(/)&.

C. &$("!)#!$0!$&$.

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

    :355:4998